March 21, 2013 In the story the Hunter’s in the Snow, the three protagonists were bickering throughout the entire morning. One of the main characters, Tub, shot his friend Kenny due to reflex, after Kenny had shot a dog in the head. Kenny had provoked Tub, with what most would consider an idle threat, however Tub had responded by shooting his friend in the stomach. Some might argue that Tub’s reaction was justified due to Kenny’s earlier recklessness; this suggestion is not accurate because if we all responded to threats in this matter no one would be alive. Tub has been hunting before so he knew that the shot in the stomach would make him suffer. He got sick of being picked on and feeling excluded and with the constant power struggle between all three of them, Kenny of course being no longer on top. They stopped to warm their hands and left Kenny in the car to freeze. And again to eat pancakes Tub said, “I’ve never been so full,” meaning being satisfied about shooting Kenny.
Frank is the instigator for Tub. Followed Kenny around before he was shot, then after Tub shot him, Frank apologized for picking on Tub and stopped for food and coffee. Frank was the new “leader” even though Kenny was still rolling around in the back. After they left the coffee shop Frank forgot the directions on the table but told Tub he “remembered” them pretty good.
Kenny was the “alpha male” of the group and made Tub the center of his jokes. In the story Tub says that Kenny “made” him do it. When Tub and Frank saw that Kenny was out of the truck they flung him back in like a dead deer.
The farmer didn’t care about Tub shooting Kenny; he had no bandages, or a flashlight for them to see. Instead of giving Tub and Frank directions fifty miles to a hospital the farmer should have brought them. Even though he wasn’t involved with the men before the shooting, he did only tell Kenny it was okay to shoot his dog while Tub and Frank didn’t know.
Although Kenny had provoked Tub it doesn’t justify Tub shooting Kenny. All these characters contributed and played a role in Kenny’s murder, by calling it self-defense it would be unjust. In the end of the story they didn’t just take a wrong turn from the hospital but, a different turn away from being human beings, and toward being no better than animals.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The friends make their way to a farmhouse to ask the property owner if they could hunt for a deer on his land because they had seen tracks leading up to his property. The farmer agrees but tells them they probably won't find anything. But the three men head back out anyways. Hunting is an activity which Wolff's father used to take him and his brothers out to do (Biography 2). It's interesting to see how Wolff uses hunting as the basis for the story. Not long later Kenny appears to start going crazy. He states that he hates certain objects- then he shoots them "dead." He shoots a tree. He shoots a dog. Then he says to Tub: "I hate you" (Wolff 78). But before Kenny could pull the trigger, Tub shoots off his rifle, hitting Kenny right in the stomach, knocking him over backwards. Frank just stood there stunned while Kenny started apologizing immediately, saying he was never going to shoot Tub. Meanwhile, Tub just keeps saying he shot him out of defense. That it wasn't his fault. Which could be a lie, but it isn't said in the story. Wolff is known for his lies and he even states that saying: "I…
- 835 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
“Just past the house, Tub slipped and threw out his hands to catch himself. The boards fell and Kenny tumbled out and rolled to the bottom of the drive, yelling all the way” (Wolff 6). Tub saved himself rather than his friend Kenny, who had just been shot. He is so inconsiderate and self-absorbed, that when he slipped, he was only worried about himself. Kenny is helpless and now in danger of infections along with hypothermia because he was just rolled down a snowy hill. If Tub fell he would have just gotten a little wet and a few bruises. So this was inconsiderate and disrespectful. Real friends would have made sure their injured friend made it to the truck safety. Tub and Frank don’t have any sympathy for…
- 1484 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
When your friend dies, you may feel as if it is unfair and may want to seek revenge upon someone or something else. By doing so, you are bringing your pain and anger towards someone else so that they feel what you are feeling. Even though this method of dealing with death is not the best way to go, it is still common and when you are in a state of death, you do not consider how others will feel, rather how you feel. In the book, O’Brien explains that a time this happened was after Lemon was killed, Kiley’s best friend, Kiley shot a Viet Cong water buffalo several times. After Kiley shot the buffalo, it laid there bleeding but still remained alive. Kiley was distraught over Lemon’s death and so all he wanted was to see something else in the same pain he was going through. This coping mechanism is used when you do not blame yourself, rather the world for their…
- 1081 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Curly began agitated as he could not find his wife. He then began to assume the worst (involving other men working on the ranch). He soon grew embarrassed when he found these assumptions not to be true. Taking this rage out on Lennie, he began to punch and beat the child like man. Lennie defenseless and bewildered looked around the room for instructions when old friend George soon directed him to fight back, leading to the small man to look even smaller.…
- 307 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
An unfortunate event occurred when Tub had to shoot (in what appears to be self defense) Kenny after he fired at a post, killed an innocent dog, then turned to Tub and said “ I hate you”. As the story moved forward Kenny remained in the bed of the truck bleeding out as Frank and Tub stopped at a diner in the midst of promising Kenny they would take him to a hospital. One they get back on the road Wolff ends the story in suspense when Kenny is saying to himself “ I’m going to a hospital ”, but it is made clear to the reader by the narrator - “But he was wrong. They had taken a different turn a long way back”.…
- 456 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Some locals claimed that they heard Lennie playing with his dog and once Curly’s wife came, they very quickly heard a scream and then what sounded to be someone snapping branches. The detective’s theory was that Lennie killed his dog from frustration and was in a rush to leave the ranch before anyone could notice so he covered the dog in hay and attempted to flee the scene. He got distracted by Curly’s wife and tried to get his way with her. It didn’t go well so he threw…
- 183 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Set in the South Bronx, the film follows the lives of a pair of brothers and their group of friends, all of whom are devoted to various elements of early hip-hop culture. Kenny Kirkland (Guy Davis) is a budding disc jockey and MC, and his younger brother Lee (Robert Taylor) is a hardcore b-boy who dances with Beat Street Breakers (the New York City Breakers). Kenny's best friends are Ramon (Jon Chardiet), a graffiti artist known by his tag, "Ramo", and Chollie (Leon W. Grant), his self-styled manager/promoter.…
- 3944 Words
- 16 Pages
Powerful Essays -
1. In this paper I will argue that Singer is wrong to claim that human suffering and animal suffering should be given equal consideration. He claims that human animals and non-human animals with vertebrae experience pain and suffering in the same way. (41)…
- 1055 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
On the psychological standpoint, this story has almost everybody’s perception. People change according to time and situations. After Tub shot Kenny, Frank simultaneously changed his subordinate position from Kenny to Tub. He himself believed that favouring Tub would give him a chance to fill his loneliness. Frank was smarter and he took his decision according to time, however, the decision was perfect. Kenny, the first alpha person, had a secret of Frank’s, and Kenny was restricting Frank to stay with him in any situation or he would reveal the secret. On the other side, Tub was totally opposite and the situation was also in a favour of Tub. Kenny was shot and Frank was the only eyewitness, and with mutual understanding, Frank disclosed his secret to Tub and tried to get emotional support. After becoming the new alpha, Tub definitely chose supporting dogma get support.…
- 600 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
1. Explain how the ecosystem was affected by the missing species for each round of the demonstration.…
- 450 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
When Ken and Leon find the body of their grandfather under the big cottonwood tree they seem to handle the situation rather well. When they discovered the body, which has apparently been lying under the tree for at least a day Leon and Ken herd the sheep back to the camp and return by truck to the body. They don’t seem to be saddened at all which a lot of people in that situation would be. They just go right along with tying a feather in the old man's white hair and painting his face. When Leon is finished painting he steps back and smiles at the face of his grandfather showing no emotion and asks the old man to send some rain clouds.…
- 433 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
town and Tom happened to blunder upon him. He gave him some of the food he had…
- 395 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Arguments based on emotion work in different media by getting the audience to feel a sense of what the advertiser is trying to convey. The effectiveness of these arguments differ based on the promoter and what they are trying to present. For example, if the promoter is trying to get a message across through a book, they have to include something that might interest readers. Unlike books, if they are trying to advertise something through television, they include something that might interest people who like watching T.V., such as “couch potatoes” etc. The approach for magazines is different. If someone is already reading a magazine they are in for ads therefore it is much easier to grab their attention. However, arguments based on emotion vary significantly on websites. You can go from a positive response to an extremely negative response in a few seconds, therefore you must be careful. Certain things an ad might portray may go against what someone believes and will instigate “hate” comments which technically may not deserve that type of classification. Others may be able to receive the emotion the ad is trying to present and therefore the ad can be successful. Newspapers are an emotionally colder source than television news in my perspective because when you are watching the news, the reporters can sound a little enthusiastic, delivering the news in a hopeful manner. When reading the newspaper, you can only interpret it how you envision it and so if the tone of the paper is depressing, then it would be emotionally colder.…
- 265 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The story begins with Carter Druse being referred to as a criminal for being asleep on his post: The clump of laurel in which the criminal lay' (Pojman, Vaughn 356) yet some may argue that a son shooting his father is immoral and criminal no matter in wartime or not. In keeping with Kantian thinking and philosphy, I think it is the perfect example of putting aside emotions and basing a decision soley on reason and duty.…
- 286 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Andy James : He tried to hit a vein of oil, to find one strike that would keep the family on the ranch. They borrowed again from a bank that already had taken back much of the ranch.…
- 536 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays