Preview

Addie's Criticism In The Crucible By Arthur Miller

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
520 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Addie's Criticism In The Crucible By Arthur Miller
Cora’s as a Christian women contrasts with Addie’s real experience with sin. As Addie put it, “people to whom sin is just a matter of words, to them salvation is just words too (176).” This quote describes Addie’s religious views perfectly. She does not consider her affair a bad thing; therefore, why is repentance necessary? If you have done nothing wrong then why do you need forgiveness? Cora believes it is pride that holds Addie back from Christ, that she has done nothing wrong (167). Rather ironically, Addie had an affair, with a minister of all people. However, Addie does not feel any different than what Cora believes, yet for different reasons. If Cora knew the truth she would be amazed at Addie’s genuine feelings about sin. Any social …show more content…
Jewel is not a likely candidate for a savior, at least on a moral sense. He exhausts profanity often, even uses God’s name in vain numerous times. Yet to Addie, he is the son she most cares for, the product of her affair with Whitfield. She gave her other children to Anse but since the affair was kept secret, Jewel belonged only to her. Since they both share an independence from the rest of the family, Addie and Jewel have a special relationship. While discussing sin with Cora, Addie prophesied that he would save her both from the water and the fire (Faulkner 168). This prophesy was to be later fulfilled on the trip to Jefferson. Jewel holds onto Addie’s coffin with a rope to rescue it from the raging river (154-155). Later on in the novel, Darl sets fire to the Gilliespie barn in an attempt to give his mother peace (217). Darl had reasons for commiting arson but did not understand Addie’s wishes. Her request to be buried in Jefferson, with her own family reflects a lack of emotional connection to the Bundren family. Anse died to her long ago and she felt that her children violated a sense of aloneness (174; 172). The religious significance of her statement is in the confusion of Cora’s over who she was referring to. To Cora, an example of the exemplar Christian woman, Christ is the savior; she considers Addie’s remark idolatry. It is a violation of the first commandment, that nothing or no one shall come before

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    To understand Jewel Bundren better, one must first examine his mother, Addie. Before she fell in lust with Jewel’s father, Brother Whitfield, she was married to Anse Bundren. She had two children by Anse. Then she had Jewel by Brother Whitfield. While she is proud of this silent rebellion against her husband, she nonetheless feels that she owes her husband a true third son that he has always wanted. So, Addie delivers two more children, a daughter and a final son, Vardaman. Addie says, “I gave him Vardaman to replace the child I robbed him of. And now he has three children that are his and not mine” (Faulkner 176). Of course, Addie does not count her daughter Dewey Dell in this quote because Anse did not want a daughter. Therefore, Jewel and Dewey became her children and the other three, she feels belong to her husband. Addie says of Cash, Darl and Vardaman ,”I did not ask for them” (Faulkner 174). When Jewel was conceived, Addie gained something from her rebellion; she gained a son that was not of Anse’s blood. Jewel was the product of Addie needing to live a little. She wanted to experience the forbidden fruits of Eden, and what better way to taste them, than to consummate with a holy man?…

    • 1560 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In every form of entertainment whether it be a movie, book, or play there has to be a problem. For the problem the metaphorical significance is the substance and the vapor. The point of the crucible is to get rid of the substance that is inside the flask. This is saying that the society is trying to get rid of the witch rumors that are going on in Salem. In the play the judge is was trying to get rid of the problem by executing people that were considered witches.…

    • 191 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    happen and encouraging sin in her everyday life. After they were on their trek to Sandy Bar and they…

    • 642 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The fact that she always wears a cross reveals that she may carry some guilt regarding her relationship with William and the dishonesty toward William’s wife. She carries religion close to her heart in hopes of gaining forgiveness from God.…

    • 1435 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Carl has since grown up into a resentful son toward his father, because at some point he found out about his lustful affair. Carol then revels unto his father Barden that he knows and doesn’t respect him for being unfaithful to his mother. Barden asked Carl to forgive him, but Carl couldn’t it seems to let go that his preacher father was acting of flesh and not as a clergyman. Barden not only ask his son Carl for forgiveness but he also asks God. Time and time again Barden goes back and does the same thing that he asked to be forgiven for previously. Barden is having an affair with Louise whom is married as well. So not only is Barden committing adultery, Louise is doing the same. Louise not only has a husband she has three daughters.…

    • 1194 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Crucible Essay

    • 1228 Words
    • 1 Page

    Proctor seems to be a good man except he has one secret, which is his affair with Abigail. This…

    • 1228 Words
    • 1 Page
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    "The Crucible" by Arthur Miller explores the themes of hysteria and fear, drawing parallels between the Salem witch trials of the 17th century and the McCarthy hearings of the 20th century. One of the central themes of the story is the destructive nature of hysteria. The fear of witchcraft in Salem spread quickly, leading to baseless accusations and the wrongful death of innocent individuals. This theme is evident when Reverend Hale exclaims, "Life, woman, life is God's most precious gift; no principle, however glorious, may justify the taking of it" (Miller 132), highlighting the disastrous consequences of unchecked hysteria. Through vivid portrayal of mass panic and paranoia, Miller shows the dangers of succumbing to irrationality and mob…

    • 221 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “The Crucible”, Arthur Miller used dramatic irony to create anxiety and to demonstrate the tension between the people about the lies of witchcraft in Salem. Because of the use of dramatic irony the audience knows about everything that is going on, but the characters themselves do not. This is why so many innocent people in Salem get hanged. The judges and eventually the people of Salem fall for the lies of Abigail Williams and the girls. Dramatic irony in “The Crucible” is not only used for the false accusation, but also for many other things in the play.…

    • 871 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jewel is Addie’s third child but not Anse’s child. Jewel is the product of an affair that Addie had with Whitfield, the town minister. Addie spoiled Jewel because he was a symbol of her happiness with Whitfield. Jewel constantly pushes his luck with Addie, getting into all the trouble he can possibly think of, but he loves his mother. Jewel just wants Addie to be able to die in peace and quiet without Cash sawing away at her coffin where she can see and Dewey constantly fanning the air away from Addie’s face (Faulkner 15). Jewel’s love for his mother is more openly expressed when he runs into the barn to save her coffin from the burning barn (Faulkner 222).…

    • 482 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Crucible Essay

    • 352 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Hysteria overshadowed logic and enabled the townspeople to think that their neighbors were acting out senseless and unbelievable crimes like dealing with the devil & murdering babies. In The Crucible, the townsfolk accepted and became active in the hysterical outbreak not only out of religious loyalty, but also because it gave them a chance to express repressed attitudes & to act on long-held grudges. The most obvious case was Abigail, who used the circumstances to call out Elizabeth Proctor of witchcraft and have her sent to jail. However, many others used the hysteria to their advantage as well. Reverend Parris strengthened his position within the village, no matter how brief, by making scapegoats of people like John Proctor who questioned his authority. The wealthy & ambitious Thomas Putnam gained revenge on Francis Nurse by convicting Rebecca, Francis’s wife, of the uncanny deaths of Ann Putnam’s babies. In the end, hysteria thrived only because people benefited from it. It postponed the principles of daily life and allowed the acting out of every dark motive & hateful urge under the pretense of justice. The witch trials were central to the action of The Crucible, & dramatic accusations/ confessions filled the play even beyond the confines of the courtroom. In the first act, even before the hysteria began, we saw Parris accuse Abigail of dishonoring him, and he then made a series of accusations against his parishioners. Giles Corey and Proctor responded in turn, & Putnam soon joined in, creating chaos even before Reverend Hale entered the scene. The entire witch trial system thrived on accusations along with hysteria. Proctor attempted to break the cycle with a confession of his own, when he admits to the affair with Abigail, but his confession is beat by the accusation of the act of dealing with the devil against him, which in turn demanded a confession. Proctor’s decision at the end of the play to die rather than confess to a sin that he…

    • 352 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Novel: “His tone implied that Mother failed to grasp our mission, and that her concern with Betty Crocker confederated her with the coin-jingling sinners who vexed Jesus till he pitched a fit and threw them out of the church.…

    • 441 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    She acts very self righteous, saying that she is not a sinner and therefore has no need for him.…

    • 367 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In society, truth has no meaning because people in numbers, rule and come together, only believing what they want to believe. Great strength in numbers is a key factor in The Crucible, written by Arthur Miller. What the townspeople of Salem said, always went. There is no arguing and no deciding. If someone was accused or judged as being a witch, they were most like condemned for being one.…

    • 786 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    At the beginning of the poem, Christabel is described as innocent and pious. There are clues, however subtle, that this is not entirely true. Christabel’s character is first described as being one “whom her father loves so well” (line 24). It can be inferred from this that she must be worthy of such love, meaning that she is one that can be viewed as good or moral. The reader is also made aware that Christabel is one that cares for others, as she is “pray[ing] / for the weal of her lover that’s far away” (lines 29-30). This paints Christabel as a pious, loving,…

    • 1628 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Christianity plays a major role throughout the poem to characterize Christabel. “Christabel herself personifies moral innocence.” She “appears well-intentioned, virginal, and naïve” (Ulmer 378). These qualities go along with those of a Christian who has not been exposed to sin and still has purity. “Christabel is repeatedly characterized “as a sinless child… “Christabel suffers innocently, like Christ [;]” her “beauty has a particular innocence about it, being associated with the beauty of Christ” (qtd. in Ulmer 378). Christabel is seen as pure and sinless on the surface, but as the poem continues the perception of her innocence shifts toward her permitting sin to come into her life. “Cooper contends that “physical evil, no matter how supernatural its source, cannot touch Christabel’s soul unless she consents to it”” (qtd. in Ulmer 379). At the oak tree Geraldine deceives Christabel and causes her to question her faith and give in to sin. Ulmer reports that…

    • 1208 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays