ESL 118
Prof. Shields
April 7, 2014
Final Draft
An image that speaks
Some photos never leave one’s memory. The photo that I choose for this essay is one such photo. It is the Pulitzer prize-winning photograph taken in 1994 in Sudan by Kevin Carter during the Sudan famine depicting a child about to die of starvation with a large vulture type bird in the background waiting for child’s impending death. The question I want to discuss in this essay concerning the photo “the starving child and the vulture” photograph, is how does this photo illustrate some of the terms that Barbie Zelizer uses in her essay “ The voice of the Visual Memory” including: collective memory, subjunctive voice, third meaning and the about to die moment and the rhetorical terms to describe this photo?
Koeller 2
This photograph was produced by Kevin Carter, the Pulitzer award –winning photographer, who in March of 1993 went on a trip to Sudan. Carter photographed the poverty that people faced in Sudan . He was getting ready to photograph a starving young little girl who was trying to reach a feeding center when a vulture landed behind her. As he was taking his pictures, Carter was told that he was not allowed to touch any of the starving children, because they had contagious diseases. It was said that he waited about 20 minutes hoping that the vulture would spread its wings. He did chase the vulture but he did not help the little girl.(Macleod,1994) A few months later after Carter received the Pulitzer he took his own life committing suicide as a result of his sad experience with this little girl. In the “Time” magazine article following Carter’s suicide the article portrays the guilt that Carter felt and how “ even some of Carter’s friend wondered aloud why he had not helped the girl” ( MacLeod. 1994). The photographer purpose for publishing this photo was to get the world’ s attention on the poverty and hunger and misery that Africa was dealing with and also to encourage help from humanitarian organizations. This image is incredibly powerful because it visually shows the terrible conditions of people in poverty. The pathos of this picture causes the audience to be extremely distressed especially when innocent children are involved. As a result, they feel the need to help the people of Sudan in any way possible. When looking at this picture, the child appears naked skeletal and does not look to have a chance of surviving. She looks as if she has collapsed without any source of strength in her limp body of skin and bones. Even the ground that the child is laying on shows no signs of life. Koeller 3
The ground shows a lack of water and moisture. The most disturbing part of this picture is the vulture in the background which appears to be waiting for the child to become its prey. The colors of this photo are very important to the viewer. If the photo had been in black and white, it would not have given the same effect to the viewer. The colors of different shades of brown in the background of the picture show the lack of life and add to the reality of the suffering child. The color of the photo makes possible for the audience to immediately focus right way into the two characters in the photo. Barbie Zelizer in her essay " The Voice of the Visual Memory" suggest and elaborates on how different visual images effect a person’s collective memory. Collective memory refers to social groups who construct their own images by constantly shaping and reshaping the past. Zelizer says “ that images such as portraits ,pictures, photographs, films –which constitute a cogent means tackling the past and making it work for the present.(186). This photo makes the viewer realize that there are still starving children in the world like this little girl. She mentions how images are important because “they help us remember the past freezing it’s representation at a powerful moment already known to us.”( 186). When one looks at Carter’s photo of the starving child, it forever remains in the mind of the viewer. If the same information were given to the audience through printed words, the impact would not be the same. Zelizer states this idea when she says, “how we remember through images remains powerfully different from how we might remember the same event were images not involved”(186).
Koeller 4
When the viewer sees the picture above they think about the tragedy of death by starvation and the problems of hunger in the world. In addition to this, if we would have just only read about the story without an image we might have not remembered this event as a tragic moment. What does this powerful image of a vulture who is looking for his prey, the child, do to our collective memory? As Zelizer says, it “makes us remember the past by freezing its representation at a powerful moment known to us” (186).
Looking at the picture many viewers might have different opinions whether or not this little girl was rescued. People could say “ This person might have not survived” or “maybe she did”. At this point the audience might be hoping that the photographer that took the picture could help her. I think this photograph relates to Zelizer’s article. She defines this moment as the subjunctive voice. She says that this is a way a photo allows us to think about multiple alternative possibilities. She writes “ that by freezing the sequencing midway at a particularly memorable representational moment, spectators are able to embellish numerous imaginary schemes on the“about to” moment that is depicted in sequencing of action ( 192) .This photograph illustrates Zelizer’s term in her essay, subjunctive voice, which “offers and apt way of depicting the difficult topic of death” .( 193) The audience responds strongly to this photo because makes the viewer wonder what the final outcome was for this little girl. Was she helped or did she die? Also the audience is wonders if the child will die of starvation or will she be killed by the vulture in the background. This demonstrates the subjunctive voice because you have to try to fill in missing information to draw a conclusion as to what happened in this situation. Koeller 5
The third meaning can be used to analyze my photo. Zelizer in her essay explains that there is a first and second meaning. The first meaning is defined as literal and informational. Zelizer explains that the first meaning is “ photographs work through a denotative force that is connected with verisimilitude, or the ability of the image to reference things “as they are”(187). When the viewer sees the photograph of the starving child, the viewer understands that it is an image of a suffering child. This is the first meaning of the photo.
The second meaning is defined as a symbolic dimension. Zelizer explains that the second meaning is “ photographs that through connotative force are connected with symbolism and is capable of invoking and repairing to broad symbolic systems that draw on certain meanings for the visual representation that are displayed. ( 187) . In the background of the photo of the starving child is a vulture like bird that seems to be waiting for its prey. This is symbolic of death. The vulture becomes the death symbol of the dying child and even makes the viewer wonder if it will even be the cause of death.
The third meaning is defined as “ drawing off or connecting to a reoccurring visual element in our “ collective memory”. It is going back or making us connect with other experiences in our lives to make us remember. Zelizer quotes Barthes that the third meaning “is difficult to locate because it is not situated structurally or in a certain place of the image”(187). The third meaning of the picture of the starving child is different for everyone. To me the image brings thoughts of the past when I was in danger and feeling hopeless. The image brings about fear of the unknown.
Koeller 6
Zelizer’s term “the about to die moment” is also illustrated in this photo. The gruesome image of death was not used in this photo, but the viewer is given an image which shows that death is almost inevitable. The “about to die moment” in this photo is horrific enough to the audience. Zelizer states, “the image tells the story of what happened at a point just before the end of its unfolding(195). The choice of using the about to die moment seems to used because that is what the journalist and photographer wanted to see. It almost seems that the photographer thinks that the public can’t deal with the truly newsworthy subject of death. Therefore, they chose to depict something that gives reference to death without giving all of the detail.
This photo of the starving girl with the vulture in the background is a horrific picture that stays in the collective memory of the viewer. It is a photo that never leaves one’s memory. It will not have been taken in vain, if it inspires people to help other starving children in the same condition of this little girl.
Works Cited
Zelizer, Barbie, “The Voice of the Visual Memory.”
Carter, K. (1999). 1994 Pulitzer Prize winner, Retrieved October 10,2011,from http//pulitzerprize.orf/files/2009/07kevin-carter-1994.jpg.
MacLeod, S (1994, September), The life and death of Kevin Carter, Tine,144. Retrieved from http://members.home.nl/gerhardnijenhuis/msp/time.htm
Cited: Zelizer, Barbie, “The Voice of the Visual Memory.” Carter, K. (1999). 1994 Pulitzer Prize winner, Retrieved October 10,2011,from http//pulitzerprize.orf/files/2009/07kevin-carter-1994.jpg. MacLeod, S (1994, September), The life and death of Kevin Carter, Tine,144. Retrieved from http://members.home.nl/gerhardnijenhuis/msp/time.htm
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In the essay, The Boston Photographs, Nora Ephron argues that it is “irresponsible” and more “inaccurate” that newspapers show pictures of death unless they come from the Associated Press Wire (Ephron 172). The Boston Photographs is one of the reasons why Ephron feels that way. The Boston Photographs are a series of photographs of a fireman trying to rescue a lady and a child from a burning building. As the fireman reaches for the rescue ladder the fire escape they were standing on collapse, which causes the lady and child to fall from the top of a five-story building. Stanley Forman, the photographer who took the pictures, captures just about everything from the fire escape breaking to nearly the lady and child hitting the ground. Unfortunately, the 19 year old Diana Bryant did not survive the horrible fall, but the child did by landing on Diana’s body. This whole incident caused quite a stir with the press.…
- 429 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
words and images are masterfully combined, as shown in image 1. This image is one of…
- 822 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
This photograph has two main purposes: to commemorate a loved man who was murdered and to point out the injustice of his murder. There is a painting of this man with clouds behind him signifying he was a great man who is now in a better place, however, the man is covered in red and there is a large amount of red underneath him on the curb representing the bloodshed of his unfair death. Right in the center of this photograph written very largely across the wall of the building is the phrase, "When you take someone's life, you forfeit your own." There are also flowers that people have placed in the surrounding area, somewhat like a grave site. These things represent the people's opinion about this man and the killing.…
- 631 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Photography is not just used to show an event; photography is used to capture the details, feelings, and thoughts of something – it provides a compelling representation of the author’s view. All this is done by Jacob Riis’s How the Other Half Lives, where the reader is informed about the hideous conditions that the poor had to face in New York City. Riis uses detailed images, facts with statistics, and examples to create an image to the reader of what these people go through in their everyday lives. Using this process, Riis is able to create an important image, which allows the reader to imagine the conditions of these people, make a change to help these poor people, and to promote and inform the public of these conditions, which allows for…
- 705 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Alcohol has been produced by humans for over 12,000 years many ancient farming efforts were undertaken not so much for the food alcohol has impacted every society since caveman times in one way or another. Some have used it in worship rituals, some in social customs, some have had widespread social problems with alcohol and have banned it altogether.…
- 576 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Americans enjoy more personal freedoms than any country in the world, but, since the attacks on the “World Trade Center” and the “Pentagon” on 9-11-2011, and the subsequent passing of the “Patriot Act”, the American way of life has been forever changed, and a lot of the personal, private freedoms Americans enjoy are gone. The text in the center of the art piece sets the tone. It forces the viewer to ask themselves the question. Are we really free?…
- 1399 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
The reading first starts off by talking about the photograph of her father. I think this is a good example of how images shape someone’s life. They tell stories, hold memories, and share the past. I believe this when the author states this passage: “This snapshot was taken before marriage, before us, his seven children, before our presence in his life forced him to leave behind the carefree masculine identity this pose conveys.” (Bell Hooks. “In Our Glory: Photography and Black Life.” Rhetorical Visions.…
- 492 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The Coca-Cola companies' website portrays a plentiful amount of information and images to its visitors. It seems to have a very calm mood embedded into the site.…
- 538 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The composer of The Shoe Horn Sonata, John Misto, utilizes projected imagery in a way to create effective visual impacts that bring the audience to an understanding of the P.O.W camp. In Act One, Scene Five Misto uses a photograph of starving children, who are the innocent victims of war. These photographs are used to take the modern audience who weren’t there back to the times of the P.O.W camps and help them understand the nature and effects the camp had on the individuals. This creates distinctive visual impacts towards the audience or reader by letting the images stay on the screen whilst there is no acting, this helps the audience take in the full effect.…
- 1002 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
However, this particular person carries a strong ethos because of the trustworthy web sight producing the image. A volunteer who works for Chris Relief associated with Crimea receives credit for this photo. Chris Relief is a nonprofit, Christian run organization, which strives to aid those in need during times of war and after disastrous events such as earthquakes, floods, and terrorism. Since this foundation is nonprofit, the author’s career does not revolve around the pictures he or she chooses to produce. The author decided to actually take action and expose a type of hypocrisy commonly found on social media. Hypocrisy being when one tells followers to like the post to advocate understanding, then follows by performing no action to aid the situation explained in the image. This particular picture emphasise dread and discomfort. A primary example of imagery representing dread for this picture is the one legged child lying in a hospital bed as a consequence of either malnutrition or violence. While the child grieves, people surround him with their thumbs up which shows how out of touch with reality some social media users are. Another example of imagery comes from the color, or lack thereof, in the photo. Only two colors, black and white, appear in the photo, which symbolizes the troubles faced by groups of people during conflicts. The volunteer seems well educated on this matter of social media although he/she appears to have a slight bias against social media. Some social media posts actually do benefit a charity or cause. For example, the ice bucket challenge, although silly, raised tremendous awareness for ALS patients throughout the country. The credibility of the author stays in tact despite the slight…
- 1040 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
There is a vulture in the background watching her; waiting for her to die. This eye-opening picture brings awareness to the, often overlooked, issue of people starving in other countries because it gives a strong sense of emotion, a strong sense of determination, and a desire to be more compassionate. This picture conveys an emotional message of the mighty versus the weak because most people can relate to this on some level. To relate to something means to show a connection or have something in common.…
- 640 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Entering college comes with a new sense of freedom to do whatever a person wants. Partying and drinking, be it legal or illegal, is one of these freedoms. Its common, even encouraged and pressured that while out we partake in drinking and getting “wasted”. This has become a common stigma about college, and binge drinking has become a serious problem on all U.S. college campus. In an attempt to bring awareness of consequences of binge drinking Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board released a series of Public Service Announcements and launched a website to educate its target young audience to be careful while drinking. The public service announcements use very specific image and text placement, typography, and color to make their message evident in the still PSAs.…
- 914 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Advertisements are the most commonly used way to sell and market a product or message. Although we may not realize it while watching or seeing the advertisement, there are many underlying factors that cause us to buy into the advertisement. Whether it may be the color, picture, text, or sound; the advertisers find a way to draw us in without even a second thought. Many advertisers focus on guilt, they try to find a soft spot with in us by showing us those that are less fortunate than us. “Don’t you feel bad that you are so fortunate and these people are living like this? Give to them, help them, give up your luxuries, and share with them.” This is the message that many companies and organizations are trying to convey when they post advertisements showing people in third world countries struggling. Cordaids advertisements are making big spenders in America feel guilty in order to help their cause of helping the less fortunate in third world countries.…
- 955 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The picture that the reader had to analyze was about a family being destroyed by misery. The family looked as if they were hungry, poor, and sick. The young children looks like their life was ripped or sucked right out of them. The dreary sky conveyed the deadly atmosphere.…
- 455 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Yet the photograph that epitomized Sudan's famine would win Kevin Carters fame”. In May 1994, Carter won the Pulitzer Prize for the now famous photograph of the vulture stalking a child, now over a year from when it was taken. Carter couldn’t enjoy the prize because of his absolute regret of not helping the young little girl. Cater was consumed by the violence had had witnessed and haunted by the questions not only from the press, but also from the world. The photograph could not be unseen or deleted.…
- 1337 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays