Preview

American Experiences: The Man Who Changed His Skin

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
Bibliographical Citation:
Sharpe Jr., Ernest. “The Man Who Changed His Skin.” American Experiences: Reading in American History Volume II from 1877. Seventh Edition. Randy Roberts and James S.Olsen. United States: Pearson Education Inc, 2008.240-250. Print.

Main Point of the Article:
The article’s main purpose was to give an idea of racism through the perspective of a white man in the shoes of a black man. In the article, the author gives a brief account of the life of an unusual man who for short period of time posed as a black man in a racist society. The article highlights some of his life achievements, emphasizing one of his greatest- his quest to understand racism firsthand by ‘temporarily becoming black’.
Why is the article significant?
…show more content…

In regards to Griffin, he says, “It is hard to imagine a person worse suited than Griffin to pass for black. A cultural epicure who had spent his adolescence in France and lived a blind, sheltered existence for the previous decade, Griffin had remarkably little in common with Southern whites, let alone with blacks” (248). Though this may have him slightly awkward when interacting with both races, I believe these qualities made him the best candidate for the task he wanted to undertake in discovering the degree of racism in the South. Because of these qualities, i.e. not being raise in the American racial society, being a cultural epicure, being sheltered, and even being blind, I felt equipped him, if it’s safe to say, with the ‘naivety’ he needed to have an experience free from biasness. This we see in his reaction and comments to some of the acts of discrimination and violence towards him, he was shocked, and I interpreted that as his naivety to the situation. I felt his novel on his experience spoke volumes because of its tint of non-biasness. This is what I believe prompted the authors comment about the book “Black Like Me”, that “there was too much of the author, too little of others”. Griffin experience was personal, from his perspective. Including others, I believe would have lead to biasness of the report. I argue against the author’s perspective that Griffin’s work was ‘imperfect’ because of this. I say that it was the exact factor that was needed, i.e. the explanation of racism from a personal standpoint; this is what I believe gave voice to the book “Black Like

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Black Like Me Book Report

    • 2124 Words
    • 9 Pages

    In the late 1950’s John Griffin, a white journalist and specialist on race issues from Texas, made the decision to experience the racial south as a black man in order to help him more understand the suicide rates. John documented his life changing experience first-hand as a Negro and the discrimination based on skin color.…

    • 2124 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    As a fictive tale, the novel leaves one speechless and appalled by the ignorance once held prior to reading, wholly unaware of the horrors individuals faced in the North, and the cruelty that even free African Americans were exposed to, one could not be blamed for harshly judging individuals, like Frado, who look racially ambivious, for choosing to pass as a European American. After receiving an enlightening re-education, one who reads the work of James Weldon Johnson, The Autobiography of an Ex-Colored Man, may not choose to judge the novel’s protagonist as a criminal, as he does, but view it as a mechanism for survival. Johnson’s novel shares similar themes with Our Nig regarding identity, race and freedom to an African American individual of racially ambiviliant appearance. Wilson’s work allows the reader to sympathize with Johnson’s unnamed narrator, and his betrayal of the African American race by passing for a Caucasian American, even though he is unable to forgive himself.…

    • 665 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Although the Civil War left slaves under the impression that they had won their freedom, blacks were still constantly the target of discrimination and it took many years for them to finally gain equality. In James Weldon Johnson 's The Autobiography of an Ex-Colored Man, a story is told through the eyes of a man in this troubling time, who learns in his early childhood that he is black, but with the ability to pass as a white man. Throughout his life he develops and fights a conflicted opinion: whether to live safely as a white man, or acknowledge his racial identity and act to advance his own race. Having been passed as a white by his mother the first several years of his life, with no knowledge of being in any way different from his white companions, the lines of race in America soon became blurred. This gave him the advantage of seeing and understanding both sides of the race issue. This man, half-white half-black and of very light complexion, was forced to choose between his heritage and the art that he loved and the ability to escape the inherent racism that he faced by passing as a white. This man learned about and struggles with his identity; he made his way through each of the social classes, became a linguist, and learned the tongues of the different people and through this becomes his own person. Above all, the ex-colored man realized the distorting influences in which colored men act upon in the U.S. in the post-Reconstruction era. These influences were external, a result of the societal pressures around him and the actions of others.…

    • 1847 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Black Like Me

    • 543 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Black Like Me was written by John Howard Griffin about his adventure in some southern states and what he observed when he pigmented his skin to be an African American; who at the time was being discriminated against. Throughout his experiment he experienced many things including racism, discrimination, and survival. Griffin was a privileged southern white from Texas. During the pigmentation process he set out for New Orleans, once the procedure was done completely, he seen things as a black man. The restaurants he went to as a white man did not tolerate the colored. He went to a shoe shiner who he had previously met as a white didn’t recognize him. Griffin then entrusted him with his secret about his experiment. He came by a couple days later and then began his journey to the other southern states, such as Mississippi, Alabama, and Georgia.…

    • 543 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In My Black Skin Makes My White Coat Vanish, Mana Lumumba-Kasongo writes about an issue many minorities experience: not being believed to have a prestigious occupation. Lumumba-Kasongo is a doctor—a black one. There are many occupations in the United States that are made up primarily of white men: doctor, judge, chief executive officer, special operation forces, etc. Unfortunately, it shocks people to learn that someone of a different skin color and gender achieved one of those positions. This is just another example of racism beneath society’s surface and proves it does not need to be overt and violent. Lumumba-Kasongo reflects on different circumstances in which she was viewed as incapable of fulfilling her duties as a doctor because of…

    • 323 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There is a spontaneous vivid description of his childhood years and origins in which he describes some of the main reasons for anti-White sentiments. The author effectively sustains the reader’s interest with the development of different conflicts. Each chapter contained dramatic, suspenseful and action-packed accounts until the end. Inclusion of famous quotations and powerful speeches makes the narration more powerful and captivating, especially in the last chapters.…

    • 1078 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the society we live in we interact with people of all different types of race, ethnicity, and gender. Even though we are all human, we are still separated by the social stereotypes in which our race, sex or gender play major roles as to how we are treated in society. Blind to the eyes of the ignorant people who fail to believe racism sill exist. The issues of prejudice, discrimination and racism are deeply rooted in the shaping of today’s society. This was made clear to me in the analysing of the 2006 film Crash.…

    • 358 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Black Like Me

    • 666 Words
    • 3 Pages

    An incident that really showed America the persisting problem of racism was when Griffin tried to cash a check but was rudely denied the right to do such on several occasions. It’s clear that this was a racist remark because Griffin, an African American, knew that as a White man he would have never been treated with such incivility. Another proof that the Whites considered only skin color is because every time he walked into a store they became sour as it says, “Their smiles turned to grimaces” (pg. 47). This really showed America that the segregation and bad attitude towards African Americans had nothing to do with nature of their character, but rather only with the colour of their skin. This really opened up America’s eyes about the ugly truth of racism…

    • 666 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Black Like Me Reflections

    • 296 Words
    • 2 Pages

    John Howard Griffin pivoted in and out of an African American life for no more than 2 years, yet he was called upon to speak for the blacks on problems they have suffered their whole life. At lectures, Griffin is respected and praised for telling the truth, something that would not be accepted if the same words came out of an African American's mouth. The whites see it as "submitting" their superiority to the blacks if they (believe it or not) actually listened and took opinions from a colored man, an idea they are not comfortable with. Therefore, they place Griffin in a uncomfortable position where he tells the white men exactly what the black men would have said. In other words, he becomes a bridge between white and black communities and speaks on their behalf. From these experiences, Griffin is able to solidify his belief that whites are largely prejudiced towards blacks; in fact, they would rather hear a testimony from a relatively inexperienced white man, than have to suffer the humiliation of hearing the same testimony an African American. The credibility of a person's word depended wholly on their pigmentation, and in this case, a colored person's opinion was questioned, critisized, and rejected. Unfortunately, this was just another instance of racial…

    • 296 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    In reading this essay, we found that we agreed with the argument that there is somewhat of a ‘pecking order’ of oppression that results from the intersection of race and gender. We disagreed with, however, the idea that Sula’s version of agency is the only version or ‘correct’ version, and that Nel and Helene somehow betray their race by not having the same type of agency. We believed that the intersection of race and gender creates a different type of discrimination: a white woman and a black woman will have different experiences based upon their skin tone, and even though they are both women, are also not equal in social and institutional status. We argue that black women are at the bottom of the ‘ladder’, and white men are at the top. In…

    • 1620 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Identity has been a major concern of African and African American authors from the beginning. In fact African American identity underwent drastic transformations between the eighteenth century and twentieth century. As Amistad, "Federalist No. 54", The New Negro and The Souls of Black Folks shows, African American identity has shifted from an early tribal identity, to a dehumanized identity based in slavery, and finally to a ‘new' type of Negro identity based in art and African origins. These transformations of identity have been a tremendous struggle that were produced by their exploitation by white America.…

    • 1508 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In our current society “playing the race card” is often heard. Many people are against the use of the terms black or white. The mentioning of race has been stated as being antagonistic to the whole belief of anti-racism and non-racialism which is constitutionally embedded. A lot of people have made claims that the earlier people move beyond racial thinking the better the principles of anti-racism and non-racialism will be implemented, but most people world-wide do not know the meaning of Anti-racism and Non- racism and take it to be the same meaning, the purpose of this essay is to differentiate between Anti-racism and Non- racism, the essay begins by give brief definitions of terms that will be used in the essay and goes on to give detailed…

    • 151 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Within bell hooks’ chapter entitled, Representing Whiteness in the Black Imagination, which was published in the edited volume, Cultural Studies, hooks addresses the term “whiteness” in regards to suspicion, fear, and hatred, all of which are coming from an angry place in the minds of a black person. As a consequence of white racist domination, many black people do not know how to separate themselves from “whiteness”, leaving them unable to see themselves as their own person. This essay will primarily focus on how “whiteness” is a privilege, whereas the “other”, in this case, coloured people, are often left defeated. This essay will also explore the ‘idea’ that racism no longer exists, and incorporate other authors such as Ruth Frankenberg,…

    • 142 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    rodriguez versus harris

    • 2222 Words
    • 9 Pages

    In the essay, “Complexion”, Richard Rodriguez describes the effect of his dark complexion on his self-image as he grew from a child into a man in order to heal himself, understand how his dark complexion became the governor of his existence and also to help readers interpret their own beliefs regarding their own metaphorical “complexion.” He uses a surprisingly light tone to describe his feelings and issues with his complexion by giving readers an honest, broad, chronological and realistic set of his life experiences.…

    • 2222 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The dynamics are in fact harshened by the mere fact that colour is perceived as a marker of identity, thus the social inferiority does not only stem from a territorial element but mainly from a racial one, according to which the symbolic association between place, colour offers an evaluation of social properties and values. Hence members of the American black community living in ghettos suffer from what the author calls conjugated stigmatization, cumulating the negative symbolic value attached to both colour and territory. Consequently, if there is a way to escape stigmatization for French inhabitants of the Red Belt (even if temporary), the possibility for American ghetto residents to do the same is highly improbable, thus being necessary for the latter to learn how to survive despite the unacceptable…

    • 910 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays