A southern white female slave owner only saw black women as another slave, or worse. White women needed to do this in order to keep themselves from feeling that they were of higher status than every one else except for their husband. White women as, Gwin describes, always proved that they had complete control and black women needed to bow to them. Gwin's book discusses that the white male slave owners brought this onto the black women on the plantation. They would rape black women, and then instead of the white women dealing with their husbands. They would go after the black women only since the wives had no power over the husbands, but they maintained total control of the slaves, the white women would attack the black women and make their lives very diffucult. The white women would make sure that the black women understood that the white women completely hated the black women for being raped and wanted only pain for the them. This is how the black women of that time got the stereotypes of being very sexual beings and hated by there oppressors. You can see evidence of this when Gwin discussed the realities of such hatred in the book Absalom, Absalom by William Faulkner. The main character, Clytie, sexual assaults by her male master upsets her because she doesn't desire to be involved with him, but her female master feels that she should be punished for it. So the white female slave owner beats her and abuses her as much as possible. The passage goes on to show how rape, gets Clytie labeled as a whore.
The book discussed how one of the principle reasons as to how the white woman or mistress and the black women got along, depends on whether or not the slave women appeared to threaten the social status of the women. When the white men tried to rape the black women it made the white women socially look like nothing more than a slave. This made the white women feel forced to prove to the black women that power still remained in the white woman's corner regardless of the master's sexual desires. The mistresses made sure that the slave women understood that they valued less than any white women, for the main reason that the white woman had true power as long as the main wanted her. An example of this that I read would be when a white woman outwardly expressed that she worried mainly about her loss of power, not actually about marriage. Saphire, a fictional character that Gwin analyzes, says "...mainly concerned with her power... she views her husbands affections for a slave as an undercutting of her power over him in their relationship which. As the husband himself describes as, what makes her the master and him the miller." (pg 133) The slave that caused this upset usually received many beatings and unnecessary overworking of the slave. At the time, this treatment was not unheard of and needed, the white slave owners used it as an example to show all slaves that they were not worth the air they breath except in the fields.
And even those who were not involved were treated as sub-human and found that life remained hard for them. Gwin describes the black communications with their oppressors as a surrogate mother and her children that need guidance, looking after, and strong discipline. The black women knew that no matter what she did she would get beatings from the white women and their mistresses, they took chattel slavery to its boundaries in how the women treated the black women when they felt threatened. White women didn't just physically abuse the black woman they also mentally abused her. The slave women were "associated with sex and loss of control, sexually suggestive, and wild Negroes."(pg 119) These derogatory names were what most white women came to stereotype as being the definition of the average black woman. So they to had it hard when they were being worked by the woman of the house. Being that the mere idea that if you were a black woman your mistress or lady of the house felt threatened by your presence, so they did there best to make sure the black women got to tired and to low of self-esteem to do anything.
In are class we discussed how women, during the 1700's & 1800s, began to conflict with their roles in society. Our class observed how women's lives began to change during this time period. The women of this time period were raised to believe in a patriarcle system because it promised to protect, privilege, and subordinate them. We took note in our class room lectures that ultimately this system gave women a great amount of power being they had what their husband wanted. This book gives good examples of what happened to this system and how it starts to change from its way. The slave women's sexual relationship with the white husbands had made it very hard for the women to have the power they had in their homes, and the system was not serving them as it should, so the women made a change. This example of how the women had gone from a lifestyle that they enjoyed to taking some responsibility over their life. The women had to begin make sure for herself that she still remained at her proper lady status no matter what her husband does, and that is why they beat and made the lives of African women much harder. But more importantly you can see how the white women of the south were beginning to make the changes needed to get what they needed from society, by using their own system that works the best for them. This shows the change from total power to obtaining things on their own. Because of these changes in their lifestyles women found they needed change their identity in order to keep some kind of power. Gwin's book goes on to talk about how the white woman's lifestyle changes. And how they got directly involved in their lives, and start looking out for themselves, being that the system of the husband looking out for her began to disappear. The white women of the south felt threatened by what they felt could be a definite challenge to their power and they needed to begin to change so that they could still be able to achieve the goals that they need fulfilled in life. The southern women during this time period were having to become much independent and begin to get jobs and all become more active in the ways of working because the south could not remain the same with the release of the slaves. Women had began to get jobs and work along side of her husband, and begin to become more involved in the everyday ways of life.
I think that Gwin's book is a good illustration of what has and still is happening to women. Their lifestyle is always changing. Gwin's argument that life was never a sisterhood between the blacks and white in the so-called American fiction and autobiography seems prove true. These women were very much different and the ethnocentrism in a white woman keeps her from ever getting past the dark skin, and makes the white women feel more like the Africans were more of an animal then an actual person. The white women always feels that the slave must understand that the man may rank higher than her but even if her husband wants to mess around then fault goes to the slave not the husbands. And the slave will never be to her level, because the black slave will never be a lady.
And in the book you can see how the white women lost there power in the house and that their system of life that they received didn't prove to work out anymore for them so they had to attempt to adjust to a way life took would take them. I feel that Gwin argues that the main reason for the confrontations for the struggle of power became evident in that it had gotten to point that certain black women would not let their own female owners hit them. This is an example of how not only how the whites women challenged the system, but also how the slave women started to make changes in how they willed to be treated.
Bibliographical citation
Gwin, Minrose. Black And White Women Of The Old South. Knoxville: Tennessee Press, 1985.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In her essay, Engendering Racial Difference, author Kathleen Brown argues that “early definitions of racial difference and the accompanying discriminatory practices resulted ultimately in a race-specific concept of womanhood.” Such a ‘race-specific concept of womanhood’ was eventually ingrained in the laws of Virginia which expedited the perpetual enslavement of the African people and their children. The initial legal ambiguity in Virginia laws regarding slaves facilitated either the exploitation of slaves by their masters or servitude and their eventual release subject to the “good-will of their masters.” As more slaves (who were mostly African) started arriving in Virginia, however, a need for a slave code soon developed. Because many of…
- 520 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The Plantation Mistress by Catherine Clinton is a historical non-fiction book which details the lives and the daily struggles of the white women of the planter class as it existed during the antebellum era in the southern United States. Through the use of historical records and diary entries of the women themselves, Ms. Clinton clearly documents that the lives of the Plantation Mistresses were remarkably different and significantly more difficult than what is that of Scarlett O’Hara and her family. Furthermore, the expectations of the white females of the time were not that of the pampered southern bell who was indulged and spoiled by her husband and whose every need was tended to by slaves. In fact, the women of the time were in only a…
- 796 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In the old south the Antebellum era was characterized by a slave society that affected nearly everything. In the South’s slavery defined social and political institutions while also fueling their economy. Slavery influenced made the South’s cotton trade more efficient with codependence on northern banks and merchants. The south’s cotton industry depended on slave labor a lot and later fueled political debates at economic conventions in 1837 to 1839. Regards the south northern dependence on financiers and importers these two things were the threat of the Old South’s commercial independence. Slavery had many other effects on politics where yeomen farmers wished to shape the society off their own democratic values.…
- 245 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
In the book the white women has power over the black man all because he is black. “She turned on him in scorn “listen nigger,” she said “you know what I can do to you if you open your trap?” crooks stared hopelessly at her and then he sat down on his bunk and drew into himself. She closed on him “you know what I could do?” crook seemed to grow smaller and he pressed himself against the wall “yes ma’am “ that a woman was able to make a black man feel bad about himself and make him stop talking. Also how a curley has power over his wife. H=because she is women and during that time women were just property (……) that he is able to make his wife feel like property and that she can't do anything just stay at home and clean. Then how the white men has power over black men all because the color of her skin(…) that they won't talk to him or anything else beside play horseshoes with. Plus how he's not allowed to go into the buk where they other guys are he has to stay in the barn with the…
- 632 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Simple yet precise, Sojourner Truth’s speech, “Ain’t I a Woman? ” brings to the foreground the issues that many of the White Anglo-Saxons females, purposefully or un-purposefully, overlooked during the fight for equality in the mid 1800’s. Upon my first reading of this speech, I thought the message was clear: women are not treated as equals. However, as I read and reread the speech, I realized that Sojourner’s message is much deeper than the unequal treatment of all women. Her message is about the unequal treatment of the African-American women.…
- 327 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Slavery is the saddest period of human’s history. What slaves went through was really hard and it takes strong people to survive to that’s situation. They not only had to work every day of their lives without any compensation, but they were also broken down morally and separated from their families. Slaves were not treated as humans. They were treated as objects and machines and the only thing they were supposed to do were to obey to their masters, and if not, they would get beaten up, whipped or even killed. This is clearly shown on the Angela Davis’s essay, Reflection on the Black Woman’s Role in the Community of Slaves.…
- 533 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Angela Davies starts by pointing out the plight of the black people, and especially black women, at the hands of slavery in the 19th century. With the rise of black people movements and abolishment of slavery, the black women’s working conditions didn’t seem to improve. They were still subjected to bad working conditions if not worse at the hands of the whites. The rise of the white feminists’ movement didn’t improve the plight of African women as they were still viewed as servants (chapter 5). Women were subjected to slavery in the modern times due to their sorry economic…
- 1162 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Amanda America Dickson or also known on her family’s plantation in Hancock County, Georgia as “Miss Mandy,” was born to Julia a housekeeper at David Dickson’s plantation. David Dickson a 40-year-old white male raped her mother at the age of 13 and later she gave birth to Amanda. Amanda was extremely lucky to have been in favor of her father and grandmother in which she was treated very well and received a lady’s upbringing despite being legally enslaved to her father. Amanda eventually married a white male that was her father’s nephew and had two children of her own. The marriage would end prematurely and she would return home with her children where her father became very fond of his grandchildren. She would tend to do this throughout her life where she would move away from her home and her father but when she would return back to her house her father would welcome her back with welcome arms and always had a special place in his heart for his daughter Amanda.…
- 429 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
During the years between 1960-1970, there was an increase in involvement of white southerners in the Republican Party compared to the previous years of whites in the Democratic Party. This is seen as a result of a southern strategy of Conservative Republicans to centralize their campaign towards the Southern United states by appealing to racism against African Americans. “By isolating white southerners as carriers of the racist gene…the southern strategy narrative understates the role of racial reaction on the right.” Not only did they pursue southerners, but also those in the North and West who were dissatisfied with the Democratic Party; a majority of whom did not agree with the ideals set in place by the New Deal, which transformed the…
- 728 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In Harriet Jacobs’s narrative, Incident in the Life of a Slave Girl, she gives realistic and truthful descriptions of life as a slave. Although not all blacks in the South were slaves, they were still oppressed in many ways such as with discrimination and lacking certain freedoms. Of course, situations concerning the daily life of blacks in the south, enslaved or free, varied in different areas due to the different treatments of white masters, as well as white civilians. Some blacks had it more difficult than others. Whites in the South surely dominated and controlled society, but did they have total domination over blacks? Were the two races only relatable as oppressor and oppressed? Although one would believe so, there is much evidence in the Jacobs’s narrative that shows that blacks still had a few freedoms, even under the overbearing weight of slavery and racism. The truth of the matter is that even though some of their unalienable rights had been taken away, little freedom was at the tip of their fingers. Once discovering a way to grab on to that freedom, they could pull it in closer until it was entirely there own. Some evidence proving that blacks were not totally dominated by southern whites involves the situation of Jacobs’s father, the slave’s celebration of Christmas, and also the situation of Jacobs’s Uncle Benjamin.…
- 1141 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
In Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl, Harriet Jacobs wrote, “Slavery is terrible for men; but it is far more terrible for women.” (Incidents, Chapter XIV). In addition to being subjected to the same punishments and heinous treatment as male slaves, raping of women occured, for example. Jacobs wrote that “No matter whether the slave girl be as black as ebony or as fair as her mistress. In either case, there is no shadow of law to protect her from insult, from violence, or even from death; all these are inflicted by fiends who bear the shape of men.” (Incidents Ch V). Women in today’s society are frequently subjected to sexual equality and sexual harassment issues. For example, recently several high-powerful men, such as Harvey Weinstein, have been accused of preying on socially weaker women whom are not in similar positions of power. Similarly, in Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl, Jacobs wrote that “My master met me at every turn, reminding me that I belonged to him, and swearing by heaven and earth that he would compel me to submit to him.” (Incidents Chapter V). The same sexual equality issues faced by Jacobs remain commonplace in today’s…
- 956 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
2. Once again, the values of the people influence society directly. In the 1800's, women had very little power. In the early 1900's, women made up a little more than half of the population of the United States. As a result of increasingly liberal opinions, the United States government was forced to give the people what it wanted, and granted women the right to vote in the 1920's. The same was seen with the Civil Rights Movement of African-Americans. Deciding that generations of abuse had to end, African-Americans decided to voice their own opinions. Once again, with increasingly liberal opinions, the government gave people what they wanted: desegregation. And it happened yet again in modern times. Homosexuals were not officially allowed to…
- 196 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
One of the points one is in concurrence with, is idea of mistaken matriarchy with black women. That instead of black woman being placed in a higher standard, their efforts are continually driven under the rug. We see this in the work force. Black women were always given more work than off course white women; we also see this in modern day society. A black woman becomes the bread winner of the family, when their men, “black men”, go to prison. It seems there efforts to up hold the house hold…
- 575 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In the Jim Crow Era, women struggled and forged on in the name of gender equality, while adding a new characteristic to women’s identity, race. As Anna Julia Cooper expressed, “the colored woman of today. …is confronted by a woman question and a race problem”.…
- 187 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The purpose of the article is to explore the need and advantages of conducting community based research with women of colour in the United States. The authoritative knowledge that these women can provide about their lives and their health could form the basis of collaboration between researchers and participants and lead to successful strategies to improve the health of African American women. The article provides the goals for improving African American women’s health before investigating the issues related to cultural sensitivity, reciprocity, accountability and authoritative voices in order to argue that the research on these women and their health must be attuned to the multiple identities the women possess that are associated with race, gender and class.…
- 850 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays