Preview

Cafs

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
728 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Cafs
Discuss arguments for and against surrogacy. When developing your arguments, consider the viewpoints that might be expressed by different groups within society such as a childless couple, a same sex couple, a blended family and different cultural and religious groups.

Arguments for surrogacy:

Surrogate motherhood raises difficult ethical, philosophical and social issues. There is debate in the community as to the wisdom of surrogacy arrangements. There is scope for disagreement as to the morality of aspects of such reviews the arrangements. This Chapter reviews the arguments for and against surrogacy, including the moral bases for making judgements about surrogacy. In raising these issues the Commission is seeking guidance on community attitudes to assist in formulating principles on can he made.

Arguments against surrogacy:
Considerably more arguments have been advanced against the use of surrogacy arrangements. Surrogacy may involve identifiable risks to the child, to the surrogate mother, and to the commissioning parents.
Welfare of the Child
Surrogacy arrangements involve not only the commissioning couple and the surrogate mother, but the resulting child as well. Accordingly, it is argued that the society has a right to prohibit surrogacy in order to prevent children being born in undesirable circumstances. It is further argued that such arrangements are in reality contracts for the purchase of a child, which are quite unacceptable.
Some would argue that there are very specific risks to the child born as a result of a surrogacy arrangement. Unlike the position when a child is adopted, if unregulated surrogacy arrangements are allowed to occur, there would be no objective, impartial assessment of the suitability of a commissioning couple to be parents. The risk would be that the governing selection criterion would simply be the capacity to pay the surrogacy fee. Of its very nature the surrogacy arrangement is likely to lead to more custody disputes

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The first benefit is to prevent or minimize a decrease in future fertility. By preventing this avoidable decrease, that child is given to the opportunity to make future reproductive choices. Failing to offer fertility preservation deprives the child of a choice that he or she would have otherwise had. The second benefit is the demonstration of concern for the child’s future fertility. Undergoing a fertility preservation procedure is no guarantee that the patient will become a parent to a baby who is genetically related to him or her. However, the attempt to preserve the child’s fertility demonstrates the parents’ and clinicians’ concern for the child’s future reproductive choices. These significant benefits justify a presumption in favor of attempting fertility preservation, assuming that there are effective and established techniques…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Surrogate parenting is a process where an arrangement is made and an individual who is not a parent is given the parental rights, duties and the responsibility of parenthood either it is court pointed or voluntary. Another example on the more scientific level, an infertile couple can pay another woman who agrees to carry the baby for the infertile woman (couple) through artificial insemination. (Medical Encyclopedia, 2013). The ethical dilemmas surrounding parenting involves several parties, the surrogate, the intending family as well as the child. Some of the dilemmas from the surrogate are is she going to be able to let the child go once it is delivered, after taking the pain of carrying and delivering the child not to mention the stress that comes with it. The dilemmas on the intending family can be questions as, is the surrogate able to carry the child to full term, is she going to change her mind by trying to keep the child, is the child truly theirs since another person carried it, are they going to disclose this information to the child one day?…

    • 1281 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Wiesemann Natality

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “The Moral Challenge of Natality: Towards a Post-Traditional Concept of Family and Privacy in Repro-genetics” is an article from Gottingen University, written by C. Wiesemann. Wiesemann discusses how “repro-genetic is going to change the way we conceive children, and will have a substantial influence on the family” (61). He evaluates the two family models, the traditional model and the care model. They are part of an “ethical debate” of which model is better for a family. Instead of choosing between the two he suggests a third model, the kinship model as a “moral agent” for the debate (61). He thinks of the kinship model as being better suited for the family model. Wiesemann persuades his view by appealing to the audience’s emotions for the most part. Although he does well to prove his point, his arguments are ineffective due to hasty generalizations, ad populum, and ad misericordiam.…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hca 322 Week 5 Assignment

    • 2523 Words
    • 11 Pages

    When one or more persons contract with a woman to gestate a child than relinquish that child after birth to the person or couple is known as surrogacy. It is a course of action that goes outside of natural reproduction. For some, it is the only method of having children, extending family. Surrogacy has been stirring up many controversies over the years. Ethics, morals, laws, religious views, etc. have played a major role in the issues that follow the topic of surrogacy. Laws and regulations pertaining to surrogacy vary from state to state. Some states have no enforceable laws towards surrogacy, while others only permit surrogacy contracts that are uncompensated arrangements and gestational agreements (Trimarchi, 2011). Some states prohibit same sex couples from entering into any form of surrogacy contracts. In this paper, I will be address the legal and ethical issues involved and other aspects of surrogacy.…

    • 2523 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The legal aspects surrounding surrogacy is very complex and mostly unsettled. In some jurisdictions the possibility of surrogacy has been legally allowed and as a result, the intended parents may be recognized as the legal parent’s right from the birth of a baby. In all states of Australia (except Tasmania) altruistic surrogacy is legal however, in all states in Australia commercial surrogacy is a criminal offence and is illegal. Countries around the world have similar laws towards surrogacy.…

    • 1122 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Recent evidence by Stanford University has shown that a surrogate’s womb may act as more than just a home for a fetus, in fact, the womb may effects how a child’s genes will be programmed (Moss and Baden). If this study is correct it would suggest that surrogacy may be more than just a service. Additionally, this evidence would change the role of a surrogate to lean farther away from a service provider, and closer to selling a child with whom a surrogate has genetic ties too. Studies like these have amplified anti-surrogacy arguments like those of Barba Rothman. In her article, “On Surrogacy” Rothman rejects the idea that, “a woman can be pregnant with someone else’s baby… it reduces a woman to a container.” Furthermore, Rothman insists that surrogacy is baby-selling.…

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    cafs

    • 772 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Education Newsletter 15 March 2014 Volume VII Into the mindset of a HSC Student A Mount Carmel Catholic High School student, goal easily achievable. The set goal helps him by the name of Charles Baker has been in order to gain better outcomes which recognised for his determination to complete ultimately helps him with his habits later on in the HSC. This dedicated high school student life. has set goals he aims to achieve in order to get into his hopeful career as a Paramedic in Similar to his short term goal, Baker aims to the Australian Defence Force. remember and to be extremely confident with the notes written throughout the span of year…

    • 772 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    cafs

    • 4094 Words
    • 17 Pages

    Immediate and unplanned change> results in them being unable to meet the immediate needs of members.> results in trauma.…

    • 4094 Words
    • 17 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Family Law for Paralegals

    • 2146 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Within this paper an overview of family law will be highlighted. The impact and state requirements by the Child Support Enforcement and Establishment of Paternity Act of 1974 will be discussed. Child support, guidelines, enforcement, duration, and tax implications will be analyzed. The difference between permanent alimony, lump-sum support, and rehabilitative support in spousal support will be examined. Classification of property, marital property division and valuation, distribution, and tax implications will be highlighted. The significance of Levy v. Louisiana and the legal framework for paternity issues will be discussed. This paper will also describe the pros and cons of artificial insemination from a sperm bank versus a known donor.…

    • 2146 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Surrogacy Parenthood Act 1988(QLD) was repealed in 2010 in which the Surrogacy Act (QLD) 2010 was introduced. Under this Act there are two types of Surrogacy. Alturistic and Commerical. Alturistic surrogacy which is legal, is where a woman agrees to be the surrogate mother with no intention of financial gain. A commercial surrogacy arrangement involves a person receiving a reward, payment or any material benefit for entering into the surrogacy arrangement. Thus being illegal in Australia, it does not stop people from going overseas and applying for Surrogacy. A number of reason why there have been a rise in the surrogacy services, because of the decrease in number of children available for adoption domestically. In Australia state based…

    • 129 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    An Estimated 10-15 per cent of Australian couples who want to start a family are infertile, similarly same-sex couples are unable to reproduce and this has led to the use of surrogacy and birthing technologies to provide a means to overcome such barriers in having children. The changing views of society along with the corresponding reforms of the law in relation to these procedures have been main contributors to contemporary issues within the area being addressed, however the effectiveness of legal and non-legal measures in place is questionable. With diverse perspectives and interpretations on what is a just outcome for all parties involved, it is difficult to evaluate such a controversial matter. Issues relevant today in relation to surrogacy include the exploitation of women overseas through commercial surrogacy as well as the presumption of parentage and parentage orders, even with the approval of legal measures dealing with such problems, conflict of views indicate many people do not agree and feel there is a great need for reform. Birthing technologies hold many interrelated issues of concerns with difficulties in defining legal parents in relation to birth certificates as well as the roles and responsibilities of gametes donors. The amendment of previous laws in addition with the introduction of new ones aim to better reflect the changing values of society with non-governmental organisations and the media attempting to assist in informing the public and creating awareness with current issues.…

    • 3044 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Infertility

    • 378 Words
    • 2 Pages

    There are few cases where the conventional options cannot be used for having a baby. In such cases, couples can solicit the assistance of a third party to provide sperm, egg or carry a child for them. This is termed as ‘surrogacy.’ Women without uterus or with uterine diseases or with hysterectomy done can choose surrogacy for having a…

    • 378 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The surrogate motherhood controversy has been an ongoing battle for many years with two different sides giving their viewpoints. This has created much of a battle over recent years. Surrogate motherhood controversy has stirred up many critics and authors viewpoints to justify whether surrogacy should be practiced at all and if it should be legalized. While interpreting and analyzing the debate on whether surrogacy has ethical or moral values, or if it has turned the creation of a child into a new form of commodity to individuals, especially the women who bear the child for childless couples.…

    • 3706 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Where a child is born unplanned there may be alleged negligence in allowing that conception to occur or where because of negligence the mother goes on to give birth. If a sterilization procedure is negligently performed and this results in a pregnancy there may be a miscarriage or the baby may be still born or the mother may decide to abort the pregnancy. In these cases the courts would have little difficulty in awarding costs in relation to the suffering and allied costs. The woman may go on to give birth to a live baby. The claim would then be for the costs of a child which they did not want and it is this which the courts have found problematic.…

    • 3290 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Surrogacy is not a new concept, but rather it is believed to be the oldest alternative to a male and female partner conceiving a child by sexual intercourse (Fisher, 2013). There are two types of surrogacy which are traditional surrogacy and gestational surrogacy. A traditional surrogate is inseminated with the sperm of the intended father or with donor sperm through in vitro fertilization or IVF, and the surrogate uses her own egg and the surrogate is genetically related to the child. A gestational surrogate has an embryo placed into her uterus, also through IVF, but the surrogate’s egg is not…

    • 1518 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics