Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Racism in Brazil

Powerful Essays
2806 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Racism in Brazil
Introduction Racial disparity and discrimination is not a new concept to any nation. In fact, many were built on the back of slave labor, whether the slaves were indigenous peoples or imported bodies. While many nations have undertaken measures to overcome racial disparity, others have encouraged racial democracy. Brazil, a modern and industrialized nation, suffers from racial discrimination based on their position in the world economy and built on the ideology of the past.
History
Brazil’s history is rife with racism and slavery, dating back to its discovery by Pedro Alveres Cabral in 1500. Brazil was originally settled with the intention of harvesting Brazilwood. However, over time the profits from that were supplanted by sugar, which soon became the major export (Phillips 117). Over a short period of time, Brazil became the leading producer of sugar in the Atlantic world. The production of all these exports meant cheap labor was needed. During this time, the Portuguese were sending between 4,000 and 5,000 slaves per year to Brazil from Angola and West Africa; by the 18th century, one million slaves had been imported (117). The continually shifting landscape meant that Brazil’s exports continued to shift. By the time the 19th century came around, Brazil’s major export was coffee as sugar production had shifted to the Caribbean Islands. The continued influx of European slaves and citizens resulted in an uneven population. European labor was generally more skilled and slowly began to overtake slave labor. Around this same time, the abolition of slavery happened in 1888, resulting in a decline in the slave population. By 1888, it was estimated that only a half-million people were slaves, compared to the one-and-a-half million slaves in 1872 (117). This is in part due to the fact that the coffee production process became more and more elaborate, requiring those with sophisticated skills to take over. Coffee production soon fell into the hands of a wave of European immigrants, not freed slaves (122). The slaves that were freed often became vagrants, homeless, jobless and penniless (Rocha, “Analysis: Brazil’s ‘racial democracy”).
The history of Brazil continues to inform the current day Brazil. The current day population of Brazil tops 160 million, with about half of that being black. Yet, the black population is nearly absent from all levels of power, meaning “government, congress, senate, the judiciary, the higher ranks of the civil service and the armed forces” (Rocha, “Analysis: Brazil’s ‘racial democracy”). In 1999, the Minority Rights Group International reported that “black and mixed race Brazilians still have higher infant mortality rates, fewer years of schooling, higher rates of unemployment, and earn less for the same work. Black men are more likely to be shot or arrested as crime suspects, and when found guilty, get longer sentences” (Rocha, “Analysis: Brazil’s ‘racial democracy”).
Racism Persists There are many theories as to why racism continues to persist in modern day Brazil. One thing to look at is their placement within the greater world economy. Phillips believes that “racism and its continuation exists with the capitalist world economy and, as in the case of Brazil, can also exist above and beyond it” (Phillips 122). When the Portuguese settled Brazil, they created a line of trade that focused on Brazilwood, gold diamonds, sugar, and coffee. As such, the result was that the Portuguese and the plantation owners became very wealthy, all at the expense of the nearly three million black and mulatto slaves.
A truly capitalist world is one that where each countries worth is weighed in terms of their strengths (military, trade, financial, production) and what they can contribute. A superpower such as the United States is naturally more diverse, which means that tolerance and racism are not tolerated as easily in modern day society. Core countries are those that have the greatest strengths and the peripheral countries are the ones that are expendable. Phillips says “the peripheral countries were exploited by the core, and ‘semi peripheral’ countries were exploited by the core and exploited peripheral countries. The relations between these three geopolitical units are ones built on inequality” (122). Phillips goes on to say that “similar to the inequality that can be seen in a class system within a country, this template is now spread around the globe to view inequality on a world scale” (122). In other words, Brazil is treated with discrimination based on their trade abilities and overall contribution. This has trickled down so that individuals are also being treated with the same discrimination. It is also important to note that “racism is fundamentally rooted in processual class structures, historically shifting modes of production, distribution, and consumption, and increasingly, in the unequal exchanges that tie local political economies to the global processes of capitalism” (Phillips 122). Brazil’s history of racial prejudice and discrimination has established a mode of living and ideology that persists to this day. It would be too easy to blame slavery on the world economy, but it is safe to say that the capitalist world economy has helped perpetuate racial prejudice and discrimination. Slavery existed long before profit was exchanged for labor. As Brazil has grown, “the means to social mobility after emancipation was closely guarded by the Brazilian white ruling class, who allowed for a pool of relatively less expensive labor consisting mainly of Brazilian natives and other European immigrants” (122). The influx of cheap European labor resulted in the black and mulatto population being pushed aside.
After Brazil abolished slavery, the ex-slaves were left with two choices: work under the same conditions as when they were slaves or join the masses of unemployed (Phillips 122). They had additional challenges; they were competing with native Brazilians and European immigrants for a limited number of jobs where the new economic order was wage labor (122). Racism played a major role after the emancipation of the slaves as many of the ex-slaves were discriminated against in the free job market. While the shift has been to the detriment of blacks and mulattos, racism has not helped the white population of Brazil (123).
Despite the racism running rampant, there is no black movement in Brazil. There is seemingly no racial tension or conflict. Blacks that live in Salvador, who make up 80% of the population, say they feel safer in that environment than they do in the US (Rocha, “Analysis: Brazil’s ‘racial democracy”). It is speculated that this is because appearances matter more in Brazil than heritage. In the US, one drop of black ancestry means you are black, while in Brazil, if you appear white, you are perceived as white (Rocha, “Analysis: Brazil’s ‘racial democracy”). It can also be noted that the US has a history of violent racism where oppressed populations were treated harshly. Those past grievances have not been forgotten, and in some cases, not forgiven which means that racism still persists even though the US espouses equality and freedom. It would seem as though the US operates under a shadow of racism, attempting to sweep it under the rug and pretend that equality is real. Brazil does not operate under such false pretenses. Racism is alive and acknowledged.
As of the 2010 census, 51% of Brazil identifies itself as black or brown. The government estimates that the income of white Brazilians is more than double that of black or brown Brazilians and that blacks are at a distinct disadvantage in relation to education and access to healthcare (“Brazilian 2010 Census Highlights Racism Problem”). The racial divide in Brazil is based on a social pyramid. Many will argue that the black community is poor because class, not race, stratifies their society. However, there are many that would disagree. According to Mario Theodoro, an activist for social equality believes that “slavery’s legacy of injustice and inequality can only be reversed by affirmative action policies, of the kind found in the United States” (“Race in Brazil: Affirming a Divide”). Yet, it is also fair to note that in the US, there are many of different races that are in positions of great power and that social class is often dictated by wealth. The history of the US supports the advancement of the white race, but progress is showing that race is beginning to take a backseat to skill set and overall acumen.
In Brazil, the race line is well drawn. Most of those in the public eye, such as TV news anchors, doctors, dentists, fashion models, and lawyers are all white. The majority of black and mulatto’s are working in the “blue collar” trade, often deemed the unskilled labor pool. The salary disparity is even more telling. By 2011, the average black or brown worker was earning 60% of what the average white worker made (“Brazilian 2010 Census Highlights Racism Problem”). Statistics do not differentiate between gender, only race, though it can be assumed that the same problem occurs between gender lines.
Affirmative Action Brazil, once considered a “racial democracy” is fighting hard to shed that moniker. Racial democracy, in relation to Brazil, is defined as the thought that compared to other nations; racism was actually very minimal in Brazil (Telles, “Discrimination and Affirmative Action in Brazil”). However, today, most Brazilians concur that Brazil is victim to racial prejudice and discrimination. Blacks and mulattos are the major victims of widespread police violence and often earn half the income of their white counterparts. In addition, television and advertising portray Brazilian society as one that is almost entirely white (Telles, “Discrimination and Affirmative Action in Brazil”). This is because the working class and elite are almost entirely white, so the melting pot of races exists only in the working class and poor. According to Antonio Riserio, a sociologist, “It’s clear that racism exists in the US. It’s clear that racism exists in Brazil. But they are different kinds of racism” (“Race in Brazil: Affirming a Divide”). He continues to argue that the racism itself is nefarious and veiled, unlike the racism that used to run rampant in the US. In Brazil, there was never a Ku Klux Klan or enforced segregation or even a ban on interracial marriage (“Race in Brazil: Affirming a Divide”).
Affirmative action is often put into place to attempt to create a racially diverse atmosphere. Most often this is in correlation to the workplace where employers do not discriminate based on race, gender, or religious affiliation. In Brazil, the new affirmative action can be most notably seen in the university setting. By 2008 almost 50% of Brazilian universities have a race-based affirmative action policy (Telles, “Discrimination and Affirmative Action in Brazil”). Traditionally, to attend a university, students were required to pass a standardized test. Now, leading universities are mandated to allow a fixed percentage of nonwhite students to attend. In addition, they have quotas for indigenous peoples and for the disabled (Telles, “Discrimination and Affirmative Action in Brazil”). Even though affirmative action was put in place to help, it is not without controversy. Those that oppose the policies include “much of the media, private school students, their parents and the schools themselves, scholars and artists who value the racial democracy ideal and even black students who believe in meritocracy” (Telles, “Discrimination and Affirmative Action in Brazil”). They maintain that affirmative action does nothing to further racial equality; instead, it merely promotes racial equality without any substance. In addition, many academics are fighting against affirmative action in schools and campaigning against quotas. They argue that enforcing affirmative action is, in itself, inherently an act of racism. It divides people into arbitrary color categories; a feat, which is not as easy as it seems since much of Brazil, is a country of mixed race (“Race in Brazil: Affirming a Divide”). They also argue that it undermines the equality of the admissions process, even though in the past, nepotism and whom you know have been the quickest routes to advancement (“Race in Brazil: Affirming a Divide”). Despite these arguments, studies have shown that many of the “quota” students are performing academically as well or better than their white counterparts. This can be attributed to the fact that many of those white students were admitted because they had the means and money to prepare for the entrance exam (“Race in Brazil: Affirming a Divide”). The next target is the labor market, a place where affirmative action could show positive benefits. In the United States, only 12% of the population is black, yet we have a black president, numerous black politicians and millionaires. In contrast, Brazil has a limited number of black people in positions of power. Because of this, some private sector companies are making racial diversity a requirement in their recruiting process (“Race in Brazil: Affirming a Divide”). But again, the same problem occurs that showed up in the university setting. Just because a person is of a different race does not mean they are qualified for the job at hand. It often follows that work production and quality decline because employers are hiring based on color, not skill level. Unlike the US, affirmative action in Brazil is being done in a very Brazilian way. There is little to no government interference or enforcement. Universities and private companies are making their own policies. The Supreme Court is involved, but is slow to act in hopes that society will figure out their own issues (“Race in Brazil: Affirming a Divide”). Society is moving fast though. Businesses and advertisers are now targeting black populations, but changing the minds of the consumer sector is an easy task compared to changing the mindset of racism ingrained after years and years of overt racism. Many Brazilians assume that blacks and browns belong on the bottom of the social ladder, making the push for proactive change difficult (“Race in Brazil: Affirming a Divide”).
Solution?
In order for Brazil to pull down the racial divide and move beyond racial democracy, the boundaries between black and white need to be weakened. There is no denying that Brazil has racism that is based on power, exploitation, and slavery, but despite this, the racial division is not nearly as rigid as they are in the US. An interesting note is that most Brazilians perceive their culture to be an example how race and culture can coexist peacefully. Despite this somewhat astonishing claim, it is still believed that 90% of the white population is prejudiced against the black and mulatto population. However, their idea of racism differs greatly from person to person so it is difficult to judge what this really means. In a recent event in Brazil, a six-year-old boy was kicked out of a pizza polar supposedly for the color of his skin. According to the restaurant manager, he mistook the young boy as a local street boy. The boy’s parents have since then filed a complaint with the local police department and are also considering taking legal actions. This story launched a huge race-debate in Brazil (Phillips “Does Brazil Have a Race Problem”). While stories like this continue to gain traction, it is hard to figure out where Brazil goes from here. Affirmative action plans seem like a step in the right direction, but that will not be enough to change 500 years in ingrained behavior. Brazil will need a complete economic and social shift if it wishes to eradicate racism. If the US is a learning curve, Brazil has a lot of work to do, and so does the US when it comes down to reality.

Conclusion
Many people around the world see Brazil as a country full of racial diversity where racism just simply does not exist, where as others claims Brazil suffers from invisible racism where blacks earn less, live less, and are educated less. Although blacks make up for most of the population in Brazil they are still grossly under-represented in higher education, media, and politics. The continued racial divide will only be removed when government and individuals work together to not only acknowledge the problem, but find a way to move above and beyond racism and look at the individual for the value, not their skin color. References
Arcand, J., & D 'Hombres, B. (2004). Racial discrimination in the Brazilian labour market: wage, employment and segregation effects. Journal Of International Development, 16(8), 1053- 1066. doi:10.1002/jid.1116
"Brazilian 2010 Census Highlights Racism Problem." Fox News Latino. N.p., 18
Mar. 2013. Web. 04 Nov. 2013. http://latino.foxnews.com/latino/news/2013/03/18/brazil-racism-problem G, Kevin. "UL-Lafayette User Authentication." Afro- Brazilians Fighting for Affirmation Action (2001): n. pag. UL-Lafayette User Authentication. Rio De Janeiro, 9 Oct. 2001. Web. 04 Nov. 2013.
Phillips, Brian. "Brazil 's Racial History." International Journal Of Diversity In Organisations, Communities & Nations 5.1 (2005): 117-124. SocINDEX with Full Text. Web. 19 Nov. 2013.
Phillips, Tom. "Does Brazil Have a Race Problem." GlobalPost. N.p., 4 Jan.
2012. Web. 4 Nov. 2013. http://www.globalpost.com/dispatch/news/regions/americas/brazil/120104/does- brazil-have-race-problem
"Race in Brazil: Affirming a Divide." The Economist, 28 Jan. 2012. Web. 4 Nov.
2013. .
Rocha, Jan. BBC News. “Analysis: Brazil’s ‘racial democracy.’” Web. 19 Nov. 2013.
Teller, Edward E. Wide Angle. “Discrimination and Affirmative Action in Brazil.” PBS. Web. 19 Nov. 2013

References: Arcand, J., & D 'Hombres, B. (2004). Racial discrimination in the Brazilian labour market: wage, employment and segregation effects Mar. 2013. Web. 04 Nov. 2013. http://latino.foxnews.com/latino/news/2013/03/18/brazil-racism-problem G, Kevin. "UL-Lafayette User Authentication." Afro- Brazilians Fighting for Affirmation Action (2001): n Nov. 2013. Phillips, Brian. "Brazil 's Racial History." International Journal Of Diversity In Organisations, Communities & Nations 5.1 (2005): 117-124 Phillips, Tom. "Does Brazil Have a Race Problem." GlobalPost. N.p., 4 Jan. 2012 "Race in Brazil: Affirming a Divide." The Economist, 28 Jan. 2012. Web. 4 Nov. 2013 Rocha, Jan. BBC News. “Analysis: Brazil’s ‘racial democracy.’” Web. 19 Nov. 2013. Teller, Edward E 19 Nov. 2013

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Racism has been around the world since the beginning of time. Racism in its most basic form is the idea that if you are of a certain skin color you are better than another person of a different skin color. It is a topic that most people do not like to talk about but whether they like it or not it is a major issue that needs to be addressed. People of darker skin are the ones who have been oppressed by people of lighter skin since colonial times. However, most of it had stopped for a while but now we see that it is coming back. The same issues that people struggled with to get over and create harmony are entering back and haunting society today. The current event, the mass deportation of Haitians from Dominican Republic echoes its racist history.…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For example, when I first arrived in the Dominican Republic in 2013 I could not tell the Dominicans from the Hattians. Now because of the culture and the ways people treat Haitians I can tell if a Dominican or Haitian person walks down the street by the color of their skin. Another place which racism appears is when people see African American frizzy hair they call it pelo malo (bad hair) and they call my hair pelo bueno (good hair) because of its straightness and fineness. This custom creates sadness because God created everybody different and he purposely gave these women frizzy hair while the Dominicans reject it and call it bad. Through many other example racisms in this country shows itself…

    • 562 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Chapter 5 Outline

    • 5552 Words
    • 20 Pages

    6. How does the concept of race differ between Brazil and the U.S.? 
A. In the U.S. a person with any amount of Black ancestry has historically been designated as Black; this has not been the case in Brazil.
B. In Brazil a person with any amount of Black ancestry has historically been designated as Black; this has not been the case in the U.S.
C. In the U.S. and in Brazil one’s racial categorization is strongly…

    • 5552 Words
    • 20 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Mentality In Brazil

    • 2050 Words
    • 9 Pages

    For as long as there have been civilizations, people have separated themselves into groups. Most of the time into groups like: the have and the have not’s or us vs them. This has happened in Brazil between the upper and lower class. Brazil is a country with a very small to non-existent middle class, causing a huge gap between the two classes. This huge gap is causing the us versus them mentality or a we/they divide between the upper and lower class, based on a process of social categorization. The central hypothesis of the mentality is that group members of an in-group will seek to find the negative aspects of an out-group, thus enhancing their self-image. The in-group in Brazil is the upper class where as the lower class has been named the…

    • 2050 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    Brazil is a vast country rich in natural resources and beauty in the continent of South America. Located in the east-central coast of South America, it is the largest country in South America occupying nearly half the continent. Brazil’s topography is vast with its most priceless treasures inarguably being the Amazon Rain Forest. The Amazon River and its components attribute to two fifths of the country with the Amazon Basin making up 40% of the continent of South America (“Brazil”, n.d.). The Portuguese settlers were the first to arrive in Brazil and quickly found they were not alone, discovering the many tribes of natives that called Brazil their home for hundreds and maybe even thousands of years. These Portuguese settlers were not determined to conquer as the Spaniards, but were poor sailors who were seeking items for trade. This made it easy for the settlers to intermarry with the natives as well as the slaves they had brought from Africa, creating the mix of races known in Brazil today (Geographia, 2006). The Portuguese were not the only ones to seek Brazil to escape their situation and they were quickly joined by many immigrants such as French, Dutch, German, Italian, Japanese, Chinese, African and Arab, with Portuguese remaining the dominant and official language of Brazil. These cultures have blended into one…

    • 3774 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Latin America’s trade and economy grew very slowly. Between 1700 and 1800 was the highest import of African slaves. The Triangular/Atlantic slave trade was where African slaves were exported to Latin America, where the raw materials and crops produced would be exported, through Spain, to the world, and finished products would be exported from Europe to Latin America. Early discoveries of gold and silver production created the first basis of its economy and the exports of silver and gold would make up more than 2/3 of Latin America’s economy, trade, and income. Plantations, agriculture, and the crops produced would make up the majority of the rest of Latin America’s exports. Sugar would continue to be a major cash crop and an economic booster for Latin American countries even into present day. Recently, the Latin American region has generally begun to privatize exports, and sold state-controlled companies to private owners.…

    • 420 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    [ 17 ]. Thomas E. Skidmore, Brazil: Five Centuries of Change (New York: Oxford University Press, 1999), 16.…

    • 1819 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Syncretism generally refers to the process of reconciling or melding of differing views or beliefs or uses. This can happen intentionally, or by a natural, unconscious process. More or less discrete cultures that come into contact with one another, either through geographical proximity, migration, conquest, trade and exploration, or in other ways, will start to syncretize aspects of each culture. A melting pot is a metaphor for a society where many different types of people blend together as one. America is often called a melting pot.…

    • 260 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Mistreatment of Slaves

    • 4288 Words
    • 18 Pages

    Williams, Mary Wilhelmine. "Negro Slaves in the Brazilian Empire." The Journal of Negro History 15 (2002): 315-56. Print.…

    • 4288 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In 1549, the first Jesuit missionaries arrived in Brazil to spread Catholicism. In the late 1500’s, there were no longer Native American slaves because of the large decrease in their population due to European diseases. Some Native American tribes forced there slaves to undergo human sacrifice, such as the Aztecs. There were now Black African slaves. While this was happening, the…

    • 552 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mexico and Brazil had different social views in that Mexico had abolished slavery, but Brazil had not. When Mexico won its independence from Spain, the Constitution of 1824 abolished all kinds of slavery. Mexican efforts to free slaves played a vital role in the formation of the Republic of Texas. Though the presence of a large slave population angered the elite’s thoughts of independence in Brazil, there was an amplification of slavery until 1850. The development of coffee as an export crop brought economic rebirth. This difference socially between Mexico and Brazil occurred because the majority of the population in Mexico was Catholic and slavery was seen as immoral and…

    • 554 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    - Everyone in the community is a different color, in America it's either your black, Asian, white, etc. In Brazil, everyone is a different color it seems, like a rainbow.…

    • 432 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The paper discusses one aspect of the theoretical underpinnings addressed in my ongoing doctoral research. It discusses the approval of a law making the teaching of African and Afro-Brazilian history and culture compulsory in K-12 (basic education) curricula at both public and private schools. The law is seen as curriculum policy aimed at promoting racial equality and a benchmark in the struggle to implement an anti-racist education in Brazil. The paper explores academic literature and legislation in order to understand the trajectory of Brazilian black movements. It also dialogues with epistemic perspectives stemming from Latin American postcolonial studies. I examine the rationale and context in which an education policy for race relations…

    • 136 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Violence In Brazil

    • 155 Words
    • 1 Page

    Popular culture and mainstream media has not been kind to favelas; films such as ‘City of God’ and ‘Elite Troops’ have consistently portrayed the Brazilian slum as a place of perpetual poverty, crime, and violence. To combat this limited, but dominant portrayal, the government of Brazil has increased police raids and drug crack downs in slums, as well as making efforts to potentially demolish and raze favelas. Without questioning the political, social, and economic needs to fix the slum, including stopping of violence and raising the standard of living for the poor, one should not dismiss the organic and highly social edifice of favelas that are almost never seen from the outside; shops, businesses, children, pets, and even tourists… there…

    • 155 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Racism in South Africa

    • 1188 Words
    • 4 Pages

    This type of cruelty is not as common as it once was, but any act such as this should not be allowed to take place in the free world. Imagine living every day in fear, never knowing what the day is going to be like. What about tomorrow? This behavior is something most people never have to experience in their lifetime, but what about those that get to witness these events first hand? The violence and hatred that has caused a country to live in fear, was said to be a symptom of globalization, by a country that calls itself a “Rainbow Nation”,…

    • 1188 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays