Comparative essay on the Giver and Animal Farm
There is no doubt that challenging or difficult situations can reveal the best or worst characteristics in individuals. These similarities and differences of overwhelming personal adversity in Animal Farm by George Orwell and The Giver by Lois Lowry will be discussed. Napoleon does not enjoy the idea of having a democratic government so he chooses to exile snowball to start a dictatorship. The selfishness in napoleon’s leadership is contrasted to the hardship that Jonas must face when refusing to submit to the dictator’s figure of the Giver. The right has been given to Jonas to receive memories before “sameness”, which is very similar to the role that Napoleon plays in the communist community of the pigs after the death of Old Major. In substance the compare and contrast of the vivid personal adversity will be gone over in these two major novels.
In Animal Farm, the plot goes around the victory of Old Major and the overthrow of Mr.Jones leading to the full overtaking of the farm. After this overthrow Snowball and Napoleon are put in charge over the pigs with the motto “all pigs are equal.” However during this leadership Snowball is run off the farm by Napoleon’s taste for power starting a dictatorship. Therefore takes control of all the animals of the farm. Boxer who had thought about what Napoleon had did spoke his mind saying” if comrade Napoleon says it, it must be right.” From there he adopted the saying “Napoleon is always right” this shows how Napoleon has failed to keep the oath he had made to Old Major, and now is running a communist regime. This shows how Napoleons idea of equality had completely diminished creating alliance with the humans.
Also in The Giver, Jonas a young boy who has been given the privilege of receiving the memories of the giver before the time of “sameness.” This novel takes place in a communist dystopia, which reflects the unique gift of receiving memories before people were taught to act “the same” in this type of society.
In Animal Farm, the plot goes around the victory of Old Major and the overthrow of Mr.Jones leading to the full overtaking of the farm. After this overthrow Snowball and Napoleon are put in charge over the pigs with the motto “all pigs are equal.” However during this leadership Snowball is run off the farm by Napoleon’s taste for power starting a dictatorship. Therefore takes control of all the animals of the farm. Boxer who had thought about what Napoleon had did spoke his mind saying” if comrade Napoleon says it, it must be right.” From there he adopted the saying “Napoleon is always right” this shows how Napoleon has failed to keep the oath he had made to Old Major, and now is running a communist regime. This shows how Napoleons idea of equality had completely diminished creating alliance with the humans.
Also in The Giver, Jonas a young boy who has been given the privilege of receiving the memories of the giver before the time of “sameness.” This novel takes place in a communist dystopia, which reflects the unique gift of receiving memories before people were taught to act “the same” in this type of society.