Preview

African Americans and Medicine: From Slavery to Modern Times

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1988 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
African Americans and Medicine: From Slavery to Modern Times
African Americans and Medicine: From Slavery to Modern Times

Imagine being sick, but never going to a doctor because you knew they would do bad things to you, make you sicker, or even kill you. When we see doctors, we are trusting them to make the best decisions to help us. However, there was a time when doctors committed the most heinous acts against those who needed them. African American’s have been used for unethical studies and cases since the time of slavery. Some were used against their will, while others were taken advantage of by the people who were supposed to take care of them. The earlier cases of this inhumane treatment were scarcely documented, but through tales and word of mouth were passed from generation to generation. African Americans never forgot what happened to their ancestors or what could still possibly happen to them and as a result lead to the mentality that they should stay away from hospitals and doctors, furthermore creating a culture of fear surrounding institutional medicine. Unfair treatment of African Americans started during the time of slavery. In Slavery and Medicine: Enslavement and Medical Practices in Antebellum Louisiana, author Katherine Bankole describes the mentality of whites and white slave owners which dictated the treatment of slaves medically. Bankole says, “The three main areas of enslavement and medicine in the antebellum period are: theory, management, and experimentation” (Bankole 8), doctors theorized that the biology of Africans was innately inferior to that of the white race. The second area, management, involved “general health, disease, diet/nutrition, clothing, mortality, and the medical costs incurred by slaveowners.” (Bankole 8) Medical management was the most important factor that determined the success of a slave owners land. The healthier a slave was, the more he could work and produce a profit for the slave owner. This meant health care was provided at a lower cost to those who owned slaves.



References: of night doctors are again seen here where Savitt notes, “Black fear of medical schools and dissection inevitably carried over into the postbellum period, when whites, as a mean of maintaining control over freedmen, reinforced the idea of ‘night doctors’ who stole, killed, and then dissected blacks” (Savitt 340). My final thought from Savitt comes from Southern medical schools boasting about their large supplies of blacks for study material. Even after their schooling, white physicians maintained the idea of the usefulness of African Americans. African Americans continued to be used for new techniques or treatments, and doctors did not fear consequences as long as death or permanent injury did not result. “Blacks, therefore, did have reason for fearing misuse at the hands of southern white physicians.” (Savitt 341). Much advancement was made in medicine as a result of experimentation. Certain doctors received their fame off the unethical treatments of slaves and African American patients. Dr. J. Marion Sims was an American surgeon who became credited with developing the area of gynecology, and has even been called, “The Father of Gynecology.” Sims used enslaved women to try to discover a cure for the disease vesico-vaginal fistula. During Sims time, the practice of gynecology did not exist and obstetrics as well as child delivery were taught with dummies. Because enslaved women were poor, and lacked proper nutrition as well as prenatal care, they were at higher risk for developing VVF. After Sims graduated he became interested in surgery and began conducting experiments on enslaved women which resulted in the perfection of a certain surgical technique to repair the fistula. This was not Sims initial objective, but after looking after a patient one day who had fallen from a horse and had pain her pelvic area he discovered a way to better see inside the vagina which made him feel more confident in his ability to perform surgery on women with VVF. Sims used 7 enslaved women as his subjects so their consent was not necessary. His first patient was a woman named Lucy, and Sims was so sure he had discovered the proper technique for surgery he invited local doctors to come watch the surgery. Lucy had to stay in a position where she was on her knees and elbows with everyone watching, and she was not given anesthetics. Lucy was in horrible pain during and after the surgery and nearly lost her life from a blood infection she developed as a result of Sims’ experimentation. It took Sims four years to finally perfect his surgery and cure women of this disease. His first success was on a woman named Anarcha who had already received thirteen operations, all without the use of anesthetics. White women began coming to Sims after they heard of his success, but none of them could endure the pain of surgery. Among the list of unethical experiments done to African Americans, one of the most famous was the Tuskegee Study. Syphilis was a huge concern during the 1930’s in America, but not much was known at the time of the effects of advanced syphilis. The study was conducted by investigators from the United States Public Health Service on 400 African American men from Macon County, Alabama. The study was meant to last from six months to a year, but the investigators knew that the most important information would come only after the men were dead. In Experimentation on Human Beings, Susan Lederer describes the men used for the study: “The men recruited into this study were impoverished individuals; many had never seen a doctor in their entire lives” (Lederer 21). The investigators would deceive the men by offering free treatment and perform spinal punctures collecting fluid, telling them this was a treatment for the condition. The investigators wanted to make sure the men would go on not receiving treatment so they would keep them from being enlisted in military service, during World War II, because once in the military they would receive mandatory syphilis treatment. The Center for Disease control held a meeting in 1969 to discuss whether the study should continue or not. Only one professor protested the study saying the men should be receiving treatment. It was only three years later when reports of the study flooded through American media, and Americans were shocked and disgusted in the governments treatment of these vulnerable subjects that the study was closed in 1972. In light of the study as well as other unethical studies at that time, Congress adopted the National Research Act in 1974. This act required that the people must give a written consent before partaking in studies. Given the history of medical experimentation of African Americans, one is left to wonder if it has had an effect on the modern day perspective of the African American and medicine. A study conducted in 2006 by doctors, Elizabeth Jacobs, Italia Rolle, Carol Estwing Ferrans, Eric Whitaker, and Richard Warnecke, to see what trust or distrust of physicians means to African Americans. They found that the African Americans they tested had more trust based on the “interpersonal and technical competence of physicians.” While distrust stemmed from “lack of interpersonal and technical competence, perceived quest for profit and expectations of racism and experimentation during routine provision of health care.” If patients felt their physician was untrustworthy they would either keep information to themselves or lie about their medical history, change doctors, or even refuse to seek medical care. Multiple studies have shown that African Americans are more likely to distrust physicians than Caucasian Americans. One of the female patients in the study was quoted saying, “Over my period of time dealing with the medical field, I know that you do need a hell of a lot of trust in the physicians or the medical field and the institutions.” The patient goes on to say, “But I don 't know how most people are, but it reminds me of the Tuskegee Institute where they messed around and they made the brothers have the disease instead of treating them they just wanted to see how it was going to affect them. So maybe sometimes you go instead of getting treated they just want to see what it’s going to do to you and they 'll try this and try that and they may give you a sugar pill. Because it’s not like they haven 't seen anyone dead before so the only time they get affected [by dead people] is when it’s personal. So that 's why a lot of people have mistrust.” (Jacobs et al) Although there have been great medical discoveries made over the last two centuries in American medicine, the cost of these discoveries has been paid by the lives of individuals who were or deceived into partaking in these experiments. As a result, centuries later, there is still concern as to whether or not physicians are to be trusted to ethically perform their duties on patients. We owe so much of what has been established in the field of medicine to the slaves in America. Their pain and suffering paved the road to medical advancements, and their sacrifices need to be recognized as well as praised.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The Tuskegee Syphilis Study began in 1932 in Tuskegee, Alabama. The case was created by the United States Public Health Service, the objective was to analyze the natural course of untreated latent syphilis. The disease was injected into roughly 400 African American men without their consent. The men were misled of the promise “special free treatment”. Instead the “treatment” were spinal taps done without anesthesia to evaluate the neurological effects of the disease. It was morally wrong to test these men without permission and mislead them to false hope of an antibiotic.…

    • 393 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the film Ms. Evers' Boys, a group of doctors withholds penicillin from a group of black men who are suffering from syphilis. The movie itself depicted a true, historical (and quite controversial) study known as the Tuskegee Experiment, which took place in the times after the Civil Rights Movement. The doctors taking part in this research were trying to prove that the effects of syphilis were as severe in blacks as they were in whites in order to get more money for medication. They also wanted…

    • 389 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    James Derham was the first African-American to practice medicine in the United States. Born in Philadelphia, Derham started life as a slave. He was owned by three doctors in the area. In one of the households he learned to read and write. In 1788 he was sold to a prominent surgeon in New Orleans, and the surgeon encouraged Derham to learn medicine. Derham showed great aptitude at helping others, and he also quickly learned the art of surgery. He was popular for his medical knowledge but also his fluency in speaking French, English, and Spanish. He would have been a godsend to African-Americans who would not have been allowed to visit a white doctor.Slaves and African-American freemen were not permitted to consult a white doctor. For those people, Derham would have made a big difference. He is quoted as saying about Derham: “I conversed with him on medicine and surgery and found him learned. I thought I could give him information concerning the treatment of disease, but I learned more from him than he could expect from me.”…

    • 313 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Henrietta Lacks Quotes

    • 342 Words
    • 2 Pages

    “It wasn’t routinely taught in medical schools, and many American researchers—including Southam—claimed not to know it existed. Those who did know about it often thought of it as “the Nazi code,” something that applied to barbarians and dictators, not to American doctors.” (131)…

    • 342 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The black sharecroppers in the area were persuaded by researchers to participate in study by way of bribe. Due to the illiteracy in the community, the men were told they were being treated for “bad blood”. In turn for their willingness to participate, the men were granted free medical exams, burial insurance, and free meals after every visit and treatment (Head, 2012). The researchers gathered over 600 men for the study- 399 had syphilis, the remaining 201 did not. Those who did not have the syphilis infection, were injected with the bacteria against their knowledge and consent. None of the men were informed about the disease process; none of the men knew whether or not they were infected; the men were not informed about penicillin; and all the men were denied access to penicillin when it became available in 1943 (Head, 2012). The study was originally established to last six months. Unfortunately, the study lingered on for 40 years. The researchers involved in the study felt the only way to know how syphilis affects the body was to prohibit access to penicillin and study the corpse of the men who died from the disease throughout the duration of the research. Finally, in 1972, the experiment was exploited, and in 1973, a lawsuit was filed on behalf of all the men who participated in the study (Head, 2012). Sadly, many of the men died prior to the exploitation…

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    C. (2005). Daniel Hale Williams: Pioneer Black Surgeon and Educator. Journal Of Investigative Surgery. Retrieved from http://eds.b.ebscohost.com.proxy01.shawnee.edu/eds/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?vid=2&sid=fb7b77a6-5c21-49c9-bd27-e6416eee2d92%40sessionmgr102&hid=111…

    • 544 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Henrietta Lacks

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The purpose of the Mississippi Appendectomies was to sterilize America of bad genes meaning anyone women who was mentally challenge, a criminal, Black, Alcoholic, etc… would get sterilized so they couldn’t reproduce anymore. Doctors figured that in order to stop mentally challenged blacks alcoholics etc… from walking this earth is to sterilize them and make sure their genes don’t flow in the gene pool. The treatment for these appendectomies was horrible it was just blacks that were treated it…

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1932 the “Tuskegee Study of Untreated Syphilis in the Negro Male” began. The original intent was to learn the effects of syphilis on the body. The study began with 600 black men and was intended to last six months. Shamefully, the ethics of this experiment were nonexistent as misinformation and deception led the experiment to last a striking forty years. A primary object for the disgust surrounding the experiment was the lack of consent.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In my opinion, the public should have not allowed this type of research to be conducted. In the research study on page 264 in our textbook (MLE Fourth edition) it states “ the public was outraged that poor black men had been subjected to a research project without their consent and denied treatment for a treatable disease in an attempt to gain what was seen as useless information”. The public in this research did not know anything about this research until the 1960s when a researcher working for the U.S. Public Health Service tried to have the project ended but when that was unsuccessful. He then notified the press and ultimately the project was stopped. This let the public be aware of the research being conducted.…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the past, scientists have done very unwise and unimaginable experiments with humans as the test subject. Like in 1932, the public health service was working to find treatment for syphilis in the african american race.They had 600 black men, 399 with syphilis and 201 that did not have the disease. Without the patient's knowing that they were contracted with syphilis, scientists told the men that they were being treated for “bad blood”. But really they were not given the right treatment to cure their illness. Also in exchange the men received free medical exams, free meals, and burial insurance, which is like life insurance. But in 1968 this research raised concern for peter buxton and others, so they wrote a news article about what these…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Speaker notes 440

    • 1485 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The history of the African American population in regards to healthcare will provide us with background information about the experiences African Americans have encountered with health care. Once we gain knowledge regarding these historical encounters we will have a better understanding of the African American population. During the slavery periods health care was often unavailable to the African American population and/or their was a deficient in the quality and quantity of care being provided. African Americans were often faced with discrimination such as segregated hospital wards and was also misled by the United States Public Health Service. The United States Public Health service led a Tuskegee syphilis study in which the patients did not receive informed consent and did not receive treatment once it was available(CDC,2013). For these reasons African Americans were more into folklore remedies versus seeking medical treatment.…

    • 1485 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    A doctor is perceived by the public to be an ethical individual who is be able to heal and care for those in need, but in his short story “The Use of Force,” William Carlos Williams depicts a doctor who is called to the Olson home to diagnose his patient with unethical methods. His patient, a girl named Mathilda, is suspected to have diphtheria; however, because of Mathilda’s lack of cooperation, the doctor has no other option to examine but to use force. Through his use of force, the doctor accomplished his goal of diagnosing Mathilda and perhaps saving her life, while his methods of obtaining that goal raise a question about his ethic of using force.…

    • 117 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    When you think of a doctor you think of a remarkable, intelligent human being who works tirelessly every single day to save people’s lives. Doctors are the people who heal others, who cure others, who take care of others. Doctors are a vital part of our society. When people go to the doctor they put their lives in their doctors hands, typically people trust doctors. Unfortunately that is not the case for everyone, some people do not trust doctors because maybe they’ve had a few bad experiences with doctors or in some African American’s case they don’t trust doctors because of what has happened in the past in American history where African Americans are abused and taken advantage of by doctors solely because the color of their skin.…

    • 1166 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1932, a study called The Tuskegee Syphilis study had just begun in Macon County, Alabama. The study in the beginning had involved a small group of 600 black men, and throughout the time of the study’s existence those numbers would change by either death of individual or an addition of a new black man added to the study. In the study, of those 600 men, an estimated 400 were purposely left unaware of the fact that syphilis infected them and they were not being treated for the disease. The main hypothesis in the study was the study of the natural course of syphilis in black male, and there were no questions asked if this was the study was ethically the right thing to do. This study would go on for about 40 years, and end in 1972 due to being exposed in an article by the Associated Press. The exposure of the study would lead the US government and the medical world down a path of change, those changes deal with patient’s knowledge of the experiment and ethics involved in human experimentation.…

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Medical Apartheid

    • 489 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The radio show concerning the medical apartheid discussed the history of medical “tests” conducted on African Americans from colonial times until present. It is disturbing how much many doctors were able to get away with when inhumanly testing on black people. Even up until the 1970’s it was common practice to conduct medical tests specifically on black people. Medical Apartheid was a disturbing practice in America that many doctors justified by suggesting that these African Americans would not have received any medical care if it were not for their testing. These medical professionals were presented with many ethical questions, however, not ethical dilemmas because the issues with what they were dealing with had a clear right and wrong.…

    • 489 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays