The Struggle for Power Russia In 1923 written by Valentina Vilkova, a senior scientific researcher at the Centre for Political and Economic History of Russia of the Independent Russian institute is an integral documental presentation of the power struggle in Russia from 1923-1924. It aims to enrich source material with these new documents unknown in Russia to allow for certain corrections of historical concepts in that period.
The value of this book lies in how Vilkova uses recently uncovered archival materials from the 1923-1924 period in Russia to give an accurate representation of the events in Russia at that time. Her close analysis of these documents with an objective view allows me to investigate the impact of factors in the early stages of the power struggle without having to worry about a bias or subjective view point.
On the other hand this source only provides an analysis of events in the power struggle from 1923-24. The dismissal of events in the 1925-28 period signifies that this source only offers a partial analysis of the power struggle rather than complete analysis needed to be able to compare Stalin’s position of General Secretary to all the factors in the power struggle contributing to his success.
Stalin Author of The last Tsar written by Edvard Radzinsky, a Russian playwright and author of history, is a biography Stalin based on new documents from Russia’s secret archives. It aims to uncover the secrecy of Stalin’s life in the power struggle and as leader of the Soviet Union with the recent exposure of Stalin’s personal archives.
The value of this book lies in the analysis of Stalin’s personal archives which illustrate Stalin’s role in the power struggle from a critical perspective. This allows me to appreciate the importance of Stalin’s meticulous strategies in the power struggle as opposed to simply the position of general secretary he held in the party. Radzinsky suggests that Stalin was a calculating and ruthless man and stresses the importance of events initiated by his ruthless personality such as preventing Trotsky from attending Lenin’s funeral. This provides me with an opposing view to that of other sources which suggest Stalin’s position of General Secretary was the most important reason for his success in the power struggle.
On the other hand Radzinsky’s occupation of a playwright influences the descriptive nature of the book which exaggerates only Stalin’s ruthlessness. This may be evidence of Radzinsky’s own view of Stalin prevailing where he should be providing an objective view.
414 words
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Throughout the period 1855 to 1954, opposition to Russian governments was a common occurrence due to dissatisfaction of many civilians’ lives and the lack of development seen throughout Russia. However, as much as there were some successful movements throughout 1905 such as the Bolsheviks gaining support and eventually gaining power, there were also several failed attempts due to intense use of violence, terror and censorship by the state. It is arguable that whether opposition was successful, merely came down to the strength of the opposition group or the weakness of the government in power.…
- 1646 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
How significant were the personalities of the contenders to succeed Lenin in accounting for Stalin’s defeat of his opponents in the years 1924-29…
- 1502 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
The truth, tons of revealing mysteries, hidden secrets, the true motives of one infamous dictator of the Soviet Union. It is time to find out the true motives of Stalin and his rise to power in the Soviet Union. The book titled “Stalin’s Curse” that is written by Robert Gellately goes all the way back in history to his life as an exile before being a ruler. There are many books written by Gellately that look into the life of Hitler, Stalin, and Lenin. Writing many books, Gellately is one of the leading historians of Europe especially in the time of World War II and the Cold War. To make this book even more interesting, it does not only focus on Stalin and his adventures, but also includes the roles of Lenin and Hitler in the time of World War II. Leaders of their times, these significant people are depicted as we journey through the life of Stalin.…
- 755 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Many historians argue The Emancipation of the Serfs in 1861, to be a key turning point within Russian history. It drastically altered Russia’s economic, political and social stipulation. One could propose the argument that this event lead to the fall of communism in 1990, further more suggesting the extent to which this event affected Russia. Hence this is ‘perhaps the most defining moment in Russian history, with its impact being seen many years after the event itself’. Although historians identify short term effects of this event, the significance to which this event developed Russian government and society up to the 21st century has been so tremendous that they cannot be disregarded. However when one considers the argument of the likes of Louis Hobart who suggests the event was only a contributing element to ‘the social and economic transformation’ it must be asked to what extent was this event alone a key turning point in the development of Russian Government?…
- 1456 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
In 1922, when Vladimir Lenin died, someone needed to step up and the Soviet Union. As he was slowly dying, a power struggle emerged between Leon Trotsky, and Joseph Stalin. Even though Trotsky “had been widely viewed as the heir of Lenin, it was relatively easy for Stalin to combine with the other Bolshevik leaders in order to head off this threat” (Paley 10). In Lenin’s “Final Testament”, Lenin could already see that Stalin was quickly and surreptitiously gaining power. Stalin’s position of General Secretary gave him the ability to appoint people to important positions. Lenin was also reluctant to see Stalin as his successor because he thought that Trotsky could do a much better job. Lenin believed that Trotsky was the best man in the central…
- 199 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
Adenosine triphosphate (ATP) is the immediately usable form of chemical energy use for muscular activity. It is stored in most cells, especially muscle cells. Other forms of chemical energy, such as that available from foods we eat must be transforming into ATP before they can be utilized by muscle cells .…
- 969 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Bibliography: Auty, Robert, and Dimitri Obolensky. 1976. "An Introduction to Russian History (Companion to Russian Studies;1)." Brisol, Great Britain : Cambridge University Press Ltd.…
- 1742 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
- Concerned with frontiers and borders, protect territory; (surrounded by Turkey, Iran, China, NK) – brought into conflict with other nations.…
- 1142 Words
- 6 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Russia was torn between the world war and the population was threatened as levels of starvation rose whilst industry fell. The provisional government could not do much to stop Russia plummeting as they did not have much power and the people of Russia failed to support them (1). The citizens of Russia were desperately looking for help and the Bolshevik party, created with the help of Lenin and Trotsky in the year 1917, had the answer. Slowly, they had managed to become one of the most powerful parties ever created, but many factors were to cause the consolidation of power. In this essay I will be comparing the significance of Vladimir Lenin in the Bolshevik consolidation of power with another important factor; Leon Trotsky.…
- 1843 Words
- 8 Pages
Better Essays -
Dziewanowski, M. K. (2003). Russia in the twentieth century (6th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.…
- 1696 Words
- 7 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Even though Stalin’s victory in the power struggle was partly due to his popular policies, it was not just this that allowed Stalin also because of the mistakes made by other rivals and factors that played into his hands. For example Trotsky was a former menshevik which helped Stalin accuse him of not been a true Bolshevik.…
- 885 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Khrushchev’s vilification of Stalin in his address to the Twentieth Party Congress was meticulous in detailing precise failures of his predecessor’s rule. Above all, Khrushchev strongly elaborated on Stalin’s extremities, especially the cult of personality that he had built up over the years. The speech also in turn attacked ‘Stalinist repressions, arrests, terror and murders…[and] for bungling foreign affairs and mishandling the war’. Despite this, Khrushchev was cautious in limiting his other criticisms of Stalin, and it was this focus on him as an individual rather than of the overall Soviet system that defined the boundaries of acceptable criticism. As such, the speech sought to condemn Stalin without endangering the party’s validity or the system that had indeed allowed Khrushchev to rise to power.…
- 1064 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Monumental Propaganda relates a bottom-up history of the Soviet Union from the end of WWII to Post-Socialist Russia of the 1990s. The story is presented from the perspective of an unwavering defender of the cultural mores of post-war Russia, Aglaya Stepanovna Revkina. It is through this outlook that the reader glimpses the political transformations of the Soviet Union. Because Aglaya remains a devoted Stalinist, reactions to her should also be taken as reactions to Stalin and his ideology. Though Aglaya does not change her opinions, the world around her certainly does. In the course…
- 2546 Words
- 11 Pages
Better Essays -
Bibliography: Bernstein, Laurie, and Robert Weinberg. Revolutionary Russia: A History In Documents. New York, New York: Oxford University Press, 2011. Print.…
- 2030 Words
- 9 Pages
Best Essays -
When discussing why public opinion of the tsar was so easily pliable in the lead up to revolution in 1917, we must acknowledge that Russia was evolving rapidly. As modern historians and public spectators, it is simple to map out how Russian society became a pressure cooker of discontent and anger. Mass industrialisation made living for a working, urban class almost unbearable, the class divide was still rigid, revolutionary ideas from the West offered a foundation to base claims for the removal of the autocratic system, and the pressures of World War 1 served to unite the people in one cause to end hardship. These factors stoked a population already vying for change and such an environment made revolution in Petrograd (St Petersburg) in the February of 1917 almost inevitable, foreshadowing the end of the…
- 1502 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays