Preview

According To Douglas Hofstadter's A Person Paper On Purity In Language

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
871 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
According To Douglas Hofstadter's A Person Paper On Purity In Language
“In any case, Niss Moses (once again) raises a ruckus on this score, asking why we don’t have a corresponding word for young whiteys who play blackeys’ games and generally manifest a desire to be blacks. Well, Niss Moses, if this were a common phenomenon, we most assuredly would have such a word, but it happens not to be.” — William Satire (alias Douglas Hofstadter), “A Person Paper on Purity in Language” I highly enjoyed Douglas Hofstadter’s piece. Although I had never given any serious thought to the problem of sexism in English, I found myself strongly agreeing with many of his arguments. In fact, I even became a bit angry and ashamed with myself for not recognizing some of the more blatant examples of sexism in the language. For example, I had not thought about the distinction between ‘Miss’ or ‘Mrs.’ The change in title was something that a married woman did as part of tradition, but I never stopped to wonder why she made that change, or why …show more content…
Being a ‘tomboy’ is acceptable, but only for pre-pubescent girls. It is a stage that a girl is supposed to grow out of when she becomes older and assumes her prescribed role as wife and mother. However, there is no corresponding word for a boy who enjoys activities that have traditionally been associated with girls. The satire piece explains that it is not a common phenomenon for boys to manifest a desire to be girls; therefore, there is no word to describe the few who have this desire. I think the word does not exist because our society has very strict notions of masculinity, and boys who prefer girl toys, clothing, and activities go against those notions and should not be acknowledged. They are giving up their maleness, their position of authority, in order to take on a weaker, lesser role — the role of a

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    What is it that makes a woman a woman, or what makes a man a man? Deborah Tannen, author and Ph.D. of linguistics, investigates this question within the essay, “There Is No Unmarked Woman.” An excerpt from a larger publication, “Talking from 9 to 5,” written in 1994, “There Is No Unmarked Woman” is an effective examination of the social injustice as to why the state of womanhood is “marked” while the state of manhood is “unmarked”, and what this means for each sex. The book itself is a result of real-life research about the conversational styles in a workplace setting and how conversation impacts productivity and success. Although Tannen uses many effective strategies within the excerpted essay, she most pointedly uses devices such as narration, vivid description, definition, compare-contrast, and example to make herself heard. She also adopts a critical, but humorous, outlook in order to effectively analyze why these social structures exist without discrediting her own voice or style. In the opening paragraphs of “There Is No Unmarked Woman,” Tannen narrates a past experience from a professional conference, therefore beginning the essay on a more personal and relatable note. She begins with, “Some years ago I was at a small working conference of four women and eight men. Instead of concentrating on the discussion I found myself looking at the three other women at the table, thinking how each had a different style and how each style was coherent.” These few sentences allow the reader insight into the author’s thinking process and that even she may judge other women for how they dress and act, creating a more intimate atmosphere between the audience and the author. “One woman had dark brown hair in a classic style, a cross between Cleopatra and Plain Jane...Because she…

    • 1837 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    For centuries, society defined women using their generational stereotypes. According to Laurel Thatcher Ulrich, the woman’s social status progression and digression needs to be investigated. Her book, “Good Wives”, expands on what societal stereotypes created the ideal women in 17th and 18th century New England. Ulrich approached the topic with a virtually unbiased opinion and attempted to explore all socio-economic classes to relay deeper understanding of pre-modern gender roles.…

    • 710 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Most of the time the reason why labels are used is to help others grasp a clear view on a certain phenomenon. Meltzer's article differs from Romano’s in the sense where she is not trying to rename and remodel a specific label but she is discussing how the word tomboy is no longer used as often as it was before, because she believes it has now become extraneous. Many feel the word comes with a stigma to the female who embodies it, Meltzer seems to agree with this point and this is illustrated in the last paragraph of her work when she refers to another author who called it a double masculine. Some people seem to think that it is empowering, carefree, and shows signs of inner strength and beauty. Whether it is empowering or not it certainly shows that there is a dividing line between what is meant for girls and what is designed for boys.…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Since I was a child I was always described as a "Tomboy". One way to define the term "Tomboy" is, a biological girl/woman who doesn't fit society's ideal and beliefs of what is consider being feminine and/or doesn't correspond with stereotypes of feminine roles. Personally, I can somewhat agree to being call this, but on the other hand I never really thought about how it affects/affected my life. I was raised by my grandparents, who were used to working physical jobs, and also involved with activities like hunting, woodcutting, and farming; so, as a kid I always thought it was pretty normal to want wear jeans or overalls instead of dresses, and getting in trouble for grass stains on my clothes from playing outside.…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    His boyish looks make him seem to young for politics whereas in comparison his political opponent Stephen Harper is a older male who is settled down giving the framing that to be a true candidate in politics one must be older more mature, this is not a clear definition that Trudeau is not able to run a country. Trudeau has made mistakes in the past from being young which the Conservative party is sure to mention to the public to get votes. By the Conservatives exploiting Trudeau makes Stephen Harper look good as a candidate. The media itself puts into societies minds that a political leader of the country should follow certain qualities. They are as follows; to be masculine, take charge and make decisions that will help all, put aside the personal life, engage or communicate with people and to be confident just to name a few. Through these gendered stereotype’s Trudeau is no reason he does not fit under these categories, his voice may be higher pitched and less monotone as Harpers but this is not a linguist reason for him to be categorized into a female role. Trudeau has put aside his personal life; only the conservatives pull out his past to put him down as a leader. He engages people through communication and this specific event is a way to specifically focus on women and their concerns and questions yet media easily takes this and makes it become a sexist event, which was…

    • 2387 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Lesson 4 quiz

    • 551 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The use of masculine pronouns as generic references is an indication of the extent of linguistic sexism.…

    • 551 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Feminism. Arguably one of the most misunderstood terms to date. In order to move forward and grow as a society, feminism is vital. Of course, sexism still exists and I doubt, there will ever be a time in history where it does not; much like racism- but generally, we have come a long way. The road for equal rights has been a long and sometimes, dangerous one as can be observed through texts such as Shakespeare’s The Merchant of Venice, Robert Browning's My Last Duchess Sarah Gavron’s Suffragette and Charlotte Perkins-Gilman’s The Yellow Wallpaper. This idea of gender inequality can be readily observed through the aforementioned texts and in fact, many others, regardless of the era in which they were first written. Women being treated as possessions,…

    • 1567 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Commoners In Frankenstein

    • 521 Words
    • 3 Pages

    During Romantic England, the people were still divided into different classes based on their social and economic status. These classes were distinguished by “...the basis of power, education, economic status, prestige etc”(“hierarchy”par.3). In English society women were prevented from being an individual that “thinks” on their own behalf and were…

    • 521 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Men’s and women’s roles in society have and continue to change throughout the centuries. In this century alone women have gained the right to vote and society’s expectations of us altered, making women working a variety of jobs common – such as being a doctor, business woman, or politician. Furthermore, the expectations of men have changed considerably as well – modern men take paternity leave upon the birth of their child and it is not unusual for the man to be the chef in a relationship. However, gender roles and expectations have clearly not always been viewed this way and continue to develop over the generations. It would be foolish to believe that we cannot learn from past genders ways in different cultures. Late medieval France had extremely different gender roles and views than we do today and through examination of them I have been able to appreciate that the way gender is expressed today is not the only way the roles can exist. By learning from the past I am…

    • 3543 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    “In Heaven’s own time, a new truth would be revealed, in order to establish the whole relation between man and woman on a surer ground of mutual happiness” (ch. 24). The Scarlet Letter; where there is a woman, a husband, and a lover. A story where women are downgraded, humiliated, punished, and judged for their actions. It is an obvious that eras have changed as well as customs, women now have a say in our government. Therefore, we mainly focus on two political issues that have affected our society, feminism and sexism. We go in depth of researching how their definitions have changed throughout time and how they have affected our society solely in the United States.…

    • 1255 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I found the article written by Emily W. Kane so insightful and it reminded me very much of the film Tough Guise 2 by Jackson Katz. We find gender nonconformity of girls much easier to accept than that of boys. Girls can dress like boys and play sports like boys and they will simply be considered just a “tomboy”. However if boys choose to behave more feminine, they are constantly bombarded with insults such as “fag, pussy, or bitch”. Although often brushed off the shoulder, these insults can cause a boy to feel…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The roles of men and women have long been different. Women have always been struggling to make themselves known, while men easily gained respect and superiority over women. In Virginia Woolf’s two passages, Woolf makes a profound distinction between the male and female schools in which she partook meals from. Including details that describe the luxury of the male school and the relative poverty of the female school, Woolf uses varied sentence structure, imagery, sensory words, and diction to describe her attitude towards the inferiority of women.…

    • 438 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Best Essays

    Feminism in South Park

    • 3199 Words
    • 13 Pages

    South Park has been around for a while now. Since it was aired for the first time on 13th August 1997, the show has constantly pushed the boundaries taking on everything, leaving out nothing. The reception among the wider population and the media had a wide range from “shocking” to “excellent”. One of the aspects of this success story is that, because of its provocative tone the show has managed to stay in the limelight. Public debate was evolving around certain episodes, bringing more and more attention to the show. As it was constantly picking up contemporary themes, topics or events, expectations were growing and “ 'How will South Park deal with x ' has become a common catch phrase” (Johnson-Woods 257). Another reason why South Park is so appealing is its humour which is absolutely unrestricted and irreverent (Johnson-Woods 257). Seemingly, the creators of the show do not set any boundaries for themselves, taking on everything and everybody. Even public figures and celebrities are not spared. The viewer witnesses events like Barbara Streisand mutating into a giant, destructive monster, Martha Stewart taking a turkey up her rectum, or Ben Affleck having a sexual affair with a nine-year old boy. People apparently enjoy the stylistic, humorous and critical social approach of the show, making it the most successful satire so far. Being full of toilet humour and foul language, South Park is pushing “the boundaries of good taste. Few shows have dared to go where South Park goes” (Johnson-Woods 244). “It is also full of introspect and unbiased social commentary” (Khodasevich 2) and is characterized by its libertarian attitude, which is granting freedom to everyone and especially to itself. As it is a satirical approach to social conventions. South Park tries to make a point on various discourses within our society by “filtering these problems through children” (Johnson-Woods 163, 164). These children are a group of elementary school boys, namely…

    • 3199 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Conversely, “gentleman” is not recycled as the equivalent of “ladies” in many context. The act of allowing the word gentleman to stand alone inequivalent, belittles the value of women within…

    • 905 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Gender Identity Crisis

    • 657 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Are you a boy who played with girls dolls as a child? Or vice versa, are you a girl who preferred to climb trees, get dirty and never take baths growing up? Usually, it has been shown one would have been called a sissy or a tomboy. What happens if these individuals never grow out of their gender crisis? They live their lives either as a cross dresser, or a transvestite. If they are homosexual some will go as far as to alter their genital appearance. There are those who disagree and say we are wired the way we are whether we want to be boys or girls. It all breaks down to how society sees the different sexes of people. The idea of gender specifications are a learned behavior.…

    • 657 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays