From: Amber Vlaminck
Date: October 5, 2012
Subject: Hamilton County Judges
Introduction
In this analytical Report we will be analyzing and evaluating the performance of judges of Hamilton County, based on the amount of cases that were appealed. We will be counting appealed cases as mistakes that have been committed by the judges. In this report, will we go through and determine which judges in the county are making too many mistakes.
1. The probability of a case in Hamilton County being appealed and reversed in
Common Pleas Court
.04462
Domestic Relations Court .00403292
Municipal Court
.005556867
2. The probability of a case being appealed for each judge
Common Pleas Court
Judge Probability of case appealed
* Fred Cartolano .04511 * Thomas Crush .03529 * Patrick Dinkelacker .03497 * Timothy Hogan .03071 * Robert Kraft .04047 * William Mathews .04019 * William Morrissey .03991 * Norbert Nadel .04427 * Arthur Ney Jr. .03883 * Richard Niehaus .04085 * Thomas Nurre .04033 * John O'Connor .04344 * Robert Ruehlman .04524 * J. Howard Sundermann .06283 * Ann Marie Tracey .04043 * Ralph Winkler .02848
Domestic Relations Court
Judge Probability of case appealed
Penelope Cunningham .002565
Patrick Dinkelacker .003166
Deborah Gaines .005455
Ronald Panioto .002467
Municipal Court
Judge Probability of case appealed
Mike Allen .006993 Nadine Allen .004352 Timothy Black .005155
David Davis .005558
Leslie Isaiah Gaines .006626 Karla Grady .001142
Deidra Hair .001975
Dennis Helmick .003671
Timothy Hogan .005633
James Patrick Kenney .002144
Joseph Luebbers .005321
William Mallory .004591
Melba Marsh .004137 Beth