Preview

Compare And Contrast Clockwork Orange Book And Movie

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1578 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare And Contrast Clockwork Orange Book And Movie
“There is, in fact not much point in writing a novel unless you can show the possibility of moral transformation, or an increase in wisdom, operating in your chief character or characters. Even trashy bestsellers show people changing” (Burgess). In the novel A Clockwork Orange a moral transformation is shown whereas in the film it is absent. Although Anthony Burgess’ novel A Clockwork Orange and the 1971 Stanley Kubrick film version are similar in matters of the use of nadsat language and the presence of a self-serving deceitful government, they are however different in terms of the ending. All these concepts tie into the theme of the battle between good and evil. To begin, the novel and the film are similar as they both keep the nadsat language and the ensuing effect it has on the audience is the same. Nadsat (“teen” in Russian) is the slang language created by Burgess and is inspired from a mix …show more content…
Towards the end of the novel the Minister of the Interior; who is under fire by the general public and media for the use of the Ludovico technique (unethical aversion therapy) on Alex which resulted in Alex trying to kill himself; makes a deal with Alex. The deal is that if Alex supports the government publicly and takes pictures with the Minister smiling and showing he is a ‘’good man’’, the government will in return give Alex a job and turn a blind eye to any of the violent crimes he has and will commit. Alex accepts and then goes on continuing to do “...the old ultraviolence” (Burgess 1) ;as he calls his violent actions; and the government is fine with this as long as their pristine image is upheld. While the movie ends on this scene (we do not get to see the ultraviolence after this) the deal he strikes with the Minister is the same and it is implied that he does continue after with his violent acts. The minister says

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    * Two officers pull the old man that was beating Alex off him, when they do; Alex is surprised to find his old friend and old enemy Dim and Billy boy. Billy boy and Dim take Alex to the country side and beat him brutally.…

    • 795 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    One of his biggest triggers is the milk from the Korova Milk Bar. His drink of choice, milk plus, by his own admission “will sharpen you up and make you ready for the ultra-violence” has a detrimental effect on Alex and his thought process. Once consumed, as various other drugs Alex’s self-control is lost deep inside his mind and the conditioned response of violence comes to the forefront in dramatic fashion. Alex’s has conditioned himself through his consumption of milk plus to act out his violent impulses. It is plausible that his conditioning is a direct reaction to the socialistic society that shows very little respect to the disenfranchised youth during that time period. The ultra-violent outbursts Alex displays could be a statement on his struggles against the oppressive society he is a part of. Alex and his droogs’ ultimate goal are to make the victims of their crimes appear to be the lowlifes of society and that they are being punished for their role in perpetuating the socialist agenda. Moreover, Alex has convinced himself of the delusion that he is a freedom fighter or the savior of a pre-socialist society…

    • 2151 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Anthony Burgess’ dystopian novel, A Clockwork Orange, takes on the theme of free will and why it's highly crucial to people in society. In his novel, Anthony Burgess explores the absence of free will from a government project leading the main character, Alex, to become sick whenever he thinks of violence, leaving him defenseless, and having suicidal tendencies. After the undergoing the experiment, Alex finds the violent acts that he once loved are now unenjoyable and sickening whenever they are upon his mind. After his release from prison, Alex is left alone in the streets unable to fight back without getting sick. Lastly, realizing the effects of the experiment on his body, Alex concludes the experiment…

    • 1976 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Angela’s Ashes by Frank McCourt and A Clockwork Orange by Anthony Burgess are two books with a similar environment. The books environments are influenced by a lack of humanity, lack of civility, and human spirit. Salman Rushdie quotes, “Literature is where I go to explore the highest and lowest places in human society and the human spirit.” Salman Rushdie’s quote and the books that have been mentioned above share the idea that we can explore and learn from these fictional or nonfictional situational environments. Both of these books teach and portray the cruel parts of human society and also relates to the quote from Salman Rushdie.…

    • 421 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Burgess’ novel, A Clockwork Orange, carries many themes prevalent to the time-period of the novel’s release. In a futuristic city governed by a repressive totalitarian super-state, humans have become machines or lower animals. The main protagonist of the story, Alex, asserts his free will by deciding to live a life of debauchery and violence before being robbed of his free-will by the government. When A Clockwork Orange was written the war against Communism was at its peak. With many countries such as Russia and Cuba spreading communism to different parts of the world, the fear of depriving an individual’s free-will in light of the public was set in with the United States and its ally forces. Free-will then despite its predication that individuals such as Alex can make the choice of being wicked can also make the choice as a moral agent to do well. Without those choices the human-act of kindness/good becomes nothing more than a shallow behavior.…

    • 502 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The differences between the movie and the book are great. There are people missing and scenes cut. There are people added and scenes added. For the most part, though, the theme seemed to stay generally the same. These differences come about because of the difference of how movies focus more on drama and books go more in depth, so they can give more detail.…

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “I don’t care about the dangers father, I just want to be good; I want the rest of my life to be one act of goodness” (Kubrick, 1971). The father responds, “The question is whether or not his technique really makes a man good, goodness comes from within, goodness is chosen, when a man can not choose, he seizes to be a man” (Kubrick, 1971). This is a conversation between the delinquent Alex and the prison chaplain in the 1971 film, A Clockwork Orange. They are discussing the Ludovico technique, which is an experimental aversion therapy for rehabilitating criminals, but all this technique seems to do is take away a man’s free will. “The film is used to explore the political and social realities of punishment, in particular the examination of the moral question of "voluntariness" and the implications for "treatment" as a mechanism of social control” (Lichtenberg, Lune, & McManimon, 2004).…

    • 1589 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Anthony Burgess has been heralded as one of the greatest literary geniuses of the twentieth century. Although Burgess has over thirty works of published literature, his most famous is A Clockwork Orange. Burgess's novel is a futuristic look at a Totalitarian government. The main character, Alex, is an "ultra-violent" thief who has no problem using force against innocent citizens to get what he wants. The beginning of the story takes us through a night in the life of Alex and his Droogs, and details their adventures that occupy their time throughout the night. At fifteen years old, Alex is set up by his Droogs—Pete, Dim, and Georgie—and is convicted of murder and sent to jail. At the Staja or state penitentiary, Alex becomes inmate number 6655321 and spends two years of a sentence of fourteen years there. Alex is then chosen by the government to undergo an experimental new "Ludovico's Technique." In exchange for his freedom, Alex would partake in this experiment that was to cure him of all the evil inside of him and all that was bad. Alex is given injections and made to watch films of rape, violence, and war and the mixture of these images and the drugs cause him to associate feelings of panic and nausea with violence. He is released after two weeks of the treatment and after a few encounters with past victims finds himself at the home of a radical writer who is strongly opposed to the new treatment the government has subjected him to. Ironically, this writer was also a victim of Alex's but does not recognize him. This writer believes that this method robs the recipient of freedom of choice and moral decision, therefore depriving him of being a human at all. These themes are played out and developed throughout the entire novel. Alex eventually tries to commit suicide and the State is forced to admit that the therapy was a mistake and…

    • 2182 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In A Clockwork Orange, Anthony Burgess has created a dark, gloomy socialist state of futuristic world and the theme of this novel deals with the struggles between the governments. The society in the story is inhabited by fearful citizens, wild young outlaws, and a totalitarian government which is unable to control the society's flood of violence. The citizens are more than usually suspicious of strangers, especially after dark, they would not go out to the dangerous streets, unless they are really needed. Also, this government owns all property, every citizen is forced to work, jails are cruel and the government controls the media. In this novel, social contract is eliminated from the story. “The social contract is an unwritten set of guidelines that embodies the most basic laws governing a society. Included in the social contract are such topics as courtesy, theft, murder, and tolerance.” Since youths are less educated, they always hang together, do foolish, violent things and disobey the laws. Therefore, the three problems that struggle the government are youths go wild due to negligence, insensitive government deny free will from rehabilitating youth, and government abandons youth.…

    • 1254 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The metaphor and imagery of the title, a clockwork orange, symbolises what conformity does to a man. If we cannot choose where to belong we cease to be human but clockwork, or some type of deterministic mechanism. We need to be able to choose where we belong for if it is not chosen, its authenticity ceases. The novel ends with Alex choosing the path of goodness, the established normality of society. He states; “Perhaps I was getting too old now for the sort of life I had been leading, brothers” Alex chooses to belong to society, thus allowing a connection to be formed between him and the world. This sense of belonging is authentic as he has…

    • 692 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Set in a dystopian near future, A Clockwork Orange shows Alex, a 15-year-old boy who roams the streets at night with his gang members, committing violent crimes for fun. A Clockwork Orange follows the utopian convention of the state attempting to create a utopia by controlling the individual, as Alex is used as an example of the states power to "rehabilitate"…

    • 952 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The metaphor and imagery of the title, a clockwork orange, symbolises what conformity does to a man. If we cannot choose where to belong we cease to be human but clockwork, or some type of mechanism. We need to be able to choose where we belong, for if it is not chosen its authenticity ceases. The novel ends with Alex choosing the path of goodness, the established normality of society. He states; “Perhaps I was getting too old now for the sort of life I had been leading, brothers” Alex chooses to belong to society, thus allowing a connection to be formed between him and the world.…

    • 680 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Movies and book are never the exact same. Sometimes the book have boring or imposable parts to reenact in it. In those scenes they either skip or adjust to fit the movie and make it better, but that is not always a good thing. Some people think that the book is better than the movie, others think that the movie is better than the book. Sometimes people say you should read the book before you see the movie, because the movie is make from the book.…

    • 464 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The psychological conditioning treatment used in A Clockwork Orange , the Ludovico treatment , raises many moral issues. Is it justly to take a persons “free will” to make the world a safer place? In this paper I will discuss different perspectives from the novel, including my own reflection on the treatments moral effect on the novels protagonist, Alex. After spending two years in jail , Alex our youthful narrator sees an opportunity and is given a choice that can change his life forever. He can spend the rest of his life in jail or he can undergo the Ludovico treatment offered by the government. The Ludovico treatment is a psychological experiment designed to hopefully cure a criminals mind. That is to take away the hunger for any wrong doing towards anyone else or oneself. This treatment is a mind conditioning experiment designed to modify behavior . It consists of a type of injection that takes away a persons ability to harm. It also consists of viewing violent films that conditioned the mind to want to reject crime and violence. Given the horrid life Alex had chosen to live previously, with acts of violence and hatred , this contingency did not seem to be a bad idea for anyone who knew him. There are a few concepts that that can be viewed through different lenses to determine whether the Ludovico treatment is morally correct. When it comes to a psychological treatment such as the Ludovico treatment , is it morally acceptable to take away a persons ability of choice? Alex 's human rights are taken away from him to make him an acceptable person in society ,preventing Alex of making a decision that would be of a negative consequence. Another way to view this treatment is in a way of revenge or karma. Alex hurt many people in this novel. Should he be treated with pity after this Ludovico treatment,…

    • 2442 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    belonging

    • 2605 Words
    • 11 Pages

    The idea that negative interactions within a group dynamic can lead to a limited experience of belonging is further explored in Stanley Kubrick’s film, A Clockwork Orange, through the rebellious protagonist Alexander de Large and his inability to belong to society as a whole as a result of the sadistic actions he inflicts on people. The audience is introduced to the protagonist in the opening scene through an intimate close-up shot of his smirking face and piercing blue eyes. He dons one fake eyelash and an elaborate top hat, symbolically the mockery of a civilised society, and it is through this intimate close-up that the audience realises that the character of Alex is i…

    • 2605 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays