Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Analysis on Mulan and the Twilight Saga Through a Feminist Point of View

Good Essays
466 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Analysis on Mulan and the Twilight Saga Through a Feminist Point of View
Mulan
The society is sexist.
Women are to be beautiful, curvy, delicate, poised, graceful, refined, thin, curvy, quiet, demure and polite.
Men are portrayed as the leaders of society, whereas women are only there to give birth to children.
Mulan is graceful, calm, and unique she is also beautiful and curvy, just like society wants. But that is where it stops. Unlike society’s wishes, she is not quiet, demure, or delicate. Instead she is intelligent, strong, and independent and is not afraid to be what she wants to be. And therefore, when the time came when she did not want her father to lose his life in battle, she goes against society’s standards when it comes to women on the battlefield and disguises herself as a man to be able to join the army. She proves that she is just as capable as a man by joining the army and doing the same things the men do at training camp, if not more. But by the end of the movie, she saves the country.
Feminists hope that people’s outlook on female roles and equality will change for the better, and in some ways the hope lies with the media. Books, movies, poems, songs, TV shows and any other types of influences on the public are their hope in delivering their message. Mulan is an animated movie that many kids watch and enjoy from a young age. At a young age they start to develop opinions about everything they interact with. Therefore, developing a movie like Mulan will influence the children to treat females as equals. The treatment of females will be improved through the next generation. This will help the feminists with their cause.

Twilight
Throughout the story, Bella Swan does not have trouble coming to a decision as all her decisions are based on the fact if a decision will bring her closer to Edward or help him. Her choices are not based on her benefits or what will help her, which portrays the sexist outlook of women – weak, obedient, and not equal – which has been shown throughout history. In New Moon, when Edward leaves Bella, she does everything in her power to be able to see Edward, from riding a motorcycle recklessly to jumping off a cliff into stormy waves. This also shows that women are nothing without men, which is not what the feminist movement wants. Yes the love they had for each other and the devotion that was expressed in the novel was well-played, but the weakness of the female lead does not push society to accept woman as equals economically, politically, or socially. This book does not promote female equality but instead female inequality. Furthermore, Bella relies on Edward for her to live and on Jacob in New Moon.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Kayapo: Out Of The Forest

    • 1441 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The President and his cabinet hold the leadership position in our society. In addition, men and women are equal in our society just like the Waorani, but there are exceptions. The men are considered the head of house and the majority of the time they are considered the breadwinners of the family and make the more important family decisions although the women of the house may put input into the making of the decisions. Also, some men are paid more in our society than women are paid.…

    • 1441 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “The Ballad of Mulan” comes from the fifth or sixth century. It was written in a time when China was divided between the north and the south (Hamby). If Mulan actually existed, she would have lived during the Northern Wei dynasty. She joined the army and prepared to…

    • 776 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Due to gender difference the society places men and women in unequal positions. Men are considered superior and capable of being leaders while women are considered inferior to their male counterparts. Traditionally, it was assumed that women were incapable of reasoning but were endowed with the capability of nurturing the society. It was also believed that the position of women…

    • 1848 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Hua Mulan was one of the women in history who went and fought in the battlefield and kept her gender a secret. Hua Mulan took her father Hua Hu’s place in the Chinese army. Hua Mulan was proven both brave and powerful. Hua Mulan’s…

    • 102 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Setting including time period and location can have a direct effect on how genders roles are perceived. I believe that this is true in both fiction and in real life when the times are good and the country is stable people will fall into the age old mindset that men are the rulers of the household, country and any establishment of power while women are the homemakers, the healers and the bearers of children. This is because people are afraid of changing anything lest their comfort and stability be taken away-why change what’s been tried and proven and risk upsetting the peace we have now? When times are tough however, people will look towards those who can lead them back to comfort and stability-no matter their gender.…

    • 1015 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Society has shaped us many different ways. If you were to look at society 50 years ago you would see that it was believed that a woman belonged at home, in the kitchen, or taking care of the kids. Most people think we have changed but if you watch T.V. or listened to most people (Male or Female) talk you would realize we haven’t changed all that much. In today’s world you still hear things like “he’s the man of the house” or “That’s a man’s job”. You may even hear “It’s the woman’s fault”. This is just one way society has shaped us since the beginning of time. Even Adam blamed Eve when he ate the fruit from the forbidden tree.…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Examples Of Social Norms

    • 1456 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Many individuals may believe that gender stereotypes and typical norms amongst the sexes are long gone, but these traditional views for both men and women, according to society, are still quite prevalent today. This human experience, that men and women both have specific roles to play in society, has been around since the beginning of time and will most likely continue for decades and centuries to come. Men are viewed, by societies standards, as being strong, dominant (at least more dominant than a women), leaders, and they should always restrain from showing weakness. Ronald Levant, a physiologist, explains in his article Men and Masculinity that men are prone to be raised as their fathers were,…

    • 1456 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    A women’s life is centered around her reproductiveness and ability to be a caregiver. For example, there are significantly more women in elementary education than there are in higher education. In contrast, since men are unable to bare children, they have time after time been responsible for providing the necessary for the his family, while “their” women stay at home carrying over the children, maintaining a clean household, and being responsible for all their needs. Since men tend to be stronger and bigger than women, this ultimately has lead society to believe that men are more dominant than women; hence, women are often portrayed as weak and vulnerable. These biological characteristics translate to cultural myths about what a man or women can or cannot do; therefore, discriminating gender. This male dominance and privilege has contributed to the notion that men hold more power roles than women. In addition, being naturally more violent and at higher rates than women has contributed to the myth that men are better leaders. Today, men are in charge of significantly close to most if not all of the largest corporations. If a women happens to be part of the leading group of one of these corporations, it leads to question whether she has the position in order to increase diversity or because she deserves and worked hard to be there. It is is unfortunate that society promotes that women are simply not good enough for the…

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sexism In Disney Movies

    • 257 Words
    • 2 Pages

    This paper explores the ideas brought up by many different articles about Disney movies and their effect on the thoughts and behaviours that children possess and how these thoughts and behaviours effect the way they communicate. The research found was mostly based on observations of certain behaviours in various popular Disney movies. The topics brought up by the articles were that Disney portrays sexist and racist behaviours, questionable gender roles, indirect aggression, negative body images, and plenty more. The argument is that these movies display these topics to our children which causes them to learn to adopt the mindsets and behaviours that come with them through the social learning theory. Many different movies such as Fantasia, Dumbo,…

    • 257 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Disney and Masculinity

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages

    today I want to present my project about how Disney films show masucliity in almost all Disney movies and the four types of masculinity.i want to give everyone the idea of how disney have shaped and influenecesx the idea of masculinity,feminisxm and gender roles in young kids . Disney has many films in ehich thy show masuclinyt, feminicism and gender roles and often include violence,sexist relationships, and show dominance to show power. And often many young kids imitate these characteristics and grow up with them and even feel uncomfortable or f eel less than the rest of the young boys when they realizr that they don’t have these characteristics. As we all grew up we remember watching a lot of Disney movies and remember most of the characters and the stories. For young boys there was such films such as lion king,toy story,ect and for young girls there are many princess stories like Cinderella, Pocahontas,little mermaid, etc. but does anybody wonder or think about how Disneys ideas of masculinity have affected the men of today or will affect the man of tomorrow? We often think or remember about the princesses finding their own prince charming and how the male has certain characteristics that show authority and power, well, this one of the many things that Disney have made us believe and we grew up with this idea.but for my project, I wanredto be specific and wanted to focus more on masculimty and the four types of masculinity that Disney uses as well as sexism in films.…

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Hunting Ground

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Gender roles are constantly changing, but there is not enough progress in the gender identity chosen by society for women. A woman being depicted in the media as weak or lesser than a man is not tolerable. Just because these femininity performances have been repeated for so long in history does not make it natural that women should act and be represented in that way. (Alberts, 2007) It is the twenty-first century and women should be considered strong, independent and equal to men. This is still not the case as women are often also over sexualized in the media, which causes real world…

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Men were always seen as the more dominant position of our society since the beginning as well as today. Stated from Source 1, “Men were active, independent, course, strong, ...stoic, aggressive, dependable, and not feminine.” (excerpt from Partners in psychology, “Chapter 7, Gender Stereotypes:…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    With popular culture setting the norms for society women are left at a large disadvantage as far as how they are viewed and treated in society. As stated in the lecture “These sources have created many different cultural norms and expectations as well as have affected sexuality and sexual behavior. These sources have dictated many gender expectations and have subjugated women in many aspects of social life.” (Reali, 2017) In popular culture beauty among women is one of the most romanticized topics.…

    • 1730 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Gender Issues and Roles

    • 3421 Words
    • 14 Pages

    The root of all gender issues which presently exist in society may be traced back to The Creation Story in Genesis. This crucial chapter of the Bible provides evidence supporting that God intended for man and woman to exist as equals, yet he assigned gender roles once Adam and Eve disobeyed him by eating the fruit from the forbidden tree of good and evil. Thus, men have been characterized as the “breadwinners” and women as “child bearers and housekeepers” since the beginning of humanity. Men and women have been trapped in certain roles since the beginning of time, and have always had a power struggle between them. Gender issues have not evolved over time; they have always existed.…

    • 3421 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women are the strongest and most capable species on the planet. The society assumes that the ‘men’ are the strongest. Usually women are underestimated and not given a chance to display their true colours. Countries that give women equal rights are much better and developed society compared to countries that don’t give women equal rights. Women make up 50% of our society and if 50% of our society is unhappy then we as people are failures and we need to fix it. Women are what actually run this society and are the only source of sustainability in this society.…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics