Preview

apush

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
435 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
apush
Colin Trimble
Global 2 Honors
Summer Assignment

The Sunflower Over the summer we read the book “The Sunflower”, a story written by Simon Wiesenthal. The story consists of a man named Simon having to make a choice of to forgive someone that has brought him great pain. Simon is faced with Nazi asking for forgiveness for all the people he has killed over the years. Simon makes a choice but later regrets it. The book “The Sunflower” starts with Simon Wiesenthal being put into a concentration camp during the Holocaust. He lives his life as a prisoner day by day until one day he is taken with a group to clean trash at a hospital. While walking through the town to the hospital he sees a cemetery for Nazi soldiers. He noticed that each grave had a single sunflower planted on top of it. When Simon reaches the hospital he is called inside by ta nurse who brings him to a patient’s room. The room he was brought to was the one of a dying Nazi named Karl. Simon was stuck in Karl’s room listening to his story about what he has done to Jews, the people he has killed and his mother. When Karl is done telling his story, he begs Simon for forgiveness. Without answering Simon leaves. He couldn’t decide whether it was a good idea or not to forgive the Nazi. The day after, Simon is brought back to the hospital. The nurse again brings him inside and instead of going to the patient’s room she gives him Karl’s possessions. Karl had passes away the night before. One day after Simon is freed from the camp, he goes to visit Karl’s mother’s house. He thinks it will help him decide whether or not he made the right decision of not forgiving Karl. After he speaks to her, he still can’t decide whether he made the right decision. At the end of the story he asked the reader what they would have done the same thing.

I understand why Simon made that decision he did. I would’ve done the same thing. In anger a lot of decisions are made. Simon was just very angry with Karl

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Simon Wiesenthal takes his readers on a course back in time with his writings of The Sunflower. Simon recollects moments when he was subjected to live in Nazi concentration camps during World War II. Karl, a dying SS soldier implores for forgiveness for his crimes against Jews to Simon. Our main character is conflicted by the request and leaves his readers by asking what would one have done being in his position. Proving an answer to this question can be determined by the analysis of Simon’s experiences and findings of experimenters. Philip Zimbardo and Stanley Milgram’s experiments demonstrate the relationship and effects that authority has on subjects. In “The Perils of Obedience”, Milgram applies his analysis of his experiments showing that…

    • 222 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the book The Sunflower by Simon Wiesenthal, Wiesenthal speaks to the reader and states, “You, who have just read this sad tragic episode in my life...and ask yourself the crucial question, ‘What would I have done?’” (98). Wiesenthal was task with the decision of whether to forgive Karl, and 22-year-old SS soldier, for his sins committed against the Jews. Wiesenthal, doesn’t forgive Karl, and I agree with this decision. If placed in Wiesenthal’s shoes, I would not, and could not, forgive Karl for his sins, and crimes, against European Jewry because only God can forgive man for sins against God, but also because Karl never seemed to show any true remorse.…

    • 418 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    HUM 301 Sunflower

    • 3280 Words
    • 14 Pages

    A profoundly poignant account portraying the internal conflict Simon Wiesenthal experiences when a dying Nazi soldier earnestly seeks his forgiveness, The Sunflower provokes introspective discussion about forgiveness, justice, mercy, and human responsibility. While metaphorically gazing upon the sunflowers displayed on the graves of soldiers, Simon is forced to mechanically march towards the Technical High School he once attended. The familiar surroundings evoke memories of the hatred and contempt he encountered while he was a student, particularly on the examination days that had been entitled "a day without Jews" by his Polish classmates (Wiesenthal 20). When he arrives at the Technical High School (now a military hospital), Simon and the other prisoners are instructed "to carry cartons filled with rubbish out of the building" (Wiesenthal 22).…

    • 3280 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    I felt her tears would wash the inhuman acts for decades as well as all perpetrators' sins. I wondered if the winged mother hastily forgets her child to give that simple forgiveness speech, or she forgives, but she never forgets! The scene comes along with the big theme of "The Sunflower" when Simon Wiesenthal challenges with the question about forgiving. He refuses to forgive Karl on his going bed for his atrocities against Jews (Simon 55). The great anguish of Simon drives his humanity along with his believe and puts him in awkward time with his conscious. No doubt, the outstanding about Simon’s question is not only the possibilities of forgiveness or who deserves to be forgiven but most important is the brought endeavor to decide. Although it is normal to those, who believe that forgiveness depending on the human nature and different conditions such as repentance of the perpetrator or the mercy of the direct victim, my close arguments acknowledge that unconditional forgiveness does not come along with the human nature and needs a supernatural power to…

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the novel The Sunflower, Simon Wiesenthal, recounts his time while in a concentration camp. During this time there were some Jews that were moved into a camp and others that had remained in the ghettos. A few men from the camp would sneak over to the ghetto to gather any information, whether it be good or bad, to share with the others in the encampment. At this point it was rare to receive any good news as most news was bad and they always expected to worse.…

    • 290 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The book Sunflower is based on the possibilities and limits to forgiveness , and it’s even in the title. The book talks about a young Simon Wiesenthal as he goes to a concentration camp. There he had seen all the horrible acts ,that we read about now, firsthand . While he was there he was put on duty to help a mortally wounded Nazi. As Simon is nursing the Nazi he hears about all the horrible acts that the man has committed. This whole time when the Nazi was on his deathbed Simon could not see how he could ever forgive this man.The…

    • 235 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Simon Wiesenthal Analysis

    • 1055 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Simon Wiesenthal takes his readers on a course back in time with his writings of The Sunflower. Simon recollects moments when he was subjected to live in Nazi concentration camps during World War II. Karl, a dying SS soldier implores for forgiveness for his crimes against Jews of Simon. Our main character is conflicted by the request and leaves his readers by asking what would one have done being in his position. Providing an answer to this question can be determined by the analysis of Simon’s experiences and findings of experimenters. Philip Zimbardo and Stanley Milgram’s experiments demonstrate the relationship and effects that authority has on subjects. In “The Perils of Obedience”, Milgram applies his analysis of his experiments showing…

    • 1055 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    No matter how bad a crime a person commits, one should still forgive that person when he or she asks for forgiveness. Sometimes people go for the wrong thing because they’re forced to do it just like the dying Nazi. Simon Wiesenthal should have forgiven the dying Nazi because one should forgive but not forget, it is a central tenet of the Jews religion, and there’s no limit to forgiveness.…

    • 660 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In his book "Sunflower", Simon Wiesenthal poses a very difficult philosophical question. With a SS man, Karl, on his deathbed, he asks you for forgiveness on all the atrocities and specifically one horrible one he has committed throughout his service as an SS man. What do you do in his place? The most difficult part in answering his question is that you really can't know until you were in such a position yourself. Yet we can project our feelings on this dilemma. So forgiveness becomes the focal point in this query. What is forgiveness and who deserves it and why? These are the questions posed. In my answer to his main question of what I would have done I seem to relate more to the approach of Stein and Heschel rather than that of the Dalai Lama or Dith Pran. I tend to side with them for one reason. I believe that Karl decided to confess just so he could feel better about himself instead and his fear of death rather than coming to a realization of his wrongs. I believe this for several reasons.…

    • 836 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Robert Cole

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Berger, Rebecca Goldstein, Rodger Kamenetz, and Arthur Hertzberg are all against forgiving Karl, their reasoning’s behind non-forgiveness vary. Alan Berger provides various reasons. First, he questions the repentance of Karl and ponders on if it’s genuine or not. He provides a valid reason to not forgive: the beliefs of Judaism followers. Additionally, he also feels Karl perpetuated the Nazi stereotype and expected to cleanse his own soul at the expense of a Jew. Robert Coles, however, believes that Simon does not have to forgive, but he must be prayed for. He agrees with Berger’s idea that Karl spoke in the name of all Jews, not just Simon (page 137). Rodger Kamenetz is on the same page in that he believes Karl did not address Simon as a person, rather a Jew thus removing any individualism left in Simon. Rebecca Goldstein also feels that Karl does not have the right to die in peace because he does not provide each Jew with the individualism deserved. She provides a valid comparison of the Nazi’s thinking Jews are like water. She states,…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    To me personally, I find the simple question of “What would I have done?” in Wiesenthal’s autobiography to not have a simple answer at all. This concept of putting yourself in Simon’s place leads the mind to wonder. Trying to understand that same traumatic experience as described in The Sunflower seems nearly impossible to determine what your probable response would be. After all is it even possible to forgive, forget, and offer compassion to someone who is capable of such a massive massacre? Did Simon show justice, mercy, forgiveness, punishment, suffering, or were moral obligations unfulfilled? One single decision can cause various people to interpret Simon’s actions and reflect upon them according to their beliefs. As for my personal thoughts,…

    • 446 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Sunflower

    • 2287 Words
    • 10 Pages

    The primary story line of the book, Simon Wiesenthal was a Jewish prisoner in a concentration camp in Lemborg, Poland. He did pass a Polish cemetery on a forced journey to a Technical School which had been turned into a make shift hospital. On each grave site a sunflower had been planted, each standing straight. This is where the title of the book derived from. He envied those lying in their graves because they had been properly buried, a sunflower marking their graves, with butterflies flying overhead. He predicted his burial site would be a mass grave. After arriving at the make-shift hospital, he was secretly led by a nurse to a dying SS member’s bedside. The soldier recalled his past experiences with the Hitler youth group and his volunteering for army duty. The SS soldier described “the terrible thing” he had done and said, “Some time elapsed before I realized what guilt I had incurred.” Simon couldn’t forgive the soldier and left him in silence.…

    • 2287 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Griffins Text

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Susan Griffin’s main focus in her essay “Our Secret“ is on Heinrich Himmler’s life. She hopes to better understand how people come to be who they are as a product of childhood and adolescent experiences. Through this process she hopes her readers can become conscious to the truths of their upbringing and not only find their true identity, but have the strength and courage to change their destiny. Griffin is ultimately interested in finding her own identity but has been oppressed by her grandmother to not search inwardly. She therefore uses Himmler as a mask by examining what experiences shaped him as a child to understand what may have molded her. Griffin concentrates on connections between people, childhood, and objects to Heinrich Himmler’s life to better understand social and personal identity, and oppression. Although Griffin writes an excellent account on the connections and metaphors that define Himmler, she leaves the reader feeling lost and unfulfilled by her lack of connection to her own personal search for identity.…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Large Scale Crime Analysis

    • 1359 Words
    • 6 Pages

    We do agree that a man has no right try to forgive injuries of other victims. However, in The Symposium of The Sunflower, Christopher says that, “But insofar as this act of not merely a personal act of one SS man against one Jewish child but an incident in a general campaign of genocide, the author was as much a victim…” (Christopher 179). In his words, if the Large-Scale crime comes too large that millions people involved, every single victim or offenders could be seen as the whole side because every individual’s surroundings, actions and endings would become increasingly similar with each other’s that we can consider those individuals as a whole groups. For example, in The Sunflower, Wiesenthal could represents all of Jewish victims in a massacre because he was also suffered from Nazi’s torment and forgiveness would be easier because Wiesenthal might be killed soon or later by Nazi, same as those Jewish families killed by Karl. The only difference is who will shot at him actually. Whereas, I think Wiesenthal could not represent all Jewish. First of all, even though World War II was a world scale warfare and millions of Nazi solider involved, and killed millions of Jewish victims. In this case, everyone still have to treat individually, though. To illustrate, Wiesenthal and Karl even never met each other before that nurse guided Wiesenthal to Karl in the hospital before Karl died, so Karl has no possibility harass Wiesenthal and he only feel guilty about what he had done instead of feel guilty about whole Nazi’s killing history. So Wiesenthal did not need to forgive the whole Nazi and he has no right to replaces that Jewish family to forgive Karl, because nobody authorized Wiesenthal with rights to represent others. In the other hand, Wiesenthal already knew he was going to be killed soon or later, by Nazi, so I hardly…

    • 1359 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Goodness Holocaust

    • 881 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Jews suffered continuously for about six years. They were uprooted from their homes, and forced into ghettos or camps. By recalling this time, honor is brought to the men, women, and children who were killed. Honoring those who lost their life is an act of goodness, and reminds people that being well-mannered is much better than being wicked. “No. I Have to Remember and Never Let You Forget,” (Kimel). Kimel is deeply saddened by having to constantly live on and reliving every time he was tortured, starved, or beaten. But, he knows that by remembering, and telling his tale, he can change someone’s perspective and try to make them provide goodness in this world. “My brother and I wanted those leaflets to open people’s eyes and put an end to the terrible slaughter of other people peoples and Jews,” (Sophie Scholl: The Final Days). Sophie only wanted to spread goodness to people through these leaflets. Even if she pays for these actions by death, the people of today remember her. That is the whole point she wanted to get across. She wanted people to become aware of the real circumstances, and they did. People still do. Goodness conquered the Nazi’s, which is why the Holocaust ended.…

    • 881 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays