Preview

Assimilation Among Second Generation Native Americans

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
629 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Assimilation Among Second Generation Native Americans
It is safe to say Shukumar misunderstands the flexibility of the nuclear family. He fails to see the nuclear family can stretch only as far as the inside of a 1,000 square foot home in Levittown, but not as far as India. He views the nuclear family or the American dream as a way to prove belonging – a couple adhering to South Asian identity, while also fitting into the American fold – but the American Dream is really about assimilation. The Oxford English Dictionary defines Assimilation as “The action of making or becoming like; the state of being like; similarity.” In the context of Ethnic American Literature this meaning becomes much more sinister. It means to scrap away the home culture from the immigrant and force them to adhere to the American way. …show more content…
He does not want assimilation, he wants to keep his Indian heritage, but he completely overlooks the attitude of American society towards immigrants. In “Negotiating Identity Among Second-Generation Indian Americans: A Collaborative Ethnography,” Kelly Murray describes the understanding of assimilation among second generation South Asian Americans. The participants thought of assimilation as an “‘unintended consequence of the pursuit of ‘success’ in the United States’ (Sinha 2010:1). There seems to be a straight-line trajectory: pursue economic success in the U.S., lose your Indian Identity”

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the short story, "Two Ways to Belong in America", Bharati tells that there are two ways to belong in America. The first one is belonging legally. To belong legally you either have a green card, or you are a citizen. The other way is to fit in with society, and to feel as if you belong. Bharati is an American citizen, and married outside of her culture. She was prepared for this and was ready for the emotional strain. Mira had only a green card, and married an Indian student in 1962. Mira has become nationally recognized for her contributions in the fields of pre-school education and parent teacher relationships. After 36 years as a legal immigrant in this country, she clings passionately to her Indian citizenship and hopes to go home to India when she retires. This shows how both of the sisters have different views on their lifestyles.…

    • 260 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The argument that whether American Indians should be fully integrated into the American society or that it is best to continue to maintain and support American Indians staying on their reservation has been an important dispute for many years. The place of Indians in American society may be seen as one aspect of the question of the integration of minority groups into the social system. Only by maintenance of freedom for cultural variation can a heterogeneous society keep conflict at a minimum. In my opinion, in the long run, integration is the best way to go. Not only is it human nature to feel belonging in a greater society regardless of origin, but it also promotes multiculturalism in America. A way of incorporating American Indians…

    • 151 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Culture and Richard

    • 1827 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Take a glance of what is cultural tradition. There are two types of cultural influences: Traditional culture and Non-traditional culture. The first one is a cultural construct rooted in traditions, rules, symbols, and principles established predominantly in the past. The other one which is often called modern is based on new principles, ideas, and practices. While the traditional tends to be conservative and intolerant to innovations, the non-cultural tradition tends to be absorbing and dynamic (Eric Shivaev & David Levy, 2007). Assimilation is a main subject in the Pocho and religion and gender are two other aspects that we focus on to see the problems. Jose Antonio Villareal, in his novel Pocho, pictured of assimilation as it applies to the experiences of Richard Rubio and his family. The Rubios are Mexicans attempting to start a new life in the United States, and the book records the difficulties they…

    • 1827 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    The graphic novel American Born Chinese (2006), by Gene Luen Yang, is a very modern and influential piece of work that can be compared to the short indie film Two Lies (1990), directed and written by Pamela Tom, which had preceded the novel by 16 years. These two different forms of work, both utilizing their ability to teach the audience, are used as powerful venues for the topic of identity crisis among the Asian people in a majority European American world. In the film, we have Mei and her family who are all having some trouble adjusting to their lives in Southern California but more specifically we have Mei and her trouble to understand her mother 's cause and intent for having undergone double eye-lid surgery. In ABC, we have our protagonist, Jin, who is having trouble fitting into his new school in San Francisco since he is one of the very few Asian admitted to the school. Another time line in the novel is the story of the monkey king who does anything to get rid of the fact that he is a monkey in order to fit into society. The third is the story of Danny, a European American who has trouble and often becomes embarrassed with his hyperbolic Chinese cousin, Chin-Kee. This character is first introduced by saying "Harro Amellica!" while Jin 's father, carrying giant Chinese take out container says "I 'll put your luggage into your room, Chin-Kee" (48). All three of these time line show our characters having some sort of shame or embarrassment to the fact that their own image or background is different from those around them.…

    • 2458 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The four regions that constituted the U.S. at this time are the nation's major cities, the South, the North, and Trans-Appalachia. -The nation's cities were centers of commerce, trade and manufacturing. The artisans and apprentices of the 18th century gave way to factories and wage-based pay in the 19th century which caused urban life to radically shift toward a labor-focused rather than agrarian-focused lifestyle. In New York shoes and iron were top commodities while Philadelphia was a center for textiles. With agriculture becoming less of a focus, the gap between the lower and upper classes was widened between laborers and factory owners.…

    • 2190 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    The year is 1776. In an act of defiance of the oppressive rule of the powerful nation of Great Britain, the political leaders of the British-American colonies sign into existence the United States of America. Even before this inception of the United States, North America had been seen as a place where one could move to start a new life and reap the full rewards for one’s work. These opportunities combined with the new United States government founded on the ideals of freedom and equity have attracted countless families from all over the world, making the United States truly a country of immigrants. Immigrants from European nations coming to America both assimilated and helped to shape the culture of the nation. Others, either immigrants or those forced to come to the United States, were marked with distinguishable differences from the European majority. The Africans and Asians are examples of some of these minorities, but, in my belief, one of the groups that has had the most unique struggle to become part of the ‘great melting pot’ of America is the Latino culture. For many different reasons Latin Americans have struggled to assimilate with the American culture for hundreds of years.…

    • 1291 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Native Americans had no other option than assimilation. Today, we have the right to choose. Back in the days you had rights only if you were part of the elite society, in this case, a white person. White people were so hungry power that they did whatever they had to as to gain all the land that belonged to the Native Americans. They took advantage of the inocense of the Native Americans and achieved their goals. Whites wanted total control over the Native Americans, they forced them to assimilation, tricked them and took everything away from them.…

    • 764 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Assimilation In Canada

    • 951 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Stretching from 1887 to 1934, assimilationist practices had begun, The Allotment Act had passed in 1887, “with the liberal value of individual property rights displacing the common ownership of land associated with tribal government (Brock 368).” By 1924 natives had begun acquiring American citizenship as a result of the Allotment Act, while it bestowed the individual with the right to vote it had the inherent drive of assimilation (Brock 368). Policymakers had begun to directly interfere with the internal affairs of First Nations groups upon the basis of their system of government, further deploying assimilationist policies that reflect their own beliefs (Brock 368). Individualism versus collective rights, similarly as to what Trudeau had…

    • 951 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The article examines United States policies that affect Native American people, in particular their educational issues. The author connects the government assimilating of Native Americans into “main stream society” and the current issues Native American’s face such as violence and drug abuse. Cherokee people are the primary focus in the article, but even though every tribe is different, many are faced with the same problems. General information on the development and reasoning of assimilation, as well as the use of boarding schools are thoroughly explained.…

    • 1458 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are some benefits to assimilation. For example, someone who wrote an article called “To Assimilate or to Acculturate?” says, “After returning to America, I entered grade school. At first, I felt like an outsider coming from an Indian home. Students used to stare in bewilderment when I brought handvo, a traditional Gujarati…

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    American Dream Analysis

    • 1286 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Although walking different paths, they ended in similar places: Mira felt betrayed by America since she devoted her almost entire career into American education system but had to face the new rules curtailing benefits for legal immigrants like her; Bharati, the author of this article, although not yet compromised by this country politically, had undergone a hard time fitting into the community that she was supposed to be in. Undeniably, cultural difference between America and India played a significant role in Mira’s feeling of not belonging to America so much—-as the final sentence of the article says: “The price that immigrant willingly pays, and that the exile avoids, is the trauma of self-transformation”. It is the unwillingness of cultural self-transformation that make Mira “happier to live in America as expatriate Indian than as an immigrant American”, which causes her political disadvantages and thus tears apart her American dream of living well as an Indian in America. Unsurprisingly, unwillingness of cultural self-transformation is neither the only nor the most important factor that complicates people achieving American…

    • 1286 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Long before the United States became a nation in the Americas, Empires had risen and fallen, tribes had made their homes, and of course, established their culture. As foreigners settled their “new world,” Native people were pushed away from the homes they had long since known. Going back much farther back than this however, there were other foreigners, that came not from the sea, but from the land, from the north. Most likely coming in waves through the Bering Strait from East Asia and Russia. Such ancient cultural ties; shared history, religion, land, and especially languages, are instrumental in retaining strong identity. With these connections being threatened by cultural suppression and an unfriendly, changing world, tribal identity is…

    • 1306 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Native American Sociology

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages

    A common saying within our society is that history repeats itself. This expression, although short and simple, is more accurate than one would think. This repetition is seen in all corners of history, in all walks of life, and in every single time period. It is almost exactly like the circle of life; an idea is born, the idea grows and develops, the idea is accepted, the idea is rejected, but the idea never dies. Instead, it haunts society until it is once again needed by the community. In the past, one sees how capitalism aided in the removal of Native Americans, now, today this is seen once again as history repeats itself.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Beginning in 1910 and ending in the 1970s, Australians Federal and State government agencies and church missions made a policy to forcibly take many aboriginal and Torres Strait children away from their families in an attempt to destroy the Aboriginal race and culture. There was an impact on the aboriginals with a particular policy the Australian Government had introduced, which was the policy of ‘Assimilation’. This policy was to encourage many Aboriginal people to give up their culture, language, tradition, knowledge and spirituality to basically become white Australians. Unfortunately this policy didn’t give the Aboriginals the same rights as white Australians, as a result of discrimination, aboriginals were moved to live in special housing…

    • 268 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    America was founded by a group of diverse immigrants. All immigrants are coming from different parts of the world such as Asia, Europe, Africa and Mexico and so on. Therefore, each person has his or her own culture, religion and beliefs. Most of the people who are immigrants are non-English speaking and face struggles and numerous challenges to assimilate into American society. Millions of people have been discriminated due to skin color, religions, and beliefs, so it means that people face struggles with assimilation and acculturation. One sure thing is people must understand others cultures when they fall in love with different races, or when they go to school at different countries. However, most of the people are not assimilating for their religion, and they are proud of being what they are.…

    • 1588 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays