assignment5
Revenue Recognition
“Revenue recognition” refers to when sales and other revenues are recorded. Recognizing revenue is fundamental to accounting. In theory, you recognize revenue when you earn it. It sounds like it should be simple, but it isn’t.
Until recently, revenue recognition in Canada followed a trend of becoming more and more complex and arcane. The problem started in the late 1990s when, in response to perceived abuses in the United States, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission issued a series of accounting rules that resulted in the codification of extremely complex and sometimes contradictory requirements. Concepts such as “persuasive evidence of an arrangement,” and “multiple deliverables” entered the accounting lexicon. Canadian accounting then adopted the U.S. rules, with sometimes bizarre results. For example, a small start-up company could be in the position that it has sold product and services, received the cash, and has no further obligation to its customer, but cannot record revenue from the sale.
Over the past two years, old Canadian generally accepted accounting practices (GAAP) for most organizations have been changed to either International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS, primarily for public companies) or Accounting Standards for Private Enterprises (ASPE, primarily for private companies). The conversion of Canadian GAAP to IFRS and ASPE has simplified the previously overly complex rules related to revenue recognition, and restored elements of common sense to the measurement of revenue. Our start-up company referred to above would now be able to record a sale in its accounts. However, some large accounting firms have attempted to eliminate choices and so have prescribed rules for their clients that go beyond the written IFRS or ASPE requirements. In complex situations you should discuss revenue recognition with a qualified accountant, and if necessary seek a second opinion. Note that, in general, IFRS and ASPE requirements are
“Revenue recognition” refers to when sales and other revenues are recorded. Recognizing revenue is fundamental to accounting. In theory, you recognize revenue when you earn it. It sounds like it should be simple, but it isn’t.
Until recently, revenue recognition in Canada followed a trend of becoming more and more complex and arcane. The problem started in the late 1990s when, in response to perceived abuses in the United States, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission issued a series of accounting rules that resulted in the codification of extremely complex and sometimes contradictory requirements. Concepts such as “persuasive evidence of an arrangement,” and “multiple deliverables” entered the accounting lexicon. Canadian accounting then adopted the U.S. rules, with sometimes bizarre results. For example, a small start-up company could be in the position that it has sold product and services, received the cash, and has no further obligation to its customer, but cannot record revenue from the sale.
Over the past two years, old Canadian generally accepted accounting practices (GAAP) for most organizations have been changed to either International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS, primarily for public companies) or Accounting Standards for Private Enterprises (ASPE, primarily for private companies). The conversion of Canadian GAAP to IFRS and ASPE has simplified the previously overly complex rules related to revenue recognition, and restored elements of common sense to the measurement of revenue. Our start-up company referred to above would now be able to record a sale in its accounts. However, some large accounting firms have attempted to eliminate choices and so have prescribed rules for their clients that go beyond the written IFRS or ASPE requirements. In complex situations you should discuss revenue recognition with a qualified accountant, and if necessary seek a second opinion. Note that, in general, IFRS and ASPE requirements are