Preview

Analysis Of St. Lucy's School For Girls Raised By Wolves And The Cherry Orchard

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
950 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Analysis Of St. Lucy's School For Girls Raised By Wolves And The Cherry Orchard
The Supremacy of Human Civilization
It’s said that when feeling alone, one should turn to a group of people for support. However, the sad reality is that often, when surrounded by people we don’t share the same views with, we feel even more secluded. This theme is present in both “The Cherry Orchard” by Antonin Chekov and “St. Lucy’s School for Girls Raised by Wolves” by Karen Russell. In the works, main characters Madame Ranevsky and wolf-girl Mirabella are forced to adapt to a change they don’t want to undergo. Madame Ranevsky, who lived her life on a cherry orchard, is being asked to sell her home and to move on to a new life, one more urban and less extravagant. Mirabella, the youngest of the wolf girls, is sent to a reformatory girl’s
…show more content…
This refusal to detach is perceived as bothersome by the people around them. This shows the wildness the characters possess; as they cannot adapt as well as most rational beings are able to. Madame Ranevsky’s daughters, Anya and Varya, both grew up on the orchard and are adapting with ease. Similarly, Mirabella’s sisters Claudette and Jeanette adjust well to the change, abandoning their ties to the wild world. It’s clear that both Madame Ranevsky and Mirabella feel isolated and excluded when surrounded by those easily adapting, and this makes them seek out support from their loved ones. Mirabella begs for support from the pack, whimpering as she “rolled belly-up on the stone cold floor” (Russell 237), an action animals do to display feelings of weakness and vulnerability. Madame Ranevsky wanders about the house weeping, exclaiming that “(this) disaster seems to me so improbable that I don't know what to think, I'm all at sea . . . I may scream . . . or do something silly” (Chekov 1649), refusing to listen to those around her who warn her of her inevitable foreclosure, yet at the same time turning to them for news on the selling. This demonstrates that living among other people may actually push them closer to what they are having trouble letting go of, which for both Madame Ranevsky and Mirabella are nature and the …show more content…
Instead of simply accepting the alternative to foreclosure, she cries, “I can’t conceive a life without the cherry orchard, and if it really must be sold, then sell me with the orchard” (Chekov 1651), showing that she’d do anything to remain with the orchard and avoid chopping it down. Madame Ranevsky’s link to her land leads us to question whether she is holding on to the plot of land for the beauty of the orchard, or rather for the memories and nostalgia attached to the property. For example, the drowning and death of her son on the property ties her to the land, as she views the cherry orchard as a place where her son is with her. Madame Ranevsky asks Trofimov- an eternal student who lives in the village- to help her keep her land, repeating that her “son was drowned here,” asking him to “have pity on [her], good, kind man” (Chekov 1651). Additionally, Madame Ranevksy’s lineage is represented on the property, as she was raised on the land herself as a member of the Russian aristocracy, and established her family on the orchard. Thus, it’s clear that human experience within the natural world leads to a strong attachment and reliance on it, and Madame Ranevsky’s madness regarding the sale of her land is arguably due to her experiences on it. Because she shares the land with so many loved ones, Madame Ranevsky’s struggle to adapt to a changing world is intensified.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    “St. Lucy’s Home for Girls Raised by Wolves” by Karen Russell is a short story about a “pack” of girls raised by werewolves that are severely lycanthropic. Their parents send them to a home called St. Lucy’s run by Jesuit nuns that’s goal is to eradicate all traces of wolf culture and behavior from the girls, and assimilate them into human culture. To help them, the nuns have a handbook called “The Jesuit Handbook on Lycanthropic Culture Shock”. The handbook divides each part of the “packs” development into human culture into 5 stages. The main character, Claudette, develops a lot throughout each of the 5 stages, but still has some struggles. By the end of the story, Claudette is very close to fully adapting, but still has some wolf like tendencies.…

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the short story, “St. Lucy’s Home for Girls Raised by Wolves” by Karen Russell, Claudette displays how she has not fully adapted to human society and reverts back to her origin of the wolf. When Claudette gets anxious, there were numerous times when she turns to wolf behavior for comfort. She narrows her eyes at Kyle and flattens her ears, (Russell 242) and when the time comes to do Sausalito, Claudette panics and can only remember how to the “pump and pump” (Russell, 243). Claudette advances through the stages as necessary, but in desperate times she forgets everything the nuns have taught her.…

    • 320 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Very few books are capable of eliciting the same notoriety than that of Vladimir Nabokov’s Lolita. A story told solely through the mind of a pedophile in love, Lolita has become one of the most arduous books to read, which consequently made it one of the most talked about during the mid twentieth century. With a plot immensely difficult to ingest, and a protagonist with hauntingly low morals and an indisputable fondness of word play, Lolita was and still remains a landmark book with undisputable prominence. With such a serious topic written in the midst of a highly conservative era, both Lolita and Nabokov received disturbed reactions from offended audiences. The reputation of Lolita most notably is due to the misinterpretation of the character…

    • 2409 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Analysis of Karen Russell

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages

    St. Lucy’s Home for girls Raised by Wolves, Karen Russell’s collection of fantastical short stories take all that is mundane and fractures it into a fantastical world with humor, dramatic tone, or cultural/religious undertones. Russell whirls a reader into her stories with her capability to encase a reader in the story with her repetition of one’s senses. Constantly brining in the senses of a reader brought in the smells of a surrounding from the protagonist or in this case the narrator. In St. Lucy’s Home for girls Raised by Wolves, our narrator, Claudette, speaks from the mind of a half human half wolf in transition. Of the pack’s reaction to the nuns, how Sister Josephine “tasted like sweat and freckles” (226) after Claudette bit her ankle, which she “smelled easy to kill” (226); how the mousy social worker was “nervous smelling” (226), eventually Claudette herself “smelled like a purebred girl, easy to kill” (242). When the sisters were reunited with the brothers they no longer smelt as of family they knew but of “pomade and cold, sterile sweat” (241). Russell creates such realistic imagery in a non-realistic world. Not just with scents but with a sense of touch sensory. How the girls went “knuckling along” (224) the floors when they first arrived; even when speaking, their ineptitude to force their tongues to “curl around our false new names” (229) creates such realistic imagery you sense your tongue running across your own teeth.…

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “‘All happy families are alike, all unhappy families are unhappy in its own way’ is the first line of Anna Karenina and, like any self respecting concierge, I am not supposed to have read it … for although common people may be sensitive to great works though they do not read them, literature, in the presence, cannot aspire to the lofty…

    • 1097 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    One of the most complex and elaborate characters in Bastard Out of Carolina by Dorothy Allison is Bone. Throughout the story Bone has to live a life where she thinks that she is the leading mystery of the trouble being caused. She has numerous unhappy situations and is in no way self-satisfied with herself. She doesn 't appreciate who she is physically. She constantly thinks she is the most homely and dull person who causes the most inconvenience in the family. This sense of selflessness is mainly due to the physical and sexual abuse brought upon by Daddy Glen, Bone 's stepfather. Unfortunately, the assaults were stretched out over a long period of time, leaving little chance for Bone to recover as an adult if any at all. I decided to take a more scientific approach to discussing Bone 's future as an adult. The most common disorders I feel Bone is likely to face are posttraumatic stress, cognitive distortions, emotional pain, and avoidance, an impaired sense of self and interpersonal difficulties. After finishing some research I concluded that Bone would most likely be diagnosed with posttraumatic stress disorder. It entails enduring certain psychological symptoms that occur in reaction to a highly distressing, psychically disruptive event. A diagnosis of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) requires the occurrence of a traumatic event, as well as frequent experiencing of the event through nightmares or intrusive thoughts, a numbing of general responsiveness to, or avoidance of, current events, and persistent symptoms of increased arousal, such as jumpiness, sleep disturbance, or poor concentration. All of these occurrences are a result from the sexual abuse Bone was forced to tolerate from Glen. Triggers of flashbacks include sexual stimuli or interactions, abusive behavior by other adults, disclosure of one 's abuse experiences to others, and reading or seeing sexual or violent media depictions, all of which would more than likely be experienced throughout Bone…

    • 1231 Words
    • 36 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Through an exploration of the boundaries between social constraint and inner compulsion, Melville and Chekov reveal the restrictions forced upon one’s personal desires as they struggle to find a balance between conflicting values and social norms. Anna and Gurov in ‘The Lady with the Dog’ are restrained by the socially expected conventions in their marriages, inhibiting their ability to express their inner compulsion of desire. Chekov reveals their yearning to escape their individual lives as they cope with personal troubles by distancing themselves from marriage through a sexual relationship with each other. When away from the city of Yalta, their lives seem their own without the social constraint forced upon them; however, in the presence of others their marriage binds them, forcing them to question their affair. Through lingering silences their relationship reveals passion yet also the underlying sorrow that Anna feels for betraying her husband. During these moments of silence, they struggle in a personal battle of questioning, perplexed by the conflict between their inner compulsions and the restraints of society as they are unable to fully indulge themselves in their passion for each other. The image employed by Chekov of the “long grey fence” (Chekhov 1998, p. 371) keeping them apart alludes to this sense of restraint and personal desires as a symbol of restriction. The fence keeps Gurov from Anna, fending him from her as their love is forbidden in the eyes of society. Their freedom is held within this fence as their desire cannot fully be embellished under the guise of society’s rules. While in Melville’s ‘Bartleby, the Scrivener’, Bartleby shows the uprising of a world of preference where his inner compulsions drive him to defy all rules of social constraint. In order to live,…

    • 1405 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Likewise the students in “St. Lucy’s Home for Girls Raised by Wolves” and Native Americans were both forced to assimilate into a new culture. If a Native American tried to join the American society, Native Americans could still be forced to be relocated sometimes hundreds of miles away. While the students in “St. Lucy’s Home for Girls Raised by Wolves” were forced to assimilate into a new culture, the girls became very civilized. In addition, “100,000 Native Americans were forced by the U.S. government” (Indian Country Diaries/Boarding Schools) to attend the boarding schools. Generally, Native American and the students at St. Lucy’s were both forced in many ways to grasp (assimilate) into a new culture.…

    • 115 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    This chapter started out by telling us that Granpa had never held a job in public works, which is a job for regular hire. During Little Tree's childhood, corn was very cheap in its regular form, but in whiskey form it was worth a profitable amount. Granpa's trade was making moonshine. This was the only way to make money because they had such a small corn patch that it was impossible to make money selling regular corn. Granpa got his trade from his Scotch side. He thought that it was an honorable trade that was often given a bad name because of bad moon shiners. There are many ways to cheat and Granpa didn't do any of them. He said that some big moon shiners try to get rid of the small ones by doing things like telling people that the moonshine is aged which makes no difference according to Granpa. He called the people that purchased that barrel sniffers.…

    • 573 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    So first up is “The Bouquet”; I sympathized mainly for the young girl named Sophie. Society’s faults stunted her growth as an individual, and kept her from bonding with those she desired relations. The whole culture surrounding her took away most of the attributes that make oneself human- such as love, happiness, and human connection.…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Blue Against White

    • 605 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Lena does not want to be different anymore. She decides to go to the city and there she goes to school. Hoping for a new life and no more standing out, Lena easily gets disappointed. She learns that even if you move to a place with a higher population, you can still be alone. After coming to terms with herself and realizing that the city is not what she expected, Lena goes back to the reserve. She was happy to return to her roots. They are the one place you are always welcome to come back to. As she was coming home she was glad to see the dogs running freely in the reserve and the blue door that she despised all her life had now shown her a sign of home and safety.…

    • 605 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    At several points, Semyonova writes of the abnormally high rates of infant mortality in the villages (7). Coinciding with an increase in fertility and not enough food to go around, this leads us to an unpleasant reality of peasant life: infanticides, abortions, and intentional miscarriages were a common method of population control (57). In very real terms, women held the power of life and death in Russian peasant society.…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The story “Marigolds” by Eugenia W. Collier tells us of a fifteen year old girl coming into young adulthood during the great depression. It discusses the most memorable childhood memories of Elizabeth’s life in poverty, especially Miss Lottie’s beautiful marigolds. The life changes that this young girl passes through represents the end of childhood innocence into a recognition of reality in the cruel world in which she finds herself. This leads her into a new world of compassion. It is through this act that Elizabeth steps into an adult personality out of a childish mentality. The process in which she enters adulthood is represented by symbolism, vivid imagery, and details provide by Collier.…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In Karen Russell’s short story, “St. Lucy’s Home for Girls Raised by Wolves”, she develops the progression of the characters in relation to The Jesuit Handbook on Lycanthropic Culture Shock. The characters, young girls raised as if they were wolves, are compared to the handbook with optimism that they will adapt to the host culture. The girls’ progression in the five set stages are critical to their development at St. Lucy’s. The author compares Claudette, the narrator, to the clear expectations the handbook sets for the girls’ development. Claudette’s actions align well with the five stages, but she has outbursts that remind her of her former self.…

    • 1892 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The text under analysis is a story written by O’Henry. His real name is William Sidney Porter and O. Henry is his pen name. O. Henry is an American short-story writer of the late 19th century. He is a representative of realism, who wrote about the life of ordinary people in New York City. Typical for O. Henry's stories is a twist of plot which turns on an ironic or coincidental [kəuˌɪn(t)sɪ'dent(ə)l] (випадковий) circumstance. Although some critics were not so enthusiastic about his work, the public loved and loves it. The plots of his stories are clever and interesting, and the end is always surprising. His works include ‘The Four Million’, ‘The Gift of the Magi’, ‘The Furnished Room’, ‘Shoes’, ‘The Last Leaf’ and so on. No matter how many times you read them they always give you the same feeling of freshness. So does the story ‘The Green Door’.…

    • 1498 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics