A Rhetorical Analysis Of Jane Austen's Proposal

Marriage is one of the most important parts of someone's life, so giving a compelling proposal is vital to receiving an acceptance from the woman. The men in both passages propose using different types of arguments to express their reasons for the proposal. In Jane Austen’s proposal, Mr. Collins does not effectively use the rhetorical strategy of understanding his audience when he presents his proposal with attitudes of self-centeredness. Contrarily, In Charles Dickens’ passage, his speaker proposes with passion and vitality that convey a sense of love and openness. The rhetorical strategies each speaker used was based on their understanding of effective persuasion, which undoubtedly led to Collins’ rejection and Hedwig’s undeniable acceptance. Austen’s speaker presents his proposal as if he is describing a business agreement, and lists ways that will benefit him rather than his intended. Mr. Collins arrogantly assumes Elizabeth will agree to his proposal, and doesn’t consider her feelings. Collins views the marriage as something that will
He has a genuine attraction to the woman, and he creates an affectionate impression on her in which he explains what he has to offer her, rather than what he desires from the marriage. Dickens’ speaker reveals his vulnerability to the woman by offering himself completely to her. He exclaims, “you could draw me to any exposure and disgrace. This confusion of my thought, so that I am fit for nothing…” Hedwig is truly devoted to being with this woman, and he demonstrates his love and loyalty by accepting any disgrace his marriage will bring. Hedwig’s affectionate word choice helps create his message, as he uses phrases like “with all my heart,” and “I love you.” These all have positive connotations to them that exaggerate his point and add to the overall tone of his proposal, leading to a conclusive acceptance from the