Preview

Ain't No Makin' It by Jay MacLeod

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1083 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Ain't No Makin' It by Jay MacLeod
In Ain’t No Makin’ It, Jay MacLeod studies how two groups from the same low class projects, the Hallway Hangers and the Brothers, respond differently to the achievement ideology put forth by school systems. Although both groups live in the same housing development, they all have different school experiences, family situations, and personal lives that ultimately make up their individual habitus, causing different beliefs and attitudes amongst them. The Hallway Hangers have a negative view that rejects the achievement ideology and results in a lack of motivation for social mobility, whereas the Brothers hold a more optimistic view that leads them to believe the achievement ideology that as long as one tries hard they will succeed – an ideology schools reinforce and lead many to believe. Some factors contributing to the habitus of the Hallway Hangers is that they have less authoritative parents, less male figures in the house, less family members whom have graduated, more siblings in prison, less education in siblings, less employed fathers, and have lived in the projects longer. On the other hand, the Brothers have exactly the opposite in their family experiences. Race plays a role in their habitus as well. The Brothers’ parents grew up in a time of racial change that benefited blacks in society, leading the Brothers to feel that if their parents’ generations improved so much, theirs could too. This explains their optimism about social mobility, while affirmative action causes racism in the Hallway Hangers. The many different experiences that shape their habitus contribute to the formation of their beliefs about the achievement ideology. Furthermore, cultural capital, the cultural background, knowledge, and skills passed down generations, stems from one’s habitus. The role of culture capital in how schools reproduce the class structure is evident through the way schools value that of the higher class and devalue that of the lower class. They reward the higher

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Where we come from is a huge part of shaping the development of our character and personality. In reading Lasch’s chapter, “Racial Politics in New York,” it reminded me of Peggy McIntosh’s hypothetical line of social justice. In sum, she argues that race, along with many other factors (race, class, gender, religion, sexuality), can serve as determinate of what side of the line you are on. Whites tend to be on the top with privilege and blacks on the bottom with disadvantage. Thus, one could conclude that two different developments of character and personality arise. Due to the environment that whites are in, they possess qualities of success, opportunity, and good education. Whereas blacks, due to the environments they are exposed to are qualities of crime, violence, and poor education. Therefore, I could argue that although Sleeper is correct when he argues that New York should stress the problem of class divisions as opposed to racial divisions, I believe those class divisions result from racial inequality. However, within that state, although there is social inequality, Lasch would defend that we must commit to being respecting, self-reliant, and responsible, or else we truly have no chance in equalizing or advancing our democratic society. With a heavy emphasis on inequality comes to the challenge of how to approach education and what should be taught in the classroom. Lasch argues that with the…

    • 607 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The book, Ain’t No Makin’ It, allows us to enter the world of two distinct peer groups in a low income housing project in America. Jay MacLeod takes us on a journey to explain why the attitudes, beliefs, expectations, and aspirations of these two groups of teenagers differ so greatly despite their similarities. One of the primary focuses is on education and the Hallway Hangers and Brothers experiences within Lincoln High School. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child are important documents whose intention is to guarantee basic rights to all people, including children, regardless of where they live in the world. Both documents unequivocally state that education is an important and fundamental right for all. After reading this book, it is my belief that the United States falls short in fulfilling the educational rights set forth in these important declarations. The Brothers and Hallway Hangers were not granted an education that promoted tolerance, encouraged attendance, or provided equity in their education.…

    • 1366 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Eaton takes her time illustrating how inner-city students, many from single-parent families of the working poor and from crowded, broken-down neighborhoods, require more support than their suburban counterparts in generously funded schools. Spend a day or a week or a year with many of the students in Room E4, as she did, and the urgent need for improved educational equity becomes clear. Eaton supplements her portrait with accounts of the courtroom progress of Sheff v. O'Neil, a lawsuit striving to make legally clear the "blameless" segregation created by the convergence of zoning regulations, municipal politics, discriminatory housing and banking policies and the creation of suburbs. She demonstrates that de jure segregation has been replaced by de facto segregation. There are few winners in this story, and it's made clear that the problems of our troubled public schools have no easy or quick solution.…

    • 576 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Fainstein’s sociological thesis of what he calls “The Underclass Narrative” was a research study on African Americans in the latter half of the 1970’s. The underclass narrative can be defined as the disadvantaged lack of progression within low income, typically black inner city neighborhoods—a generational reality not captured elsewhere in the U.S. I think what is equally important to point out within this article is that Fainstein makes it clear that the underclass narrative can also be a defined as a universal euphemism for anything black (ie. the general topic of race itself or the poor black “ghetto” experiences). An interestingly written encompass of three key elements that are used to outline a narrative that continues to keep working…

    • 258 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although cultural deprivation plays a huge part in how well working class children achieve compared to middle class children, there are also other factors involved. Both material deprivation and culture capital affect a child’s educational achievements.…

    • 741 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In “Just Walk On By: A Black Man Ponders His Power To Alter Public Space,” Brent Staples discusses the development of standard stereotypes that can not just affect the actions of the victim, but the suspect. Throughout the essay, Staples describes himself in a sequence of events, and proceeds to tell the readers how people around him react. Brent Staples was a tall black man and always faced the same reaction when walking the streets during his late night strolls. People that were walking late as well especially white women would avoid Staples either by crossing the street to avoid him or immediately be quiet and walk faster. Staples, being a six-foot two black man, appeared to be dangerous which caused the white women to cross the street or walk faster. When he is telling this story, he states that “it was clear that she thought…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    “For the most part, class avoidance of class-laden vocabulary crosses class boundaries” (Mantsios 304). There are measurements in salary, physical appearance, and education to determine class. Mantsios studies showed that 34 percent of America’s wealth is held by the one percent, and almost one of every eight people are living below the poverty line ($19,307 dollars for a family of four in 2004). But it is not getting any better, since it has increased approximately $4,000 since then. One of the biggest reasons people are in poverty is because people cannot afford proper education to become well-sustained. It is all dependent on factors beyond our control. Mantsios compared class backgrounds of a life of a white male, whose father is a manufacturer and an industrialist who was enrolled in a prestigious preparatory school, and a black female, whose father a janitor and mother a waitress who lives in the ghetto. Who do you think has more of an advantage in life? The white male, as a result of opportunity handed to…

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Culture is your upbringing, culture is what inspires you and motivates you to get through and be successful in life. In her reading Seeing and Making Culture: Representing the Poor, she shares with us what she learned from her family members: “… not to believe that “schooling made you smart.” One could have degrees and still not be intelligent or honest. I had been taught in the culture of poverty to be intelligent, honest, to work hard, and always to be a person of my word.” Instead of being ashamed, she is inspired by what being raised in poverty taught her. She describes throughout her reading that poverty isn’t always what is shown by the media, that there are people who are happier with the little that have than those who have it…

    • 588 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Lareau Scenario

    • 412 Words
    • 2 Pages

    A student’s ability and family background were found to have little impact on grades, but cultural capital was found to have an impact on grades. In other words, the more cultural capital one had, the higher student’s grades tended to be.…

    • 412 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Middle class children have a higher tendency of achieving more than pupils of the working class. A few explanations pay attention on the external factors outside school. This includes cultural deprivation – working class pupils are portrayed as having a lack of correct attitude, values, language and knowledge for educational success. Whilst material deprivation means that working class pupils are most likely to have poorer diets, health and housing and their parents are less able to meet the hidden costs of schooling. The middle class have mote cultural capital – they have a better advantage of their choices within the marketised education system.…

    • 1373 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cultural Capital: “refers to noneconomic goods, such as family background and education, which are reflected in knowledge of language and the arts. Also, it refers to the kind of education that is valued by the socially elite” (Schaefer, p. 13).…

    • 1762 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Wright conducted a study about academic achievement among successful African American male adolescents. In his article, I Know Who I Am, Wright denotes that “For many young African American men, academic success can come at high costs…” (612). The cost is not only high for young African American men but also young women. When a young black man or woman is seen a successful they are deemed as a threat to their peers. They become a social outcast within their own race. According to Wright, academic success within in the black race to those who are not successful is seen as “acting white” (I Know Who I Am 612). Racial stereotypes are hindering the advancement of the African American race because of the need for a high racial-ethnic identity (HREI). Therefore the racial stereotype that African Americans are uneducated prevents those who have the desire to be educated from getting there, because of the need to be accepted by their race. Why does an educated African American have pretend to be a stereotype when he or she is beyond…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Organisational Cultures

    • 15155 Words
    • 61 Pages

    The concept of culture has become increasingly significant in education during the 1990s and into the twenty-first century. This enhanced interest may be understood as an example of dissatisfaction with the limitations of those leadership and man- agement models which stress the structural and technical aspects of schools and colleges. The focus on the intangible world of values and attitudes is a useful counter to these bureaucratic assumptions and helps to produce a more balanced portrait of educational institutions. Culture relates to the informal aspects of organisations rather then their official elements. They focus on the values, beliefs and norms of individuals in the organi- sation and how these individual perceptions coalesce into shared meanings. Culture is manifested by symbols and rituals rather than through the formal structure of the organization:…

    • 15155 Words
    • 61 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Despite having the desire to work hard for achievement, some minorities still had few options. In Richard Wright’s short story Native Son, he described why his actions lead to the murder of a young woman while his lawyer was setting up a court argument, “Why should I want to do anything? I ain’t got a chance. I don’t know nothing. I’m just black and they make the laws. /.../ I wanted to be an aviator once. But they wouldn’t let me go to the school where I was suppose’ to learn it.” Due to his lack of options, (said character) suffered from the issue of white power in society and resorted to actions that began from the way he was treated. Having a lack of opportunity is demonstrated in Hidden Figures when the narrator describes the unnecessary obstacles that Mary had to go through to become an engineer just because of her ethnicity and gender. “If Mary had applied for a job as janitor, the doors to the school would swing wide open. As a professional engineer-in-training with a plan to occupy the building for the nefarious purpose of advancing her education, she needed to petition the city of Hampton for “special permission” to attend classes in the whites-only school. ”…

    • 947 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Money Matters

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages

    It's no secret that schools in high-income communities are better than those in low- income communities, or the fact that students are being better prepared for desirable jobs. It’s astonishing to learn how huge the difference in education from wealthy communities and those from a poor community. In “Social Class and the Hidden Curriculum of Work” by Jean Anyon, Anyon observes five different schools for a whole school year of fifth graders; two working class schools, one middle-class school, one affluent professional school, and an executive elite school. Anyon’s research indicated that students are being prepared to occupy particular jobs on the social ladder. Students are being set on course of education to prepare them for jobs within their own social economic status.…

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays