Preview

Analysis Of Hilda Polacheck's 'I Came A Stranger'

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1534 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Analysis Of Hilda Polacheck's 'I Came A Stranger'
In her autobiography I Came a Stranger Hilda Polacheck reveals the conflicting role of women in the late 19th / early 20th century as workers, caregivers, and social activists in a conflicting age of progress, hardship and missed expectations. Coming from a very traditional Jewish family in Poland it seems that Hilda Polacheck was destined to be a full time mother and wife never having immersed herself in the American society where women were becoming more and more relevant. The death of her father changes all of this forcing herself her mother and her siblings to fight for survival. This fight is what not only transformed Hilda Polacheck into the woman we remember her as today, but into an American as well.

At age thirteen and even much
…show more content…
Much of the hardship women faced was because of the expectations set for them by men and failing to meet those expectations due to problems also caused by men. Susan W. Fitzgerald puts it best in her 1908 essay; Women in The Home. In this piece Fitzgerald puts forward the common furtstaion of the urban women as they were expected to clean the house, keep the children healthy, fed them, clothe them, and develop their sense of morraily. But in an urban society as America had become at this time women faced difficulty with these expectation male society had placed on them because the filth of cities was impossible to clean up, because in the ghetto markets clean food was hard to find, because the air and water were full of diseases, and because the city was full of evil. All of these issues made it impossible to meet expectations set by men as without the iurgh to vote women didn't even have a voice in decisions they affect them more than anyone. Both Polachek and her mother face this hardship living in Chicago after becoming the sole parent of a family and having to sustain that family on the lower wages paid to women for brutal work. Polachek event illustrates her frustration with the problems of the city as a teen ager with her essay The Ghetto Market specifically in her second paragraph “Not until the city takes the matter in hand and orders all vegetables, meat and fish to be sold only in adequate and sanitary rooms will this condition be entirely overcome” This was written by Polacheck after seeing the filthy conditions of chicago markets and seeing many of her peers and neighbors fall ill or even

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Despite the growth of industry, urban centers, and immigration, America in the 19th century was still very rural. The “Cult of Domesticity” first named and identified in the early part of the century, the beliefs embodied in this “cult” gave women a central role in the family. Women’s god given role, it stated was a wife and mother. Pulling against these “beliefs” was the sense of urgency, movement, and progress in the industrial and political changes affecting the country. Women could not help but see themselves in this growth. Women wanted new options, jobs, education and more. Not many women pursued their dream though because many had little to no support, but that difficulty didn’t stop some women from pursuing their goals. Rosa Cassettari and Luna Kellie were two of the women from the same era that decided to pursue the wishes in order to have a better and prosperous life and be able to provide for their families as best as they could. These two women were great examples of how hard but not impossible it was to gain their own freedom and rights aside of what society believed a women’s role was. Even though the faced many hardships and obstacles these two women found the courage to overcome all the…

    • 1286 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    This story explains exactly how gravely they were oppressed and has a much longer story to it than “Letter to John Adams” does. This story explains how the men oppressed all women, and what they would do to the women. This story explains how women didn’t have as many rights as men, how they were seen as inferior, how they were treated like they were of little importance, how women had to fight for their independence from man and how she hoped they would get equal rights as a woman in America.…

    • 936 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Metzger excels in pointing out the poor treatment of women in the early 1900’s. The Plan of Chicago was a bold plan to establish a new Chicago metropolitan region. Daniel Burnham, crafted this plan to benefit the business world, he did not consider Jane’s suggestions - that being “when focused on infrastructure it was to investigate or publicize the human cost of poor sanitation, overcrowded classrooms, corrupt inspections, or any of the host of other problems at the time” (Metzger 3). Ideas like women’s suffrage was a turning point in American history and the historical context of this time is beneficial to Metzger’s…

    • 507 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “Women worked hard to create income for their family, such as making clothes from scratch, turning fresh raw game into meals, cleaning homes and baking” (Bowles, M. 2011). Women did just about everything that a man did on top of their own work; they had to be prepared for the unexpected. Women would have to do other things like, tending to the farm animals, and handling the crops. Where democratic freedom is concerned, women fell short along with African Americans for the longest of time. 1842-1932, Anna Elizabeth Dickinson,…

    • 2680 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    As American women's roles evolved over time, women were confronted with contradictory messages about their place in society. Traditional ideals about women met new challenges with each generation, from outside forces like war and economic depression, and from the activity of women themselves. This caused many women to struggle with societal expectations that did not fit their reality, and with an identity that did not fit expectations. Colonial society delegated to women the job of protecting and sustaining the morality of the people, yet it refused them a public forum in which to do so; the nineteenth century ideology of domesticity presented a standard of maternal care that could not be universally achieved; the twentieth century offered women the opportunity for education, independence, and a place in the labor force, but expected her to return to her proper place in the home after marriage.…

    • 881 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Womens History Lit Review

    • 1886 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The article From the Russian Pale to Labor Organizing in New York City written by Annelise Orleck reveals how the working class immigrant community played a significant role in influencing women’s labor movements in the early twentieth century. Orleck maintains that as a result of their background, Jewish women had an experience in America different from most women. She posits that since they did not subscribe to the Victorian ideal of a traditional women’s role, Jewish immigrant women were able to form networks which transcended class, ethnicity, and even gender. Orleck’s book is a significant contribution to how labor history is understood and this significance lies in the way she presents her work. Orleck frames the story of the early labor movements of the twentieth century within the personal stories of four Jewish Immigrants: Schneiderman, Newman, Cohn, and Lemlich. These women formulated an “industrial feminism” which was heavily influenced by the class consciousness of socialism, and the unforgiving actuality of industrialized labor. Orleck asserts that their personal relationships and beliefs offer significant insight into the politics and economics which pervaded the women’s labor movement.…

    • 1886 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Some individuals viewed women who applied for aid or paid work as taking money and jobs away from more deserving men. Despite the opposition from men, women experienced a gain of two million jobs between 1930 and 1940. Women helped their families survive through their own fortitude and strength, despite all of the resistance they felt from men and societal expectations. As Eleanor Roosevelt said during the Great Depression in her book entitled It’s Up to the Women, “...it is [women’s] courage and determination which, time and again, have pulled us through worse crises than the present one.” (Ware par. 1) Without women, there is no doubt our nation would have suffered more at the hands of the Great Depression than it already did. Although the Great Depression brought pain and tragedy, it was certainly positive in its effect to help women begin to break the glass ceiling for the first time, as well as exemplify the inner strength in women that was previously suppressed as a result of confining gender…

    • 1601 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Stranger Essay

    • 509 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the philosophical novel “The Stranger”, written by Albert Camus, the story ended with Meursault’s last thoughts. He thinks, “For everything to be consummated, for me to feel less alone, I had only wish that there be a large crowd of spectators the day of my execution and that they greet me with cries of hate” (Camus 123). The question is: Why does Meursault hope for this? Why does Camus end the novel at this point? And who is the “Stranger” and why?…

    • 509 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Before the war, it was unheard of for women to be working long hours and getting paid good money for it. (HIST 222 lecture, 19 OCT 10) This era was the beginning of women working permanently. (HIST 222 lecture, 28 OCT 10) It was also unheard of for Negros to have jobs and make money. With both of these groups working, there was more money to be spent on products. These new women began to become more political. They cut their hair short, smoked in public, and discussed Freud in public. (HIST 222 lecture, 19 OCT 10) Although women or blacks were still not treated fairly, and were definitely not treated as well as white men, they were treated better than they had been before. It was a step in the right direction, and a step which lead to the Women’s Rights Movements and the Civil Rights…

    • 728 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The employers of the industrial city took advantage of the growth of population, and exploited the migration of immigrants moving to the cities looking for work, along with the fact that there were no regulations to keep the businesses in check at the same time the growth of the city was so fast and the lack of education on sanitation, life for the immigrant was dirty and difficult. For example; in New York City 1870-1920, population grew from 942,292 to 5,620,040 with the percentages: Austria-Hungary 8%, Russia 8%, Italy 6%, England 6%, Ireland 30%, Germany 33%, and Other Foreign 9%. (Rise of the Industrial City: New Places, New Peoples) With such a growth and the need for workers along with the need for employment, businessmen took advantage of this to fuel their greed at the cost of people’s quality of life and health. There are eight basic categories that these affected; Income and Wealth, Child Labor, Working Conditions, Public Health and Length of Life, Rise of the Middle Class, Working Class Families, The Role of Women, and The conditions of living. So, what were the conditions of this time period, and what affects did they have, just how much of a role in this period did women have, and what kind of role did women have in causing there to be changes.…

    • 2282 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women were underpaid, expected to stay at home to run the household, and abused, all without others taking a second glance at the morality of these situations. From the 1830s to approximately the 1860s, women who chose to work in mills made about three to three and a half dollars a week; this was about one third to half of a man’s wages (Dublin, Working Class Women). At that time, three to three and half dollars was much more than a farmer’s daughter could earn but was still not enough for a single person to live off of. (Dublin). A single woman making low wages could only afford to pay their rent; they were unable to buy extra necessities such as food or clothing. Due to low income and being unable to support themselves, a woman's goal was to get married. After marriage, she would be supported by her husband’s income and no longer had to worry about the financial burden alone. Consequently, married life could be considered almost as hard as the life of a single woman. Women were still required to get a job after marriage to help pay for needs. Women also tended to eat less than their husbands and children to ensure their family was their main priority and was managed adequately. Women who failed to manage the household sufficiently or those who spent too much money were often abused. The abuse would go unintervened unless a man beat another man’s wife or death was suspected. (Working Class Women). Women of this time were second rate compared to men and had much less important than males. This caused tension among feminists who believed that men and women should be treated equal. With this in mind, those same women who saw the unequal treatment of women during this time in history, were probably women who started the fight for women’s…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the past, women cooked, cleaned the house, took care of the kids, prepared the meals, etc. Pertaining to the economic struggle, women were discriminated for employment and how much they were able to receive for their work. As of today, it still is not "normal" in society for women to have a CEO position, be a doctor, an entrepreneur, or a head coach. Even though, society has open their arms a little more for allowing women to achieve greatness, there still remains inequality. As far as educational issues, women were not perceived to be intelligent.…

    • 420 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the autobiography, “Out of the Shadow”, author Rose Cohen, a Russian-Jewish immigrant, explains the social and economic conditions during the late 1800s and early 1900s for Jews immigrating into the United States. Cohen explains how many Jews fled Eastern Europe and Russia during this time due to the ruling of the tsar, fear of religious persecution, and economic restrictions. Because these restrictions were becoming the norm for Jewish people in their county, Rose’s father, a tailor, began to embark on a journey to the United States of America, in hopes of beginning a new life for himself and his family. Even though her father is captured at the border of Russia and returned home, he managed to get to America. Once in America, he began work as a tailor, striving to earn enough money to bring his entire family to America. In the next year and a half, Rose’s father is finally able to get Rose and her aunt Masha to America. During the early years of Rose’s life in America, she experiences many obstacles and conditions that were faced by Jews throughout the United States during the late 19th century and early 20th century.…

    • 965 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    An issue women struggled on during the 1920’s was that their working conditions and education rights were not given much importance. After World War One, women were asked to quit their jobs as the men needed to return to their workplaces. At these times,…

    • 1001 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Great Depression

    • 390 Words
    • 2 Pages

    “Unemployment, homelessness and hunger were considered a man’s problem.” For the women in society, their jobs usually consisted of cooks, servants, nannies and washwomen. Of the work force, 25% were women. Older women were discriminated because of their “old age and long history of living outside of family systems.” Times were worse for black women for they had suffered 42.9% unemployment to the 23.2% of white women without jobs. Some black businesses were “barbers and hair dressers” because many white barbers refused to cut black people’s hair.…

    • 390 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays