Preview

Causes Of The Second Punic War By Livy

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1297 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Causes Of The Second Punic War By Livy
Livy describes The Second Punic War as being Rome’s greatest conflict. Also known as Hannibal’s War, it is true, after reviewing the numbers lost on both sides and the length of the conflict that this statement by Livy is a true one. Why was the conflict sought out and who started the war? Livy is the greatest source on the topic. Based on the information that Livy provides, Hannibal’s destiny leads to his actions that caused The Second Punic War. Hannibal was Rome’s strongest enemy in its history. Hannibal would bring Rome to its knees before the war’s end.
Hannibal’s hatred for Rome began early in his life. At the age of 9, Hamilcar, Hannibal’s father, had made plans to start a new life for the Barca family in Spain. Before Hamilcar and his sons left, Hannibal was taken to an altar and made to swear that he would make Rome his enemy as soon as the
…show more content…
At the time Rome was a developed diplomatic entity that had connections across the known world. Due to this aspect Rome was an ally of both Carthage and Saguntum, so coming to the aid of one would mean going against the other, although Rome would have met the requirements of Fetial Law, that otherwise restricted war without reason. Rome was also restricted by the Ebro River Treaty that stated no Roman force could cross into southern Spain where Saguntum lied. Due to these complications, Rome instead of sending troops, sends an embassy to Saguntum and to Carthage to learn what has happened.
When the Roman embassy arrived in Carthage they were meet by hostility and given the message that the people of Saguntum initiated the war and that Rome should support its long-term allies, the Carthaginians, rather than the city that lied in the Carthaginian territory. It is true that Carthage and Rome had been allies long before this conflict, but Rome could not ignore the rash actions of Hannibal and demanded that he be given to the Romans and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Hannibal resumed his siege of Saguntum and conquered it after a terrible and costly siege. Hannibal, although he held preeminence in Carthage, still had to rely on his allies to keep him in power. A delegate was sent to Rome to answer a question regarding whether Hannibal had acted on his own or had the approval of the Carthaginian senate. The delegate, according to Livy, was the best orator in Carthage. He quickly quashed the argument regarding the border of Hasdrubal because the Carthaginian council had not been part of the talks. Furthermore, he argued that the Romans had broken the treaty after the First War by invading Sardinia; finally, he stated that Hannibal broke no treaty because the Saguntines did not have an alliance with Rome when the treaty between Hasdrubal formed. However, the Romans did not care about that, they wanted peace or war. The Carthaginians declared the Romans needed to choose, and the Romans chose the later. At this critical juncture, Carthage still held with Hannibal and wanted to help him.…

    • 296 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hannibal became a Carthaginian statesman and eventually grew in power. The Romans were scared that with Hannibal’s increase in power, he would lead another revolt against them. They made Hannibal give up his power and they exiled him. Hannibal traveled to many places including Tyrus, Ephesus, Crete, and Asia Minor. In Ephesus, King Antiochus, was at war with the Romans. Antiochus put Hannibal in control of one if his fleets, but he was defeated. After this, Antiochus was prepared to give Hannibal to the forces of Rome. Hannibal then fled to Crete, after a while, Hannibal was ready to go back to Asia Minor. King Prusias let Hannibal stay with him and Hannibal helped him in the war against Rome’s allies. Hannibal won many victories for Prusias, but the Romans let Hannibal keep helping him. They forced Prusias to hand Hannibal over. Hannibal was not ready to fall into the hands of the Romans. In 183 B.C. Hannibal ingested a deadly poison and…

    • 580 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    One general, wreaking havoc throughout the Roman lands was known as Hannibal Barca. Following in his father’s footsteps as a superior military general, he challenged Rome in battle every chance he could. After several attempts of coaxing Rome into battle he achieves a decent victory at the Battle of Trasimene in 217…

    • 1788 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although the relationship between Carthage and Rome at this point was cordial they decided to ally themselves with the Mamertines making themselves solely responsible for joining into a wider conflict with the Carthaginians. The acceptance of the mamertines into the Roman alliance forced the Syracusans and Carthaginians to co-operate in order to prevent Messana…

    • 1048 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Whereas Polybius feels this is the beginning of the war rather than an underlying cause. The Romans then prepared for war and sent out two main armies, one went to Sicily to invade Carthage under the command of the consul Sempronius Longus and the other was sent to Saguntum in the Iberian peninsula . They left only a small force in northern Italy just in case the Gauls took this as a chance to attack. What the Romans didn't expect Hannibal to do was to cross over the alps, because it was presumed impossible. Hannibal used this to his advantage and did exactly what the Romans thought to be impossible by cross the alps.…

    • 1559 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Critical THinking

    • 958 Words
    • 3 Pages

    During the Punic Wars, Rome made an effort to take over Italy(most importantly Sicily). Although they had a land power advantage, they realized they could not win without a navy. The Roman navy eventually defeated the Carthaginian navy, and won the first Punic War. Sicily became the first Roman province as a result. Eventually, Carthage retaliated, and with the help of general Hannibal, almost retook all of Rome's provinces. However, Rome fought back and won the Second Punic War. After the Battle of Zama(202 B.C.E), Carthage signed a peace treaty and lost Spain. Fifty years later, the third and final Punic War defeated Carthage once and for all (which was advocated by the politician Cato). This marked the beginning of the great Roman Republic and Empire.…

    • 958 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rome was afraid that Carthage would gain power and attack them while they were unprepared. As soon as Carthage heard that Rome was declaring war on them they sent General Hannibal out to invade Rome. Meanwhile Rome was gathering their army to send to Spain and Carthage. Rome sent most of their army overseas to stop the Carthaginians. They kept a couple of legions in Rome, but it was not nearly enough men to stop Hannibal.…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Second Punic War was a major turning point for Rome and its continued overseas expansion. The Romans drove the Carthaginians out of Spain, and then attacked Carthage itself. The Romans, led by Scipio Africanus, defeated the Carthaginians,…

    • 311 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Hannibal’s influence came as a result of his involvement in the Punic Wars. The question of whether the Second Punic War was of Hannibal’s making is debated greatly amongst modern historians but regardless, it is unlikely it would have taken the course it did without Hannibal as the predominant leader of the Carthaginian forces. Both Polybius and Livy described Hannibal making an oath to his father at the age of nine that he would never become a friend of Rome. With this and his defiance of Rome by attacking Saguntum as evidence, many modern scholars have attributed the outbreak of war in 218 directly to Hannibal. Bagnall for example, suggests that “Hannibal was bent on war and Rome was not loathe to accept the challenge” (Bagnall, 1999) whilst Caven writes, “Hannibal was an impetuous young man in whom the principal driving force was a burning desire for military glory” (Caven, 1992). This modern interpretation of ancient sources would suggest a key impact of Hannibal on his time: the outbreak of the Second Punic War. Whilst numerous historians refute this being the main cause of the war, with Polybius for example suggesting that it was the seizure of Corsica/Sardinia or Scullard suggesting that “The Second Punic War was largely of…

    • 1528 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is commonly believed that if you are in a position of power and authority you will always remain so. In his fictional short story, “The Most Dangerous Game,” Richard Connell’s characters, Sanger Rainsford and General Zaroff, had the same opinion. Like many individuals, neither men ever expected to be placed in a position of weakness. The deadly conflict that led to both Rainsford and Zaroff hunting and being hunted developed the theme, “strength and power are temporary,” because two once powerful men suddenly fell.…

    • 638 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Causes of 2nd Punic War

    • 2323 Words
    • 10 Pages

    The ancient sources written by Livy, Polybius Dio Cassius and Appian place a great deal of blame on Hannibal in starting the Second Punic War. Though some of the authors justify his actions to an extent, Hannibal’s invasion of Saguntum is pinpointed as the immediate cause of the Second Punic War. Dio Cassius and Appian find little sympathy in the motives behind Hannibal’s actions. As discussed by each of the writers, Hannibal’s father, after the loss of Sicily, harbored extreme hatred toward the Romans and instilled these feelings into Hannibal from a very young age. All four authors mention an oath taken by Hannibal at age nine in which he vowed revenge against the Romans for their unjust actions. Livy writes that this oath “bound Hannibal to prove himself, as soon as he could, an enemy to the Roman people” (Kagan 93-94, 1975). Sure enough, upon ascending to power, “as if Italy had been decreed to him as his province, and the war with Rome committed to him,” (Kagan 95, 1975) Hannibal…

    • 2323 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The 3rd Punic War

    • 1504 Words
    • 7 Pages

    A big turning point was the 3rd Punic War and the End of Carthage. In 509 BC Carthage and Rome signed a friendship treaty. But this friendship would not last forever. There was series of wars fought between Carthage and Rome known as the Punic Wars. Fought between 264-146 BC. Carthage was a city-state on the Greek model that had been founded by Phoenicians. It was the strongest city in the Western Mediterranean by the 3rd century and it became very wealth through trade. Carthaginian merchants went from one end of the Mediterranean to the other, the city's fleets were huge, and its army was one of the best in the ancient world. It was Carthage that pried loose the Greek hold on the western ports, and Carthaginian merchants traded as far north as England and down the West African coast. Unlike Rome, but like the Greeks, the Carthaginians also made extensive use of mercenaries. By the early 200s, Carthage had expanded across North Africa but also had control of the Belearic Islands, Sardinia, Corsica, and much of Sicily. She took the goods from these regions, and her own fertile hinterland, and shipped them to eastern ports. Once Rome had conquered most of Italy, it was only a matter of time before these two ambitious and powerful empires came face to face with one another. Rome was a civilization that grew out of a small agricultural community founded on the Italian Peninsula. As years past Rome began to expand its empire all through out the peninsula. Later on they conquer most of the Italian peninsula. The Romans were very skilled fighters. Their army was fierce. They were stronger on land than on water. They wanted to expand their empire…

    • 1504 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Both Rome and Carthage had to react to the declaration of war. During the First punic war, Rome sent a fleet to take over Sicily, which was the main focus in this war. Sadly for Rome, they failed to gain complete control of the city in 260 b.c.e. Four years later, the Romans set another naval fleet to the coast of Africa, while they were there, they set up a beachhead. Once, Carthage decided to surrender, the Romans asked of terms they could not afford and created an army that focused on calvary and war elephants.…

    • 1097 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    What was Lincoln supposed to say after the war? Fifty thousand people died in a total of three days, and what on earth is he supposed to say? That he is sorry, that he doesn’t know why everything happened the way that it happened? Lincoln gave a speech, it was very short, and a lot of people didn’t even listen but what he said was; that the living can honor the wartime dead not with a speech, but rather to continuing to fight for the idea’s they gave their lives for. Lincoln’s Gettysburg address was giving during the dedication ceremony for the soldiers that lost their lives in Gettysburg.…

    • 578 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Europeans, in the 18th century experienced changes in marriages and families, children, and food and medical care. Unlike the early years when the people married at young ages, more and more Europeans began to marry at much older ages and form families with an established household. In the early 18th century, children were often neglected; however, as time went on, parents began to express their love more openly for to their children. The diets and medical care of the Europeans improved through new sources of food and experiments. During the 18th century, Europe and its people were beginning to experience a change where people were marrying at a young age, ignoring the children, and improving in their nutrition and medical care.…

    • 1241 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays