Preview

Arguments Against Compatibilism

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
741 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Arguments Against Compatibilism
There are many different topics and subjects that can go as far back as our first ancestors that people argued against one another. Each person wanting to prove the other wrong. Some of the questions have been answered today like the sun is in fact the center of the solar system and everything revolves around it. Before, many people believed earth was the center of the universe and would kill others that didn’t go along and agree. There are some subjects that have not been answered however. Everyone has different opinions and not one person is going to think like the next. Some people want a lot of evidence and some only need to be told to believe. The topic of free will fits into this category. Free will is the ability for a person to be able …show more content…
Compatibilism is the idea that free will and determinism can coexist. The choices that we are faced with today are the causes of choices we have made in the past. Compatibilist believe that freedom is the ability for a person to be able to make their own choices and not be restricted. One of the major objections to compatibilism is that many other philosophers believe they have the wrong idea over what freedom is as well as free will. Other arguments over compatibilism are that they don’t believe that compatibilist are asking enough of free will and are only looking at the surface and not at the genuine facts about free …show more content…
Hard determinism is a view on free will which states that determinism is true and that it is incompatible with free will. Because of this, it states that we do not have a free will at all. This can be a major objection because it spells out that we don’t have any free will and no control over our actions. Many people can see this as scary to think about and therefore reject it. Everyone likes to think that we have choices but when you truly sit down and think about it, do you? All our actions are determined by external factors. The big argument against hard determinism is the opposite than listed above. People think they have the choices in their life and they are results from the past and it will impact the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Gates of Fire

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Gates of Fire By: Steven Pressfield Subject Person- Spartan Warriors Place- Greece 480 B.C. Event- Battle of Thermoplae. Concept- Xeones recounts his life leading up to the battle. Object- Greek city-states consisting of 300 Spartan Warriors, 400 Thebans, 700 Thespian Volunteers And around 900 Helots Fought The Persian Empire at the pass of Thermopylae. Reason For Choosing Book Prior to reading this novel I had some knowledge of the Battle of Thermopylae. I watched the movie 300last year and it is based on the battle of Thermopylae and the lifestyle of the Spartan Warriors. Summary Gates of Fire tells the story of a young Greek boy, Xeones, who is the sole Hellenic survivor of the epic battle of Thermopylae in 480 BC. After losing his village and family to the treachery of the Argives, Xeones wanders in the countryside with two companions, and spends his formative years as an outlaw. He eventually is captured and enslaved by the Spartans, who cast him with other slaves, called helots.…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Compatibilism, in other words, soft determinism is the “belief that free will and determinism are compatible ideas and that it is possible to believe both theories without being logically inconsistent. Compatibilists believe freedom can be absent or present in situations.” Therefore as a compatibilist, I believe that despite determinism being true we still have the freedom to control our actions.…

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hard determinists believe in the theory of universal causation-that is for every physical even, there is a prior physical cause. Benedict Spinoza out it as ‘In the mind there is no absolute or free will; but the mind is determined to will this or that by a cause, which has been determined by another cause, and this last by another cause, and so on until infinity.’ They say that as the universe in governed by laws of nature, with enough information, we could necessitate what will happen and therefore accurately predict everything that will happen in the future. This area of determinism is known as scientific determinism who, in the words Pierre-Simon Laplace, believe that ‘If you know the speed and position of a particle, it would be possible to know their position at any other time’, meaning that you can predict the future by the state of the universe now. Humans are part of the universe and like everything else, are made up of particles and so are governed by the laws of nature. All our actions have a prior cause and choices that…

    • 2062 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When it comes to determinism and free will, there are two categories which determinists would side with. Either they are a soft or a hard determinist. Determinism is defined as the theory that “everything in the universe..is entirely determined by causal laws, so that whatever happens at any given moment is the effect of some antecedent cause” (Pojman & Fieser, Free Will and Determinism, p. 388). In this essay, I will be reviewing philosopher Baron d'Holbach's arguments against the concept of free will in the perspective of a hard determinist.…

    • 597 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Firstly, to speak of compatibilism, you’d have to assume that the world is deterministic, meaning that everything that happens from here on out, including human action, is caused by the facts of everything that has happened before it. With that assumption in mind, compatibilist believe that we still have free will as long as we aren’t operating under external limitations. The problem with that is that although compatibilists believe we are free, there is still disagreement on just exactly how free we may be, which is the weak spot indeterminists and incompatibilists use to try to break the argument.…

    • 1592 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    philosophy 3.2

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages

    >>> Traditional compatibilism is the doctrine that free actions are caused by one's will and not externally constrained.…

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Chisholm and Free Will

    • 1277 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Before I begin it is pertinent to note the disparate positions on the problem of human freedom. In "Human Freedom and the Self", Roderick M. Chisholm takes the libertarian stance which is contiguous with the doctrine of incompatibility. Libertarians believe in free will and recognize that freedom and determinism are incompatible. The determinist also follow the doctrine of incompatibility, and according to Chisholm's formulation, their view is that every event involved in an act is caused by some other event. Since they adhere to this type of causality, they believe that all actions are consequential and that freedom of the will is illusory. Compatiblist deny the conflict between free will and determinism. A.J. Ayer makes a compatibilist argument in "Freedom and Necessity".…

    • 1277 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The article “Girl Moved To Tears By ‘Of Mice and Men’ Cliffs Notes” from The Onion is a satirical passage criticizing students and the way they read assigned novels; by not actually reading it but by looking at someone else’s notes on it. The literary element of satire uses irony, sarcasm, parody, hyperbole, or other methods of ridicule and humor that criticizes, but also attempts to improve human institutions or human follies. In this article, the use of situational irony is used to support the satire by making it appear as if the character, Grace Weaver, has actually read the book but in reality has not. The way that Weaver reacts to the cliffs notes about Of Mice and Men by Steinbeck, one would usually expect that she read through the novel and not only understood it but connected to it. However, Weaver did not read the novel at all and only read through cliffs notes of it. In the article Weaver says “I’m also going to find that book about rabbits that George was always reading to Lennie, so that I can really understand that important allusion.” The irony in this statement that Weaver makes is extremely evident to the whole satirical aspect of this article. Weaver wants to learn more about the story; to get more in depth, but the option of actually reading the novel isn’t there in her mind. She thinks of other things to do to get a better understanding of the book, but the best option she doesn’t think of; reading the book. Weaver’s professor says in the article after knowing that Weaver chose to read cliffs notes instead of the novel, “I look forward to skimming her essay on the importance of following your dreams and randomly assigning it a grade.” This quote shows that Weaver is not, necessarily, going to get a good grade on the assignment because she never actually read through the book and so doesn’t really know what it’s about. The satire of the article criticizes the way students choose to do book projects, but then attempts to reform that folly by…

    • 369 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hard determinists believe that every event has a cause, therefore, no one can act freely. In the video, Free Will and Determinism, the speaker states that society, upbringing, culture, and environment all play key roles as to how we feel emotionally. These four concepts interfere with our lives, and establish our actions. In addition, Honderich offers, “It is not merely a chance [External situations that may occur] or random event.” Hard determinists believe we have unknown forces acting upon us that cause us to act in a certain way. Everything that happens to us has already been mapped out and we are forced to live the life we have been given. In contrast, soft determinist believe that every event has a cause.This results in the person being free (Vaughn, Lewis, and Theodore Schick, Jr.). As described in the video, Freewill and Determinism, soft determinists believe in two types of causes: internal causes and external causes.…

    • 1475 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hard Determinism

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Hard determinists hold that if every human action is caused then humans cannot have free will in regards to the choices that we make. Determinism and free will are incompatible theories. If humans have free will then they have the power to properly choose between two actions as an extension of their will; they must to be able to do or choose the reciprocal with equal ability. Hard determinism does not argue that we do not make choices; no hard determinist would refute this obvious fact. But they bring to question whether our reasoning behind the choices is free will, or causally…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Soft Determinism

    • 1913 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Determinism currently takes two related forms: hard determinism and soft determinism [1][1]. Hard determinism claims that the human personality is subject to, and a product of, natural forces. All of our choices can be accounted for by reference to environmental, social, cultural, physiological and hereditary (biological) causes. Our total character is a product of these environmental, social, cultural, physiological and hereditary forces, thus our beliefs, desires, values and habits are all outside of our control. The hard determinist, therefore, claims that our choices are determined by these factors; free will is an illusion because the choices and decisions we make are derived from our character, which is completely out of our control in creating. An example might help illustrate this point. Consider a man who has just repeatedly stabbed another man outside of a bar; the other man is dead. The hard determinist would argue that there were factors outside of the killer's control which led him to this action. As a child, he was constantly beaten by his father and was the object of ridicule and contempt of his classmates. This trend of hard luck would continue all his life. Coupled with the fact that he has a gene that has been identified with male aggression, he could not control himself when he pulled the knife out and started stabbing the other man. All this aggression, and all this history were the determinate cause of his action.…

    • 1913 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Freewill Vs. Determinism

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages

    You don’t know what you going do until you do it. Many believe that they can predict things off what you have done in the past. For example, if a teacher see that you have been acing every exam they have given you. They are going to believe that you will ace the final exam. However, if determinism is false than nine times out ten the student could bomb that exam extremely bad.…

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Various philosophers have explained iterations of free will in more depth, resulting in a greater number of issues connected to it. When arguing against free will, the concept of determinism is advanced as the main argument. Determinism is the philosophical idea that every event or state of affairs, including every human decision, and action, is predetermined. The main perceived threats to our freedom of will are various alleged determinisms. These can be physical, psychological, biological or theological in nature. For example, suppose you meet a person you are instantly attracted to. Practically every thought and emotion in your body commands you to approach the person but for various reasons you hold back; the moment doesn't feel right.…

    • 157 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Compatibilism

    • 877 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The view of compatibilism is preferable to me for a few reasons; first the saying that nothing has a cause is simply absurd, as there are clearly things that have a cause. Second is that some human actions are free, this seems improbable because I have never seen any uncaused actions, nor can anyone give an example of an explicit action that does not have a cause, and to say that there just are is not a good reason to believe that. I am not arguing hard determinism because…

    • 877 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Desiree's Baby

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages

    “Desiree’s Baby” is a tragic short story written by Kate Chopin. The story is about the struggle between the main characters Armand and his wife Desiree. The relationship is torn apart after they come to the realization that they have a quadroon baby or quarter black. Neither of them know that either one could be the cause of the mixed baby. Armand sees this as a curse to his family name and disowns Desiree and the baby. After Desiree and her baby are disowned by Armand, Desiree feels she has nothing to live for. She disappears into the bayou where we can only guess she kills herself. In the end, we learn that when Armand is burning the possessions of Desiree and the baby he finds a note from his mother to his father revealing the truth. It was his mother that carried the blood of the slaves. Chopin uses the story of “Desiree’s Baby” to discuss gender, race, and the inequality between them in a time when slavery and race were mainstream issues of the day.…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays