Because of John's lack of communication skills, Ann feels isolated psychologically and emotionally, and as a result, she is seen by the reader as a woman in despair seeking companionship during the Great Depression.
Ann is dutiful and submissive, so typical of the women of the 30's, as it is shown when she claimed, "Plenty to eat - plenty of wood to keep me warm - what more could a woman ask for?"(p.48) even though it is clearly the opposite of what she really wants. She says to John "I know. It's just that sometimes when you're away I get lonely…" the hesitation in this particular sentence explains her powerful desire to have someone to talk to, yet is afraid of John's response.
But we think Ann is more than just what she appears to be. There are moments where her rebellious personality is shown, such as when she went out of the house during the blizzard to feed the animals when John had plainly stated to her, "Everything's fed and watered, and I'll see that there's plenty of wood in." This depicts Ann's willingness to go so far as to distract herself from her loneliness. Also, the way she beseeches John to stay and the way she reacted, "She glanced up sharply, then busied herself clearing the table…" (pg49) at the mention of a visit by Steven shows that she presents some good intuition and intellect as to what may happen.
One can argue that Ann is unconsciously selfish and even ungrateful, for John is constantly trying to please her by working continuous hours without aids of others. She also has a roof over her head and food in her tummy that so many lacked during that era, and yet, she gives hints that she is highly unsatisfied of her current situation and commits adultery. However, the lack of companionship, increased by the barrenness of the surroundings in which the character lives in, makes Ann desperate for anything that would get her out of her miserable existence. As we know, humans are extreme social creatures, and when Steven arrived on her doorsteps with his, quote, "still-boyish face" (pg57) and "his lips drawn in a little smile that was too insolent, but at the same time companionable"(pg57) , Ann forgets all rules and drops her mental barrier, giving into what she desires the most: companionship.
So in conclusion, we feel that Ann is a woman with an extremely good heart, but is misguided into doing wrong actions by the isolation and loneliness in which her husband had ultimately caused.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
While John’s treatment of his wife’s depression is wrong, he does not necessarily do anything to make it worse. Just by ignoring her he is mistreating her. The problem with John in the story is that he holds all of the authority. He is her doctor as well as her caretaker. He is also stubborn and so sure he knows what is best for his wife that he disregards her opinion as just a symptom of her illness. His overly rational disposition and ignorance towards her proves him to be dangerous. John treats his wife more as a medical case than a person. He wants her to get better but ends up just making her situation a lot worse. It is this counterproductively that makes John’s character ironic.…
- 917 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In activity 6 (K101, DVD, Block 1, Unit 1 Activity 6) Bob suggests that Angus treats Ann like a slave, Ann is very emotionally drained in this instalment, she is aware that Zoe needs her due to problems at school, Bob needs her to be a wife and enjoy the anniversary meal he has prepared and Angus needs her because he needs her help. She has to put her role as a carer first and mother and wife when she has the time. As with Ann and many other carers, their life change’s, without really realising it has. It can cause unanticipated stresses which alter relationships within the family. (K101, unit 1, page 15). It isn’t all bad though, there are also rewards in caring for a family member, it can be a wonderful experience to help and look after your family. In the beginning Ann doesn’t see herself as a carer, just a dutiful daughter, mother and wife, but as issues start to unravel, Ann has to seek advice and help. Her identity therefore changes from daughter to…
- 1315 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
This demand on Ann’s time is causing difficulties within her relationship with the rest of her family as they seek time and comfort from her also.…
- 1150 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Also, while in New Salem, Lincoln, met Ann Rutledge. “Ann was the young daughter of a tavern keeper where Abraham boarded occasionally (Gienapp, 2002. pp. 21). At the time that Abraham first met Ann she was engaged. Lincoln was always more sociable around women who were already involved with someone. “Ann was engaged to John McNeil when Abraham first took notice of her. Some time passed and McNeil admitted to Ann that his real last name was McNamar. After this confession John left for New York to take care of family business” (Gienapp, 2002. pp. 21). John left leaving the availability for Abraham to act upon his emotions. “Abraham and Ann became conditionally engaged in 1935. Unfortunately, Ann died suddenly in August 1835 before the couple…
- 233 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The Diary of Anne Frank shows many stereotypes, such as Jews, adults, parents, and teenagers. Stereotypes are a standardized mental picture or belief held in common by members of a group. The Diary of Anne Frank identifies that the stereotype of a teenafer is moody, argumentative, and self-absorbed. The three teenagers, Anne, Margot, and Peter commonly show these traits in the play, The Diary of Anne Frank.…
- 627 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Ann dwells on the fact that her husband is not an intellectual companion whom is engaging and captivating towards her. She has no more motivation to initiate conversation with her husband, making her dwell the time she spends with him. She has all these past memories in her head that shine a false negative light on her husband. Her past memories are blinding her of the virtuous and giving person that her husband really is. She is relying falsely on the past to interpret how she wants to live in the future. She is scrutinizing John for the little things he does that are wrong but does not focus on the bigger picture, as he makes sure “ she should have the clothes... should slave away fifteen hours a day to give them to her”. John makes many sacrifices for Ann and always puts her first. However, Ann does not see this as she is fixated on a delusional reality of what she wants her ideal husband to be. At this moment in the story her ideal husband is not John, by the time the false expectations that she has formed from the past have faded away it is too late. Jay Gatsby is quite similar to Ann on that he relies heavily on the past to affect his future…
- 1108 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Ann was referred to counselling by her husband. He claimed that she was experiencing bouts of teariness, sadness, and exhaustion for six months.…
- 475 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
1. After seven years of ever-lurking silence Ann does something she soon regrets. At the end of the story Ann says, “If you knew him though- John would try” (p. 7). So did Ann really know John? I think Ann did know John and she knew that he would come home like he always did. But I think she let herself believe what Steven continued to say which was no one would risk coming home in such a bad storm. Ann always had feelings for Steven, but they were all for the wrong reasons. So I think her act with Steven was her defiance of seven years of ‘ever-lurking silence’ with John. Ann always felt alone with John and I think she thought Steven could give her more than what John had given her, but soon after her act with Steven she realized she was wrong. Ann realized John was a man and there was nothing Steven could give her that John wouldn’t, but by the time Ann realized this it was too late.…
- 879 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
John moved his wife to the country in hopes it would cure her of her “temporary nervous depression”. (pg. 655) He cares for his wife and seeks her improvement,…
- 439 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
This view of a good Anne seems convincing at first, but you can tell that she does this to prove that she is a grown lady and doesn't want people to treat her as a child anymore. She just wanted to show everybody that she is a civilized women, when she actually still acts just like a child. If she was truly this thoughtful she woud not have made everyone's every day life so difficult and…
- 557 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The narrator, just like the rest of her gender, is expected to be obedient and submissive, while at the same time having the ability to discipline her thoughts, attitude, and actions. John, the narrator’s husband, serves as a representation for the masculine sovereignty within their society. Although the narrator suffers from a serious condition, John does not pay attention to this and his only concern is that she remains a compliant wife. Therefore, he treats her like a frail child and does not allow her to make her own decisions, giving his wife no other option but to become fully dependant on him. In addition to ensuring that his wife is subservient and reliant, John strives to make sure that she is sane and well behaved. He claims that her condition is merely “a slight hysterical tendency” and decides to confine his wife to a state of isolation and inactivity. By doing this, John encourages the narrator to conceal her issues and frustrations, hoping that she will learn to control herself better. Furthermore, John “seems to consider fancy an inner weakness of [the narrator] and registers fancy as a real threat that exerts its influence on [her]” (Suess). Since John regards his wife as a second class citizen and restrains her from any meaningful activity, he demonstrates that the society in which…
- 582 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Throughout the story, Ann’s cultivating conflicts against herself, the environment, and with other characters establish the negative tone and pessimistic outcome. In the beginning, Ann does not believe that it is right for John to leave her “alone” in the house. Despite John’s intentions to keep her safe inside the house, Ann is unable to accept the lack of attention she is receiving. Most importantly, John wants to provide the best life possible to her by saving for a “mortgage-free house” and purchasing “pretty clothes” for her to wear. However, all Ann desires is John’s affection, and John is unaware of how to fully satisfy Ann. Secondly, Ann experiences a series of mental struggles, including being stranded on a farm. She faces difficulties embracing the role as a farmer’s wife, and the rigidity of class structure of her era. John is free to travel anywhere he…
- 415 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In my opinion, Anne Shirley's character has changed during this weeks chapters. When Anne first arrived in Green Gables, she was a very sweet and well mannered girl, who said her nightly prayers and never talked back. But during this weeks reading, we have seen that Anne can have violent outbursts.…
- 129 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
What is something that Anne Frank learned throughout her time in the "Secret Annex"? What is something that everybody can take away from this book? Both of these questions can be answered in one simple theme found in The Diary of a Young Girl by Anne Frank: we must accept some things that happen and learn to live with change.…
- 588 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
First, Anne has an optimistic attitude. She tries to make the best out of her situation. She makes her small room in their hiding place like home. She jokes, finds joy and happiness in the little things, and continues to write short stories and dreams for the future. Once she is a journalist she then wants to go on to become a famous writer. Anne proved herself a good writer when she wrote her father a book for his birthday. Anyone can clearly tell she already enjoys writing and has the inspiration and skill to do…
- 737 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays