Preview

Analysis: Why College Athletes Should Be Paid

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1745 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Analysis: Why College Athletes Should Be Paid
A customer walks into the local Pizza Hut, and sits down. A waiter approaches and asks what kind of pizza they want. The customer gives his order to him, and lays 200 dollars under the menu. The waiter notices, and takes the money. The customer’s pizza is 10 dollars, and he pays for it by a debit card. When he leaves, he puts 300 dollars under his own plate. The waiter grabs the money, places the money in his pocket, and goes back to working.
Now, if two new characters illustrated the names of the waiter and the customer for the football player, and an athletic booster, then everyone would be saying how rude it is, and how corrupt our society is. That is an exact reason why we shouldn’t pay players, and how the sanctions that the NCAA has
…show more content…
Finding information on this rule is very tough, because all search engines bring up many blogs about people's opinions and those aren't credible. I've noticed that some people think that rule changes are needed, and some say that the whole rule should be abolished, and all athletes should be paid. With my personal knowledge of secrecy and how people can secretly hide items of interest, some students would possibly work at Pizza Hut, have a boosters guy order a $10 dollar pizza and leave a $500 dollar tip. We all know that that's not right to do, but some regulations need to be lifted. If you let college athlete’s work within the school, such as in the cafeteria, or the library, the NCAA could possibly monitor the earnings they make. It's possible that if they worked at a Pizza Hut, or a Taco Bell, they could make sure that the NCAA has some sort of access to see the paycheck they earn and make sure it makes it to the bank …show more content…
To define what the NCAA calls a Professional Team, “is if it declares itself to be professional or provides any player more than actual and necessary expenses for participation on the team.” (NCAA Guide 10) The NCAA-made pamphlet answers all questions to the rules that I’ve mentioned. It states rules for students who are in Division I or Division II schools, such as Division 1 student-athletes aren’t allowed to accept a salary, while Division II student-athletes are permitted to do so. Division II teams can enter a contract with a professional team, while Division I teams can’t. Do these rules sound fair? I have to say yes, because Division II teams don’t get any TV Time. If a team has some TV Time, it increases their stock value to play in the NFL. There are also some rules that apply to both Division I and Division II teams. For example, Division I and II teams can’t receive benefits from an agent, or enter an agreement with an agent. The reason that this rule is made is because agents would have the most contact with an athlete, and would be able to obtain money from a boosters guy and the athlete would illegally receive the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Although on the other hand, the NCAA sells thousands of jerseys everyday with the players number on them for a profit, and the jersey symbolize the player, even if they don’t have the name on them. This makes the NCAA look very hypocritical, as they preach against one thing, but then turn around and do the same thing. If players can’t make a profit off themselves, then why should the NCAA be allowed to make a profit based off who the players are and how well they perform?…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Introduction. We are in a heavily demanding athletic world that everyone feels they are entitled to money for their skills and that it is never too early to be paid millions if they think they deserve it. These athletes are infatuated with the life of the professional league players and the life these players live. The amount of money they make, the cars they own, or the houses they live in are a few of the things these athletes want. If the NCAA starts to pay elite players at the highest level, then they should also have to pay the players at the lowest level. There is no difference between these athletes, other than the school they play for and their skill level. They are all students who play a varsity sport. Every one of these athletes goes through rigorous practice schedules, long seasons, and high demands no matter what level you play at. Every team has the same goal of winning a national championship, so how could you pay the top players and not the lower ones if they are all playing for the same championship title?…

    • 1752 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    These days athletes are getting paid under federal labor laws and entitled to form unions and negotiate wages, hours and working conditions. Most college athletes these days are getting paid under the table according to Kenneth J. Cooper. This article explains why college athletes go to certain colleges. Donald Remy, the NCAA’s general counsel and vice president for legal affairs, says court precedents and tax laws have upheld the status of college athletes as students. “Remy believes that student athletes are not employees under the law, and that they should not be treated as employees either by the law or by the schools they attend”. Tommy Amaker a former basketball star at Duke…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    If colleges were to pay athletes there would be no fair way to distribute the money. Athletes perform their sport at different levels of ability and for various lengths of time. In addition, not every player is able to compete in a game. Problems would arise about the athlete not playing which would not allow for him/her to receive the money they deserve. The first issue about this problem is that some people believe that athletes should be paid based on an open market system. This idea of an open market system would allow for supply and demand to come into play. In addition, a school would be able to pay their scouted athlete based on the money that comes in because of their ability. However, The payment would vary depending on the market along with the deals that each athlete has with the school. The second issue is about the colleges because not every college can afford the players they want to recruit. In 2013 the NCAA had an investigation on the economic stability of Division 1 sport programs. This study showed that out of 288 Division 1 schools only 23 were running their programs in a profitable way. This means that only those 23 schools had the money to pay a college athlete. In our society, any business not profiting from anything is likely not hiring, and there is no idea…

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Personally I think it is unethical for the NCAA to prohibit payment to college athletes. I say this because college athletes generate so much revenue by playing in games for the school, especially men’s basketball during March madness. March madness brings about 90% of total revenue brought in by college sports, and u might say it’s a lot so why not just pay the basketball players, but that 90% is out of 700 million a year business which is the NCAA. So the other sports are still generating a couple million dollars a year them self’s. The NCAA has a 14 year 10.8 billion dollar contract with TV broadcasting stations such as Comcast and they also generate money from student athletes wearing different name brand uniforms and sneakers. Companies like Nike…

    • 455 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The football/basketball coach is the highest paid employee at most private and public universities. The maneuvering to pay large amounts of compensation to the coaches via ‘booster organizations’ if there is a State government cap at a public university Not to mention, each bowl game is sponsored by a different company such as AT&T, PlayStation, Chick-Fil-A, etc. The College playoff committee states “A conference will receive $6 million for each team that is selected for the semifinal games. There will be no additional distribution to conferences whose teams qualify for the national championship game. A conference will receive $4 million for each team that plays in a non-playoff bowl under the arrangement (in 2014-2015, the Cotton, Fiesta and Peach Bowls).” In other words, each conference is rewarded for each team that makes the semifinal games. Of course, the athletes themselves receive no compensation it’s only fair right. In an article in the New York Times Magazine “ Let’s Start Paying College Athletes” by Joe Nocera, Nocera himself writes “The hypocrisy that permeates big-money college sports takes your breath away. College football and men’s basketball have become such huge commercial enterprises that together they generate more than $6 billion in annual revenue, more than the National Basketball Association.” Nocera’s point is that the NCAA makes more money than its professional counterpart, none other than the National Basketball Association (NBA) and arguably the most important asset gets paid nothing. The business wouldn’t exist without them. Picture the movie and television industries with the actors/actresses prohibited from making any money. Or everyone in the hospital except the surgeon. In short, the athletes are participating in an industry, in a business…

    • 1325 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    College Athletes should get paid they are the fomor NFL and the NFL get paid millions. When a college athlete gets a scholarship they get a free ride to go play football or whatever the sport is that they play but they deserve that scholarship because they are working hard to get what they want in life and they are getting better everyday.…

    • 155 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    To show just how much money college football brings in, in 2010, the SEC, a conference in Division I college football, became the first to make over a billion dollars in athletics. The Big Ten brought in $905 million dollars that same year (Branch). These astonishing numbers show just how much money a single conference can bring in during one season. It is not just conferences and teams that make money off the players, it is also the NCAA. “The NCAA itself takes in nearly $800 million a year” (Nocera). However, the NCAA is very hypocritical, as it uses the players to make money without paying them any of this. For $29.99, the NCAA offers DVDs of more than 200 famous games (Branch). This proves again the NCAA’s hypocrisy, that they think the players do not deserve money for playing, yet they will make money from selling DVDs of games. Another example of the NCAA using players to earn money is on their official shop website. By typing “Manziel” into a search box, a number 2 Texas A&M jersey with no name pops up (Gregory). It is a rule that schools cannot sell a player's jersey with their name on it, but by typing in the name that would be on the back of the jersey, it pops right up. This is another act of hypocrisy by the NCAA, by selling players jerseys without the players themselves earning any money. Not only does…

    • 1747 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Associated Press (2011, January 20) University Of Texas, ESPN Form T.V channel. Hearst. Retrieved May…

    • 851 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Richard Sherman, a premier athlete in the NFL, is what one would want to see in a student athlete. In high school, he was the salutatorian(second in his class) and graduated with a 4.2 GPA, while putting in the demanding hours required to be an elite athlete. He attended Stanford and continued his academic excellence, while maintaining that NFL prospect status. In an interview, Sherman was asked his stance on college athlete treatment: “While student athletes are being offered a free education, they do not have the time or enough opportunities to take advantage of that education. These athletes are being cut short and not getting what they deserve.” They are given a scholarship for school, yet they are expected…

    • 1487 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why should college athletes be paid to participate in their sports? College athletes are awarded tuition free college due to their hard work and athletic abilities, why should they get paid extra money outside of their tuition being paid? Student athletes in college only have two jobs while they are attending, to learn and become a better and smarter athlete. These student athletes don’t need extra money outside of having their tuition, room and board, and food paid for. They are also given clothing which takes away another money based need.These student athletes are given much more than other students and yet they still believe that they should be paid for their extra work outside of their performances. The main reason is because they are already paid through their scholarships to go to school and play sports. Other reasons to this opinion is to maintain their amatuer status, difficult…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Classes. Game time. Stress. College athletes have a plentiful amount on their plate. Not knowing where money would come from adds more on top of school and sports. Paying athletes would eliminate stress. The NCAA refuses to pay athletes, but it’s not that they don’t have money. They have billions of dollars off of capitalizing, ticket sales, and team winnings. So why don’t they pay players? College athletes should get paid because their sports are jobs, paying would make sports more competitive, and people capitalizing off college names while players still get nothing.…

    • 634 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    College Athletes are basically being used by the NCAA and all the NCAA is thinking of ways why student athletes should not be paid. In the article for the case for paying college athletes it basically explains the reason why the NCAA haven’t decided to give athletes any type of…

    • 1352 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    For many college athletes, the lure of playing pro sports is intoxicating. Dreams of fancy cars, luxurious homes, tailor-made suits, voluptuous women, and the mental images of a crowded stadium chanting their name is enough for any collegiate athlete to think about abandoning their education for a chance at stardom. When the dreams are solidified with million dollar contracts, think immediately is replaced by impulse. Left behind in the frenzy is the much needed college education that no one seems to care about any more. An athletes only hope is to complete a college education first for what life's lessons has to offer later when hard-knocks is the final exam.…

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    $53.4 Million the combined salary of the top 15 paid coaches in division 1 college football, $0 the combined salary of all student-athletes. Over the past few decades, college athletics have gained popularity across the United States. Whether it is football, basketball, or baseball, ever since the turn of the century, intercollegiate sports have brought in a surplus of revenue to their respective Universities. A recent study found that the University of Texas’ Athletic Program had the highest revenue of any other University at a little over $120 million. Yet with this large sum of money, NO college athletes are legally compensated for their work. According to NCAA rules, “You are not eligible for participation in a sport if you have ever: Taken pay or the promise of pay, for competing in that sport”. While it may seem odd and unjust to pay college athletes, the reality is that compensation of such athletes is a necessity not only to keep competition at a steady level in college athletics, but also to encourage students to graduate and get their college degrees.…

    • 872 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics