Preview

Black Death Muslim and Christian Responses

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
517 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Black Death Muslim and Christian Responses
Imagine yourself alone on a street corner, coughing up bloody mucous each time you exhale. You are gasping for a full breath of air, but realizing that is not possible, you give up your fight to stay alive. You're thinking why is this happening to me? That is how the victims of the Black Death felt. In five short years, the plague killed between 25 and 45% of the populations it encountered. So how different were the Christian and Muslim responses? In 1348 Christians who were followers of Jesus Christ and Muslims who followed the teachings of Muhammad came face to face with the Black Death. In truth, Muslims and Christians responded in many different ways. Even the way the blamed others for the cause of the plague and religious views about the disease were very much different. In a similar manner both religions acted completely out the norm, they basically set aside their spiritual beliefs for a moment.
One of the similar responses between the Muslims and Christians were acting out of the ordinary. According to document five both religions were finding non-religious alternatives to prevent the Black Death. In some cases, the Christians would try to sleeping on their backs to prevent the plague, while the Muslims would even avoid going outside. In addition they both drank a solution of Armenian clay to cleanse the body and built fires hoping that this would purify the contaminated air. Based on document nine both the religions united together to pray and they went back to their religious ways. These documents prove that each religion in some cases stepped out their religious backgrounds to try to prevent the Black Death.
Religious views played a big part on the different ways the Christians and Muslims responded to the Black Death. The Christians basically thought the plague was their fault. They believe that they’re being punished for their sins they’ve imputed against God. On the other hand the Muslims are taking the plague lightly. They believe that “a Muslim

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    DBQ crusades

    • 1109 Words
    • 3 Pages

    During the crusades political leaders and writers used religion as a way to persuade people to join the fight. Their ways of persuasion were to fight against Gods' enemies, who were the Turks, Franks, and Arabs. People who invaded other Christian and Islamic lands to conquer them, killing many of their people in the process. Documents one, two, four, and five show the way the political leaders and writers had put the image of the attackers into their people's minds. Leaders such as Pope Urban II, Ekkehard, Saladin and Solomon described the attackers in ill manners. They would agree and describe the attackers as “barbaric”, “enemies”, “demonic.” These descriptions had persuaded audiences (their people) to join the fight against the “demons” of their “Holy City.” What even motivated some people, especially the Christians, were the deals the Pope had given them, such as serfs being liberated from their ties to the manors. The subjects had to fight for the land that they stand on to continue being good Christians. If you died fighting for this, you would get instant remission of sins, meaning you would be forgiven for all of their sins. After the fight, the crusaders had stayed in the holy city and realized how corrupt the church was when they found out the promises the Pope gave them where just white lies. They abandoned the church rules and started living on…

    • 1109 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    DBQ Essay: The Black Death

    • 1721 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In history every small or large issue had a great effect on the lives of many and created categories which people could associated, such as religion, economic classes, medical etc. The Black Death is one of those issues that help enforce and evolve many of this categories such as, Religion, economic, social, medical, and in this documents show people desperation and greedy.…

    • 1721 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1346 European traders began to hear reports about earthquakes, floods, locusts, famine, and plague in faraway China. They knew very little then that the plague they were hearing about would follow the same trade routes to the Middle East, North Africa, and Europe that they themselves used. (doc. 1) In five short years, the plague killed between 25 and 45% of the populations it encountered. (doc 2) So how different were the Christian and Muslim responses? In 1348 Christianity and Islam came face to face with the Black Death. (doc. 3A) In truth, Muslims and Christians responded in many different ways. Their ideas for what caused the Black Death were somewhat different from each other also. Even the way they thought they could cure the disease was almost entirely different. With evidence and accounts of people that exist from the Bubonic Plague, one may come to a conclusion that Christians were actually much more out of control than Muslims were during this time of need.…

    • 936 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    History reveals the mid-14th century as a very unfortunate time for Europe. It was during this period when the continent became afflicted by a terrible plague. The source of the pathogen is known today as bubonic but was colloquially known as “The Black Death” to Europeans of the day. The plague caused a tremendous number of deaths and was a catalyst of change, severely impacting Europe’s cultural, political and religious institutions.…

    • 1511 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A lot of fear was happening during the Black Plague, but not just fear but doubt as well, doubt in God, doubt that humanity is doomed to their own impiety. Religion plays a major role for the Black Plague impacting the Western Civilization. An entire civilization, multiple civilizations were facing death, and once a person is almost facing death a natural reaction would be to turn towards the church for support and guidance through a person's final days. The priests during this time were even worried about being infected with the Plague that priests were gaining the reputation for not attending to the decaying bodies in an appropriate amount of time that funerals had no choice to but to perform hasty…

    • 535 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    People used to believe in god because they think god is selfless and kind, so they think plague was the punishment from god. But they realized that even though they pray more and do more kind things, it didn’t do any good to reduce the death. People lose the faith in God. People started to believe that Christian clergies are greedy, self-centered and filled with a sense of their own importance. The idealized image suffered. (Gottfried, 1985) Since people no longer believe in god after Black Death; the religion revolution is sprouting. People began to relived the rules they obtained from Christians, and exposed their human…

    • 549 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Prior to the Plague, the Church, ruled by the Pope, was the sole guardian of religious thought and theology, dispensing information, blessings and curses as it saw fit. The general population had no access to the bible or scripture except that which was meted out by the priests and clergy. Anyone who questioned the teachings of the Church was denounced, excommunicated and sometimes burned at the stake” (The Impact). “The Black Death set the stage for more modern medicine and spurred changes in public health and hospital management. Frustrated with Black Death diagnoses that revolved around astrology and superstition, educators began placing greater emphasis on clinical medicine, based on physical science” (Effects of the Black Death). People grew tired of going to the church for help, when the church had no answers to their problem. “When the plague arrived, people believed it was a punishment of God. Therefore, they often turned to the Church for help. But since the priests and bishops could not actually offer a cure or even an explanation, the Catholic Church lost a lot of its influence and for many people, their view of the world changed drastically” (The Black Death). As a result, many of the clergy got sick and died. However, those that did not get sick, abandoned their post. ‘“With fewer priests, and quicker deaths, Pope Clement VI was forced to grant remission of sins to all who died of the…

    • 926 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Black Death and Smallpox were terrible plagues that lead to great loss of human life. As a result, Europe’s population decreased by a third and experts estimate that the New World lost more than 90 million. Both the Black death and Smallpox raised wages, were used as weapons and lead to loss of religious faith, but during the time of the Black death people lost faith in god, whereas during Smallpox, Indians lost faith in their traditions and the Black Death allegedly conserved the land, whereas Smallpox did just the opposite.…

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dbq- the Bubonic Plague

    • 987 Words
    • 4 Pages

    14Th Century Europe was a period of chaos and turmoil. The Great Famine of 1315-1317 produced the worst famine in the Middle Ages that killed millions of people all over Europe. The onset of the Bubonic Plague (“Black Death”) only made things worse. The Black Death swept throughout Europe and killed as much as two fifths of the already diminished European population. The Black Death effected Europe politically, socially, and economically. Europeans responded to the Black Death differently. We got to see what Europeans did, thought, and how the Black Death affected Europe socially through physicians, firsthand accounts, and written reports.…

    • 987 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Justinian Plague Analysis

    • 1104 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Black Death and the Plague of Justinian had profound effects on society. Both cultures, when faced with the plague, reacted differently.…

    • 1104 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Black Death Dbq

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The entire reason that the Black Death even spread in the first place was because of interactions. Trade was the main way the plague spread, mainly in Europe. (doc. 1) Since the Black Death spread more into Europe, more Christians were stricken with the epidemic and they thought it was a punishment from God. The Muslims saw it as a blessing because one of their rival religions was being depleted. This map was made to show where the Black Death spread and the paths it took throughout Europe, Asia, and the Middle East. Both Christians and Muslims could agree on at least one thing: The symptoms and effects of the plague were dreadful. As Agnolo di Tura, a chronicler in 14th century Italy, stated, “…one who did not see such horribleness can be called blessed.” (doc. 3) The people that had interactions of any sort with those who were afflicted with the Black Death, whether they were Muslim or Christian, can agree that the plague was awful. The authors wrote this to emphasize how terrible the Black Death was, and how much people suffered from it. When Europe was being overwhelmed with countless cases of the Black Plague, Christians needed someone to blame. Pope Clement VI, a Pope from Europe in the 14th century, stated that “Since this pestilence is all but universal everywhere…Jews have provided the cause…for such a crime is without plausibility.” (doc. 8) Interactions…

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dbq Black Death

    • 1455 Words
    • 6 Pages

    According to a map of the Middle East and Europe, the Black Death didn’t have many routes through the Middle East, but quite a lot of routes are shown in Europe. Most of the routes in Europe spread over water, the Mediterranean Sea, but there were still routes on land. Judging by this, it’s easy to tell that the Black Plague affected more areas in Europe than in the Middle East because of all the different routes. In the Middle East, there was only 3 or 4 different routes for the plague to travel, all were and except for one in the red sea. It appears that the Black Death entered in through the Middle East through the Red Sea and Mecca. Mecca is a highly populated city, and this most likely led to many deaths. On a document about death counts in Europe, and the Middle East, they were very similar death rates; about 30%.The Black Death killed more people in Europe, simply because it had the highest population. Europe had a population of 75,000,000, which dropped by 23,840,000 people to only 51,160,000 people. That is about a third, 31% of the population. England itself had a higher death count, probably because of its denser population. About half of all the priests and monks died, probably because of them going around and trying to help people with the plague, while only 33% of the population died in England. They had 4,200,000 people before the plague, and about 2,800,000 after the plague; a drop of 1,400,000. In the Middle East, there were similar death counts to those in Europe, for example, the death count in Egypt was about 25%, while the death rates of Syria were about 33%. Another document describes points of view of people from societies that witnessed the disease first hand. The speaker from Italy spoke…

    • 1455 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Black Plague Dbq

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages

    People thought the world was ending, thought it was the cause of witchcraft, and just looked to point the finger to somebody. At the time, no one knew the source of the disease. “Panic spread faster than the disease.” (Black Death and Sin) Source 2 says that people called Flagellants believed the plague was a judgment of God and they started flogging each other. They preached that doing this for thirty-three days would make them cleaned of all their sins. Other people blamed Jews for inciting God’s wrath. In Germany rumor had it that Jews poisoned the wells, which caused the plague. Jews were arrested, put on fire, and were generally attacked. In all, people were reacting quite terribly and were persecuting adn getting persecuted for misunderstanding. Europe was in a…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The black plague killed an estimated 75–200 million people in the 14th century. It is estimated that between one-quarter and two-thirds of the European population (35 million people) died from the outbreak between 1348 and 1350. This reduction in citizens lead to scarce labour. The Black Death not only generated a massive loss in population, but also caused famine. This loss is because labourers were dying of the sickness, fields were unploughed, wheat was not sowed and vines not trimmed leading to a shortage of food and insignificant food income. Source A shows the percentage of the deaths caused by the Black Death in Europe. Families were devastated as they watched relatives die. There was segregation of the sick and friends and family were forced to abandon the affected, leading to a breakdown in the family unit. The Black Death also triggered ethnic hatred on a massive scale. A group of lay extremists called the flagellants emerged. They directly challenged the power of the church. They began to blame themselves for the black plague and punished themselves through pain and suffering. They walked the streets, stripped at the waist, and in large groups. Source B shows a contemporary view of the flagellants as they torcher themselves by whipping themselves. These short-term effects also triggered the long-term effects which impacted on the…

    • 1081 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Several civilization had different religious beliefs for the cause of the plague. In Document 4 after the…

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays