I cringed when I look at the statistics Kozol provided; this claim of segregation becomes an eye-opener to tax payers and the people who elected our government officials. Based on the data he provided, the vast “majority of enrollment in most of the public schools in our major cities is black or Hispanic: 79% in Chicago, 94% in Washington, D.C., 82% in Saint Louis, 96% in Detroit, 84% in Los Angeles, up to 95% in New York”, to name a few(Colombo 220). One would think that maybe this is happening in Alabama or Mississippi but not in New York, Illinois, Michigan and Los Angeles. It is more discouraging to hear from black teachers that if you happen to be in a major city and would like to see the segregation in action, just look for a school named after Martin Luther King Jr. or Rosa Parks. And on top of that according to Kozol’s research, Caucasian children living in the public school districts that enroll blacks and Hispanics as majority will often opt-out of attending that particular school and instead enroll in a predominately white school.
Kozol also argued that students of the minority basically are limited in what they can achieve from a very young age because of financial status. He states that wealthy individuals are able to educate their toddlers in very extensive programs before they even enter kindergarten. By the time the students are expected to take “high-stakes tests” in 3rd grade, these wealthy students have had far more education than minority students who are expected to take the same standard exams. He is right on target when he mentioned that money makes the difference of whether or not a parent can afford to send their child to a private school that costs $30,000 a year, or an inner city urban public school down the street. But the shortage of money does not come only to the poor families. It is also very true for poor state and local governments. Kozol augmented this claim by describing the differences in urban and inner-city school conditions and how money can buy clean bathrooms, nice well-equipped libraries and hire art teachers. Each factor that he describes seems to further indicate that racial segregation is present. The differences in teacher salaries between city schools and the suburban “white” schools plays another important role in Kozol’s claim. The more money the teacher gets paid, the greater the spending allowance per student, which unintentionally places the white student a step ahead and creates yet another barrier between the different student populations. According to Kozol during his interview with Dennis Wholey on This Is America show which aired in 2005, he visited “60 schools covered by 30 districts spanning 11 states over the last five years” (Wholey). During his school visits, he documented detailed description of the school, the classroom, and the law-and how it trapped inner-city students into the same, poverty-stricken life they were born into. Through segregation and poverty, these poor students tackle a school system designed to deny them an education, a sense of well-being, and hope for a brighter future. A school system mandated and supported by the government who blames its own failures to its schools.
. During his visits, he sees obvious patterns that strengthen his claim why predominantly minority schools always seem to let their students down. One thing that is evident in all the schools he visits is that he “simply never sees white children” (Colombo 222). Even though the presence of white children does not necessarily indicate the presence of experienced teachers and useful resources at a school, letting minority children go to schools where all their classmates are not black and brown would reduce the damage done to them. He also visited many minority schools that were forced by the government to take in so many students that, in order to school them all, they have to improvise their class hours and venues. He also mentioned classrooms that based on a drill-based program using a Skinnerian curriculum where one teacher quoted “I can do this with my dog” (Colombo 230). This is so unfair. How can these inner city minority schools implement drill-based programs, when other suburban wealthier schools are focusing on hands-on, engaging curriculums?
Students at the high school level are being limited in what they can achieve as well. For example, Kozol supports this argument by talking to students who want to take certain classes, but are instead forced to take other classes that will benefit the businesses and factories who are looking for cheap labor in their community who already employs their parents. This is sending the wrong message to high school students that society expects them to only have certain careers, and limited choices regarding their own future. What did our government leaders do in response to these inequalities? Rather than using the power of the federal government to fix the funding or infrastructure between wealthier and more impoverished districts, the government has implemented the “No Child Left Behind Law, which requires students to take many standardized tests than before, and reduces resources to schools whose students perform poorly” (Wholey). I agree with him that constant testing would not make a student smart. Especially if that is the measurement in order to be advanced to the next grade. Preparation at an earlier age is what makes them successful in school.
Overall, his hard work provides more than enough evidence to that fact that minority children have been treated unfairly. Teachers have failed to properly educate them. Schools and our government education department have failed to provide adequate resources and create an environment in which they can succeed.
As Kozol goes on and on to prove his point by working closely with the schools, students, and teachers, he did not offer any solutions to this problem. However, his work is key part of a national conversation that has driven politicians to take notice of the current education system. Arguments such as this one surely were a driving force in President Obama 's signing of the White House’s initiative on Education Excellence for African Americans on July 26, 2012. My question is, why just African Americans? What about the Latinos and Asians? Is this just another reelection propaganda or do we really need more than a decade to fix the color of education in America?
Works Cited
Colombo, Gary. Rereading America: Cultural Context for Critical Thinking and Writing. Eighth Ed. New York: Bedford/St. Martin’s, 2007. Print
Wholey, Dennis. This is America with Dennis Wholey. Thisisamerica.net, 2005 Web. 05 Sep 2012.
Cited: Colombo, Gary. Rereading America: Cultural Context for Critical Thinking and Writing. Eighth Ed. New York: Bedford/St. Martin’s, 2007. Print Wholey, Dennis. This is America with Dennis Wholey. Thisisamerica.net, 2005 Web. 05 Sep 2012.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Jonathan Kozol, in his essay Still Separate, Still Unequal, is proposing that many Americans that live far from major cities are under the impression that racial isolation in urban public schools has steadily diminished in more recent years. But truth be told, according to Kozol thousands of schools around the country that had been integrated either voluntarily or by forced o to f law have since been rapidly resegregating. According to statistics, Kozol found that between 85 to 95 percent of students enrolled in public schools in big cities like Chicago, Washington, St. Louis and New York are black and Hispanic while only less than 10 percent are white. Kozol also express how the decay and disrepair one sees in ghetto schools "would not happen…
- 286 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Jonathan Kozol use logic and many statics to prove segregation is still relevant in our school systems now after all these years. Kozol noticed segregation in schools where they lacked funds and importance of education. For an example one of the student sent a letter and she wrote “we do not have the things you have. You have clean things. We do not. You have a clean bathroom. We do not have that....”.(book #4) The student was from a student in the Bronx who just wanted better. Jonathan Kozol visited many schools to find out that schools where they are named after African American has the highest percent of Blacks and Hispanics and weren’t as fortunate and supported/funded as the Caucasian…
- 241 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
Eaton takes her time illustrating how inner-city students, many from single-parent families of the working poor and from crowded, broken-down neighborhoods, require more support than their suburban counterparts in generously funded schools. Spend a day or a week or a year with many of the students in Room E4, as she did, and the urgent need for improved educational equity becomes clear. Eaton supplements her portrait with accounts of the courtroom progress of Sheff v. O'Neil, a lawsuit striving to make legally clear the "blameless" segregation created by the convergence of zoning regulations, municipal politics, discriminatory housing and banking policies and the creation of suburbs. She demonstrates that de jure segregation has been replaced by de facto segregation. There are few winners in this story, and it's made clear that the problems of our troubled public schools have no easy or quick solution.…
- 576 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Jonathan Kozol illustrates a grim reality about the unequal attention given to urban and suburban schools. The legendary Supreme Court case Brown v Board of Education ended segregation in public schools in America because the Court determined that “separate but equal is inherently unequal.” Over a half century after that landmark case, Kozol shows everyone involved in the education system that public schools are still separate and, therefore, still unequal. Suburban schools, which are primarily made up of white students, are given a far superior education than urban schools, which are primarily made up of Hispanics and African Americans. In “Still Separate and Still Unequal”, Kozol, through logos, pathos, and vivid imagery, effectively reveals to people that, even though the law prohibits discrimination in public schools, several American schools are still segregated and treated differently in reality.…
- 512 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
For The Shame of the Nation, Kozol constructed 5 years worth of preliminary research upon writing his book. He visited 60 schools in 30 different districts, and 11 various states. What he found proves to be disappointing. Schools today are in worse conditions than they were in the desegregation era. Schools where there are predominantly blacks and Hispanics are not properly funded and overcrowded. Standardized tests are set for students to fail, due to lack of resources in these schools.…
- 794 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In Tatum’s article the issue addressed is the self-separation of blacks and minorities and what can be done to stop the act. Kozol’s article on the other hand focused on the separation of those students in a middle class and poor households in his article he discussed the issue of these students being separated and in some instances instead of pushed to reach a higher level of education are being taught to get ready for the work force right after high school not having a chance on the college level. Similarities In both articles occur when Kozol and Tatum talk about racial segregation in these schools and how the parent’s educators and political powers do nothing to stop these acts for happening. (pg.…
- 634 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Cited: Colombo, Gary, Robert Cullen, and Bonnie Lisle. Rereading America: Cultural Contexts for Critical Thinking and Writing. Boston: Bedford/St. Martin’s, 2013. Print.…
- 1002 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
I am reviewing Jonathan Kozol’s auto-biography, Death at an Early Age. This piece of literature provides the reader with an in-depth, personable account of schools of the 1960’s and the corruption that had flourished. Throughout this piece Kozol told of grim stories about public schools throughout Boston, Massachusetts; many of which would be incredibly disturbing. I believe Kozol’s thesis was the following: although legal segregation had been abolished in 1954, (Brown v Board) socio-economic segregation was still in full effect over ten years later. Or in other words, even though segregation had come to an end, African Americans were still denied fundamental rights, including an education.…
- 1005 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays -
In his book, “The Shame of the Nation”, Jonathan Kozol outlines core inequalities in the American educational system. According to Kozol although great steps were made in the 1960s and 1970s to integrate schools, by the end of the 1980s schools had begun to re-segregate. In inner cities such as Chicago, eighty-seven percent of children enrolled in public schools were either black or Hispanic, and only ten percent were white (page#). It seems that there are many different factors contributing to the re-segregating of schools.…
- 1083 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
In the article “Still Separate, Still Unequal” written by Jonathan Kozol, Kozol expose and expresses his concern of unequal treatment in the schools according to whether they are in an urban or suburban area. Using a series of reasoning and logic techniques, he then proves his argument that because of the segregation in schools, minorities are not receiving the same education and opportunities as predominantly white schools. Kozol uses statistic, one on one interviews with students and personal reflections to bring insight to the reader, and why he is asking for a change for equal opportunity.…
- 868 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
“Still Separate, Still Unequal”, written by Jonathan Kozol, describes the reality of urban public schools and the isolation and segregation the students there face today. Jonathan Kozol illustrates the grim reality of the inequality that African American and Hispanic children face within todays public education system. In this essay, Kozol shows the reader, with alarming statistics and percentages, just how segregated Americas urban schools have become. He also brings light to the fact that suburban schools, with predominantly white students, are given far better funding and a much higher quality education, than the poverty stricken schools of the urban neighborhoods.…
- 1248 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Both authors talk about race and to some extent segregation in the education system in the United States. The focus of Tatum’s essay is within schools looking at the student population and how some clicks are formed around race. Kozol’s main…
- 1200 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Are schools really meant to be separate African American and Caucasian? The author, Sarah Carr who discusses the issue in, In Southern Towns Segregation Towns Segregation academies Are still going strong or is that true? Regardless of the history Indianola struggles to make its way educationally and economically in the 21st century. This serves as a wake up call of how schools can be separated and unequal to each other . It could divide a community, also split a place entirely.…
- 266 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
How does/did race effect American education? Well Integration brought more of a positive effect while segregation brought more of a negative effect to education. Or should I say it brought more of a negative effect to all if not most of the blacks education. Now you may be wondering How? Well, things were not equal and therefor black students didn’t have it all that fair because the white students had more than the blacks did. Whether it was neighborhoods, schools, or teachers.…
- 979 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Butler, Paul, Racially Based Jury Nullification: Black Power in the Criminal Justice System, 105 Yale…
- 1510 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays