Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

“Arab Disunity Was the Main Cause of Arab Failure in Conflicts with Israel from 1948 to 1973.” to What Extent Do You Agree with This Statement?

Good Essays
1224 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
“Arab Disunity Was the Main Cause of Arab Failure in Conflicts with Israel from 1948 to 1973.” to What Extent Do You Agree with This Statement?
“Arab disunity was the main cause of Arab failure in conflicts with Israel from 1948 to 1973.” To what extent do you agree with this statement? The Arab-Israeli tensions are a modern conflict, and a consequence of the two World Wars and collapse of British imperialism. The development and notion of Zionism in the 20th century, and massacres and scrutiny faced by Jews in Europe played a significant role in the formation of the Jewish State of Israel, which is the focal point of the conflict. Between 1948 and 1973, the Arabs and the Jews participated in several conflicts due to religious and territorial reasons. The disunity among the Arab countries, which openly opposed the formation of a ‘Jewish homeland’, played a significant role in their failures in the conflicts. However, the international condemnation of the Arabs due to ‘sympathy’ for the Jews also played a significant role in the Arab failure in relation to Israel. This essay will focus on the following conflicts: the 1948 Independence war, the 1967 war and the 1973 war. The 1948 was the ‘war of Independence’ after which the Jewish State of Israel was established. It occurred following the end of British mandate, and the withdrawal of foreign forces and government from the region. The Arab disunity was very evident during the 1948 war, as the Arab nations had various, contradicting personal agendas. There was a clear lack of trust, and each Arab country – including Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Syria and Lebanon – with each individual country aiming to capitalize and annex the area of conflict. Despite the formation of the Arab League in 1945, and a clear mutual goal to force the Jews out of Palestine; there was divisions among the Arabs. The Arabs had unanimously declared ‘jihad’ against the State of Israel and vowed to fight for ‘every inch of land.’ Despite the ceasefire in early 1948, the fighting commenced later the same year. The Arab population was significantly larger than the Jewish population, and had the militarily and physical advantage, with better weapons and population outnumbering the Jews roughly 40 million to 650,000, according the 20th Century History Course Companion by Oxford. But the lack of leadership and a unified plan of the Arabs resulted to the stationing of an army, which was significantly weaker than the Jews. Furthermore, the motivation for the Jews was that they were basically fighting for their survival whereas the Arabs were only motivated by personal gain. Additionally, the Jewish army consisted of veterans of the Second World War and managed to attain superior weapons in the form of tanks. Therefore when the individual Arab armies attacked due to a lack of a unified command; with the Egyptians from the West, the Saudis from the North East - they were easily overpowered. This war clearly indicated the Arab disunity, and highlighted the various conflicting agendas of the Arab countries. There was no united front and the Jews capitalized with strong leadership and military tactics, and managed to form the State of Israel with relative ease in the context of the conditions. The two decades following the 1948 war had two significant changes; the first being several changes in leadership in the Arab world, thus reigniting Arab nationalism, and the second being the economic development of Israel. Following Suez Crisis of 1954, the relations between Israel and Egypt had deteriorated further. Prior to the war, there were tensions between Egypt, Syria and Jordan, however an Israeli attack on Syrian jets in 1967 reunited the Arab countries. The false information provided by the Soviets to the Arabs about the mobilization of Israel sparked the Arab-Israeli conflict. However, contrary to the statement, the superior Israeli military tactics and strategy were key factors rather than Arab disunity. Israel launched a preemptive strike on Egypt, Syria, Jordan and Iraq, which effectively destroyed its weapons. This military tactic had been designed years prior, in the case of an Arab attack thus showing the Israeli militarily tactic superiority. As mentioned in the previous war, the Arab nations did not have a joint military plan thus losing several territories including Jerusalem. This was considered a ‘humiliating’ loss to the Arab cause, and significantly impacted the Arab morale. Israel had easily defeated four of its largest threats, however it can be argued this was largely due the preemptive strike on the air forces of the Arab nations, rather the Arab disunity. This war displayed the Israeli tactical and military superiority, and further displayed the role of America in the development of Israel. However, there was a minor element of Arab disunity due to tensions prior to the war but it did not play a significant role. The 1973 war was a limited war initiated by the new leader of Egypt Anwar Sadat against Israel. Sadat had also attempted to reduce the influence of the Cold War, which had been an element during the 1967 conflict, by removing Russian officials from Egypt and repairing relations with America. This war yet contradicts the statement, as Egypt and Syria had a joint military offensive strike on Israel on Yom Kippur, the Jewish holy day, and had managed to complete a successful ground offensive as well. However as the war progressed, the Israeli counterattack had begun to get more effective and managed to force the Egyptian and Syrian forces to retreat from Sinai and Golan, which were Israeli territories. The two sides were at a stalemate and the Arab allies; Egypt and Syria were united militarily and diplomatically which is contradictory to the statement and contrary the situation in the 1943 war. The looming threat of an oil embargo by the Arab countries, which was a military strategy used efficiently before, resulted to the intervention of foreign entities. Henry Kissinger, an American diplomat, stepped in for Nixon to negotiate an armistice – which was eventually successful with the Arabs accepting the armistice. This was a shorter war, and with the foundation being the Arabs being on the offensive. However it contradicts the statement, as this was the first war that the Arab countries had a joint military venture, and continued to do so during the war. Furthermore, this was a minor success for the Arab countries despite the stalemate and armistice as it strengthened Egypt and Syria’s position in the Middle East however it did not yield a territorial gain. Hence, Arab disunity was not evident with the exception of the fact that only two Arab countries participated in the 1973 war. To conclude, Arab disunity played a significant role in the 1948 war – which was arguably the most important. The Arabs had the definitive advantage in the 1948 war, however with the lack of a joint military front and strategy against Israel, it was defeated. The personal agendas, which contradicted each other, resulted to an Arab disunity and underestimation of the Jews, which allowed the State of Israel to be established despite all odds. However, in the conflicts following 1948, there was an element of Arab disunity, but it played a minor role and was not a key determinant of the wars or failure. Therefore, Arab failures can be considered to be a consequence of Arab disunity in the 1948 war, which reshaped the Middle East and provided Israel and Jews the upper hand over the Arabs conflicts following 1948.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Israel’s success in dealing with the treats it came across was due to many factors. These included Israel’s military tactics; which is one of the most important ones. Israeli determination for an independent state, the disunity between the Arab people, territory and the role of the US all played a part in the triumph of Israeli survival in the years 1948 – 73.…

    • 963 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    ‘Peaceful coexistence failed because neither the East nor the West was fully committed to it.’ How valid is this assessment?…

    • 990 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Cladogram Lab

    • 1919 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Phylogenetic systematics is away to determine the relatedness between species by creating cladograms. In this study, we observed the difference between cladograms created with morphological traits and molecular DNA with respect to Felis cattus, Canis familiaris, Didelphis virginiana, Odocoileus virginianus, and the Equus caballus. The results demonstrated that although a species is similar or closely related in regards to morphological traits, it does not mean that their DNA composition will be the same. This study is significant because it demonstrates the importance of phylogenetic systematics of both morphological and molecular traits.…

    • 1919 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Erin has been shooting up meth, herioin, and pain pills for many many months. Her children were previously taken by Jason and Kristy Smith. Jason is the brother of Trey Smith, the father. Trey is currently in rehab for alcoholism. Erin agreed to allow Jason and Kristy take the children so that she could check herself into rehab and get better, which she did not do. She did supposedly get clean for a short time. Long enough for them to bring the children back. When this situation was first discovered, Erin's arms were covered in needle marks from top to bottom and the children had been found unattended numerous times, while Erin was "dope sick" in bed and the babies were not taken care of. At those times the babies were taken to a friends home to be cared for.…

    • 340 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Opposition To Slavery

    • 1532 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Starting from the founding of the United States, dating all the way to 1835, slavery was a commonly held practice throughout the United States of America. Although less popular and to a much lesser scale in the north, the problem still existed. During these times slavery was not looked at so much as a problem, but rather an economic opportunity. Because of slavery, the plantations in the United States flourished, producing vast quantities of product to sell for large profits. Charles Post in his work “The American Crucible: Slavery, Emancipation and Human Rights” defends this when saying that, “From the seventeenth century, the slave plantations in the New World were simultaneously integrated into an increasingly capitalist world market.”…

    • 1532 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Palestine refused to accept Israel’s statehood along with many neighboring (Arab) countries. Many battles occurred the very next day after Israel gained its independent State. The battles were between Israel and Palestine, Israel and Egypt, Israel and Jordan, Israel and Syria, Israel and Lebanon…

    • 1180 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Herzl Research Paper

    • 1276 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Following the Second World War the Jewish community was in fierce conflict with Britain. Jews were fighting for a new life outside of Europe to escape the horrors of the holocaust and its affect on the Jewish community. This would lead to a declaration of independence of Israel from Palestine and sparked the Arab-Israeli conflict due to unrecognized independence and no compromise between the Arabs inhabiting the land of Israel and the chosen people of God. Israel would be accepted into the League of Nations on May 11th, 1949, further instilling the country as the Independent Jewish State long ago promised to them by God.12 Herzl’s ideas on political Zionism lead to the formation of modern day Israel, an important factor in the preservation of the way of life of the Jewish people. Many introduce Theodor Herzl as the founder of the State of Israel for his political ideology lead to its…

    • 1276 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This led to high strains between the Arabs and the Jews, as each staked claim to Palestine as the birthplace of their religion. British forces residing within the Palestine territory attempted to maintain peace, yet both the Arabs and Jews were dissatisfied with British politics. Tensions heightened in 1936 when the Arabs began to revolt in Palestine, and later as the Jews created their own resistance in 1944. Three years later, in 1947 the British attempted to resolve these issues with the United Nations Resolution 181. However, when announced on November 29th, the conflict escalated. A common issue for both parties with the United Nations Partition Plan for Palestine was the geographical divisions. It distributed Palestine into three Arab and three Jewish states preserved the holy town Jaffa as an Arab terrain within a Jewish territory and deemed Jerusalem a ‘Corpus Separatum’ regime within the city to be enforced by a Trusteeship Council, forgoing both parties’ government domains away from the sacred city. Arabs foremost concern was the granting of Jewish territories within what they considered their preordained land, and the repercussions of providing boundaries to the Jewish nation. With defined territory, it brought legitimacy to Jewish question of sovereignty, and the paved the way to establishing Jewish statehood. When the mandate was enacted, and the British withdrew its troops, came the declaration of independence of the Jewish state Israel. This quickly turned into the war between the Arabs and Israel. This war would be fought with ostensibly impossible odds for Israel, as they were not simply fighting the few Arabs currently residing within the mandates borders. Israel was attacked by a coalition of…

    • 2083 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Boycott Research Paper

    • 2145 Words
    • 9 Pages

    In 1948, the British invaded what was then Palestine. The territory had been recognized as Palestine since the end of World War I. The invasion of the land led to the 1948 Palestine War. As a result of the war, the United Nations proposed a plan to divide the land between the Arabs, the Jewish population, and a shared territory in what is today Jerusalem. While the Jewish Agency for Palestine, an organization interested in Jewish settlement in Palestine, accepted the proposal, Palestinian Arabs refused it. This was the state of affairs for Palestine as it transitioned into becoming what is now the Jewish state of Israel. Part of the agreement was that Palestine would continue to exist within…

    • 2145 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Over 20,000 people were murdered during the 1947-1948 War of Independence. The British's involvement in the conflict during the 1910's-1940's is responsible for those deaths through a narrative of events in the upcoming years to the war. The British fuelled the Arab-Israeli conflict by antagonising the Palestinian Arabs, by sentencing the Jewish people to death and by beginning the 1947-1948 Mandatory Palestine war of independence. The Arab-Israeli conflict roughly began with 'minor' disagreements and altercations since the late 19th century up until present day. Whenever the British got involved in the conflict, something seemed to go wrong. The Arabs were antagonised by the British when the McMahon agreement was not seen through.…

    • 1471 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The 9/11 terror attack on the World Trade Centre in the United States ,put the issue of terrorism on the international radar, the perpetrators (Al Qaeda) of this never before seen method of violence put forward the issue of the continued occupation of Palestine by Israel as one of the motivating reasons for their action.(observer, 2011). The conflict between Israel and the Arabs for a sovereign entity for the Palestinians had led to regional wars in 1948, 1956, 1967 and 1973.These wars though fought in the Middle East had a ripple effect on global peace and security. The Arab nations involved in these wars were Egypt, Lebanon, Syria, Jordan, Iraq, and in all these military engagements the Arabs failed to militarily defeat Israel, and in each…

    • 137 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Where once these two countries were able to find some common ground and accord, there now exists if not outright war, deep seated resentment and hostility. At the root of much conflict in the Middle East is the very land each of these countries is built upon. The area encompassing the ancient lands of Israel and…

    • 913 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The reason why the Palestinian Intifada was unsuccessful was due to the various leaders that the faction had. Chenoweth and Stephan stated, "the inability of the leadership to convince youths to stop throwing rocks, division between secular and Islamist strands, internecine violence, and PLO fickleness... is why the Intifada ultimately failed."(Chenoweth & Stephan p.120). Due to the PLO being constructed by three different parties, there was an ideological division. For example, the PLO was shifting towards a violent tactic where if one Palestinian was killed then revenge was necessary. On the other hand the PCP remained true to the cause and kept steering towards a nonviolent tactic because with nonviolence, the Intifada had reached its peak.…

    • 139 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Arab Israeli

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The 1947 – 1949 War was the first war of the ongoing Arab-Israeli Conflict. The war is known to the Israelis as The War of Independence while the Palestinians call it the Catastrophe. The war came about as a result of the end of the British Mandate and the introduction of Resolution 181. The war involved a number of Arab states fighting on behalf of the Palestinians against the Israelis who were widely viewed as the underdogs. The outcome of the war was an overwhelming victory by the Israeli who not only managed to defend their own boundaries but also gained much of the territory granted to Palestine.…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Israel Position Paper

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Cited: -"The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict in a Nutshell." Mideastweb N.p., 2007. Web. 9 Dec. 2009. .…

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics