Do you think violent criminals deserve to "feel more serene" as the speaker suggests? Not really, they are in prison not on vacation, they don’t really deserve “special treatment.”
How might the prison benefit from prisoners who are calmer? Well, that prisoner might not get beat up if the others are more calm, so he’s pretty lucky there.
Lab 2
What is the prisoners' primary demand? The hunger strike is the prisoner’s primary demand.
Why are many of the prisoners put in solitary confinement indefinitely? Well, someone on the video said they’re put there pretty much to make themselves commit suicide.
According to the video, how are California's solitary confinement procedures different from others around the nation and around the world? Do you think this constitutes cruel and unusual punishment? Why or why not? Prisoners are put there, to bring their life all the way down to committing suicide, I do think it is wrong and a cruel punishment.
Do you think that gang members should be held in solitary confinement, if so, under what circumstances? Gang members yes, but not just for having a card from one, that’s quite ridiculous.
The video doesn't mention the crimes that the prisoners on hunger strike were convicted of. Do you think this information would change your opinion on this issue? Why or why not? No it wouldn’t change my opinion, it’s ridiculous either way. Lab 3
What is the fastest-growing segment of the prison population? Aging inmates and those with mental illness constitute the fastest-growing segment of the prison population.
Do you agree that health care is a constitutional right for prisoners? Yes, you can’t just completely let them die in prison without attempting to help them.
How many "lifers" are in California prisons? There are around 26,000 lifers in California prisons.
Why does the prison doctor endeavor not to know the crimes his patients have committed? Do you think this is wise? Why or why not? It makes him feel safer not knowing the crimes his patients have committed, and it brings a better relationship between them he said, and yes I do believe it is wise.
Do you think prisoners should be let out on compassionate release? Why or why not? No, because they have been sentenced to life, so they deserve to serve life.
What is the recidivism rate for criminals over the age of 55? 9.5% is the recidivism rate for criminals over the age of 55.
In your opinion, does it make sense to keep elderly and sick convicts in prison, even though they pose little risk to public safety? Yes, like I said they have been sentenced to life, so they deserve to serve life.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
After reading “The Cost of Solitary Confinement,” I agree that the use of solitary confinement should be abolished in prison. Before the reading, I have never heard of such a thing as solitary confinement. Once I started reading the story, I immediately thought this was a foul in wrong thing to be doing, and was flabbergasted that it was even existed in our prisons today. There are many different reasons that I agree with this, but I'm only going to be focusing on if you of them. First off, if none of you are familiar with solitary confinement is, I'll give you a little run down.…
- 411 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Another aspect of security which is a big advantage to the prisoners and the officers is the dynamic side of security. Prisoner officers monitor the prisoners to ensure that they are coping with life in prison; if they aren’t coping well at all it could lead to them becoming suicidal. Prisoners could self-harm or even commit suicide if the prison officers aren’t keeping an eye on them. It is the…
- 389 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The United States prison system is notorious for the way it treats its inmates. There are so many theories, and facts to back up the claim that the prison system is not working the way it was intended to be, and it continues to be a growing issue that the government is not addressing. Further, within the already complicated prison system, there is another issue. Solitary confinement, which was originally supposed to be used as a short term punishment within prisons, or jails, has now become an integrated part of prison life (Edge, 2014). Solitary Nation, is 2014 documentary highlights the damages that solitary confinement is doing to people (Edge, 2014). Individuals whom have not shown any signs of degrading mental health come out of segregation, or as the inmates call it, “seg,” disturbed (Edge, 2014).…
- 476 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Solitary confinement needs to be eradicated not only because it changes peoples’ brains but also because it has an indelible effect on a person’s “whole person”, their essence. Hard Rock’s treatment, which is now illegal, is no different than modern day prisoners’ treatment. Both treatments yield the same thing: distortion of the mind and in severe cases, a disabling of it. Simply, these inhumane acts detract a significant amount of humanity from a person. It takes away dignity and self-awareness in some cases. It plagues the youngest, troubled, testosterone- fueled inmates with senescence. This is beyond cruelty, this passes into the realm of evil, exorbitant torture. Why is torture acceptable in today’s society? Is the government really…
- 173 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
Most people understand what solitary confinement from films or television shows that revolve around a prison. The prisoner is sent to a cell where they have zero human interaction, unless it is with the prison guards escorting the prisoner for vital human needs such as eating, which is also done alone. It is a punishment for the inmates that have been deemed unsafe to have around the normal population of the prison, or have done something wrong that caused the prison to send them to solitary to punish the prisoner for what they have done. I was originally someone who believed something such as this may seem simple enough to understand and was a humane way of dealing with a problematic prisoner, when in reality, it is much more traumatic for…
- 2193 Words
- 9 Pages
Good Essays -
However, in the case of Sully and those with the same punishment, it can be pushed beyond the brink of sanity. Based on the workings of Fathi (2015) “A considerable number of the prisoners fell, after even a short confinement, into a semi-fatuous condition...others became violently insane; others still, committed suicide” (p.170), despite these clearly immoral issues it still stands as a plausible punishment. In most cases, the negative effects of solitary confinement can be far reaching into person's mind. In a study found by Fathi (2015) “[N]o study of the effects of solitary or supermax-like confinement that lasted longer than 60 days failed to find evidence of negative psychological effects” (p.170), with ranging levels of damage done that could actually be recorded. Moreover, as stated by Abramsky (1999), could turn Robert Scully, originally convicted of robbery and drug charges, into a killer and attempted kidnapper. In his argument, Abramsky paints a vivid and saddening portrait of the vessel that holds its captives to standards that are no short of appalling, the super¬max. A place designed to torment the already freedom less and…
- 1851 Words
- 8 Pages
Good Essays -
It is hard to think that people would try to take their own lives rather than suffer for years. In studies they report emotional and behavior changes greatly on inmates like deep depression or some people even turn homosexual. In the book there where many times that inmates tried to get raped and had to defend their self to remain the person they were before they went in there. People also form gangs for protection and being beaten badly is not uncommon even murder happens in jail. There are also many laws with the jurisdiction…
- 480 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
I. There is one simple change that can be made within prisons that will preserve an inmates’ mental health and continue to keep prison staff and other inmates protected from any danger the inmate may pose.…
- 642 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The decision from Mayer Bill de Blasio to end solitary confinement for juvenile inmates in New York City may be the action needed to lead to a more humane treatment of the incarcerated. Solitary confinement has often been argued that it falls against the constitutionally given right to not be subjected to cruel and unusual punishments. Subjecting juveniles to this kind of treatment, makes it an even more controversial topic. Because solitary has the reputation of degrading the human mind, juveniles, who already have a delicate mental imbalance, are likely to suffer more as they go through the daily “23 hours” of depressions, hallucinations, and desperations that are caused by solitary. It can also be disputed that solitary can be for the juveniles’…
- 255 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
I read the story “The Bet”, during my research I found an article called “The wrong box: our prisons' use of solitary confinement is inhumane.” Although, the sceneries are different the outcome is the same. “In truth, modern solitary confinement drains more than life: It drains away the self” (Heffernan & Wood, 2015). On the one hand, a young lawyer willing to bet his freedom, and on the other hand jails where solitary confinement is used as punishment and even to protect vulnerable prisoners. The bottom line is that solitary confinement has devastating consequences to the human psyche and society (Heffernan & Wood, 2015, p.…
- 106 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
On January 26, 2016 Former president Barak Obama took actions against solitary confinement against juvenile. He announces that he will revoke solitary confinement against juvenile and such acts will be banned. He emphasizes that low level infraction and mentally ill prisoner are spending excessive amount of time in solitary confinement and this does not bring any good impact on the individuals but long lasting psychological problems. He states “How can we subject prisoner’s confinement, knowing its effects, and then expect them to return to our community as a whole people.” Former president Obama call upon the case of young 22-year-old Kaleif, who spend approximately 2 years of solitary confinement at the age of 16 years old for accusingly…
- 185 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
There is a lot of controversy about if solitary confinement be cruel and unusual punishment? So does solitary confinement violate our rights as an American citizen? Solitary Confinement is when an inmate is placed in a cell by themselves with no contact with other except with guards. The cells are usually very small and they stay in their cell for 22 to 23 hours a day .Solitary confinement is a violation of the 8th amendment ban against cruel and unusual punishment because it inmates are more likely to hurt or kill themselves , it causes brain damage and inmates are denied of basic needs .…
- 559 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Recidivism and Resettlement: Determining the Level of Satisfaction in the Needs and Accommodations in Preventing Recidivism and establishing Resettlement for Female Offenders…
- 5917 Words
- 24 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Built in 1829, the first solitary confinement prison was the Eastern State Penitentiary in Philadelphia. It was inspired by Quaker philosophy: penitence and reform through isolation. The idea was to put people back in touch with their own true self to incite a natural process of self-reformation. They would be in their cell, with a view of the sky, as if to be in touch with God. In its time, Eastern State Penitentiary was the most technologically advanced prison in the world. As time passed, problems started presenting themselves. Instead of being reformed, many inmates were physiologically ravaged. Some were completely withdrawn, and others displayed increasingly violent behavior. Statistical evidence showed that the rates of suicide, death, and disturbances were so high that eventually the system fell apart. In 1913, solitary confinement was widely regarded as ineffective and was abandoned in most places around the world. (Solitary Confinement) Today, the United States is one of the few countries in the world that still employs long term solitary confinement in correctional institutions. (Solitary…
- 1334 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
One big problem that I find with solitary confinement is that it the inmates in there are getting some kind of social reinforcement. The social reinforcement that they are getting is not the positive kind either. The inmates are cutting themselves to get attention from the prison staff while they are in solitary confinement. This is not healthy for them or for the staff, with all the blood that is coming from the inmates has the possibility of spreading disease. These inmates are learning that acting out or threatening to kill themselves ore others they will get attention from the prison staff this is not a good thing to be getting reinforcement from.…
- 881 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays