Preview

Argumentative Essay On Alcatraz

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1796 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Argumentative Essay On Alcatraz
Immediately before boarding the boat to Alcatraz, I noticed a sign that claimed that in 1933 Sanford Bates, the director of U.S. Bureau of Prisons, stated, “Alcatraz should be reserved for desperate or irredeemable types of individuals.” I promptly arrived at the same conclusion following my initial glance at the island, as I could not possibly imagine standard criminals being deplorable enough to be sent to rot in the miserable place known as Alcatraz. No, these had to be the criminals that were so appallingly treacherous that they were not even permitted to reside in traditional prisons. Killers, kidnappers, and robbers may have had an entertaining time terrorizing the real world, but this was not quite the real world. This was Alcatraz, …show more content…
Since trudging along the virtually perpendicular walkway was proving to be entirely too strenuous for me, I swiftly reached the conclusion that I should commence routinely exercising. Following this realization, I attempted to imagine how the inmates must have felt when the boat they traveled on arrived at Alcatraz and they were then forced to traipse up the walkway with chains clanging around their feet and hands as guards surrounded them. In addition, there was a high probability that enraged winds were tugging at their hair and clothes while chilling them to the bone too. Hugging my coat closer to my body, I wondered if, in that moment, they regretted their actions or maybe just regretted that they had been caught. I speculated that the answer would likely be the latter since the prisoners had to be incontrovertibly contemptible people to end up on Alcatraz, therefore not making them prone to genuinely regret impairing the lives or physical state of others. Tucking this conclusion in the back of my mind, I continued with my attempt to visualize myself in their shoes until, at last, the building I had been waiting to reach became visible to …show more content…
I glanced across the water to the mainland and suddenly comprehended one of the reasons for relocating atrocious criminals to the island. For the inmates, being restricted to a comparatively microscopic piece of property while still being able to clearly see the city where people lived freely must have been agonizing. Forced to know the glorious city was just out of reach was like extracting a cookie from a bowl full of chocolate chip flavored ones, only to realize the cookies had raisins all along. The years spent living as prisoners on Alcatraz undoubtedly produced inconceivably abysmal

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Inside Rikers Summary

    • 1104 Words
    • 5 Pages

    When I first picked up Inside Rikers by Jennifer Wynn, I could not help but notice a disturbing image of the book cover; it was an image of an inmate locked up in his cell; he had one hand holding the bar, while having the other hand out of the cell, with a cigarette in his hand. Then I read the Publisher Weekly’s description of the book in the cover page, which read, “a penetrating exploration of inmates’ lives in New York’s ‘vast penal colony’… unusually stirring.” Based on this image and Publisher Weekly’s description, I thought this book was going to talk about inmates’ involvement in criminal activities inside Rikers Island, i.e. fights between the prison gangs. Nevertheless, once I started reading, I came to realize my presumption was totally wrong.…

    • 1104 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “Caging of America,” written by Adam Gopnik is an outline of everything that is wrong with the mass incarceration problem in America. We have come so reliant on methods that do not work that we have become blind to the effects it has on prisoners. We believe have set up a successful model to handle mass incarceration, in addition to our miss guided belief that we have fixed a problem.…

    • 397 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Marion Prison History

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In 1963, when San Francisco’s notorious Alcatraz Prison shut its doors for the last time, the United States Penitentiary in Marion, Illinois opened theirs. It was built to replace the isolated prison after expenses were exceeded and the institution became a financial burden. Although not as popular, the Marion prison continued to hold some of Alcatraz’s most famous prisoners and even contains reused materials from it. Marion Penitentiary has transformed throughout the years, evolving from its unique history and varies levels of security. From learned mistakes to successful programs, the Marion prison continues to be a functioning prison today that I fortuitously had the chance to visit.…

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Pelican Bay Supermax

    • 1170 Words
    • 5 Pages

    After listening to and or reading the transcripts of Locked Down: Gangs in the Supermax by Michael Montgomery, one gets a glimpse of prison life, sociological issues inmates and staff face, and the subculture of prison life faced by staff and prisoners alike on a daily basis. However, instead of delving completely in to the situational circumstances of prisoner life, it is more important to understand the history of this Supermax prison and why it was constructed to begin with. Further, it is important to understand the philosophy of the need for the Secure Housing Unit, which is the most secure and isolated portion of Pelican Bay Prison.…

    • 1170 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Who knew that an uprising that occurred in the fall of 1971 at a New York correctional facility would help change the American penal system forever? It was the culmination of a storm that had been brewing for months. There was a tension between the guards and inmates that had not gone unnoticed. With little to no attention given to the circumstances of the inmates, they had had enough.…

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I’m Connor and I’m going to be talking about the significant civil rights movements carried out by the Native American Indians such as the Occupy Alcatraz movement and the Trail of Broken Treaties movement. The Occupy Alcatraz shown in the first and second image was a land rights movements made by the Native Americans where many students went to the island and protested for Indian land. The students had said that they were not scared of the US government and their laws because Alcatraz was Indian land. Due to the public spot light that the occupation put on Indian issues it accelerated the process of repealing the tribal termination policy. Johnson and Glasser had said “It might have happened anyway, but Alcatraz had the attention of the nation,…

    • 633 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Examining Theory Paper

    • 1235 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The primary subject of the video “Pelican Bay State Prison: War Zone” is the fact career criminals are being able to conduct their business that landed them in prison in the first place without a problem. That the major issue of overcrowding and interaction of rival gangs has made an environment of chaotic proportions. The video displays the vulnerability it has with man power compared to how many inmates there are. Now what it seems like a place for protection and a school a crime, overcrowded undermanned prison seem like a college for the career criminal.…

    • 1235 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Alcatraz was built for the “Super Criminals”. Alcatraz was built with a lot of security for the criminals.James Johnston was the one making Alcatraz. He put searchlights. The guards could drop gas from the ceiling. They…

    • 440 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Prison system has been under scrutiny for years. They have tried every way imaginable to keep the prison system from failing. Experts have come and observed our criminal system from all over the globe “Our prison system has always been a closed institution, and that very secrecy has intrigued visitors to our country” says an article in the magazine America called “Reforming the system: rehabilitation needs a chance”. The prison system has remained an intriguing issue. The prisons have been kept quiet and no one really knows about it outside the system.…

    • 553 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Prison experiences are shared by those who spent much time behind the bars and most of the experiences shared exemplify how cruel the prison system really was showing that no rehabilitation was occurring due to an excess in punishment. The Los Angeles Times published an article, “Cruel and Usual Punishment in Jails and Prisons,” in which ex-prisoners were interviewed and shared stories of their time in prison, many of which showed how corrupt prisons have truly become. The stories described prisons as appalling and cruel, one prisoner describe being handcuffed every day to his bunk while he had to remain only in his underwear, another prisoner described how it was to live in a cell located directly under broken toilet pipes for weeks resulting…

    • 349 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Isolation In Jails

    • 170 Words
    • 1 Page

    This article talks about the lack of research done on jail isolation. It also looks at the potential repercussions of the practice of isolating inmates and how isolation as a tool so becoming more and more common with time. The paper goes into detail about one specific jail, Rikers Island, which has been accused many times of participating in controversial practices relating to rape, neglect, and corrupt officers. Lurigio uses Rikers Island as an example for much of his argument. The studies done at Rikers Island and the scandals that have come out of it act as Lurigio’s evidence. The article also addresses the risk of serious harm that isolated confinement is known to represent. Lurigio believes isolation possesses a serious threat to the…

    • 170 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Anyone who has ever been to prison can testify about the harsh nature of that kind of facility. Rehabilitation has taken a back seat to punishment which has caused a very difficult transition between prison and the outside world. In the 70’s, the popular idea of prisons was to build more prisons, which will get criminals off the streets. In theory that sounds right, but in practice it has shown to be highly ineffective. Etienne Benson, with the American Psychological Association, delivers analysis around the topic by explaining the historical context while also giving reason to distrust the system.…

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1980 at the Penitentiary of New Mexico there was a riot that lasted for 36 hours and killed 33 inmates. In this selection Colvin sheds light onto the fact that there were many factors leading to the riot, and that it cannot be looked at as a random act of violence by inmates. Our society is quick to label all inmates as “animals” or to stereotype them all together as being dangerous and without humanity, but to do this is to overlook the acts of kindness and bravery that some inmates displayed. The majority of the inmates were simply looking to escape.…

    • 1126 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Intimately and intricately related to the boom in prison construction has been a boom in imagined images of prison, with the prison's walls of secrecy validating a complex set of supportive cultural fantasies that ultimately function as agents of collective denial.(6) Even superficially realistic representations, such as the Oz TV serial, end up masking or normalizing America's vast complex of institutionalized torture. Perhaps the dominant image, promulgated by the very forces that have instituted the prison-building frenzy, envisions prison as a kind of summer camp for vicious criminals, where convicts comfortably loll around watching TV and lifting weights. Just as false images of the slave plantations strewn across the South encouraged denial of their reality, false images of the Abu Ghraibs strewn across America not only legitimize denial of their reality but also allow their replication at Guantánamo, Baghdad, Afghan desert sites, or wherever our government, and culture, may build new citadels of torture in the…

    • 654 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Supermax Prisons

    • 598 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Federal Bureau of Prisons oversees 114 correctional institutions throughout the United States. Most of them are classified as Minimum to Medium security, Levels I-IV. These facilities house everyday criminals, and only contain a very small number of high-profile, high risk inmates. There are 22 prisons, however, that are dedicated to keeping the most dangerous humans in the country off the streets. These are Super-Maximum Security prisons, or Supermax. They are classified as Levels V-VI, and they offer little more than what is needed to survive; nourishment and shelter. Most offer no chance of rehabilitation, and for some, it’s just the last stop before capital punishment. The evolution of the Supermax prison can be seen the clearest through three facilities: United States Penitentiary (USP) Alcatraz, USP Marion, and Administrative Maximum USP Florence. The first real need for a Supermax prison arose in the 1920’s, during the Great Depression and Prohibition. Crime was rampant, and gangsters like Al Capone and George “Machine Gun” Kelly ran the streets. The Ashurst-Sumners Act, which prohibited the interstate transportation and sale of goods manufactured in prisons, had officially ended free-market prison industry. Prison administrators, left with inmates that had nothing to do, latched on to the concept that only through a harsh prison sentence could an inmate pay their debt to society. Prisons transformed from factories to fortresses, with maximum security and minimum freedom. But many could not handle the influx of criminals that rose with the crime rate, along with agitated inmates that incited riots just to pass the otherwise uneventful time. The Federal Bureau of Prisons, newly established in 1930, decided that a message needed to be sent to the American public that the uncontrolled crime surge would not go unchallenged any longer.…

    • 598 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics