Preview

Case Review: Faragher vs. City of Boca Raton

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
299 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Case Review: Faragher vs. City of Boca Raton
Case review #1: Analysis of the Supreme Court of the United States case of Faragher V. City of Boca Raton

After quitting her job as a lifeguard, Beth Ann Faragher brought up a case against the City of Boca Raton because her immediate supervisors, Bill Terry and David Silverman, had created a “sexually hostile atmosphere” at work. Both men would repeatedly subject Faragher and other female lifeguards to “uninvited and offensive touching” accompanied by vulgar comments. While still employed, Faragher complained to Robert Gordon, another supervisor, who failed to report it to City officials.
The District Court held the City liable for the harassment carried by its supervisory employees, arguing that Terry and Silverman were acting as the City's “agents” when they committed the harassing acts. The Court of Appeals believed that Terry and Silverman’s relationship with the City did not enable the harassment and therefore could not be credited to the City. In addition, the Court of Appeals counter-argued that the City could not be held liable for failing to prevent their actions.
In the end, the District Courts favored Faragher. I completely agree with the outcome of the case. Sexual harassment impacts negatively on one’s work performance and advancement opportunities. This case demonstrates the importance of Human Resource Management. Employers, managers and supervisors must obtain proper training in employee rights and fair treatment at work to avoid lawsuits such as this one. An employer is held responsible for the actions of its supervisors therefore adequate training on acceptable and unacceptable behaviors is imperative. Managers ought to set an open door policy which would enable employees to discuss any trouble he or she may be facing in the workplace. This would assure that situations such as Faragher’s be settled within the workplace and not in

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    LOZMAN v. CITY OF RIVIERA BEACH, FLORIDA was a case brought upon the Supreme Court questioning what kind of floating structures fall under maritime jurisdiction. The Supreme Court’s ruling in this case was decided after an immense struggle of questions pertaining to an array of issues. These issues, among others, include the definition of the word “vessel” and the necessities needed for a watercraft to be practically capable of maritime transportation.…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The law at issue is Tort Liability for Municipal Corporation through the formation of a "special relationship between the municipality and the injured party" as outlined in Cuffy v. City of New York, 60 NY2d 225, 260. (Page 2 first full paragraph)…

    • 491 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Facts: Between 1985 and 1990 Beth Ann Faragher worked part time and during the summers as an ocean lifeguard for the Marine Safety Section of the Parks and Recreation Department of the City of Boca Raton, Florida. During this time, Faragher's immediate supervisors were Bill Terry, David Silverman, and Robert Gordan. Two years after resigning as a lifeguard in 1990, Beth Ann Faragher brought an action against the City of Boca Raton, Terry and Silverman alleging the supervisors had created a sexually hostile atmosphere by touching, remarking, and commenting. Faragher asserted that this conduct constituted discrimination in violation of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. In 1986 the City adopted a sexual harassment policy, however the policy did not reach the Marine Safety Section where Faragher worked. Faragher did not make any formal complaints against…

    • 454 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Florida v. Bostick was a felony drug trafficking case which set precedence to the legality of random police searches of passengers aboard public buses and trains pertaining to said passenger’s fourth amendment rights. Shortly after boarding a bus departing from Miami headed for Atlanta, Terrance Bostick was approached by members of the Broward County Sheriffs department acting as part of a drug interception task force and without particularly suspicion was questioned by officers. Broward county sheriff officers advised Mr. Bostick of his right to not consent to a search of his personal belongings and then asked his permission to carry out the search. Terrance Bostick granted sheriffs officers request by consenting to the search which revealed a felonious amount…

    • 609 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Mgmt 520 Week 5 Assignment

    • 1552 Words
    • 7 Pages

    3. Research and support your answer with two appellate level (including Supreme Court) U.S. cases that discuss sexual harassment and Title VII, and pertain to this case. Provide the case…

    • 1552 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sosebee filed her suit to be considered sexual harassment under Title VII. According to the EEOC, sexual harassment is a form of harassment to a person because of that person’s sex, unwelcome sexual advances or offensive remarks about a person’s sex. Sosebee filed under Title VII because she felt as though the reasons for punishments were because of her sex.…

    • 736 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The legal issue in the case of Davis v. The Board of County Commissioners of Doña Ana County involved acts of ill will, which could have been avoided. While employed as a detention officer at the Dona Ana County Detention Center, Joseph Herrera was accused of unsuitable sexual behavior with female prison inmates and of exchanging favors for sex acts. One of the reasons that the Mesilla Valley Hospital (MVH) had hired Herrera is because of the favorable recommendations that were given by Frank Steel and Al Mochen who were in supervisory roles. Steel had investigated the charges that were brought up against Herrera and advised him that he would be reprimanded. He advised Herrera that his performance had been “questionable” and “suspect” and advised Herrera that he would intend to seek disciplinary action. Herrera resigned rather than proceed with the scheduled hearing. Six days after recommending disciplinary action, Steel wrote a letter on Herrera’s behalf stating that he was an “….excellent employee and supervisor. I am confident that you would find Herrera to be an excellent employee” (Walsh, 2010, p. 149). Early December 1994, Herrera applied for employment with MVH and they contacted the Detention Center where Herrera worked for a reference. Mochen told MVH that,” Herrera was a good person and a hard worker whom he would definitely rehire” (Walsh, 2010, p. 149). The Plaintiff in this case sued the County stating that if the misinformation had not been given regarding Herrera’s character and work ethic that he would not have been hired and Plaintiff would not have been…

    • 271 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Constitutional questions presented in the case included; Does 42 U.S.C. Sec. 2000e-2 [Section 703] permit employers to refuse to act on the results of such tests for reasons of race? Does an employer violate 42 U.S.C. Sec. 2000-2 when it rejects the results of such tests because of the race of the successful candidates? Did the City have a lawful justification for its race-based action? Does 42 U.S.C. Sec. 2000e permit federal courts to relieve municipalities from having to comply with local laws that require strict compliance with race-blind merit selection procedures? Were city officials who tried to diversify a civil service department guilty of racial discrimination under the Equal Protection Clause or Title VII when they decide not to utilize written test results which favor one racial class over another, and whether an employer violates 42 U.S.C. § 2000E-2(1), which makes it illegal to adjust test scores or cut-off scores based on race, when he decides not to utilize test results because the successful candidates are all of one…

    • 1069 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Williamson V Houston

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The IAD investigation determined that there was no basis for Williamson’s allegations. Williamson sued the City of Houston under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act for hostile work environment sexual harassment and for retaliation against her for reporting the harassment. In a District Court, a jury found the city liable for both sexual harassment and for retaliation. Williamson was awarded back pay and compensatory damages, as well as court costs and attorney’s fees. On appeal to the Fifth Circuit, U.S. Court of Appeals, the City of Houston challenged the judgment on the grounds that it did not have notice of the harassment until April 1992 and that her notification to her supervisor should not have constituted notice to the city. The District Court’s ruling was affirmed by the Appeals Court. 3. Main Issue: Can a supervisor’s knowledge of harassing behavior be imputed to the city to show that the city knew, or should have known, of the harassing behavior and can therefore be held liable for failing to stop the behavior? 4. Court Deciding: United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit. 5. Decision: Summary judgment affirming the decision of the District…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the case of Ms. Darcy vs. Big Car Company, I agree with the judge’s decision. Ms. Darcy did prove that Clarence was in fact her supervisor; Mr. Clarence’s behavior did constitute as sexual harassment towards Ms. Darcy, and was put into a hostile work environment while around Mr. Clarence, his supervisors, and the treatment after making a complaint to HR.…

    • 348 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dixon should recommend that Clive Jenkins be fired for Miss handling the situation. Mrs. Dixon should make a company statement saying how strong the company is against racism and discrimination and issue a personal apology to Maalick. She should suggest that all employees at Trenton be trained in diversity and harassment in the workplace. She may also suggest that an investigation be launched to find out the culprits in this situation. Mrs. Dixon may choose to fire or reprimand guilty suspects in such cases in the private sector.…

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    You Decide Virginia Pollard

    • 2757 Words
    • 12 Pages

    You Decide Project Virginia Pollard worked as a cashier and clerk for Teddy Supplies, a family-owned chain of film production equipment supply stores in Pennsylvania and New Jersey. During a routine performance evaluation, Virginia's supervisor at Teddy's complained that she made too many personal phone calls when she worked in the West Orange store. The supervisor noted this on Virginia's annual review, and warned her to keep personal calls to a bare minimum while at work. Soon thereafter, Teddy transferred Pollard to guard film equipment in the main warehouse behind the storefront; Virginia couldn't make personal calls there, and her work became exemplary. Her performance evaluation three months after her transfer was "meeting expectations" with no negative comments. Virginia Pollard was the only woman working in the warehouse, and she was often the victim of pranks perpetrated by her six male colleagues. Her co-workers taped her drawers shut, locked her out of the guard shack she sat in to watch the inventory, filled the guard shack with trash, and backed a forklift up to the door and made it backfire in her ear. One day a Teddy delivery driver sat in Pollard's chair and, when she tried to push him out of it, he bent her over his lap and spanked her. Pollard's new supervisor, Steve King, rarely enforced Teddy's rules against smoking, horseplay, foul language, and sexual harassment, and often indulged in such behaviors himself. Teddy's had a written sexual harassment policy which included a method for employees to report sexual harassment - the method included filing a complaint with the direct supervisor unless the direct supervisor was the perpetrator. In that event, the employee was to file the complaint online at www.ReportTeddysafely.com. The form for reporting was a one page document. A copy of the policy which Virginia Pollard signed is located here. The policy specifically states, "In the event of a violation of this policy, employees should report the…

    • 2757 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Shepardizing Pa201

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages

    References: United States of America v. James L. Crowder, 543 F.2d 312 (D.C. Cir. 1976)…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tennessee V Garner

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Edward Garner’s father chose to sue not only the officer who shot and killed his son, but also the police department who employed him, the director of the police department, city, and even the mayor at the time (FindLaw, n.d.). The lawsuit was filed for violating Garner’s civil rights. The initial ruling denied Mr. Garner’s motion and found in favor of each of the defendants (FindLaw, n.d.). Later, Garner’s father appealed, and this time, the courts ruled in favor of him, both reversing and remanding the case (FindLaw, n.d.).…

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Business Law

    • 408 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I made researches on employers and employees rights; here we will have some knowledge in how to deal with the similar cases and we will know if this case is considered as ethical or unethical behavior.…

    • 408 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays