To give or not to give? This is the central question brought up in “The Singer Solution To World Poverty,” an article written by utilitarian philosopher, Peter Singer. Singer’s “solution” is that Americans need to take all of their money that is not devoted to the basic requirements for life and give it to organizations that are working on saving impoverished children across the globe. In his piece, he uses two imaginary situations to draw a conclusion about the moral position of Americans who do not donate their surplus money to save the poor. In the first, a woman nearly trades a boy’s life for a material possession, and in the second, a man allows a child to be hit by a train in order to save his car. Singer compares these two concocted characters to the unwilling, selfish Americans. He uses these horrific situations to influence his audience’s emotions and make them feel guilty for not donating their extra money; Singer’s accusations make his audience question their ethics and morals by equating them to child murderers. He even goes as far as to say that in order to live a “morally decent” life, we…
Ascher writes about a man, clearly homeless, who has approached a women and her baby on a street corner. After the woman at the street corner holds up a dollar bill to the homeless man, Ascher wonders "was it fear or compassion that motivated the gift?" (212). She later describes another event of gift giving with a different homeless man. He enters a French bread shop and stands in the doorway. He is dressed in worn out, stained clothing reeking of stale cigarettes and urine. Moments later the owner comes out from behind the counter and hands the man a bag and a cup. Ascher again wonders “what compels this woman to feed this man? Pity? Care? Compassion?” (212). As a society we would rather not be confronted by the ugliness of the reality some people face every day. "We do not wish to be reminded of the tentative state of our own well-being and sanity" (213) Ascher writes. By avoiding or removing this offender we have rid ourselves of the problem. When homeless people are viewed, the most common reaction to them is…
Emily Andrews argues in her essay “Why I Don’t Spare “Spare Change”” that it does more harm than good to give money to beggars on the street rather than giving to an organization such as United Way to help the needy, pointing out that “one cannot be certain that one is giving to a needy individual” and that by giving to a charitable organization “ones money is likely to be used wisely.”…
As a child I have always wanted to help other people.When I was 8 my parents decided to separate. At the time, my mother decided to move my sister and I away from Chicago. My mother packed our luggage and decided to move us to Detroit. That wasnt the only time we moved, we moved four times while I was growing up, all over the country and even to another continent. Eventually we had to leave our mom in Nigeria and my sister and I went to Detroit. When we got to Detroit my aunt didn't hesitate to make us feel comfortable. It was just something about it,I still didn't feel right. I called my mother one day crying to her and explaining how we didn't like being there. After talking to her, I felt that it was time to go back to Chicago. I called my dad, (knowing I haven’t spoke/seen him for many years) and explained to him the situation on how we felt uncomfortable in Detroit.…
The author of the picture essay “Call for Donations” was demonstrated by U4Others. This photo essay is basically about a guy who is standing outside making donations. Some people pass by and ignore him, and others stop and make a donation. The theme is about doing something you are passionate about and helping others. For example on page 11 , “How one chooses to answer that call depend on their personal experiences, their availability, their financial stability or even their passion for a cause.”The guy making donations is cheerful and happy because he has a passion for it. He’d frown at people passing, sticking their hand up and completely ignoring the sign for what the cause is. Others stopped and made a donation and his smile grew wider. The target audience is teenagers and adults. Most of us ignore signs and…
A couple of years ago I got kicked out of my house. Homeless, I had literally no where to stay or anyone to turn to. I had never opened up to anyone about my home life situation. Due to my upbringing in a predominantly rich, christian neighborhood I didn’t feel like anyone would understand my abusive parents or try to help. When I got kicked out I was sure that was the end of the line for me.…
Though there are many homeless people in New York as well , it was a different feeling because it was mostly children and they were living as if they just needed a hand. Some looked as if a vacuum had sucked up all the meat on their bodies, others looked as if they were straining to live their last day. As I walked passed them, I realized that tears began to fall from my eyes. It was so heartbreaking and painful watching them begging and living as if they were nothing. I gave a few some dollar bills and I talked to them just to show them that they aren't alone and that there are people out there who actually care and appreciate them. After seeing them, I told my cousin to take me to a place where I can just talk to kids my age or under and spend some time with them. Especially after the earthquake that happened on January 12, 2010, I felt as if it was right to give to people that were hurt and even kids who lost their parents and had nowhere to…
Homelessness is a topic I can relate to very well, coming from a poor background and living from paycheck to paycheck has caused me to be out of residences for over ten months.It was very hard to comprehend, living under a hotel with my two daughters taught me to seek out and learn what causes homelessness.Having a background of being a nurse it was hard for me to live without a roof over my head.My oldest daughter was pregnant at the time and had no adequate health care , so it was tough for us.I am petitioning for credit from Excelsior College toward my degree in the Health Sciences department.This class will meet one of my health sciences cores.I learned a lot from being homeless.Writing is my best subject and talking with several ladies over the years who was homeless with smaller children made me learn that being homeless is a social disease and sometimes not a mental disease.Associating homelessness with mental illness does tie in for some people.…
When I was four or five, my parents and I would prepare some meals and drive downtown and distribute them to the homeless. Most of the time I would sit in the car, peeking out as my parents handed out meals to the seemingly endless line of homeless people. Some of the more rough looking ones scared me, but I remember one gentleman wearing a suit, but a little grimy looking. I thought to myself, for once challenging my simple five year-old worldview,…
It does not matter what town or city you visit in this world, at some time in your life you have seen a homeless person. Whenever we see homeless, it may create a feeling of discomfort or may feel odd. We treat them as if they are invisible. Some may question how these people became homeless, and many will say something like “they probably were drug addicts or alcoholics and the state they are in is their own fault.” This stereotype may be true in some cases; however, the homeless people are people and also consist of families. They are no different than you or me. There is a reason for everything and certainly a reason people are faced with being homeless.…
In the morning I was walking with my dog, when suddenly I noticed an old man sitting on the street while people were walking on the road ignoring him. The weather seemed a bit chillier this morning and his skin was rugged and looked tough. His outfit looked dirty, especially on the jacket. I looked at that old man, but he didn’t look at me. I was thinking, why was he sitting on the street in the morning? “Why do you sit on the road?” I asked the man, He replied to me, “this is my place”. I was shocked. I thought he may be homeless, but I’ve found that living with the homeless is not so bad as long as we understand them. Most people ignore homeless, but I don’t why. He looked hungry and I asked him “Are you hungry? “He said “YES” so I went to Country Fair to get him some pizza and a drink. I gave it to him, and he told me, “I don’t how to say thank you” I felt so bad for him. I gave him a few dollars, and I told him that…
One day, I was going to school, but kept forgetting my stuff for school so went back to my home and got my stuff. When I got out I saw 8 homeless kittens alone in the morning and I saw someone there, too. I know that the women that were there was the owner of the 8 homeless kittens and didn't have a home or a shelter to live in. She went to me and wanted me to take care of the 8 homeless kittens so I did take care of the of the kittens. I brought food to the kittens outside scenes I didn't have the stuff to take care of the…
I remember how harshly I judged a man without knowing his story and after learning it; I have never felt more ashamed. I passed him on my way to school, I always walked the same route and he always sat on the same bench in the park. He was homeless, middle-aged and dirty. I would give him a careful, quick glance and noticed that he didn’t have much, just a couple of plastic bags filled with clothes and a blanket. He never bothered me and I never felt that I wanted to talk to him. I assumed in my head he was homeless, because he might have been an alcoholic or a lazy bum. One day, walking the same old road to my school, the bench that he always sat on- was empty. The following day it was still empty and it stayed that way for weeks. I started to wonder where this man went and felt weird how a stranger that at first made me feel somehow uncomfortable, now made me feel even more uneasy and just because he was not around. The man, this dirty, homeless man- his name was Tadeusz. He was homeless because he lost his job. He was homeless because he had to sell his house. He had no place to go because his eight-year old daughter died of cancer and his wife left him. I know all of this because Tadeusz died and that put him on the front cover of my local newspaper. After reading his story I felt ashamed for having judged him so harshly without knowing his story. It was bad enough that I never stopped to ask him if he needed help or offered him something to eat, but worse than that, I looked down on him. It didn’t occur to me that there was a man inside of this “homeless” exterior; a person with dreams, memories and hopes. I hope to live the rest of my life avoiding such ill-considered judgments.…
Many different circumstances can be attributed to my current state homelessness. I grew up in a broken home which consisted of my father not being present in my life and my mother who was disturbingly addicted to crack cocaine. My mother’s addiction left me as well as my seven brothers and sisters dirt poor. In order to feed ourselves we would have to go out and steal food from local stores and rob people. I got caught robbing one day and I was sent to jail. I got out a few months later and went to my former home in the projects and to my surprise my family had moved away. From that day on I have been homeless and living on the streets.…
In the book, The Inseparability of Ethics and Politics: Rethinking the Third in Emmanuel Levinas by Madeleine Fagan, I was struck by the line “For Levinas, charity and justice cannot be separated,” on the first paragraph, page 18 on the book. Levinas believes that charity and justice goes along together. But what disturbs him is the thought that some structures might prioritize charity over justice. At first I was confused and couldn’t think of the relation between charity and justice. Charity, from the Webster Dictionary, is the voluntary giving of help, and justice is the quality of being fair and reasonable.…