Preview

Communitarianism vs. Cosmopolitanism

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1374 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Communitarianism vs. Cosmopolitanism
What are the differences between cosmopolitan and communitarian approaches to global politics? S) A P d x d A A T $ þÿ T¹ $ þÿ When looking at normative theories of politics, the main distinction is between cosmopolitanism and communitarianismÿ. In this essay the term community shall refer to political communities, or more specifically, states. It is important to note that these political communities have been defined territorially, and not necessarily by culture, although this is taken for granted to an extent by communitarianism. Communitarians say that each community is different, and therefore should act accordingly with each other. In other words, state autonomy should be absolute and law and moral standards should be self-determined by the community itself alone. Furthermore, communities should have no obligations to other political communities or any sort of international law. Contrastingly, Cosmopolitans say that there should be an overriding universal moral standard to which all states (or communities) should adhere. If a state is infringing on the rights of the individual or humanity, then intervention is appropriate and just.S A @ È È A— 0 t N… T| $ þÿc Steve Smith, The Globalisation of World Politics: An Introduction to International Relations p. 173A 8 ] T $ þÿ S A @ È È T $ þÿ S A @ È È T> $ þÿÝ Communitarianism says that communities themselves define what rightful conduct is, and therefore should not be obliged to follow any universal moral code. Morality arises from the culture that makes up the community, and therefore determines what is right for that community, whether it is or not for anyone else. Communitarians say that there cannot be a universal moral standard because where would these standards come from? Who would decide what is right and wrong? However, the argument communitarianism can be turned against it if these communities are


Bibliography: S A P A 8

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    When doing your assessment of a patient, regardless if it is an admission, surgical, emergency visit or just routine visit, you need a method, pattern to ensure completion. I am going to focus on the admission assessment. When a patient comes to the hospital, the initial assessment will plan the care. “The physical examination requires you to develop technical skills and a knowledge base.” (Jarvis, 2012)…

    • 366 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “World order” is the term given to the balance of power among the nation states of the world. Differences between these nations can lead to a power imbalance, which affects world order. It can best be achieved through agreements between states and other international instruments that set out the ideal international standards of behavior for states on a number of issues. But conflicts arise between countries due to differences in cultural attitudes and the desire for extra territory. In order to settle such disputes the international community has legal bodies such as the United Nations to cooperate with countries to find solutions and be a leader in settling and spreading ethical standards. Their prime aim is to promote world order. But for society not only the autonomy of nations and the lack of enforcement power but also a range of other factors limit the effectiveness of such an organisations.…

    • 2842 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Can cosmopolitanism a vision that explicates on how everyone should belong to the same community and share a common ground among mankind, become societies new reality? When integrating Yoshino’s idea of “the new civil rights” form his preface “Covering: The hidden assault on our civil rights”, Appiah idea of initiating conversation with other people to reach some sort of mutual understanding with those who are different from ourselves, can lead to the commemoration of cultural differences compared to the persecuting of those who we consider different. To initiate new civil rights, we must first become acquainted with our fellow inhabitant, therefore understanding the importance of cosmopolitanism in the first place.…

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Consider the mindsets of cosmopolitanism, geocentrism, and sociocentrism. Which of these makes the most valuable contribution to organizational leadership? Why?…

    • 170 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although there is no society that completely adopts these ideas with no flaws, it can be seen in many aspects of life today. Sometimes it goes all the way back to the principles we are taught as young children: "don't be selfish, help out your peers, and never complain when you are given something you don’t like." Some of the rawest components of this theory are embedded in society all around us. To demonstrate, many nations around the world show close similarities between collectivism and communism. Both stem from the ideas that everyone shall be equal and no one shall do anything to directly benefit themselves. Some communist countries include North Korea, Vietnam, and China. Additionally, other connections can be made to groups closer to home; like the cloistered nuns. The cloistered nuns are a Catholic group that voluntarily go into complete solidarity to dedicate their life to God. It is forbidden for them to look at themselves in a mirror or do anything for their own good. They put in countless hours of daily prayer to benefit the entire mankind. Likewise, Equality 7-2521 talks about some similar rules: "Men never see their own faces and never ask their brothers about it, for it is evil to have concern for their own faces or bodies…

    • 859 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Cosmopolitanism creates a more connected world by making citizens more understanding of each other and being able to coexist as Appiah states in “Making Conversations.” He says that, “cosmopolitanism shouldn’t be seen as some exalted attainment” but as an idea that people should use to be able to coexist and be able to associate with others. (71). In both cosmopolitanism and global supply chains we see people that are different come together and work amongst themselves. They have different views and come from different cultures but they are able to put those differences aside and collaborate. Not only do those people look past their cultural differences and values they are able to learn more about them so that they will be able to relate to…

    • 127 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Cosmopolitanism and Person

    • 1197 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The point of Appiah's essay is to explain the topic of cosmopolitanism is today's society. Basically, Appiah explains someone who is a cosmopolitan as "a citizen of the world"; it is also "our responsibility to exchange ideas about what is right and wrong in the world." We must also realize that we are responsible for other people in the world, and that every person has a different positive contribution that they can make to the "whole." He uses words, such as "shared humanity," to show that while humans may be spread all over the globe and live different lives, there are also many things that we share in common about everyday life. However, problems are caused when people cannot tolerate others or aren't open to diversity. There are also people who believe that in order to work together with another person, that person must "be like them." Overall, as long as we can work against the negatives, Appiah thinks that cosmopolitanism will be a very important factor in any successful community. The point of Appiah's essay is to explain the topic of cosmopolitanism is today's society. Basically, Appiah explains someone who is a cosmopolitan as "a citizen of the world"; it is also "our responsibility to exchange ideas about what is right and wrong in the world." We must also realize that we are responsible for other people in the world, and that every person has a different positive contribution that they can make to the "whole." He uses words, such as "shared humanity," to show that while humans may be spread all over the globe and live different lives, there are also many things that we share in common about everyday life. However, problems are caused when people cannot tolerate others or aren't open to diversity. There are also people who believe that in order to work together with another person, that person must "be like them." Overall, as long as we can work against the negatives, Appiah thinks that cosmopolitanism will be a very important factor in any…

    • 1197 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Cosmopolitanism and People

    • 1125 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Internet is playing a very important role in the evolution of digital technology, but although it has seen remarkable growth over the last few years, its dispersion remains highly asymmetric. It is widely believed that the so called information age will bring radical change and improvement, and countries all over the world are busy with constructing the necessary infrastructure, the "information superhighways," in order to meet the challenges of the information society of the twenty-first century. Kwame Anthony Appiah’s essay “Making Conversation” tell us about human’s conversation is better expressing themselves in person. Marshall Poe said in his article “The Hive” talks about the evolution of Wikipedia and how people are interacting online. The internet serves a purpose for research, schoolwork, and connections. However, the result from the internet age is loosing communication,lack of social interaction, and the unreliable nature of websites.…

    • 1125 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    |• How do the two countries differ in their cultural patterns? How does communication play|…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Immunitarian Democracy

    • 1400 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Does "community" refer to democracy? If not, could it or is it too deeply embedded in the conceptual lexicon of the Romantic, authoritarian and racist Right? This is the question, one already asked by American neo-communitarianism, that is emerging again in Europe at the precise moment when, some, especially in France and in Italy, are risking thinking community anew. At issue is not only a legitimate question, but in some ways even an inevitable one, in which democractic culture deeply examines its own theoretical precepts and future. This doesn't change the fact though that it's the wrong question or that it's badly put. Wrong or badly put because it takes as its term of comparison -- in order to be related to the category of community - a concept, that of democracy that is utterly incapable of "understanding" it, not only because its modern meaning at least, arrives much later, but also because it is flatter and increasingly overwhelmed in a dimension that is entirely political and institutional.…

    • 1400 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Communitarianism defines the idea where the individual needs of a person are secondary to the overall development of the social group he or she communes. The social group can be represents as any group of people that share common goals and ideals. Possible factors that define ideals of the group include ethnic background, social or economic status, religious and cultural beliefs. Constant social interaction is important with this ideal. It is communitarian teleology that humankind is social by nature and that this idea grows naturally to this end.…

    • 1085 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The basis of nationality is the sensé of belonging to the same nation and the désire on the part of its members to live with each other at this level of community. When the political scientist wants to de fine or locate this subjective sensé of community, he has used such objective criteria as common language, common history, common territory, and so forth. It is clear that ail thèse criteria are an expression of something more basic—shared expérience. This shared expérience, which may lead to the necessary mutual trust among members of a given society and to the feeling that this group as a group is différent from others, contributes continuously to national unity. National unity likewise makes shared expérience more possible.…

    • 2386 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The reading of art’s history has undergone serious transformation with the coming of Post Colonial theory where it has cogently gleaned valuable data and pushed aside many redundant theories. The time has come for post colonialism to have a reassessment of its own methods and taxonomies to question some of the discrepancies within itself.…

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Adapted physical education

    • 4402 Words
    • 15 Pages

    Young, I. (1989). Polity and group difference: a critique of the ideal of universal citizenship. Ethics, pp.250--274.…

    • 4402 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Best Essays