Preview

Battle of Ideas

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
903 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Battle of Ideas
“Battle of Ideas” The Battle of Ideas starts in 1914 showing a world with a global economy that is then torn apart by World War I. This created the economic development, world trade, and globalization all the way up to the 1980’s. The documentary explains how the world first moved toward more government control and then began to move away for most of the 20th century. During this time two young economists emerge in hope to solve the world’s economic troubles, John Meynard Keynes and Friederich Von Hayek. The story then focuses on the struggles that occur between the ideas of the two economists. Keynes, whose ideas on government intervention dominated much of the 20th century, and Hayek, whose free-market ideas were largely ignored until the economic crises of the 1970’s. Throughout the film it gives a better understanding of how the world and different economies are affected by socialism, capitalism, and communism. In Eastern Europe, Africa, and majority of South America the result was socialism, which lead to more economic hardship. In Western Europe and the United States the result was booming economies. The interesting thing about the film is how the theories and ideas of two economists could be so influential during the 20th century that they still continue to play a key role in today’s society. The Russian Revolutionary War in 1917 was the beginning of a communist economy, in which the government is very important to allocate resources and goods. Throughout the past century there has been an ongoing battle of ideas pertaining to economic policy. One is a very hands-on approach with regard to the role of government in economics. The other calls for the government not to interfere but let the market take care of itself. These two theories have gone through cycles of being accepted and rejected as good economic policy over the last century. Hayek continuously tried to prove that if government were to interfere with the economy it would cause a massive

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    His way of thinking is known as "state capitalism". He wanted to continue the way ,Vyshnegradsky had gone.By heavy taxation and forcing exports to generate capital the government got more money for investing in e.g. railways.…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Over the period from 1855 to 1964, Russia saw various reforms and policies under the Tsars and the Communist leaders that had great impacts on its economy and society both positive and negative. Lenin definitely implanted polices that changed society and the economy for example with war communism. However whether his policies had the greatest impact is debatable and in this essay I will be assessing the view whether Lenin had the greatest impact on Russia’s economy and society than any other ruler between the period from 1855-1964.…

    • 2039 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    hca 240

    • 944 Words
    • 4 Pages

    1. What were the main ideas put forward by John Maynard Keynes and Friedrich Von Hayek regarding the government’s role in economic and social development? In what way did their ideas differ?…

    • 944 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The words of Leon Trotsky, said decades before the eventual demise of central planning, highlight the underlying flaw of the planned economic system; lack of information. The central planner’s realized that the information and signaling required for any modern economy could be found more effectively in a market based system and consequentially central planning was abandoned. The systemic failure of central planning due to poor information was most prevalent in Eastern Europe and the USSR, as evidenced by their economy’s productive inefficiencies, allocative inefficiencies and pricing difficulties. This essay will classify the traditional soviet economy and examine the production, allocation and pricing difficulties which caused its end.…

    • 2648 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Milton Friedman appeared on Phil Donahue in 1979 to discuss a multitude of topics involving economics. When at first I saw the image of the video that was about to play I felt dread. How could this man impart viable information towards our class? Much of what we have discussed has been over the way our Constitution was written and the course our Judicial System. Well I was wrong. Milton Friedman was not your average Economics Professor. He was a Nobel Peace Prize winner, as well as the National Medal of Science, and the Presidential Medal of Freedom.…

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    With the ideologies basis focusing on the individual’s interest over the collective interest, creates a society where there is little government control or intervention for privatized businesses. During the time of the U.S.S.R., the government had a strong belief in the communist ideologies in which they believed would create more equality amongst all people of the country. It was the difference of opinion that added to the tensions between the U.S. and the U.S.S.R. as both theses powers believed highly in themselves and in the correctness of what they were implementing into their countries. The communist party in Russia focused largely on the development of their industry, the sciences and technology, which would increases the flow of their economy. Opposite to the majority of America, all the land and resources were publicly owned and managed.…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Comparing Lenin and Stalin one finds that both were following a communist ideal but what is the communist ideal? The main principal is to share a country's wealth amongst its people. This is the theoretical side of the communist idea; the practical side requires a careful planning of the country's economy and also a system that makes sure that everybody is treated equally.…

    • 1767 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    A command economy is one in which the co-ordination of economic activity is controlled and undertaken through administrative means rather than through the market mechanism (Ericson, 2005). Many aspects of the Soviet economy fit this description such as its organisational structure, the methods by which aims and directives were carried out and its lack of a use of pricing within its financial mechanisms, thus it can be argued that the term command economy is an accurate description. However there are another of other aspects to consider such as the use of bargaining to develop a second ‘economy of agreement’ and the use of economic incentives to achieve targets that seriously undermine the description of the Soviet Economy as a command economy. This essay will discuss the points above and show that despite some factors such as the existence of a second economy there can be no other way to describe the Soviet Economy as many economists would agree as the best example of a ‘command economy’ there has ever been.…

    • 2174 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Road to Serfdom

    • 10652 Words
    • 43 Pages

    ‘In The Road to Serfdom’, writes Henry Hazlitt in the New York Times, ‘Friedrich A. Hayek has written one of the most important books of our generation. It restates for our time the issue between liberty and authority. It is an arresting call to all well-intentioned planners and socialists, to all those who are sincere democrats and liberals at heart, to stop, look and listen.’ The author is an internationally known economist. An Austrian by birth, he was director of the Austrian Institute for Economic Research and lecturer in economics at the University of Vienna during the years of the rise of fascism in Central Europe. He has lived in England since 1931 when he became Professor of Economic Science at the University of London, and is now a British citizen. Professor Hayek, with great power and rigour of reasoning, sounds a grim warning to Americans and Britons who look to the government to provide the way out of all our economic difficulties. He demonstrates that fascism and what the Germans correctly call National Socialism are the inevitable results of the increasing growth of state control and state power, of national ‘planning’ and of socialism. In a foreword to The Road to Serfdom John Chamberlain, book editor of Harper’s, writes: ‘This book is a warning cry in a time of hesitation. It says to us: Stop, look and listen. Its logic is incontestable, and it should have the widest possible audience.’…

    • 10652 Words
    • 43 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Naked Economics

    • 2868 Words
    • 12 Pages

    The first chapter begins with an interesting story about how an advertising strategy by Coca Cola Europe proves to be a losing proposition at the start of 1989 but ends in impressive results by the end of 1995. There are myriad of different ways everyday that make modern economy work. Wheelan begins with the question, "Who feeds Paris?" as a starting point to explain how markets are powerful influences in an individual's every day life. Wheelan explains how markets use prices to allocate scarce resources and how markets are self-correcting. Wheelan expounds on how the market gears up and aligns incentives such that individuals work for their own self-interest for an improved standard of living. In no uncertain terms, the author explains how the Soviet socialist economy failed because the bureaucracy of the government controlled the economy. This chapter makes a strong stand that it is not fair to impose preferences on others. He alleges that it is "bad economics to impose preferences on individuals whose lives are much different from all the rest." (p 7).…

    • 2868 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    compromise and conflict

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages

    1 Wife of Bath sees marriage as a means for her to have sex and she has a strong sexual appetite. She feels that God gave women sexual desires and that it can't be wrong to give in to those desires because they are God-given. Furthermore, she says that she knows men also have strong sexual desires so she uses sex, or the lack of it, to control her husbands The Wife of Bath begins the Prologue to her tale by establishing herself as an authority on marriage, due to her extensive personal experience with the institution. Since her first marriage at the tender age of twelve, she has had five husbands. She says that many people have criticized her for her numerous marriages, most of them on the basis that Christ went only once to a wedding, at Cana in Galilee. The Wife of Bath has her own views of Scripture and God’s plan. She says that men can only guess and interpret what Jesus meant when he told a Samaritan woman that her fifth husband was not her husband. With or without this bit of Scripture, no man has ever been able to give her an exact reply when she asks to know how many husbands a woman may have in her lifetime. God bade us to wax fruitful and multiply, she says, and that is the text that she wholeheartedly endorses. After all, great Old Testament figures, like Abraham, Jacob, and Solomon, enjoyed multiple wives at once. She uses this power as an “instrument” to control her husbands.…

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Modern political economic theory and philosophy can be greatly attributed to the works of two men who seemingly held polar opposite views on the subject. Adam Smith, a Scottish philosopher, published his most well known work An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations in 1776 and is most often associated with the ideas and principles of the political economic system known as Capitalism. At the other end of the spectrum is Karl Marx; the German philosopher most often associated with Communism and the author (or co-author) of The Communist Manifesto. This paper seeks to discuss the core differences in their respective political economic philosophies with regards to what economic value is and what the role of government should be in their versions of political economy. This will conclude with the argument that while Smith's work had laid the foundation for modern economic philosophy, it was Marx who would ultimately leave the most significant impression upon the world with his revolutionary ideas.…

    • 2054 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The first episode of Commanding Heights begins by showing a world with a global economy that is then torn apart by World War I. Following World War I two young economists emerged that hoped to solve the world’s economic troubles, John Meynard Keynes and Friederich Hayek.…

    • 364 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Smith postulated that the amassment of gold and silver in a country's treasury doesn't mean much, but in fact it's the actual amount of trading that is done that defines a "Rich Nation". Smith reasoned that government interference in economy related issues only retarded growth. As an example, if the government agrees on granting monopole over a sector to a certain company, you banish competition and with it all efforts to advance and create new and cheaper products. Smith also postulated that without government intervention the market itself will regulate the economy through supply and demand. Facing this system that encourages private ownership of industries and free trade was communism. Communism is a very revolutionary ideology. Marx postulated that the capitalist regimes would be eventually over-thrown by the proletariat in what he called the "Class Struggle". Unlike capitalism, communism theoretically promoted a society where there was no class distinction, where the government would be handed down to the proletariat (working class), and where ownership of land, means of production, and riches by the working class government will be equally redistributed over all citizens. The individual life of a person in a communist society differs greatly from one…

    • 542 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Back to 1990s, lots of trading telegraph and telephone helped to promote a good global economy or globalization. Hayek believed that socialism is a more just society. But in 1914, the World War I changed this; people began to rethinking the political ideas. By 1918, because the government controlling their own business and most Russians had lost faith in their government, so the workers united against global economy which led to the Russian Revolution and the creation of Soviet Union. One of the most notable conservative of the twentieth century, Ludwig von Mises demonstrated that the expansion of free markets, the division of labor, and private capital investment is the only possible path to the prosperity and flourishing of the human race. Also he indicated that socialism would be disastrous for a modern economy because the absence of private ownership of…

    • 327 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays