Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

compare and contrast alice munro

Satisfactory Essays
545 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
compare and contrast alice munro
Compare And Contrast Two Short Stories By Alice Munro

In Alice Munro’s two short stories “How I Met My Husband” and “Walker Brothers Cowboy” there are many similarities and dissimilarities. The main points of contrast and comparison are the setting, social and economic standing and theme.
Throughout the two short stories by Alice Munro “How I Met My Husband” and “Walker Brothers Cowboy” There are some similarities and also some differences between the two settings. Munro’s short story “How I Met My Husband” is set in a time just after the Second World War where there is electricity, automobiles and even planes are starting to make an appearance in peoples lives and the population is in the middle of an economic boom. This is very similar to “Walker Brothers Cowboy” where the story is set in a very similar timeline as the speaker says “He was barely alive when this century started. I will be barely alive,-old, old-when it ends”(5), but the setting also has one key difference. In ‘How I Met My Mother” the people should be facing an economic boom, but in “Walker Brothers Cowboy” the family and many others are struggling with poverty “Prices fell, and they fell again.”(5) Which hints that the story takes place somewhere after World War 1 during the great depression. Social and economic hierarchy plays a key role in both of Munro’s short stories. The protagonist in “How I Met My Husband”, Edie comes form a family of low status and wealth and throughout her whole life has been accustomed to living with the bare necessities, “Mrs. Peebles had an automatic washer and dryer, the first I ever saw”(129). The family from “Walker Brothers Cowboy’ however have known both lives. At one point they “raised silver foxes and sold their pelts”(5) which was quite profitable and they were able to live quite comfortably. Soon however, they where hit by the recession and were forced to move and look for new work and the father ended up becoming a walker brothers man.

Even though written by the same author the themes in “How I Met My Husband” and “Walker Brothers Cowboy” .The main theme in “Walker Brothers Cowboy” is that of poverty, the story takes place after the conclusion of World War 1 during the great depression and it is clear that the family has been greatly affected by this, saying that even though they were poor beforehand what they where experiencing now “ was a different sort of poverty”(6). However the theme of “How I Met My Husband” is that of love as the title implies and the story is centered on “Edie’s” experiences and the unusual way that she ended up meeting her husband. However in both stories the themes overlap, Edie, a maid for the Peebles family, comes from a background of poverty, but finds love throughout the story, while the family in “Walker Brothers Cowboy” already had love and have now been just recently become poorer due to the depression.

Both of Munro’s short stories “Walker Brothers Cowboy” and “How I Met My Husband” were similar in some aspects and different in others, but both of her stories still give an accurate and enjoyable recollection of life in the mid 2000’s.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In the article Catharine Beecher and Charlotte Perkins Gilman: Architects of female power, Valerie Gill compares the beliefs of both Charlotte Gilman and her great-aunt Catharine Beecher. One of, if not the most important, factor of this article that the reader sees repeatedly is the environment in which the american woman tenants should be the center of all their commerce. This process continued to establish the idea that what initiates in the woman's home will continue to emit throughout the lives of the woman and her family. Both Beecher and Gilman attempted to define the roles of american women beginning with their private life and continuing on into their public life. Although both Catharine Beecher and Charlotte Gilman had “disparate notions about what kind of lives american women should lead..” the foundation of the argument appears to be, regardless of one's interpretation, based on the same reality.…

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Flannery O’Connors short story, “Good Country People,” the main theme is about a southern family and their faith, identity and education. Another key theme in the story is the concept of reality vs. illusion. The story employs irony and symbolism to portray the main character’s nihilism, immaturity and rebelliousness as well as the other character’s traits and personalities.…

    • 1143 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Do photographic illustrations work as well as hand drawn techniques at communicating the content and atmosphere of fairy tales?…

    • 438 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Their first baby, a daughter, was born in January 1922, when my mother was 26 years old. The second baby, a son, was born in March 1923. They were renting farms; my father, besides working his own fields, also was a hired man for two other farmers. They had no capital initially, and had to gain it slowly, working from dawn until midnight every day. My town-bred mother learned to set hens and raise chickens, feed pigs, milk cows, plant and harvest a garden, and can every fruit and vegetable she could scrounge. She carried water nearly a quarter of a mile from the well to fill her wash boilers in order to do her laundry on a scrub board. She learned to shuck grain, feed threshers, shuck and husk corn, feed corn pickers. In September 1925, the third baby came, and in June 1927, the fourth child – both daughters. In 1930, my parents had enough money to buy their own farm, and that March they moved all their livestock and belongings themselves, 55 miles over rutted, muddy…

    • 1354 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    All the pretty horses

    • 1191 Words
    • 5 Pages

    For the first thirty years of his career, Cormac McCarthy was a little known but critically acclaimed cult author. Then, with the publication of his masterful novel All the Pretty Horses, the first book of his Border Trilogy, McCarthy finally gained the mainstream audience and awards that had eluded him. Like most of McCarthy’s work, All the Pretty Horses has a dark presence about it. One can sense always that misfortune is around the corner, just a few pages forward. I think the reason that the book attracted so much attention is that there’s just something so profound about McCarthy writing; it’s different, provocative, it breaks the mold. In this novel, McCarthy does away with preconceived notions about idealistic westerns and creates a more realistic portrayal of cowboys and westward expansion. McCarthy creates John Grady Cole, a 16-year-old boy who retains a romantic vision of the cowboy culture, but places him in a profoundly unromantic reality. The book primarily concerns itself with romanticism verses realism in frontier culture.…

    • 1191 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    ‘“You rode her from Texas?’ ‘Yessir.’ ‘You and your friend?’ ‘Yessir.’ ‘Just the two of you?’ ‘Yessir.’ (McCarthy 116). It was because Don Hector had what was seemingly an endless supply of horses, and John Grady and his assistant Rawlins specialized in them, the two friends ended up with jobs on Don Hector’s thousand acre ranch. Due to John Grady’s keen survival skills, the two friends had finally found their calling. The two of them never imagined that all of their hard work was for…

    • 722 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first similarity between the two women is the way they slowly become detached from their husbands. The woman in “The Yellow Wallpaper” is very fond of her husband’s care and takes notice of it when she says “Dear John! He loves me very dearly and hates to have me sick. (Gilman)” This shows that she can clearly see he cares for her and appreciates what he does for her. Even though she does appreciate his care, she truly believes that there is nothing wrong with her, and there is no need for his extensive supervision. Towards the end of the story she becomes very detached from John when she says “The fact is I am becoming a little afraid of John. (Gilman)” With this quote, she shows that her psychological condition has worsened as feels as if John is trying to hurt her with the rest and treatments he is prescribing. In “The Story of an Hour” the main character immediately feels detached from her husband with “And yet she had loved him—sometimes. Often she had not. What did it matter! (Chopin)” With this she shows that she does not feel at all connected to her husband an shows no concern with trying to be. While these to women may have grown away from their husbands from different reason, it is still a strong similarity that the share.…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cornet At Night

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The farm versus the town represents the difference of isolation and diversity. The man at the bar versus Phillip Coleman shows the contrast of different occupations and experiences. Due to all of these dissimilarities, Sinclair Ross gives readers the message to try and new things instead of staying with the same things people usually do on their daily…

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Shinning Houses Alice Munro presents a protagonist whose personality and values conflict with her neighbours. The protagonist Mary is an open-minded, fair, but somewhat powerless character.…

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    How I Met My Husband

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The short story How I Met my Husband is a story about a fifteen year old girl who has a coming of age experience while working for a doctor and his wife. The author, Alice Munro utilizes several literary techniques to convey a very relatable theme, that of young idealized romance and the ironies we learn about these romances as we get older. Munro conveys this theme by utilizing an interesting first person perspective and descriptive language to provide the reader with a mental setting. As the story progresses, the character development employed helps to complete the picture of where the main character belongs in society, and how the other characters in the story help her to understand who she does not want to become when she gets older. Ultimately, the male and female characters and what they symbolize in the story provide a roadmap of the pitfalls that Edie realizes that she would like to avoid in life.…

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the short story “Boys and Girls”, Alice Munro portrays the difficulties of the narrator and her brother. Throughout the story, the narrator faces inequality of being a different sex compared to her brother Laird and the effect this has on her as she is growing up. The narrator goes through many experiences that she has to understand herself as she is growing up. Alice Munro shows how gender labeling, different relationships within the family and the narrator’s innocence plays a controversial role in growing up. Munro’s story “Boys and Girls” interprets growing up to be a necessary experience in every child’s life.…

    • 818 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In Alice Munro’s short story, “Soon”, there are areas for analyzation. The argument between Don the minister and Juliet holds great significance to the insight of Juliet’s character.…

    • 1041 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Alice Munro’s “Boys and Girls” the story is about a young girl’s resistance to womanhood in a society based all upon gender roles and stereotypes. Initially, the girl believes that she can be of great value to her father in his work, then the destruction of her dreams occurs when she realizes society's view and expectations of her being a female.Therefore, she loves working on the fox farm with her father as she also, loves the attention she gets from her father while working. "Wait till Laird gets a little bigger than you`ll have a real help"(pg.194) indicates that the mother did not consider the girl help at all but to her, she is merely a replacement for Laird until he is old enough to do the farm work himself. However, her mother wishes…

    • 501 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the short story “ Boys and Girls”, Alice Munro takes us through a young girl’s journey to break away from the typical life of a woman. Munro suggests that although we would like to define our identity, it is society who defines who we are.…

    • 358 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Alice Munro Comfort

    • 928 Words
    • 4 Pages

    "Comfort," by Alice Munro, is a short story based on life, death and dying, suicide and religion. With the depth of all four topics, controversial issues arise and compromising situations hold the main character, Nina, at a difficult crossroad. That crossroad is the wants and needs that Nina yearns for. "Comfort" illustrates a ride through what Nina experiences after the passing of her husband and her dire need to get what she wants or at least to obtain comfort. From the beginning of the story the reader is bombarded by the emphasis of different views of comfort. However, Munro develops a sense of what Nina believes her comfort should be and then Nina finds her comfort in an unsuspecting place.…

    • 928 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays