Mr. Bannis
Introduction to Philosophy- 1
November 18, 2014
Capstone: Philosophical Analysis The philosophical question, “Is beauty in the eye of the beholder?” is exemplified in F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby. The concept of beauty is a reoccurring theme in “The Great Gatsby”: the way Jay Gatsby views Daisy Buchanan, the way Nick Carroway views Jay Gatsby, the symbol of the beauty of the green light at the end of Daisy and Tom Buchanan’s dock, and many characters’ view of living areas as beautiful or non beautiful. Is there something in their minds that tells them these things are beautiful or do they just think they are beautiful? Plato believes that “We can recognize and judge the beauty of physical things only if the nonphysical Form of Beauty resides in the mind,” (Lawhead 145). Plato believed that beauty is objective and unchanging. Jay Gatsby, the former love interest of Daisy, who is now married to Tom Buchanan, sees her as a beacon of his hopes and dreams. He idolizes her beauty to the point of obsession. He looked at Daisy “in a way that every young girl wants to be looked at." If Daisy Buchannan is objectively beautiful, then that is unchanging no matter the observer. She is naturally pretty, wears fancy clothes, and talks in an enchanting way. These qualities combined make her objectively beautiful. If the observer sees Daisy as not beautiful, that is a weakness in them. It is not a weakness in the object or person itself. Nick Carroway and many others in the book see Jay Gatsby in an illuminated, beautiful way. “He had one of those rare smiles with a quality of eternal reassurance in it, that you may come across four or five times in life. It faced, or seemed to face, the whole external world for an instant and then concentrated on you with an irresistible prejudice in your favor. It understood you just as far as you wanted to be understood, believed in you as you would like to believe in yourself,” (Fitzgerald 35). They all see Gatsby as beautiful, and that is object and inherent in their mind. If beauty was subjective, then the term beauty can be applied to whatever the observer wants. So if beauty is in the eye of the beholder then a murderer can say, “murder is a beautiful thing” without anyone being able to rightly object him. But murder is not a beautiful thing; it is the opposite in fact, so beauty cannot be in the eye of the beholder. Plato said in “The Voyage of Discovery”, “If there is any loveliness discerned in the lineaments of the body, or beauty in the movement of music and song, it is the mind that makes this judgment. This means that there must be within the mind a superior form, one that is immaterial and independent of sound and space and time.” In the Great Gatsby, everyone considers East Egg to be the most beautiful and elegant place to live. The land has pretty physical features and the highest social class lives there, making it beautiful. Augustine says, “If the beauty of this order fails to delight us, it is because we ourselves, by reason of our morality, are so enmeshed in this corner of the cosmos that we fail t o perceive the beauty of a total pattern in which the particular parts, which seem ugly to us, blend in so harmonious and beautiful way,” (Lawhead 150). So, the answer to the philosophical question, “Is beauty in the eye of the beholder?” is no. The Great Gatsby exemplifies Plato’s stance on this issue by showing certain things as beautiful because of the qualities that make up that thing. Something that is beautiful is always beautiful, and it is the observer’s fault if they do not see that, not the object itself.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Although Nick Carraway, at times, has certain distinct attitudes towards Jay Gatsby, it becomes clear at the end of the novel that Carraway’s general attitude towards Gatsby is mixed, laden with ambiguity. Part of Nick feels sorry for Gatsby, and admires his “never-say-die” attitude. While the other side of Carraway, at certain points within the novel, disapproves of Gatsby’s position in terms of ethics, and how he tends to disregard the general code of manners. In addition, the author, F. Scott Fitzgerald, employs various rhetorical devices to develop Carraway’s attitude towards Gatsby, including imagery and metaphors among others.…
- 281 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The mystery behind Jay Gatsby allows for him to become one of the most intriguing members of the upper class. As Gatsby’s background unravels, it becomes clear that Fitzgerald chose Jay Gatsby as the main character because he defies every social normality in the 1920’s. By Fitzgerald’s writing, the reader realizes that Gatsby’s mindset separates him from others. Everything Gatsby has accomplished in the past five years is because of his dedication, ambition, and integrity in following in his dreams which Fitzgerald greatly admires. The social class one is born into is the one they belong to their entire life, unless you are Jay Gatsby. Although Gatsby attempts to convince people that his entire life has consisted of lavish and wealthy things,…
- 257 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Gatsby began life as the son of poor farmers living on the shores of Lake Superior. Early in his youth Gatsby “knew he had a big future in front of him”. He later changed his name from James Gatz to the more fashionable sounding Jay Gatsby. The narrator of The Great Gatsby, Nick Carraway, is astounded by Gatsby’s ambition. “There was something gorgeous about him… it was an extraordinary gift for hope, a romantic readiness such as I have never found in any other person and which it is likely I shall never find again”. Gatsby was determined to attain his goal and self-disciplined Gatsby was as a young dreamer. He wanted to change the world by being the one who would invent a “needed invention”. Young Gatz was bound to make it big. He had what it took: the brains, the will power, the looks, and the ambition. However Gatsby’s intentions were the purest when he was a young boy, by the time he was grown man he had already made it in the world, his story of success is quite different from that which his dreams foretold. What Fitzgerald is trying to show is the change of Gatsby’s original pure American dream to his success, infected with…
- 884 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In chapter 3 Fitzgerald introduces us to the main character of his book, and we finally get an insight into what Gatsby is like (albeit through the eyes of Nick Carraway) during the party he throws. Even though we meet the character himself, Fitzgerald continues to entice us with rumours of Gatsby, which is significant because it shows just how artificial his entire life is – he couldn’t dispel the rumours even if he wanted to.…
- 458 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby, the main character Jay Gatsby is the tragic hero in the novel. Gatsby is a rich man who falls in love with a woman from his past, but could not be with her; instead, he ended up alone and was killed.…
- 461 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Jay Gatsby can be characterized as a war veteran who is simply desperate to regain his young love, Daisy Buchanan. Gatsby has spent many years changing his life in order to win Daisy back, but when they finally meet again, “… Daisy tumbled short of his dreams” (Fitzgerald 95). Gatsby spent years building up an elaborate imagination of what he thought Daisy would be like when he finally met with her again. Not only does he spend many years thinking about her, he uses his time becoming the man he thinks Daisy wants. The way Gatsby changes his whole life for a woman speaks loudly about his character.…
- 827 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In F. Scott Fitzgerald’s famous novel, The Great Gatsby, Jay Gatsby is portrayed as being an admirable, wealthy, kind, and genuinely impressive man. However, that being said, he is also portrayed as pretentious, deceptive, criminal, and most importantly to the plot, completely insatiable. Even though the novel’s narrator, Nick Carraway, heavily sympathizes with Gatsby, he has many character flaws that ultimately assure the failure of his “dream”, and even lead to his untimely demise.…
- 1042 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
In the novel “The Great Gatsby” written by F. Scott Fitzgerald, Daisy is described ieaders in various ways. In the beginning of the story Daisy is described “by far the most popular of all the young girls in Louisville”. This quote described by Fitzgerald tells the reader that Daisy holds a degree that she has immense beauty which has blinded many men. It means that she holds the popularity status because of the beauty she has. She is also described as “ a beautiful little fool.” This also indicates that Daisy is simply just beautiful just like an angel pure and white. And in which white could also means lack of morality.…
- 595 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Things are not always what they seem to be. We can be fooled by the mask `people wear everyday. As we get older we develop habits ad an opened mind to understand the difference between an illusion and reality. The use of illusion in the novel The Great Gatsby is used very effectively to show the nature of people. Through out the novel there are many examples where the appearance of the character is deferent than what’s inside.…
- 432 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby is Nick Carraway’s narrative of his experiences with Jay Gatsby, his wealthy and mysterious neighbor in West Egg, Long Island. Set in 1922, a turbulent time in American history, Nick is a veteran of World War One who moved from his native Midwest to New York City to sell bonds. This novel focuses on Nick’s intense admiration for Gatsby who befriends Nick and leads him through a strange new world. In their travels, Nick and Gatsby encounter minorities and although they deal with these “Others” in a civilized manner, they regard them with condescension. The passage that embodies their beliefs about these minorities appears after they pass underneath the…
- 1089 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
In The Great Gatsby, Jay Gatsby is portrayed as a naive and heartbroken man who will do anything to revive his relationship with the love of his life; even if it means reliving the past. Gatsby is a victim to temptation, manipulation, society and obsessive love. However it is because of this obsessive and incessant love that the rest of his problems unfold. He is so blinded and determined to gain the approval of his former lover, he allows himself to be made a mockery by society.…
- 952 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
It is every writer's aspiration to write a literary work as deep and profound as F. Scott Fitzgerald has in his masterpiece The Great Gatsby. The novel alludes to an innumerable variety of themes; encompassing all of the symbolism, metaphorical traits, and masterful writing that an English teacher's favorite should have. In a novel of this caliber it is expected that there are many deep and well-developed characters. This book has them in spades. From all of the wide variety of characters portrayed in this novel, Jay Gatsby is clearly the most vital and interesting; the course of events in The Great Gatsby are clearly centered around him.…
- 1940 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The Great Gatsby is a tragic American literature novel that represents the hopeful American dream. Fitzgerald throughout the entire book uses certain literary devices that add onto the sophistication of the novel. In the last passage of The Great Gatsby F. Scott Fitzgerald conveys Nick Caraway’s perspective and attitude towards Gatsby through imagery, symbolism and irony.…
- 636 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Jay Gatsby is like the American government – the weak, dishonest, inefficient government we believe to be the best in the world. His individual qualities are ones that, when examined objectively, should be frowned upon. Like the government, we can hate these qualities but love the whole. From the beginning of The Great Gatsby, he is protected by the most influential character; the narrator. Because our first impression of Gatsby is provided by a biased friend of his, our view is skewed in his favor, resulting in overcompensation for his obvious flaws. Gatsby is not a good man, we just want him to be. We so strongly want to believe that he is great and pure that we are willing to look past his inherent qualities, to construct in our minds a…
- 336 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Fitzgerald portrays through Jay Gatsby’s illusion that building a life on a fantasy will only lead to an utter disappointment. Gatsby’s blind faith in his ability to “repeat the past” that he’s been dwelling on for “five years” that tribute to his romantic and idealistic nature and a clear indication that he just might be a completely delusional fantasist. So far in his life, everything that he's fantasizing about when he first imagining himself as Jay Gatsby has come true. But in that transformation, Gatsby now feels like he has lost a fundamental piece of himself, and “wanted to recover” from the past. Gatsby is telling Nick about his love for Daisy and how it all begins. For some time Gatsby has been in love with Daisy, and when this moment…
- 275 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays