Adnan Is Guilty
Usually people don’t think much about murders being convicted and put into jail. If the court decides that someone is guilty of a murder, then you will automatically assume that they’re guilty. Well in the podcast Serial, by Sarah Koenig, a man named Adnan Syed is convicted for the murder of Hae Min Lee. This podcast really makes you start thinking about who really killed Hae. With the evidence in the podcast, I have decided that Adnan is guilty. Adnan killed Hae because the, “neighbor boy” claims that he had seen a body been put into the trunk of a car by Adnan, Nisha put Jay and Adnan together when Adnan was supposed to be somewhere else, and Kathy thinks that Jay’s and Adnan’s behavior was unusual.
The first reason that Adnan is guilty is because of this …show more content…
neighbor boy, talked about in episode 6. Some people who knew him said that he had told a story about seeing a body in the back of a car. However, when the neighbor boy was asked about this, he denied ever saying such a thing. But, the people who knew him said that he could never keep a secret and that he would not just make something up. So, it would not have been something that someone would trust him with. Showing that he must have seen this with his own eyes. Maybe once the detective’s came to investigate the story and his claim, he might have gotten nervous or scared, and told a lie. This however, is important to the Adnan case because it is another witness. It is someone through their own eyes who can state, “I saw Adnan show Jay a body in the back of a car.” Without this evidence, the detectives would just be relying on opinion in the court, not the actual truth and proof to back up their case against Adnan. So, with the information of the neighbor boy's theory, you can conclude that Adnan showed Jay a body in the back of a car.
The second reason that Adnan killed Hae is because Nisha put Adnan and Jay together the day that Hae was killed, (giving more evidence to Jay’s testimony). Nisha claims that she had gotten a phone call from Adnan around 3:30 p.m., when Adnan claims he did not have his phone, but Jay did. Nisha states that Adnan had called around 3:30 and they talked for a little while, and then he put Jay on the phone because he wanted to say hi. While Jay was talking to Nisha, Adnan was supposedly in a video game store that he worked at. However, what is strange about this testimony is that Adnan had not started working at that store until later into January. In spite of her story involving him going to the video game store, she was asked again to tell the story from the beginning, where the next time it was not spoken of. This is important to the case against Adnan because it is another person who can agree with Jay’s alibi. This is also someone else who is proving that Adnan is lying. With this information, you can conclude that Adnan had his phone, because Jay had not known NIsha. If Jay did not know who Nisha was, he most likely would not have had a conversation with her in Adnan’s name. For Adnan called her recently, and she was on speed dial. Therefore, it is clear to see that Adnan is lying about having his phone at the time he says it is with Jay, and for this, making him seem more guilty.
The third reason that Adnan is guilty is because Kathy was with Adnan and Jay the day of the murder, and she said that they were acting funny, especially Adnan.
In serial, Kathy states that she had a random guy who was high in her living room, and who was friends with Jay. She said that he was acting weird the whole time that he was there and that he had gotten a phone call before he left. While he talked on the phone she said he looked worried and like he didn’t know what to do, then he burst out of the room without saying anything. This looks sketchy because he was high in the first place, then just ran outside without a word. If he was so worried, you would think that he would try to act more casual and less suspicious, or maybe it was the drugs that were keeping him from thinking straight. After he left the room, he sat in his car and talked to Jay for a long time. After a while though, he left. This information is useful for the case against Adnan because it shows that Adnan is hiding something. Without this information, Adnan would not seem very sketchy, and like he is hiding something. So, with this information, you are able to conclude that Adnan got a call from someone that made him feel
threatened.
In conclusion, most people are not going to be concerned about if they put the right man away. However, Serial makes you think. Adnan is guilty though. He is guilty because of the call to Nisha at 3:30. As well as for the call lasting for 2 minutes, and Jay not knowing Nisha. Adnan is guilty for the strange actions at Kathy’s house. Because of the call and them being high. Lastly, Adnan is guilty for the neighbor boy’s claim about Adnan showing Jay a body in the back of a car. With this information you can come to conclude that Adnan is no doubt, 100% guilty of the murder of Hae Min Lee.
The first reason that Adnan is guilty is because of this …show more content…
neighbor boy, talked about in episode 6. Some people who knew him said that he had told a story about seeing a body in the back of a car. However, when the neighbor boy was asked about this, he denied ever saying such a thing. But, the people who knew him said that he could never keep a secret and that he would not just make something up. So, it would not have been something that someone would trust him with. Showing that he must have seen this with his own eyes. Maybe once the detective’s came to investigate the story and his claim, he might have gotten nervous or scared, and told a lie. This however, is important to the Adnan case because it is another witness. It is someone through their own eyes who can state, “I saw Adnan show Jay a body in the back of a car.” Without this evidence, the detectives would just be relying on opinion in the court, not the actual truth and proof to back up their case against Adnan. So, with the information of the neighbor boy's theory, you can conclude that Adnan showed Jay a body in the back of a car.
The second reason that Adnan killed Hae is because Nisha put Adnan and Jay together the day that Hae was killed, (giving more evidence to Jay’s testimony). Nisha claims that she had gotten a phone call from Adnan around 3:30 p.m., when Adnan claims he did not have his phone, but Jay did. Nisha states that Adnan had called around 3:30 and they talked for a little while, and then he put Jay on the phone because he wanted to say hi. While Jay was talking to Nisha, Adnan was supposedly in a video game store that he worked at. However, what is strange about this testimony is that Adnan had not started working at that store until later into January. In spite of her story involving him going to the video game store, she was asked again to tell the story from the beginning, where the next time it was not spoken of. This is important to the case against Adnan because it is another person who can agree with Jay’s alibi. This is also someone else who is proving that Adnan is lying. With this information, you can conclude that Adnan had his phone, because Jay had not known NIsha. If Jay did not know who Nisha was, he most likely would not have had a conversation with her in Adnan’s name. For Adnan called her recently, and she was on speed dial. Therefore, it is clear to see that Adnan is lying about having his phone at the time he says it is with Jay, and for this, making him seem more guilty.
The third reason that Adnan is guilty is because Kathy was with Adnan and Jay the day of the murder, and she said that they were acting funny, especially Adnan.
In serial, Kathy states that she had a random guy who was high in her living room, and who was friends with Jay. She said that he was acting weird the whole time that he was there and that he had gotten a phone call before he left. While he talked on the phone she said he looked worried and like he didn’t know what to do, then he burst out of the room without saying anything. This looks sketchy because he was high in the first place, then just ran outside without a word. If he was so worried, you would think that he would try to act more casual and less suspicious, or maybe it was the drugs that were keeping him from thinking straight. After he left the room, he sat in his car and talked to Jay for a long time. After a while though, he left. This information is useful for the case against Adnan because it shows that Adnan is hiding something. Without this information, Adnan would not seem very sketchy, and like he is hiding something. So, with this information, you are able to conclude that Adnan got a call from someone that made him feel
threatened.
In conclusion, most people are not going to be concerned about if they put the right man away. However, Serial makes you think. Adnan is guilty though. He is guilty because of the call to Nisha at 3:30. As well as for the call lasting for 2 minutes, and Jay not knowing Nisha. Adnan is guilty for the strange actions at Kathy’s house. Because of the call and them being high. Lastly, Adnan is guilty for the neighbor boy’s claim about Adnan showing Jay a body in the back of a car. With this information you can come to conclude that Adnan is no doubt, 100% guilty of the murder of Hae Min Lee.