Preview

Bettina Bradbury The Home As Workplace Analysis

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1702 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Bettina Bradbury The Home As Workplace Analysis
Critical Review

Bettina Bradbury, “The Home as Workplace,” Visions: Canada Since Confederation (Winter 2016): 177-189

The Home as Workplace is an article by Bettina Bradbury, in which she discusses how the Industrial Revolution from the 1850's to the 1900's in Canada made families dependant on a wage (177). Wage earning altered the family dynamic in terms work having to be performed outside and within the household. Bradbury's principle argument is that “while many of the task performed by wives and children in working-class homes were similar to those done in agriculture, artisanal, or even professional and bourgeois households, dependance on wages shaped their work in specific ways” (177). She offers insight into the household during
…show more content…
All themes are then divided up into sub categories that cover all aspects of the family dynamic as they sought to earn a wage. The first theme considers male family heads, as at the time the male of the household was the “breadwinner” of the family. The men would earn the majority of the wages but sometimes this was not enough income to sustain the family comfortably. It was the wife's responsibility to transform the money into necessarily elements for survival such as food, clothing, and shelter (178). It was also a women's task to make sure the money lasted until the next time the husband got paid. Bradbury also discussed wage-earning offspring as children lacked a childhood since once they reached a certain age he/she needed to work so the family could contribute to the family income …show more content…
Previous to this article the reader maybe have been unaware of the major responsibilities that women had to take on within the home, that ensured the survival of their family. Bradbury makes the interesting point that if families were not dependant on a wage a women may have sent her clothes out to be washed, not subjecting herself to the hard labour this task involved such strain from lifting, burns from scolding water, and caustic substances (184). Women may also not have been concerned with sewing and mending because if they was not dependant on a wage she could buy new. Children who were not of age to work (mostly female) would help their mother with these tasks, in tern learning skills to earn money later on. Although, needing to work took children out of school which was controversial in some cities

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Women were overworked, considered “lowest antebellum worker” and segregated based on gender(Stansell 105). Not only did this work segregate and exploit these women, the outside work system, in particular, reinforced women's reliance on their family as a result of the low wages and forms of labor they did. The system of working individually in their homes made it hard to combat unfair treatment from employers, as they could not come together and unite(Stansell 116). Later when factory work became more popular, inside work, especially those that lacked heavy machinery, women began to experience some freedom(Stansell 120). In this piece, we see an economy run by mass production of textile related…

    • 521 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Britain in the 19th century was a patriarchal society and the dominant idea was that there are irrefutable natural differences between genders. Therefore, males, who occupied the dominant positions, were born for business, finance, and politics, while women were expected to marry, manage the family, and take care of the children. It seems that females in that period were thought to be miserable, tragic, and wretched and did not have suffrage rights, the right to sue, or the right to own property. Their inferior jobs such as babysitter or textile worker were barely enough to survive on. Worse still, most working women were employed in the unskilled, unorganized, service jobs and were paid a lower salary. Some of them were even required to become prostitutes out of desperation. Later, females entered some male dominated industries, but they only got one third of a man’s salary. There were still a large amount of women who lived as housewives, like Mrs. Thorold was pretending to do in the novel. They merely managed the family or were considered decoration in the living room. Women’s social value and working rights were denied by men, who were the heads of society.…

    • 1618 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    After the Second World War in 1946 all three women’s services in the armed forces were disbanded and domestic service occupations for women rose up after the war. Secretary, bookkeeper and other domestic type occupations were the sort of jobs that had became available for women. Women also did not want to work the typical 9-5 workday and they did not want to separate their work life and home life from each other as each job wanted to strictly separate. Women wanted a better life than what they had known for themselves and for their family but that would mean that they would need more than just their husband’s salary to afford the luxuries they craved.…

    • 2279 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Starting off by explaining the typical family roles in the turn of the century, Piess expresses how while the men may spend his evenings at a local saloon, at a baseball game or reading his daily paper, the women would often be expected to work her “double day”. Piess explains this concept of the double day to be that the woman is expected to go about her daily work day of typically “domestic servants, needlewomen, laundresses…” (Peiss 1986), and come home to start her other job, being the housewife. The housewife duties usually entailed cooking, cleaning, washing, scrubbing, and most importantly… making her husband and kids happy. All the while, when the woman got her hard earned paycheck, it was expected to go towards family needs. Even as young women in the family home, young working girls were expected to hand over their paychecks in their entirety while their male counterparts were only asked for a small portion of their earnings. Even though women were getting paid at lower wages and it being justified because women were seen as “temporary wage-earners who worked only until marriage” (Peiss 1986), Piess automatically…

    • 1679 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Tilly, Joan W. Scott and Miriam Cohen, who are disagree with Shorter’s points, and they are stating that his claims have no supportive evidence. They argue that no evidence found to support the point Shorter made about women that they were powerless in traditional families. Instead, there are some evidence that showed the women had power within a family because importance of their roles. They point out that vast majority women did not work in the factories, but in customary women’s jobs. Women did not work because of rebalance or to seek for independence, but to add to the family finances. Woman who worked they add only small amount to the family finances they did not make much money. Tilly, Cohen, and Scott proving different point as to why women sought work. Unlikely Shorter, the explanation they offer why women were employed was because the problem generated from industrialization. Industrialization gave new opportunities for women, it also contribute for young girls were sent out to the cities for work. Even though, young women were sent far from home their independence was very limited. Some countries had nuns, who were placed watching and restraining young women behavior and social lives. Women did not make much money and very poor, female got paid significantly less than male did, and female work was seasonal and irregular. Authors point out that young women were deficient income with unstable jobs…

    • 949 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Susanna Rowson and Judith Sargent Murray saw women’s roles in the early United States similar. In the 1700s women had a basic education of reading and writing and most were trained to become mothers and house wives. Women’s job was to take care of the children at home, cook, clean, and do housework;…

    • 1676 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    working- class families, initially by the Mom leaving home for work as a necessity and…

    • 1004 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The culture of New England in the 1830’s and 1840’s expected young girls and women to be submissive, moral, and domestic. The factory girls families weren’t too happy with their daughters working outside the home. The industrialists had to convince the public that textile mills were appropriate places for young girls to work. Working at the textile mills provided young women with financial independence that they wouldn’t get staying at home and working on the farm. This idea of financial independence really challenged the role of women in society prior to this time. The girls no longer had to rely on their father’s income for support and this didn’t sit well with the daddies. Working in the mills also provided the girls with more opportunities to extend their education and learning. Often, these working girls would become more educated than their mothers and grandmothers.…

    • 560 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women as their turned their homes to workplaces. They were in crowed apartments and still worked such sewing furs into garments, making straw hats, preparing artificial flowers and so on. However they earned earnings from every piecework but their wages were lower than factory. Also they allowed married women with young children to contribute to the family…

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the 17th century, women’s work was extremely difficult, exhausting, and under appreciated. Most colonial women were homemakers who cooked meals, made clothing, and doctored their family as well as cleaned, made household goods to use and sell, took care of their animals, and sometimes maintained and tended the farm. Middle class and wealthy women also shared some of these chores in their households, but they often had servants to help them. Women were also the primary care givers for the children, and they often had many children. Mothers were often the primary spiritual instructors in the home, especially in the latter part of the Seventeenth Century.…

    • 806 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Stereotypes Of Aba Women

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Women are not just a housewives and men are not the sole breadwinner. Women can go out to do some small jobs like trading to earn extra income for the family. They can also mingle with their friends outside and not having to stay at home all day to clean and take care of the house. (p. 1). This shows that women do have freedom and that the men were not in total control over them.…

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    On the other hand, women’s role was very demanding and difficult. Their life was focused on the home and they were expected to help their husbands with their tasks. Poor housewives had to run the house, raise their children, spin, weave, make clothes etc. Nevertheless, the conditions in their houses were poor. They were drafty, they had no inside toilet and no running water.…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although duties included taking care of children, tending to their husbands, groceries, cleaning the house, and cooking, their main purpose in life was to take care of their families. This ideal role of a woman was known ever since Christopher Columbus and colonizers came to America. This explains the gender roles displayed throughout the centuries because while the men arrived in the America’s, they had to provide for their families and did all the “dirty work” while the woman took care and taught the children. To make extra money for their families, manufacturing was often done in people homes where a woman would make and sell anything that was easy for a woman to make such as clothes, bread, homemade soaps and etc. It was until the Industrial Revolution that began to change the responsibility of women.…

    • 1105 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Poorer women had to manage families and work in factories at the same time to make ends meet. With the gender roles present, women would be expected to manage the household without any help regardless of whether they also had jobs or outside affairs, since the participation in those activities in addition to the duties she was expected to fulfill would be seen as a choice. Having these…

    • 1678 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Domestic Workers Thesis

    • 5812 Words
    • 24 Pages

    A: “There are at least 1.8 million workers work as domestic workers in American homes.”…

    • 5812 Words
    • 24 Pages
    Powerful Essays