2/20/15
Comparative Criminal Justice
Dr. Kilgallon
Article Summary The article I chose to summarize is entitled, “Columbia Court Keep Limits on Same Sex Adoption”. On Wednesday, Columbia’s constitutional court ruled to keep the current limits on same-sex adoption. The current limit states that the adoption by a same-sex couple is legal only if the child to be adopted is the offspring of one of the partners. This decision came almost two years after the Congress of the county voted against allowing gay marriages. Discussions of whether to lift the current restrictions had dominated social media. The Colombian media said the ruling showed great wisdom, arguing that it took the middle road between allowing same-sex couples to freely adopt children and straight up banning same-sex adoption. Lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender groups expressed their disappointment saying the ruling did not go far enough. Other supporters of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender rights, such as Senator Armando Benedetti, call the judges cowards.
The president of Colombia's Conference of Bishops, the Right Reverend Monsignor Luis Augusto Castro Quiroga, said he would continue fighting for "the right of children to have a father and a mother". He said, "Two mums don't make a dad".
The decision by the court does not prevent Congress from legislating on the issue in the future. In addition, the court suggested Congress should debate the "legislative vacuum" lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender couples face in Colombia. http://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-31532609
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Is another form of structural configuration better suited to multiproduct, multiservice companies? I do not believe so. As stated on our textbook, “Organizations exist for a purpose.” Further, their design considerations “seek to create organizations that are both efficient and effective” (Baack, Minnick, & Reilly, 2014)With multiproduct, multiservice companies there are many more moving parts, meaning more room for error. All the moving parts must work together, as parts of an engine. A design flaw in one division could affect other divisions, and eventually the entire company. Organizational design must be carefully thought out and planned before executed. Even then, things should be carefully monitored to work out any kinks.…
- 487 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The House Bill 2 is a direct and a distinctive response from the legislature to Charlotte’s widening of the previous rights to the transgendered, lesbian, and gay. In this case, when the government deprives a particular minority group’s rights that are enjoyed by other citizens, the government will be considered to be violating the rights of the minority people in the society. Based, the case, the bill is violating the rights of the minority people in the city. Therefore, the government should reconsider amending the group to avoid discrimination of a single group of people in the…
- 947 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In Maureen Dowd’s opinion column entitled “Happily Never After?” she expresses doubt in the Supreme Courts ability to rule in a way that she feels is fair to the Gay and Lesbian community. In her view the Supreme Court Justices are out of touch with society and they will fail to provide equality for gay couples who are only seeking equal respect in the law; to be treated just like other Americans and have the legal right to marry in their “pursuit of happiness.”…
- 980 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
This case is a landmark in the identification of the rights of homosexuals and homosexual couples. The rights of homosexuals have always been denied and restricted on many accounts, but in recent times have already made the steps to reject DOMA. Since DOMA sates that marriage is an agreement between a man and a women, it gives no innate right to homosexual unions in federal law. By looking at history we can easily define marriage, its evolution in the eyes of state and federal law and prove that…
- 1068 Words
- 3 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Same sex marriage legalization has been a continue argument for years. It was admitted as legal by California government in June 2008, but it was halted due to the passage of Proposition 8. There is no wonder why people take Proposition 8 as hate towards LGBTI community. Thus, Morse wrote a article in National Review Online to appeal more supporter, and to argue there is no hate toward LGBTI community from Proposition 8. Her rhetorical choices help to increase the probability that there are more readers will support her argument.…
- 380 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Though many know of the court case, not all people know the history of it. The part that many know is that the people were gay, lesbian, and so on, and most people also know that they were fighting for the right to marry. What too many people do not know is that even though court Justices were against it, the majority did not care since it did not affect them. Justice Scalia said the following in his statement, “The substance of today’s decree is not of immense personal importance to me.” Since in many states, previous to the law passing, barely anyone who was same-sex could marry their spouse.Though this privilege was granted to opposite-sex spouses, along with insured plans, medical plans, and many other privileges. When the law was passed, same-sex couples would have the same privileges. “Insured plans in every state will require to offer coverage to same-sex spouses to the extent such plans cover opposite-sex…
- 559 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The freedom to marry is a fundamental right, it's an expression of emotional support and public commitment. The plantiffs, the gay and lesbian communiuty, argue that they deserve the "fundamental" right to marry their partner. The state of California wants to keep sexual activity withing marriages and because of Prop 8, same sex couples are permitted to engage in any sexual activity. However, same sex couples are allowed to adopt children. Plantiffs want to have the state recognize their relationships. The Equal Protection Law of the fourtheenth ammendment states that "no state deny any person within its jurisdiction." Evidence at the trial shows that marriage in the US traditionally…
- 893 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Though traditionally the courts of the United States have abided by the conditions of the constrained court, the court was being quite instrumental in the advancement of marriage for same sex couples. With the exception of the Supreme court case Bowers v. Hardwick in 1986, there had been a general trend of the courts to serve as important implementers of social change for same sex marriage. Yet, the courts have not been able to figuratively strike the mortal blow to issue. Of the accomplishments won by activists in the court, many had been rulings that simply overturned laws forbidding same sex marriage. In order for there to be true social change, the courts would need rule that not only are same sex marriages legal, they must be held to the same standard of equality as heterosexual marriages. Though activists continue to hope that one day full marriage equality can become a reality, it is important to understand the previous cases that been brought forth in the courts…
- 1936 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The article that I read was discussing how the Defense of Marriage act, or DOMA, was recently overturned by the Supreme Court of the United States. DOMA was opposed by same-sex couples who claimed that the act violated their Constitutional rights. The act, passed in 1996, stated that the Federal government did not have to recognize same-sex marriages, even though they were considered legal marriages in certain states, therefore not giving federal benefits to same-sex married couples. The benefits included Social Security and immigration rights. DOMA was deemed unconstitutional by the Supreme Court, saying that its policies violated the Fifth Amendment’s protection of equal liberty. The case was decided in a 5-4 decision, and while many people were overjoyed by the outcome, many people were not pleased with it.…
- 343 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
What this means is that prior to the entrenchment of the Charter into the Canadian Constitution, studies indicate that gay and lesbian advocates did not believe that "legal and public policy changes [were] likely to occur" (Smith, 2005, p.334) through litigation. This is because pre-Charter courts could not influence public policies. In fact, when it comes to questioning government legislations, the courts only had jurisdiction over a limited amount of issues such as the division of power between federal and provincial government (Smith,…
- 890 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
There are various points of view involving this controversial topic. Many people believe that gay and lesbian adoption should be legal throughout America, at the same time others would rather that gay and lesbian adoption be declared illegal as a whole or forbidden in certain states. There are a good amounts of compelling reasons why gay and lesbian parenting is beneficial, but for others those reason are just not enough. The true matter at hand involving adoption is what is best for the child. This controversial topic isn’t based off of cause and effect; more as to pros and…
- 792 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Why is the LGBTQ socieaty so discriminated? The LGBTQ socieaty is discriminated because of their sexuality. People do not like people who are different, they only like people who that act or think the same way they do. This is why there should be more LGBTQ rights because a lot of people (LGBTQ) are dying everyday. Discrimination needs to stop.…
- 680 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Ohio law permitted Gay and Lesbian people individually to adopt children and their partners could obtain joint custody agreement to share parental rights. (6). Some people are worried about the children that get adopted or put into foster care with same sex couples. Mean and women considered that children would emulate the sexual orientation of their same sex parents. (2). Some local same sex couples with children plan to seek joint adoption because it is more clear cut than joint custody arrangements. (6). Men were apprehensive that a boy’s gender role behavior was more at risk if he was adopted by a lesbian couple.…
- 1870 Words
- 8 Pages
Good Essays -
There are approximately nine million people in America that represent the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender (LGBT) community. That represents 3.5% of the American population, with that number expected to rise as new legislation makes it safer and more acceptable for the LGBT community to identify themselves (Williams Institute, 2011). The purpose of this paper is to discuss current legislation in the Federal government pertaining to LGBT rights, as well as cover the history of LGBT legislation. The American Government has come a long way with gay rights, but there is still…
- 909 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Thesis Statement: The Gay Rights Movement dates back to the 19th century. By 1970 gay and lesbian organizations existed all over the United States and in other countries all over the world. Some supporters of the movement would say that our society as a whole has made great strides towards acceptance of homosexuality. However, gays and lesbians are still fighting for equality in 2009. The issues are vast and widespread, with same-sex marriage at the top of the list. In the world that we live in today one might be surprised to learn how many countries are accepting of gay and lesbians, as well as how many are not. The world has made progress within the last decade regarding this issue, but definitely not enough. We need to take steps to protect and balance Gay rights.…
- 3319 Words
- 14 Pages
Best Essays