Tagbilaran City
Name: Aimee Joy Orion Philosophy 2 (1:30-2:30 MWF)
Course: AB PoliticalScience 2 Sir Joselito Gallendo
PROJECT IN PHILO 2
(Summary and Insights)
Summary : Bicentennial Man
A character named Andrew Martin requests an unknown operation from a robotic surgeon. However, the robot refuses, as the operation is harmful and violates the First Law of Robotics, which says a robot may never harm a human being. Andrew, however, changes its mind, telling it that he is not a human being.
The story jumps to 200 years in the past, when NDR (his serial number forgotten) is brought to the home of Gerald Martin (referred to as Sir) as a robot butler. Little Miss (Sir's daughter) names him Andrew. Later, Little Miss asks Andrew to carve a pendant out of wood. She shows it to her father, who initially does not believe a robot could carve so skillfully. Sir has Andrew carve more things, and even read books on woodwork. Andrew uses, for the first time, the word "enjoy" to describe why he carves. Sir takes Andrew to U.S. Robotics and Mechanical Men, Inc. to ask what the source of his creativity is, but they have no good explanation.
Sir helps Andrew to sell his products, taking half the profits and putting the other half in a bank account in the name of Andrew Martin (though there is questionable legality to a robot owning a bank account). Andrew uses the money to pay for bodily upgrades, keeping himself in perfect shape, but never has his positronic brain altered. Sir reveals that U.S. Robots has ended study on generalized pathways and creative robots, frightened by Andrew's unpredictability.
Little Miss, at this point, is married and has a child, Little Sir. Andrew, feeling Sir now has someone to replace his grown-up children, asks to purchase his own freedom with Little Miss's support. Sir is apprehensive, however, fearing that freeing Andrew legally would require bringing attention to Andrew's bank account, and might result in the loss of all Andrew's money. However, he agrees to attempt it. Though facing initial resistance, Andrew wins his freedom. Sir refuses to let Andrew pay him. It isn't long afterwards that he falls ill, and dies after asking Andrew to stand by his deathbed.
Andrew begins to wear clothes, and Little Sir (who orders Andrew to call him George) is a lawyer. He insists on dressing like a human, even though most humans refuse to accept him. In a conversation with George, Andrew realizes he must also expand his vocabulary, and decides to go to the library. On his way, he gets lost, and stands in the middle of a field. Two humans begin to walk across the field towards him, and he asks them the way to the library. They instead harass him, and threaten to take him apart when George arrives and scares them off. As he takes Andrew to the library, Andrew explains that he wants to write a book on the history of robots. The incident with the two humans angers Little Miss, and she forces George to go to court for robot rights. George's son, Paul, helps out by fighting the legal battle as George convinces the public. Eventually, the public opinion is turned in favor of robots, and laws are passed banning robot-harming orders. Little Miss, after the court case is won, dies.
Andrew, with Paul's help, gets a meeting with the head of U.S. Robots. He requests that his body be replaced by an android, so that he may better resemble a human. After Paul threatens legal action, US Robots agrees to give Andrew an android body. However, US Robots retaliates by creating central brains for their robots, so that no individual robot may become like Andrew. Meanwhile Andrew, with his new body, decides to study robobiology - the science of organic robots like himself. Andrew begins to design a system allowing androids to eat food like humans - solely for the purpose of becoming more like a person.
After Paul's death, Andrew comes to U.S. Robots again, meeting with Alvin Magdescu, Director of Research. He offers US Robots the opportunity to market his newly designed prostheses for human use, as well as his own. He successfully has the digestive system installed in his body, and plans to create an excretory system to match. Meanwhile, his products are successfully marketed and he becomes a highly honored inventor. As he reaches 150 years of age, a dinner is held in his honor in which he is labeled the Sesquicentennial Robot. Andrew is not yet satisfied, however.
Andrew decides that he wants to be a man. He obtains the backing of Feingold and Martin (the law firm of George and Paul) and seeks out Li-Hsing, a legislator and chairman of the Science and Technology committee, hoping that the World Legislature will declare him a human being. Li-Hsing advises him that it will be a long legal battle, but he says he is willing to fight for it. Feingold and Martin begins to slowly bring cases to court that generalize what it means to be human, hoping that despite his prosthetics Andrew can be regarded as essentially human. Most legislators, however, are still hesitant due to his immortality.
Reflection/Insights
It is a very touching and heartwarming movie about a house-robot (Robert Williams) that begins a 200-year journey to become and to be legally recognized as a human. During his journey, he has to face the fact and live with it that all loved ones around him grow older and eventually die while he is immortal. Bicentennial Man is a film that depicts philosophical musings in a science fiction story.
The film doesn't contain a good an introduction to the family who adopts Andrew. But the reasoning behind the lack of focus on the family is due to the fact that "Bicentennial Man" isn't about the family who buys Andrew, but a narrative of Andrew himself but It is really about inner emotions, the changing of times, how people change overtime, and the meaning of life from an original point of view. "Bicentennial Man" is a sweet, touching production with lots of heart and a shapely message.
I also like the purity and the innocence of the story. It's a must see for all open minded people. Most people who have seen this movie are of the opinion that it was average at best. Indeed there is no complicated plot, no big action scenes and a predictable ending but there is a Story. It's Andrew with his Box of Chocolats, simply going through life searching for what eludes him and what we generally take for granted - humanity. This movie can make you cry so bad. The only real failings were the large gaps in time and how Andrew came about - but then it's difficult to compress 200 years into 1 1/2 hours.
The movie,if you really dig in deeper to it or in reality of life, it is impossible for a robot to become human. Even though how high in quality we have now in terms of technology, there is no one or nobody who can make another human being other than GOD.. Well, it was just a movie but it was very touching and full of meaning to me and for the minds of other people. They would think that not at all times things are possible especially on the scene where andrew had died before he could hear the words that the world congress announced that he is already human, it was a painful one but in reality, it was just right.
The movie also showed a moral values. Like, the robot with all his programmed mind, have a very big respect to the people around him but some of the people in the movie and in our real lives, we seldom see people who have the same attitude with Andrew. A very liberal and wide-open minded robot. Also, it revolves on the concept of humanity and how an object such as a robot could be considered as a rational being, rather than what it was originally intended to be which was to serve human beings.
I love the characters involved, they had done their acting so well and was very suitable to them. I love the Sir, since I was a fan of him even before, and Andrews wife that had done very good in acting especially when in the movie she was used or played the character twice. But most of all I admire Robert Williams, i am an avid fan of him and in this movie, he did reaaly great. I admire Robin Williams in the sense of his acting skills considering that for over half the movie he is acting within a cumbersome suit. Very good movie-we could all learn something from this-Inside is more important than external appearences.
Furthermore, the concept of sovereignty is portrayed in the scene as Andrew was able to assert himself as a rational being when he requested for his freedom since he believed that he had the right to ask for it. Freedom is a sovereign right. It is aspired by rational beings who view themselves as beings of worth. There it showed the reality that we, as human beings have freedom, we can have it but there are also bounds or limitations. Your right to freedom will end if it involves others people like violating their rights too.
Also, I was attracted and bothered on the part when Andrew visits someone who has bought one of his clock and he asks, "Do you enjoy my clock?" If it were me I would have asked, "Do you like my clock, does it keep time, does it fulfil the purpose for which it was made? It makes me wonder if God sometimes says to us, "Do you enjoy my creation? Do you enjoy my sunsets? Do you enjoy this day, that I made for you? I suspect we look for efficiency and success more often than we look for God's hand in the everyday events of our lives.
As a summary, every thing in this world have the right to exist, have the right to be loved. But, we should not also forget that of all the things that we have now, everything is from GOD and nobody can ever make the things so perfect like God because it is only God who can do things perfectly. One of it is our lives that we have now, we should cherish it because it won’t last forever.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The New Technological Hand Benedict Carey, Wrote “Quadriplegic Gets Use of Hands from Chip Placed in His Brain,” published in 2016 in the New York Time, on his article Carey elaborates on the use of technology to transmit new sense of control. Carey begins building his credibility with a story and successfully employing emotional appeals; however his attempts to appeal to reader’s emotions strengthen his credibility and ultimately, his argument. In the article Carey first sets the stage by describing a scenario of a college student named Ian Burkhart that dived into a wave at a beach and accidently, broke his neck on the sandy floor, permanently losing his hand and legs, and then Carey outlines how the field of engineering is advancing quickly. Most likely knowing that his audience is theoretically sympathetic, Carey builds a bond with his audience by showing similarities in some way and triggering their emotion positively.…
- 469 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The film that I chose for this assignment is” I, Robot.” The film is set in the year 2035 in Chicago. The director is Alex Proyas and stars Will Smith and Bridget Monahan. What I will try to show is that in the near future robotic mechanisms will be able to have some sort of loyalty.…
- 289 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
- Opening crawler, 3:00. Discussing the killing of “replicants”, artificial humanoids created, which due to their manufactured nature, had no human rights.…
- 2331 Words
- 10 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Her father John workds in the field with Catherine late into the night. During the time he does not work he builds rocking chairs to sell to people. Every year John takes all his money and tries to by his freedom, but Master Charles says, "no!" because he knows the first thing he will do is buy his wife's freedom.…
- 749 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Frank is in the early stages of dementia which is getting worse and worse over time, when robot becomes a big role in Frank’s life at the time. Frank becomes fond of the robot because Frank gains trust in the robot. Frank’s son Hunter gives Frank a robot in hopes of helping Frank get back on track with chores and having a better lifestyle. Events between Frank and Robot develop a meaningful relationship.…
- 748 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The robots are governed by 3 main laws: “1) A robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm 2) A robot must obey orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law 3) A robot must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law (Asimov…
- 742 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
When Isaac Asimov envisioned a world in which robots would be as common as humans, he determined all of the ethics and morals that would bind these smart machines with three rules: “1. A robot may not injure a human being, or through inaction allow it to come to harm, 2. A robot must always obey a human, unless this conflicts with the first law, 3. A robot must protect its own existence as long as this doesn’t interfere with the first or second law” (Asimov, 1941). These three statements were baptized as the Three Laws of Robotics, and to the day they serve as a standard for robots and a goal for artificial intelligence researchers. But as the Laws were created in a time when people thought that by 2015 visiting Mercury would be a routine…
- 1039 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
In the film wall-e, we admire a robot who spends his days cleaning up the planet by himself one piece of garbage at a time. Over the course of several hundred years this robot becomes a little lonely and develops a personality. He then finds a robot “eve” who he develops a fond attraction for. This spirals into an adventure across the galaxy. The director presents a feeling of personal responsibility to the viewer for Mother Earth and ourselves through use of foreshadowing and pathos.…
- 471 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
1. Plot: Garson Poole is the owner of Tri-Plan Electronics. One day, he wakes up in a hospital to find out that he lost his hand during a squib accident. What is worse is that he is told by the doctors that he is a human-appearing organic robot, something called an Electric Ant. Then he learns from a futuristic computer that his subjective reality is being fed from micro-punched reality tape in his chest cavity. He conducts experiments on himself, first by glazing over a couple of holes and then punching new holes to see what effect this has on his reality. The more he starts to know and understand about his reality, he gets even more and more curious about what would happen when he cuts the tape. And when he does, it becomes too late.…
- 1296 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Furthermore, as he chooses to present a White-centered narrative that pays little attention to both the ideas and the methods of the civil rights activist, he diminishes the historical importance of African American activists in transforming the United States by making it both politically and socially more inclusive. The “Great Men” narrative that Lawson utilizes fails to present the complexity of the civil rights movement and the resilience of the activist, who, despite the numerous setbacks they suffered, continued to fight for their rights. By not paying any attention to the grassroots, Lawson creates a false picture of racial and social progress. He implicitly suggests that having a more or less amicable administration in place would be sufficient to maintain or advance the interests of historically marginalized groups. That is unfortunate, particularly because the article was published at the turn of the century, long after conservative forces had begun to dismantle some of the hard-won reforms. Consequently, a more inclusive approach that depicts the essential groundwork before and after the national leaders of the movement negotiated legislative reforms with the national government, would have been warranted.…
- 670 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Young teenagers try too hard to become adults. Sometimes many actions teenagers think are mature, but always end up backfiring on them. Richard Wright’s “The Man Who Was Almost a Man” demonstrates how a young teenager seeks a level of maturity and independence that he’s not yet ready for. For example, Dave thinks he is ready to show everyone that he is a man, but in the end his actions backfire leaving him with in a position with less respect than he had before.…
- 840 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The story provides an exploration into such universal issues of the human experience as alienation, passivity, nonconformity and psychological imprisonement. Bartleby has become a robotic copist in a world surrounded by walls: he has lost his identity because of the environement, because of non-comunication. He is a victim of society for whom there can’t be salvation. Loss of identity, lack of communication- led him to death. Meville uses Bartleby to represent the American ideal of freedom of choice then creates tension through restriction of that…
- 1181 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Aunt Martha’s former mistress’ sister buys her, so that she in fact can have her freedom…
- 5901 Words
- 19 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Richard N. Wright, a maverick in the literary world, has paved the road for would be African American writers to give a voice to their stories. Wright was born on the 4th day of September 1908 on Rucker’s Plantation, between Roxie and Natchez, Mississippi. Wright’s mother Ella dies a horrible death, leaving Richard to become a man much too soon. Wrights father abandons the family and he must live with his Aunt and maternal grandmother. Wright uses his characters to tell his life story. The Anthem Dictionary of Literary Terms and Theory defines the word Character in the literary world as a person depicted in a work. (“Character”) is a brief descriptive sketch of a personage who typifies some definite quality. (Macmillan 79) In the story “The Man That Was Almost a Man” Wright’s writings are figurative birth pangs of his own life, which is perhaps why his choice to tell this story in the “third-person limited” is fitting, Dave Saunders is that voice. The setting is the rural south in the second quarter of the twentieth century, set in a farming area…
- 1490 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
“A meaningful life is not being rich, being popular, being highly educated or being perfect… It is about being real, being humble, being strong, and being able to share ourselves and touch the lives of others” (Unknown).“The Man Who Was Almost A Man,” a short story by the African American author Richard Wright, was first published in Harper’s Bazaar in 1939 under the title “Almos’ a Man”. Under its present title it appeared in Eight Men in 1961 (899). Wright was born near Natchez, Mississippi, and by the age of 17, he moved to Memphis on his own. His personal experiences of humiliation and hatred in a racially segregated South contribute to this…
- 1190 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays