Preview

Comparative Poem Analysis

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1046 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparative Poem Analysis
Comparative Commentary on “Salome” and “Medusa”
Both “Salome” and “Medusa” are poems written by a poet called Carol Ann Duffy, which have similarities and differences based on various aspects of poem analysis.
To begin with the poem “Salome” has a slightly different audience than the poem “Medusa”. The audience in “Salome” is unconfident and oppressed women who do not believe in their power and what they can do, men who underestimate women and people who discriminate others based on their sex or gender. In addition to that the audience in “Medusa” is unconfident women who were hurt before –mostly by men- and do not believe that they can be strong again, and reckless men who hurt women and torture them both physically and mentally.
Moving on to the purpose of each poem, “Salome” aims to show the audience the power of women and how at times they can act like men and be stronger. The poem tells the audience there is not much difference between the two genders and how women can turn men into slaves by using their brains and sexuality. However “Medusa” has the purpose of making the audience emphasize the mythical character of Medusa whilst showing how women can blossom and rise again from the darkness and pain that they felt before and get stronger again.
The poems also have very different contents and things that happening in them. In the poem “Salome”, a woman called Salome is waking up to a hangover, with a man beside her bed who she does not know. With the help of the religious story of Salome and John the Baptist, the audience can easily understand that she had killed the man however she acts reckless and does not care about the fact that she is a murderer, which indicates the power of women. Although in the poem “Medusa”, the audience comes across with a women who is hurt by her lover and turned into a monster because of her jealousy. Medusa realizes her power and strength throughout the poem and which shows the audience a women figure that is going

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In the beginning of both the poem and story the authors give a very visual description of the women. They are both considered to appear on the outside as if they are "a faerys child" - beautiful. But when you look into their eyes a sense of being "wild" is within them. The wildness that the men see in their eyes foreshadows their merciless nature. The wildness alludes to and foreshadows the womens animalistic and heartless actions. In both storys the women seduce multiple men with their physical attractiveness in order to gain control of them and make the situation benefit them. The authors use imagery in their texts by explaining in detail the womens outstanding physical features in order to make the reader picture the women in the same way that the narrator does. Steinbeck and Keats effectivly project the images of the women into the minds of the reader.…

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are many themes that are seen in both the poems. These include Revenge, Anger, Depression and Death. The two key themes in the both poems; Murder and Jealousy are both portrayed in different ways according to each killer’s motives.…

    • 671 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    To start with, both poems explore the conflicts in a love relationship between women and men. They are both written from a women’s perspective and display a conflict over the levels of power in relationships. In Les Grands Seigneurs, we are invited to speculate on the musings of the narrator as she looks back to the past: a time when men were her ‘castellated towers’ and she controlled them. In Medusa, the feelings of ‘a suspicion, a doubt, a jealousy’ present in the narrator’s mind show that she feels ownership of her husband and doesn’t want him to come under someone else’s control.…

    • 477 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Medusa Sarton

    • 1067 Words
    • 5 Pages

    She portrays that her muse is the purpose of her artistic talent. Sarton portrays that through projection she surrenders to Medusa's power. Her poetic creativity is considered to be her image. Sarton uses Medusa as the figurative ‘to be looked at,' allowing her to think in a different perspective: "I saw you once, Medusa; we were along./ I looked you straight in the cold eye, cold./ I was not punished, was not turned to stone--/ How to believe the legends I am told?// I came as naked as any little fish,/ Prepared to be hooked, gutted, caught;/ But I saw you, Medusa, made my wish,/ And when I left you I was clothed in thought…" (Sarton 1-8). Throughout the stanzas, Medusa is portrayed like a hero since she is a motivated force who Sarton is thankful for. The fish in Sarton's poem are images that symbolize her thoughts that Medusa inspired. These images are an element of art which require the capacity ‘to be looked at.' Women who are considered ‘to be looked at,' also known as their femininity, are nothing without this projected image. Gender identities make a difference between seeing and being seen. An image is a representation of something else like an image from a camera. Theresa de Lauretis extends this point of view throughout her excerpt of "Desire in Narrative." De Lauretis explains that we see ourselves reflected in someone else's mirror. Cinema enacts the process of "death…

    • 1067 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Medea is a great example of gender oppression leading to belittlement, but we must also take into account the fact that Medea has the freedom to express and take action against the injustice she feels has been done to…

    • 356 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    To The Virgins Analysis

    • 1356 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The general subject to both of these poems is the fact that they both have to do with love, and sex. Although in the poem To the Virgins, to Make Much of Time the writer is talking about all young girls to lose their virginity. I know it is directed to all young girls because in line 10 it states, “When youth and blood are warmer.” When he says “youth” he is talking about young girls. The poem To His Coy Mistress is talking about how the writer wants one,a certain girl in particular to have sex with him. He is doing all he by convincing her and trying his best for her to say yes. In lines 15-19 he says, “Two…

    • 1356 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The two poems; ‘Medusa’ and ‘Les Grands Seigneurs’ (LGS) have their similarities and differences. The most obvious being both speakers are women and how they subdue men. However, the most apparent difference is the way both poets present character, with ‘Medusa’ and her jealousy and mistrust towards her partner; ‘…a doubt, a jealously’. The standards of a woman are lowered; she is bitter, vicious and twisted. Having snakes for hair and revealing the monster she has become, whereas in LGS the dominance and prowess of the woman is expressed, men desperate for her attention; ‘my hurdy-gurdy monkey-men’. Almost as if she has the men on strings, the woman, a courtesan, is firmly in control. On the other hand, little can be said for ‘Medusa’ as the poem revolves around fear and revulsion; ‘be terrified’ and ‘yellow fanged’, being the complete opposite of the courtesan, a demise of evil.…

    • 1664 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the poems, , they shared many similarities. One similarity is that they both used apostrophes to make their rhythm come together. Some examples would be the words “refin’d, heavn’s, th’angelic, fill’d, and heav’nly.” Another way they compare is that they both use biblical references. Various examples are that in the first poem she ended it with “May be refin’d and join th’angelic train” and also in the second poem she said “Fill’d with the praise of him who gives the light,” both referring to God and the heavens. Throughout both of the poems she expresses how happy she was to be brought to America and be placed in the family she was. Phillis also shows that she was happy to have learned Christianity and that she found God. Those are only a few similarities I noticed, but I’m sure there are plenty more.…

    • 311 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    A Thousand Splendid Suns

    • 344 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Throughout the entire novel, both Mariam and Laila endure a lot of obstacles and heartache purely because of their gender. Yet they continue to persevere and overcome their challenges. It is their strength and power within themselves which allows “justice and power” to be “brought together”, as the women of that nation would not have been allowed to voice their opinions, let along hold any power over authority, as the text describes the main antagonist being constricted by their husband. The dialogue “A man’s heart is a wretched, wretched thing. It isn’t like a mother’s womb. It won’t bleed. It won’t stretch to make room for you” conveys fear, and powerlessness. The persona does not feel any power, but feels isolation instead. This demonstrates women’s place in many nations in the poorer parts of the world. However, later the text states that “Laila has moved on”. This quote highlights the persona empowering herself. She has moved on from her abusive husband and now “whatever…

    • 344 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Medusa

    • 326 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In medusa, Duffy uses the character of a female to show power. "Be terrfied". This quote is a short sentence which emphasises her power and that when she looks at you, it doesnt take long till you are turned into stone. The sentence also creates a sinister tone in a way that she wants you t be afraid of her because she was once destroyed now she wants to destroy others as she has the power to do so. Duffy later on uses the verb "shattered" which links with the word "spattered". This demonstartes the strength of her power to destroy, her power is so strong that anything that comes in her way either ends up "shattered" or "spattered". The verbs also infer that with power comes jelousy because Medusa destroys everything that appears to be positive and beautiful. They might also suggest that the way she has destroyed inncocent life is a way to say that she is out of contro herself.The poem structured around her transformation, and the escalating scale of the living things she turns to "stone". She starts with a "buzzing-bee" and her victims increase in size until she changes a "dragon" into a "volcano". Finally she turns her attention to the man who broke her heart. In her last line Medusa says "look at me now". this line, given great structural emphasis, is hugely ambiguous.It could be a heart-felt plea for attention as well as, of course, a heavily ironic threat and reminder of her capabilities.The paradox for Medusa is that she has become trapped by her own power. Duffy may be suggesting that the negative and destructive qualities of revenge will eventually undo their perpetrator. In the same way power is a major theme in Ozymandias, what was once so magnificent - a symbol of the king's great power - is now "sunk... shattered...…

    • 326 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Study

    • 325 Words
    • 2 Pages

    From a feminist point of view, the poem has various examples of feminism. The poet makes several references to motherhood, and her mother is a perfect example of a woman of her time. She shows her love and admiration for the mother that gave her life, and for all mothers who have given birth.…

    • 325 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Ancient Greece women lacked rights, they were oppressed by their society, and looked upon as lesser beings. Medea expresses this thought throughout the play, and provides a voice for the women of Ancient Greece, for instance when Medea exclaims, “Surely, of all creatures that have life and will, we woman are the most wretched” (Medea, 24). Medea voices her belief on the injustice that lingers in Ancient Greece, defending and representing women as a whole and depicting the plethora of ways that woman are denied their basic human rights, she also goes as far as calling their existence wretched. One instance of Medea voicing the opinions of women, on the topic of marriages and how women are treated as property is when she says, “ […] We have…

    • 257 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Medusa by Carol Ann Duffy

    • 1878 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Medusa, the protagonist, uses the myth metaphorically in order to create a modern and reliable tone, allowing a wider audience and switching the focus from her actions to her feelings. The poem rehabilitates the bad image methodology gave Medusa by making her go from a stoned hearted character into a humane one. Duffy asserts: “Poets deal in … trying to find the language and images for intense feelings.” (n.d, p. 2), based on the poem, jealousy destroys Medusa while in the Myth it is Athena’s. We can comprehend it through a metaphorical use of language: “jealousy grew in my mind”. It started growing in her and when it had no more place, outside, as dirty and vicious hair: “filthy snakes” (Duffy, 2008, p.1, l.3), which are literal in the myth but metaphorical in Duffy’s interpretation. To Medusa the snakes symbolise her “thoughts” spitting on her “scalp” (Duffy, 2008, p.1, l.4-5), as she could not hold it inside anymore, leading to grief.…

    • 1878 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The reader can infer that this initial poem is the source of inspiration for all of the others in this body of work due to a sophisticated metaphor the author utilizes to describe this particular work. It is interesting to note that in the very first few lines of this poem, the author explicitly denotes that this entire collection of poems are written in the hopes that the maiden, Stella, will read them and take “pity” and deliver “grace” to the star-struck lover Astrophel. Still, when it comes to actually forming the words that may inspire the maiden such, the poet employs a metaphor in which he likens his brain (which is responsible for his writing) to land and the product of that land to the writing which may win Stella. The difficulty that the poet incurs in effecting this process is implied by the description of his brain as “sun-burned” (Sidney), which implies it lacks the proper irrigation and water to make it harvest words. Therefore, the poet longs for “fresh and fruitful showers” (Sidney) in order to produce the words that will eventually win Stella.…

    • 659 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Medusa Sylvia Plath

    • 266 Words
    • 2 Pages

    ‘Medusa’ (originally had ‘Mum’ in the title) focuses on the relationship with the persona’s mother. It can be seen as a companion poem to ‘Daddy’ - written shortly before - and explores a similar theme – freeing the self from the (powerful, smothering) parent.…

    • 266 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays

Related Topics