Preview

Christine Stansell

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
465 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Christine Stansell
Examining Class and Gender in New York City
The article “Women, Children, and the Uses of the Streets: Class and Gender Conflict in New York City, 1850-1860,” Christine Stansell argues that during the nineteenth century the streets of New York were grounds of different outlooks toward children. The kids who wandered the city streets such as playing, huckstering, and committing theft or homeless, were an indication of the typical middle class moral failure due to their parents. Moralists often saw the home as a sanctified area that protected children from the harm of society. Parents whom worked, often their children worked too and did not receive the family support that social reformers claimed were essential to their spiritual and moral improvement. In New York City, the success of these reformers in safeguarding public areas indicated both the control of the middle class and the idea of women being encouraging role models in the home.
The article began with a children aid service worker whom found two children in search of wood to return to their mom to burn in order to stay warm. The article was dated back to the 1850-1860s when the city was occupied by the poor citizens and individuals whose
…show more content…
She believes that the children whom were on the street were expected to make a living the best way they could. Not only did reformers see children as victims of a corrupt environment, but also as the ones adding to the problem. The children of this population spent majority of their time outside of the home, mainly in the streets. The reformers did not see this as an improvement; they were more so disturbed by them being in the public environment unsupervised. The streets gave children freedom and independence with no boundaries. The middle class thought just as the woman’s domain was in the home, the children should be there too. Middle class reformers saw these children whom were left in the streets as a form of

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Swift A Modest Proposal KRAY

    • 5444 Words
    • 14 Pages

    It is a melancholy object to those, who walk through this great town, or travel in the country, when they see the streets, the roads and cabbin-doors crowded with beggars of the female sex, followed by three, four, or six children, all in rags, and importuning every passenger for an alms. These mothers instead of being able to work for their honest livelihood, are forced to employ all their time in stroling to beg sustenance for their helpless infants who, as they grow up, either turn thieves for want of work, or leave their dear native…

    • 5444 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In the book, Cheap Amusements: Working Women and Leisure in Turn-of-the-Century New York, Piess takes the reader on the journey of trials and tribulations in working-class women’s lives in the turn of the century. Going in depth of the unfair familial roles and societal female disparities, all the way to what women liked to wear and do for leisure, Piess allows the reader to step into a time machine and gives them a first-class look into what a woman’s daily life was like in late 1800’s and early 1900’s. By using ‘expert’ sources and ‘investigators’, Piess succeeds in her goal by honing in on a specific time and topic which allowed the reader to feel as if they were reading an in-depth history textbook on the matter, but failed at providing deeper substance and backbone through concrete details.…

    • 1679 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The welfare state has done a disservice to women as it perpetuates the concept of the “social exile” that Hegel believed “women…are natural social exiles” and need incorporation through other means. Pateman summarized Hegel’s theory as on that can be explained by the exploitative nature of capitalism. For Hegel, women are not made citizens in the same manner as men, but through traditional/conventional means through the family. For women, their historical citizenship status encompassed their roles as mothers and wives in the family structure in a subservient position, then how can Pateman argued the opposite? Her compelling response to this question lies in employment and…

    • 1373 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Much of the hardship women faced was because of the expectations set for them by men and failing to meet those expectations due to problems also caused by men. Susan W. Fitzgerald puts it best in her 1908 essay; Women in The Home. In this piece Fitzgerald puts forward the common furtstaion of the urban women as they were expected to clean the house, keep the children healthy, fed them, clothe them, and develop their sense of morraily. But in an urban society as America had become at this time women faced difficulty with these expectation male society had placed on them because the filth of cities was impossible to clean up, because in the ghetto markets clean food was hard to find, because the air and water were full of diseases, and because the city was full of evil. All of these issues made it impossible to meet expectations set by men as without the iurgh to vote women didn't even have a voice in decisions they affect them more than anyone. Both Polachek and her mother face this hardship living in Chicago after becoming the sole parent of a family and having to sustain that family on the lower wages paid to women for brutal work. Polachek event illustrates her frustration with the problems of the city as a teen ager with her essay The Ghetto Market specifically in her second paragraph “Not until the city takes the matter in hand and orders all vegetables, meat and fish to be sold only in adequate and sanitary rooms will this condition be entirely overcome” This was written by Polacheck after seeing the filthy conditions of chicago markets and seeing many of her peers and neighbors fall ill or even…

    • 1534 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Her main attention was focused on the servants, the house, and anything that had an appearance that could be judged. She looked after how the house was run and the detail of decoration in the house, the relationship with the servants, and lastly her children. Her relationship with her children was different; they did not see each other frequently throughout the day. The decisions the mother made reflected how the family was viewed by the outside world and the family’s appearance to society (Hyams 47-48). Unlike the father, the mother’s role was affected by the industrial revolution. Mothers of that day would have always stayed at home, but as the industrial revolution came in, it brought about change for a mother. The industrial revolution offered women opportunity. The women and mothers of that day now had a choice and freedom to have a job. Women during the industrial revolution found themselves in factories working and providing for their families. An aristocratic mother would not have worked in a factory, but an industrializing family’s mother would have worked in a factory (Kishlansky, Stearns, Greaves, and et al…

    • 2045 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Christine Herbes-Sommers

    • 269 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In the social constructive theory, theorists believe that there is no biological connection that links a human’s race to their biological makeup or basis. This theory however, suggests that race is rather constructed by societies, and thus race does not account for the numerous patterns of genetic variation. From the film “The Power of an Illusion,” Christine Herbes-Sommers goes on to explain, “There is as much diversity and genetic difference within any racial group as there are between people of different racial groups.” (Herbes-Sommers 2003).…

    • 269 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    married and have children at a young age, run the household and look after the children on a day to day basis. As she was brought up in this way, Deborah feels that she has had to live up to the family expectations. In relation to Marx’s conflict theory, at the age of 37 Deborah categorises under the feminism theory as gender inequality is one form of social inequality that she faces. (ref conflict theory)…

    • 899 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Colonial Era Women

    • 1812 Words
    • 8 Pages

    They discuss the awful lifestyle girls are born into, how women’s health was not a priority, especially during childbirth, and even how being a slave was harder for women than for men. This is all found in the article, “The Myth of the Golden Age”, by Norton. Norton talks about chores that were made for women and were time consuming and difficult. One of these chores were making clothes by spinning cloth. It was time consuming and hard, considering it demanded more technical skill and bulky loom, and young girls would usually learn early on to relieve their mothers of the chore. Women were forced to do the household chores and care for the children, and when daughters were old enough they would help their mothers. These young girls were not given a choice, they started to learn these chores early on because they were expected to continue the work when they had a family of their own. Young boys still were expected to help their fathers with hard labor, but they had many more choices than girls did. Women were expected to have a lot of children because the more kin, the more working hands you had around the house. Women were debilitated from constantly having to go through childbirth. Most women were pregnant or nursing a baby during their mature years. They had poor health, and were exhausted from having to care for all the children and doing all the housework. Present day, we have maternal leave and medicine that helps a woman recover from childbirth, but in the colonial era no one cared as much. Having a child was painful and having to care for a newborn while making sure all the household labor is finished was exhausting. As you can imagine, having to bare children while being a slave was extra excruciating. Slave women were pretty much forced to have as many children as possible from their masters, since any child born from a slave women was now a slave.…

    • 1812 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Orphan Trains

    • 2023 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Early on in American History, children who were left by their families were usually left to be cared for by their relatives or neighbors. There were very few services at the time to help struggling families in need, or to even rescue children. It was in the late 1800’s and even as late as the 1900’s where laws advocating children’s rights were being enacted. The only places where children could be left at the time were Orphanages and most were extremely overcrowded and uncomfortable. Children were not given much time or attention or even food. Adoption was not yet universally popular at the time, and there were not many laws protecting the rights of children. Often times in a lower to middle class household a family relied on its children to work in order to make ends meet. For many families it was a struggle but manageable, however, for others it was just too much and this lead to many children being left on the streets of major cities, like New York and Manhattan.…

    • 2023 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the Hemlers’ time, a father performing any child care duties would be considered preposterous let alone managing children while the wife is at work. When the nurse comes into the same room as Torvald with the children, he motions for Mrs. Linde to leave saying exclaiming, “…the place will only be bearable for a mother now” (1.303-1.305). The final reason why the Hemlers’ relationship would not compare to today’s morals is how they view women’s independence. Women today are at one of their heights of independence; working full-time, not having kids, not marrying and living carefree despite misogynistic ideals. This is heavily contrasted to the circumstances women of the 1800s were subject to where Mrs. Linde, “had to provide for [her] two younger brothers” (1.136-37) and she did not think she was “justified in refusing” (1.137) her husband’s offer for marriage. Similarly, Nora was conflicted because had to care for her children, but she could not bear it any longer and left Torvald in the end. In conclusion, power imbalance, the lack of men’s household responsibility and absence of women’s independence demonstrate the disconnect between then and today’s…

    • 374 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Stephen Crane’s Maggie: A Girl of the Streets is set in the 1890’s where there were ideologies about how women should live; however, Maggie did not live up to these expectations. The idea of a perfect woman means they would have all four of the pillars intact: purity, piety, submissiveness, and domesticity. However, Maggie was not representative of any of the pillars and this was blamed on her domicile residing in the slum area of New York. The slums during this time were depicted as dirty and were thought to further contaminate the city if left to their own. However, Brace, Talmage, and Flower utilize language of cleanliness, religion, and purity to convey the prevalent issues in the slums to the middle and upper class to solicit their help without implying their own guilt. Specifically, this was directed at the upper and middle class as these people had money and jobs to offer those in the slums.…

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In the first portion of the article she describes her life with her husband before starting a family, then moves on to tell us [avoid “you,” “us,” “we,” etc.] about the burdens of being a full time homemaker. She describes the stereo typical life in that time period where the husband often worked late and spent little time at home, while she was at home taking care of every day chores as well as the taking care of the children. When her children had become older, she stated that she was, “restricted to the company of demanding preschoolers and to the four walls of an apartment”.…

    • 1191 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Rich believes that women endured the unfairness and inequality of life compared to men because they were treated as an aspect of possession. Compared to men Rich interprets the role of women; Rich believes, “… woman has been a luxury for man… as a comforter, nurse, cook, bearer of his seed…” (Rich 8). She declares how the roles between male and female were opposite of each other, and how women had no choice but to fulfill these tasks by the men who told them what to do because the male’s role was supposed to be the bread winners and hard workers of the family. Women couldn’t do what males did, not because they didn’t want to but mostly because they weren’t allowed to, due to the prejudiced society. In the society she lived in there were many women who tried to be independent in order to be free from their dominant spouses.…

    • 1646 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    How to tame a wild tongue

    • 420 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In the 9th paragraph she says “What would you do differently, you upon your beanstalk looking at scenes of all peoples at all times in all places? When you climb down, would you dance any less to the music you love, knowing that your music has to be provisional as a bug? …If you descend the long rope-ladders back to your people and time in fabric, if you tell them what you have seen even if no one cares to listen…” What I take from this that she thinks that people in control are advertising things that in the end really won’t matter to the everyday people. They still have to make living and provide for their family’s doing these physical demanding jobs. As she states “Somebody still has to make jugs and shoes, to turn the soil, fish.”…

    • 420 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Overcrowding in cities

    • 707 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Whatever, then, relates to the housing of people in cities becomes of great importance to the whole country. It should be understood that there are now two distinct kind of cities in the Union, as respects the habitations of the industrial classes - one represented by New-York and Boston, where the working people are crowded into large tenement-houses, and the other, of which Philadelphia, Buffalo and Detroit are examples, where the working man has the inestimable blessing of his own house, hold in fee.. The tenement-house system breeds poverty, disease and vice. It tends steadily to degrade and therefore to impoverish the working classes. Under it, the laborer knows nothing of the best word in the language, the meaning of "home". His children grow up amid throngs of vicious or ill-controlled youth. His rooms are poisoned by fetid gases, and his family are crowded beyond all limits of decency or health. He has no garden of field in which he can work at odd hours and which he can call his own. While the rural laborer plants potatoes or prunes his vines after the day's work, the tenant of the city tenement must go to the liquor-shop for a change from the close room, or to find society. He and his family, living for years in this manner, lose all the healthful knowledge of nature which generations of their forefathers had possessed; they have little habit of economy or of care for property; they become used to squalor, dirt, and overcrowding.…

    • 707 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays