Preview

American Civil Service Act Pros And Cons

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1115 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
American Civil Service Act Pros And Cons
The Pendleton Civil Service Act
According to Kaufman in 1954, “...the Civil Service was like a hammer or a saw; it would do nothing at all by itself, but would serve any purpose, wise or unwise, good or bad, to which any user put it.” In the aftermath of the American Civil War, attempts were made to reduce patronage. As a result in 1883, the Civil Service created a Civil Service Commission under the Pendleton Civil Service Act. The Pendleton Civil Service Act disesteemed the spoil system to create a merit system called the Civil Service Commission which classified government jobs and created a competitive test for them.
By the time Andrew Jackson was elected president in 1828, the Spoils System was in full in which political friends and
…show more content…
The Pendleton Civil Service Act was signed into law by President Chester Arthur in 1883, and was named after its sponsor Senator George H. Pendleton. The act suggested that the president appoint a standing Civil Service Commission consisted of three members who were required to organize competitive examinations and test applicants fitness for them in order to retain a federal job. In order for the president to remove any commissioner or fill any vacancy, he must have advice and consent of the senate. Federal employees may not be required to subsidize to campaign funds or be fired for political reasons . “Neutrality was a primary value (Milkovich).” The Pendleton Civil Service Act was created to reform the United States Civil Service. Although President George Washington made most of federal appointments based on merit, consecutive presidents began to deviate from this policy. Therefore, the act suggested Government jobs be awarded based on merit rather than political affiliation which was emphasized on common sense, practical information and general goals. The merit system grew as politics …show more content…
In later decades, the Pendleton Act expanded until most federal jobs were classified. When the act first went into effect, only 10 percent of the Government’s 132,000 employees were covered. “Today, more than 90 percent of the 2.7 million Federal employees are covered (United states).” Many machine politicians are still offended today and debate about which approach is a disadvantage to the democratic party. According to local leader of New York City’s Democratic Party George Plunkit, “you can’t keep an organization together without patronage.” He also stated, “men ain’t in politics for nothing. They want to get somethin’ out of it.” The merit system helped shape the government, yet many politicians are unsatisfied because they are no longer capable of election their friends or supports for government

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Apush Chapter 23 Summary

    • 2806 Words
    • 12 Pages

    39. Pendleton Act – This was what some people called the Magna Carta of civil-service reform. It prohibited, at least on paper, financial assessments on jobholders. It created a merit system of making appointments to government jobs on the basis of aptitude rather than who you know, or the spoils system. It set up a Civil Service Commission, chaired with administering open competitive examinations to applicants for posts in the classified service. The people were forced, under this law, to take an exam before being hired to a governmental job position.…

    • 2806 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the Jacksonian Era from about 1828-1842, the Democrats set the standard to be carried on later by the Populists. The Jacksonian Democrats identified with the common man. They wanted all democrats to agree. In 1828, Andrew Jackson was elected president and he was later reelected in 1832. In the year of his reelection, Jackson established the spoils system to reform the government, removing some federal officeholders ("To the victor belong the spoils") and made the right of elected officials to appoint their own followers to public office and established feature of American politics. Also in this year, Jackson vetoed the bill to recharter the Bank of the United States. This sets the tone for his, and the Democrats, ongoing battle with the Bank and its president, Nicholas Biddle, later to rise to climax when Jackson removed federal deposits from the Bank of the United States. A year later, in 1833, the nullification crisis erupted, pushing Jackson and his Democrats into another battle, this one with John Calhoun and nullification. Jackson insisted that nullification was treason and those implementing it were traitors. The nullification crisis was averted by compromise: the lowering of the tariff of 1828, the tariff of abominations, gradually be lowered. Jackson believed in a distinct, but simple theory of democracy, that it should offer "equal protection and equal benefits" to all its white male citizens and favor no region of class over another. This meant an assault on what he considered the citadels of the eastern…

    • 685 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jackson’s sweeping presidential victory in 1828 represented the political triumph of the New Democracy, including the spoils-rich political machines that thrived in the new environment. Jackson’s simple, popular ideas and rough-hewn style reinforced the growing belief that any ordinary person could hold public office. The “Tariff of Abominations” and the…

    • 544 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Appointed to the U.S. Civil Service Commission by President Benjamin Harrison. During which time, he vigorously pressed for the strict enforcement of the civil service laws. (1889-1895)…

    • 2541 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The changes that Andrew Jackson represent in American political life are a spoils system, he removed the Natives and expanded the country onto native lands.…

    • 458 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Furthermore, politically, Jackson put in place the spoils system where he took out many people voted into government office in favor of those who supported his own partisan views. This in itself was a very corrupt decision that eliminated many people from the government that were put into office by way of democracy and instead, Jackson put in place people based on party loyalty who were not necessarily qualified for their job in place of competence and likability by the…

    • 376 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Secondly, the “Spoils System” was created by Andrew Jackson to help his presidency in many ways. The Spoils System was replacing the government officials with his own supporters or friends. Another way of putting this was to give a chance to common men, who was never involved government offices. Jackson's opponent thought that this was corrupt. But he still defended it. This made him think about the Native Americans, The rights of the States, and The National Bank of United States.…

    • 741 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Andrew Jackson Presidency

    • 3326 Words
    • 14 Pages

    final acts in office, President Jackson was regarded as a great hero, yet at the same time…

    • 3326 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Tyranny of Andrew Jackson

    • 2180 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Not only were these jobs given to those without experience, but at times the appointee’s were conniving and slimy. The best example of this would be former army comrade Samuel Swartwout. Jackson appointed Swartwout as the collector of the New York City customhouse, where the US government collected almost half of its annual revenue. After a couple years in the job, Swartwout fled with over $1 million dollars, equal to a bit more than $29,850,000 today. (measuringworth.com) (Andrew Jackson: Domestic Affairs). After this debacle among others, the rotation in public service eventually lowered the prestige and rank of government service (Van Deusen 36).…

    • 2180 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The practice of patronage was very popular during the Gilded Age. If a politician won an election, he would give his supporters jobs in public office. The office holder would also pay part of his salary to who he supported. The assassination of a second President in office, James Garfield, would spark the passing of the Pendleton Act in 1883. President Garfield was assassinated when a man, Charles Guiteau, assisted Garfield during his campaign and wasn’t rewarded for his service. Congress would pass the Pendleton Act, which created the Civil Service Commission to ensure that hiring of federal employees was based on examination and merit rather than political patronage. This would include a new, competitive examination which became required to take in order to hold public office. While the Pendleton Act was successful in putting patronage to rest, politicians had to find a new source of income in order to fill their pockets. Politicians would now rely on funding from big business. The Pendleton Act might have ended patronage, but it brought on a new kind of corruption into politics.…

    • 843 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Gilded Age Dbq

    • 1678 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Pendleton Civil Service Act - The Pendleton Civil Service Reform Act was a United States Federal Law imposed in 1883. This Act established that positions and jobs in the federal government must be awarded based on merit, not by personal or political affiliation or favoritism.…

    • 1678 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Politics is a regular business that needs experienced people. Plunkitt seldom discusses political issues but only the benefits of government. Plunkitt complains that New York is taxed to provide benefits to the rest of the state. Each political party cooperates with the other. Civil Service was created to undermine the political parties and their organizations. It makes them dependent on corporate support to this day. Municipal ownership of utilities would benefit a city . Plunkitt compares a political organization to churches; both need money to exist. A candidate for office needs money for campaign expenses. That still goes on even if a candidate gets the money from others.A successful politician, like a saloon owner, does not drink. Political bosses prevent turmoil and squabbles. They are opposed by those who wish to gain their power. High taxes on saloon keepers creates lower-cost competition from "bucket-shops"…

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Merit System Analysis

    • 2610 Words
    • 11 Pages

    It was George Washington and his men of courage that really started this performance based government system in my mind. During President Washington's time in office, it was very common for the men who displayed excellence on the battlefield to be granted high-ranking government positions. This was at a time in our country when the war and battle heroes were placed on pedestals, in addition these men were the educated men who led us into battle. So in the public mind, George Washington and his men of courage were ideal for these positions based on their performance in battle. This system was brought out in the movie, "The Patriot", with Mel Gibson being a hero in battle, but was also looked at as a political figure with a voice in the senate. Then the performance-based government took a wide turn for change with the system that President Andrew Jackson introduced called the spoils system. "To the victor goes, the spoils." This was the type of government that was favored by Jackson and typically meant that if you support my political affiliation and I am victorious, at that point you will be taken care of in return. To an extent, I agree with taking care of people who support you along the way, however I disagree with placing political supporters in very important government, political, and partisan positions. So in the early years of our nations government, we were ran by presidency that favored performance based style of government and then by one that necessarily did not favor a performance based government. We live in an era today that uses campaigns, debates, commercials, primaries and elections to inform you of the individual, who is seeking an office and what party he or she is represent. Once this person is in office there are certain things that he or she has the power to do and not to do. Congress passed the…

    • 2610 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    One thing common to both a civil servant and a public servant is the fact that they are both officials in government departments, and though they are termed servants, they are actually bred and brought up to feel superior to common people. Both have an umbrella of security in the sense that their jobs are guaranteed, even if they are average or poor performers, and this sense…

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Ccs Rules

    • 14234 Words
    • 57 Pages

    (i) who are appointed to civil services and posts including civilian Government servants in the Defence Services in connection with the affairs of the Union;…

    • 14234 Words
    • 57 Pages
    Powerful Essays