After carefully reading the essay "Arranging a Marriage in India" I believe despite all the good reasons they mention about the advantages of having your parents chose whom you will marry is simply cruelty. In the essay "Arranging a Marriage in India" Serena Nanda is a professor which travel from America to India to carry out field studies. While in India, Nanda studied about Indian marriages and how the parents are the ones to choose the bride or bridegroom. At first Nanda was against this but after researching and interviewing different people and friends she had doubts. Nanda found out many interesting point that made sense to her of why arranging a marriage was not as bad as she thought.
Nanda met Sita, who has been waiting over a year for her parent to pick whom she will marry. Nanda ask her, "why would you tolerate such a situation don't you care whom you will marry" and Sita replied, "of course I care but I am inexperience and I'm sure my parents would pick what's best for me." In other words parent knows best. Sita took the time to explain to Nanda that in America girls spend more time worrying about meeting the right person that they have no time to enjoy their teenage life. Nanda thought of this and agree but still kept insisting, how can you marry someone you don't even know? Why would you marry someone you don't love?However, Sita amazed Nanda by saying that this would be like an adventure getting to know each other and finding romance together while in the marriage. After all this, Nanda returned to America with a whole different view of arrange marriages. Time passed and Nanda returned to India and kept researching arrange marriages this time she interview many couples whose marriages were arranged. After interviewing them she came to the conclusion that they've been married for a considerate time and was still happily married. On the other hand, Nanda had friends in America whose weddings were not arranged that were in the process of a divorce.
Furthermore, after all the research and interviews she had done Nanda found arrange marriages very interesting and excited. Nanda was so excited about arrange marriages that she decided to become a matchmaker herself since she was successful in fixing up dates for her friends back in the United States. Short after deciding this Nanda found an old friend of hers and she happens to be in search of a bride for her son. Nanda offer to help her out with this so she exchanged some words to find out what were the requirements the bride had to acquire. She found out that they needed to know the well being of the family and how related they well in society. For example what was the family business, how many brothers or sisters and what was the dowry the bride had to offer.
After finding out all needed to find a bride she helped her friend find a bride for her son even thought it was not easy. Her friend was real picky in choosing her future daughter in law. They saw many girls but they well either to liberated, fat, or too high class which meant she had too much to offer and this would be a humiliation to towards the family. Even thought all the reasons giving in the above paragraphs about arrange marriages were convincing as I mention at the beginning I still see this as a cruelty.
I believe marriage has been an issue that people have tackle for many years because of different cultural beliefs. Marriage should be about being able to unite with a person that one loves, despite our different cultural beliefs. In other words Marriage is about love and one's willingness to share a life's journey together, regardless of whom you chose. I believe everyone is the same; we all eat breath and breed the same way. Therefore we should all have the same rights and privilege to choose whom we want to marry. Marriage is the state of being a married couple voluntarily joined for life. This means you commit yourself to the person you love for a lifetime and like Sita mention you can get to know each other during the marriage and fall in love but this is only a possibility.
In any marriage, certain qualities are required in order to sustain a healthy relationship. Patience, love, understanding, trust and kindness are a few of many helpful attributes that would help create a long lasting marriage. No matter what your reasons for marrying someone, you can make it a successful relationship by simply being courteous and respectful. Any marriage arranged or not has the same probability of getting a divorced.
However, in these cases arranged marriages are mostly to improve the social standing of a family. I see this arranged marriages more like a business negotiation between the family thinking in their well being and in the men's feeling and they leave the women out. In other words the bride has no saying in the marriage because they are taking away from her family and place in a stranger's house with a whole different life to which she is accustom. From my point of view this is cruelty, for example is like taking a child away from the only person that raised them and putting them in a foster home with a person they never saw before.
In addition, the bride has to stick to the command of her new family and can't protest or return to her parent's house. If she try to leave her husband she would be disowned, divorced is not a choice. Another example of cruelty is the dowry which had to be given from the bride side. Dowry is an amount of money or property given by a bride's family to her bridegroom or his family when she marries if the family finds it unsuitable their just find a way to get rid of the wife and remarried.
So stand up for your rights choosing your life partner is a fundamental right. You decided whom you want to date or married. Never let anyone treat you like an object that you buy and do as you pleased with it. Everyone has the right to be happy so don't let anyone chose for you go out and find what you deserve but don't rush into thing remember good things come to those who wait. In addition, being able to pick whom you want to marry encourages people to have strong family values. A healthy marriage allows people to be more conscious and protective of their surroundings; if and only if the negative viewpoints of different cultural beliefs in society involving marriage issues become non-existence we will all be one big happy family.
Overall My personal opinion on marriage in general is that it's all relative. If you feel comfortable that you can choose a suitable spouse, which you will be with for a lifetime, then that should be your personal choice to make. However, if you feel that your parents could decide better than you could, then there is definitely nothing wrong with getting an arranged marriage if and only if you make them traet you like a human being not an object wich they can dispose as they want. The most important thing is that you're happy. It's not the route you take getting there, but the destination. If you are married your dream mate, then why does it matter how you found them if in any marriage there is always the possibility of getting a divorced whether is an arrange one or not.
bibliographieshttp://www.indianmatrimonials.com/http://www.indianchild.com/indian_marriages.htm
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Author's attitude describes of women's status in our society, by providing the facts of woman’s right in Arfahginstan and writer states his opinion about the issue. Woman want freedom to choose that person they like, who they respect and take care of them. Because she should choose the person of their interest and their capacity. Government can't force marriages if doesn't work it is destiny to fail there's always obstacles to overcome. When people are more same standard and…
- 555 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Author Serena Nanda begins the article by introducing the concept of arranged marriage in India. Nanda then begins to describe a filed trip to India and her direct experiences with arranged marriage. On this trip, Nanda met many young men and women whose parents were trying to match them…
- 465 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Arranged marriage is somewhat offensive to feminist America. There is a level of freedom attached to choosing who and when to marry. Hollywood portrays arranged marriage as the evil separator of lovers, the extinguisher of freedom, and the ultimate subjugation of women. Vogue has an article titled “The Arranged Marriage That Ended Happily Ever After: How My Parents Fell In Love, 30 Years Later.” The article highlights the good points of the couple’s marriage which was arranged years earlier in India. Yet, these people had a thirty-year marriage without the “passionate feelings to glaze over your partner’s flaws in…marriage” (Jacob). Marriage looks clinical and dry this way. However, this is the outside view of arranged marriage. Cultural customs…
- 691 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Serena Nanda fails to write an impartial argument for arranged marriages versus "love match" marriages like those in the United States. She neglects to present the positive aspects of choosing a partner for marriage opting instead to keep the focus on the negatives. Her argument for arranged marriages is weak and unfocused leaving the reader to doubt her logic. In her attempt to persuade the reader to supporting arranged marriages, she actually emphasizes the negative effects of them. Reading Arranging A Marriage in India, strengthens the idealistic values of romantic love and exposes the flaws of arranged marriage including the extreme limitation of potential partners, inexperience and ignorance of the people, excessively traditional and sexist…
- 660 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
An arranged child marriage is when the groom or bride have no say so in their marriage that their family members planned or agreed to. Girls and boys are affected by arranged child marriages, however girls are relatively indeed impacted the most. Child marriage has an impact on the child’s: health, education, and mentally and physical toll on the body. The health of a young bride could become very deadly…
- 506 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Their choice to marry one another was a collective choice and also a third party which was the pastor at our church. Although it was a collective choice my mother still had a little doubt before they got married because my father had low self-esteem, signs of not being responsible and signs of being a cheater, which in the long run proved to be truthful. In addition to all of that, my mother was told by our pastor to move the wedding date up and he insured my mom that marrying my dad would be a perfect match for my mom so our pastor thought. As the years rode by my father’s hidden agendas came to the forefront. However with all that being said love did play a role in the marriage because my father had a good job, he fit my mother standard of physical appearance, and she felt that he deeply cared for her. As stated in the reading by Pasupathi that “it may seem obvious that different cultures will consider different criteria in mate selection” for example it says in India the criteria for marriage partners are multidimensional and includes: religion/horoscope matching, character, education, dowry, appearance, employment, caste/subcaste, geographic distance between families, financial status and lastly family status, tradition and reputation. When I asked my mother what criteria did her and my father base there alliance on she said it was her becoming pregnant, sex, how they made each other feel and the looks. They only had one criterion in common with India criteria, which was appearance. I honestly thought that my mother would have told me more characteristics that they based their alliance on but my mother said…
- 633 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The deliberation of the word marriage is connected to thoughts, feelings, emotions either its love marriage, arranged marriage or forced marriage. Antecedently, discussing the concept of forced marriage and arranged marriage, I would like to bring thoughts of the reader toward two stories related to forced and arranged marriage. Begin with a story of a poor family with only the father somehow making some earning and have two daughters that he wanted to get married as soon as possible because they were getting older. As we can assume after a certain age, usually it gets harder for the girls to get married. So whoever was telling the father or the mother that we have seen this Rishta (marriage) for a daughter? The people are exquisite, and your…
- 932 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Today, up to 90% of marriages in India and 60% of marriages in the world are arranged. In Romeo and Juliet, when asked about what Juliet thinks of marriage, Juliet told her mother that “It is an honor that I do not dream of”(Act 1 Sc. 3). In Romeo and Juliet, Romeo was about three years older than Juliet when they got married. Unlike Lady Capulet and Romeo, Juliet was was not happy about getting married hitherto her marriage to Romeo. She was too young and inexperienced to undergo such a profound milestone in her life. Arranged marriage is a source of selfishness and inconsideration, and therefore, they must be banned.…
- 111 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
After reading the article Arranging a Marriage in India my first thoughts were why would any man or woman want to marry someone they are unfamiliar with, no nothing about them. I had the same mind as Serena Nanda who is the woman who got to experience it all while her trip to India. Of course my opinions had changed after reading the article, although I never had a problem with arranged marriages because I had been aware that some cultures do that as a lifestyle, but the idea of it kind of sounding like the parents are selling the daughter. As Serena mentions that how in the U.S we find the one we love and then marry after a few years of dating if it’s the right one of course, but now divorce rate is very high and it’s usually because it’s cheating or you just get tired of being with the same person. But how a women in India see it, they marry the guy that the parents have arranged them with and they seem to have a very flow and happy marriage, but how can that be? Is what I ask myself? They are people who have never talked or seen before yet they enjoy each other, although I like the idea on how when they marry they get to know each other and they aren’t tired of each other because it’s just the beginning of their marriage, it’s kind of like dating in U.S only they’re married. They interview with Sita, Sita mentions on how her parents have experience and they know what’s best for her when picking the right guy for her to get married with. While they are picking boys for her Sita doesn’t experience dating her parents do all the work for and all she does is goes to school and enjoys her youth she has more time to spend on her life instead of worrying about the man she might marry or boys. Sita’s reasoning was very understandable and I feel like I connect to that idea and that maybe it wouldn’t be a bad idea to have an arranged marriage, but I know that it really isn’t for me. Education in man is very important when the parents of a soon to be bride is looking…
- 875 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In a strict society such as that of Yemen it is easy to see why parents are essential to the choice of a suitable marriage partner. With the exception of relationships within the family, daily life is based on a strict separation of the sexes. A young man has little or no chance of meeting women, particularly those of his own generation. Instead, he has to rely on the advice of his mother of older sisters and aunts. In a Yemeni family there is a bride search, parental agreement, the suitor meeting, two family greeting, exchange of the brides wealth, three day wedding, Laylat az-Zaffa the wedding ceremony,…
- 691 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Arranged marriages are done in around 60% of the world because the system works. In Asia, mainly India and China, arranged marriages are the main form of marriage though this has decreased as science the 18th century. To the parents, choosing their child’s spouse is much more beneficial for the family than the child picking someone that might not be the best fit for the family. Because the parents get to pick, they can chaise someone who is close to the families’ roots, someone who shares the same values of the parents, and someone who will preserve their families culture in future generations. The benefits also work as a union of families, economically and socially as the two families will become more powerful united with each other. The article, Arranged Marriages, by Jefferson M. Fish, Ph.D.…
- 761 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The arranged marriage process is extremely precise and long so spouse will truly be able to compliment each other. A spouse is chosen so they will perfectly, or as close to perfectly, match their future spouse and family to limit chance of divorce or unhappiness. For a bride, looks are taken into consideration but character is of even more importance (Nanda). Since the character of a person is so highly valued and analyzed in marriage, it is made certain that the bride will be compatible with her new in-laws and that she will be a harmonious new addition to the family. In Serena Nanda’s experience of arranging a marriage, the mother refused certain people because she knew they would be incompatible and create nothing but conflict within the household. In one case the mother refused a potential bride because her family came from a class much higher than their own (Nanda). The potential bride who came from…
- 675 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Marriages are divided into four groups, these are the following groups; "forced arranged marriage", "parents or guardians select the the individuals are consulted", "individuals select and the parents or guardians are consulted", "individuals select and the parents or guardians are neither consulted". There is a controversy started by the human rights movement that it isn't ethical to let your parents choose your partner for life. The Human rights movement actually considers it a violate to womans rights as the man is near always the dominant one in these kind of marriages. The Human rights movement is also trying to prevent arranged marriages as it is a part of one of their campaigns right now. Many people use these arranged marriages only for wealth if the family of one individual is poor and they set up a marriage with a wealthy person, without even thinking about the brides or the grooms feelings toward each other. In conclusion i recommend to always go with the normal marriages of the western world where if you love someone you marry them without anyone else's consent, arranged marriages are just to f'd up and neither partners will be happy in that kind of…
- 446 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Like most parents, Lord Capulet, in William Shakespeare’s play Romeo and Juliet, wanted the best for his daughter. He arranged her marriage to Count Paris, but did not give a thought about her feelings. This lead to a tragic end for Juliet. Just like in Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet, arranged marriages are still around today. Getting married is an important decision, and should be made by the people getting married. Parents should not be allowed to choose who their children marry because arranged marriages have a higher divorce rate than normal love marriages, their children could have no trust for the person they are marrying, and the child could not like the person he/she has to marry.…
- 388 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Can you picture yourself marrying, sleeping, or spending the rest of your life with a stranger? Someone you don’t love? Arranged marriages are very common for people in India (Nanda). Parents find their kids a partner with good education, same social class, and decent appearance (Nanda). They want to give their kids a good shot in life. But, what about love? Shouldn’t one marry the love of their life? A disrespect towards the real meaning of marriage I could say. When you are told who to marry, it’s overstepping the limit of your personal life.…
- 1492 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays