Preview

Compare And Contrast Comin Thro The Rye

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
170 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare And Contrast Comin Thro The Rye
In the original version of Comin thro’ the Rye, the line is written as,”When a body meets a body comin thro the rye ...” rather than a body “catching” another. The Connotation surrounding the original poem suggests an expression of sexuality and questions what role the world plays in determining if a sexual relationship is appropriate or not depending on the age or maturity of the individuals. In Salinger’s version, one person is “catching” the other, which Holden comes to interpret as meaning that someone is tasked with “saving” the innocent person from exploring their sexuality at too young of an age. On the street, it could have been anyone of any age singing the tune, but Salinger chose a young boy and continues by filling the city street

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Do you know anybody that acts differently when they are alone, or with people they do not know, than they do when they are around their friends and family? Perhaps you act this way. A Separate Peace and The Catcher in the Rye are different in the idea that in most cases, while Holden is alone he is very extroverted, but when he is around people he is very introverted. Gene is the direct opposite; when he is alone or around strangers he is introverted and reserved, but when he is with his friends and family he is extroverted and sociable.…

    • 1023 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Holden finds himself wandering aimlessly around New York, encountering different experiences that he didn’t expect. He also finds himself in a situation with a call girl who is approximately the same age as him. He starts to view her as a person, rather than a sex object. He pays for the service yet he only wants to converse with her but she leaves in frustration. She brings her pimp to physically abuse Holden. As the days go by he searches for nothing except embracing his surroundings after hearing a young boy sing lyrics “if a body catch a body coming through the rye “ and he misinterprets it to be as a signal Holden believes that to be a "catcher in the rye" means to save children from losing their innocence. He begins to perceive the world and comes back home to his younger sister back in his hometown. He meets a girl when watching the play “Romeo and Juliet” where he meets a girl Sally and after hanging out together for a moderate amount of time he impulsively asks her to elope with him to a place far away forever. She declines his offer and refuses to speak to him.…

    • 352 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the book Catcher in the Rye the main character Holden Caulfield is being compared to another character in The Great Gatsby Daisy Buchanan. They both live similar lifes, but they live them in different ways. Holden seems to be an anti-social person and doesnt have that many good friends where as Daisy is very social and has alot of friends.…

    • 583 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Similar observations are made by academic writer and author Sarah Graham in her book entitled Salinger’s The Catcher in the Rye. In this book, Graham addresses a variety of reading techniques, themes, and comparisons/contrasts in regards to Salinger’s most popular novel, but she specifically addresses the main theme of Holden’s attempt to escape the phony 1950’s materialistic focused society surrounding him. Graham begins her take on this theme of escaping society with a chapter on Holden’s rebellion: “Developing the theme of rebellion, Holden’s visit to Mr. Spencer confirms that he is opposed to the conventional ideas that school and society encourage in order to promote stability” (34). During this visit to Mr. Spencer’s house that Graham…

    • 1991 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Holden wants to “the Catcher in the rye”, preventing others from being mature. But his concepts come from the misheard lyrics from “Comin’ Thro the Rye”, where a girl loses her innocence, where “a body meets a body” and having sex in the fields. In his daily life, this demonstrates his lack of ability to understand what others are trying to say and misunderstands them. As a result, it makes him harder to communicate with others and therefore pushing him further from the community.…

    • 492 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Liking Holden Caulfield

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Catcher in the Rye is the story of 16-year-old Holden Caulfield’s wanderings through New York City after he is expelled from yet another prestigious boarding school. He is alone for most of the time; however, he constantly thinks about meeting up with people, desperate to make a human connection. For example, while riding in a taxi cab, Holden attempts to make friends with the driver. He says, "Well – take me to the Edmont then … and would you care to stop on the way and join me for a cocktail? On me.” At this point, Holden is desperate for someone to talk to. This is one of his first attempts to connect with another person.…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Holden mishears the words of Robert Burns’ poem. Holden hears “if a body catch a body comin’ through the rye” (Salinger 224). Instead of “ If a body meet a body coming through the rye” (Salinger 224). His misinterpretation leads him to want to become a catcher in the rye. He describes to Phoebe what he would like to do by saying “I have to catch everybody if they start to go over the cliff- I mean if they’re running and they don’t look where they’re going. I have to come out from somewhere and catch them. That’s all I’d do all day, I’d just be the catcher in the rye and all” (Salinger 225). He wants to save people from falling off of this cliff and losing the innocence they posses. Timothy Aubry further extends Holden’s need to preserve innocence in his article The Catcher in the Rye: The Voice of Alienation by stating “Holden’s urge to shield children from danger and allow them to play endlessly exemplifies his desire to suspend time, to inhabit a space of youth preserved indefinitely” (Aubry). Salinger’s illusion is a major indication of Holden’s struggle with preserving innocence. A symbol of Holden losing his innocence, was the record that he gave Phoebe. The title implies, the record was made for children to listen to. Holden giving the record to Phoebe represents him wanting to preserve her child-like innocence. He dropped the record in the park which symbolizes holden’s life and innocence shattering. Holden describes Phoebe’s reaction when he gave her the pieces as “She took them right out of my hand and then she put them in the drawer of the night table” (Salinger). Phoebe accepted the shattered record. She accepted him for who he was. She ends up influencing Holden and he learns to accept the idea of not being completely innocent. Holen had an epiphany while Phoebe was riding a carousel. He noticed “ All the kids kept trying to grab for the gold ring, and…

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Holden is quite a peculiar kid. He tends to change his mind on a lot of things. However, the one thing he changes his mind about the most is whether he is ready to grow-up or not. Throughout the book he tries to do such adult like things, because he is sick of his usual life style. Then he gets sick of the unusual adult life. He talks to his sister, Phoebe, one night about the poem by Robert Burns, and Holden gets to thinking about innocence. How he wishes he could be the catcher in the rye. Stopping all the kids from losing that sight of innocence. He begins to regret all the adult things he did and wishes he could go back to the way his innocent childhood was.…

    • 802 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the article “The Five levels of Maslow 's hierarchy of needs” by Abraham Maslow explains the basic needs that a person wants to achieve during his or her lifetime. Cherry states that there are 5 basic needs a person wants to achieve, which are physiological, security, social, esteem, and self actualization being the highest of these needs. The needs go up as a pyramid and the higher you go the longer and harder the needs are to full fill. Then higher needs become more important than the needs below it. Maslow also explains in the article how the needs will not necessarily appear in the same order depending on the type of person. In the book “Catcher in the Rye” by J.D Salinger, the main character Holden is working up the pyramid of needs. He gets to a point where the needs take over him and to reach the needs that his behavior is impacted by them. Holden has achieved part of the needs but not fully, the need of love, esteem and self actualize have not t only certain parts of it have. this has led to the behavior of change throughout the story and for him to try everything he can to accomplish the needs.…

    • 1164 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I understand you have many things to consider at your point in life, but you are over thinking many things. In you conversation with Sally you mention the word “phony” often when you describe most of the people you have met. You said: "I hate living in New York and all. Taxicabs, Madison Avenue buses, with the drivers and all always yelling at you to get out at the rear door, and being introduced to phony guys that call the Lunts angels, and going up and down in elevators when you just want to go outside..."(pg 130) This type of thinking is just meaningless, your critiquing people and things without finding an answer to how to feel better. You are isolating yourself from many others by thinking you are the only one that…

    • 696 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Journeys End Cat Notes

    • 1824 Words
    • 8 Pages

    In smll scldd vllge in nrthrn englnd yong grl lvd wth her prnts in lrge rd brck hose. Bhnd the hose wre crs of woods nd fields, one of thse ws n old frm tht stood btween the woods nd commercil frmlnd. She wold oftn go into the woods bhind her hose to hlp McBrin, the old frmr tht rn the old frm bhind the woods. One cld wintrs nght fter workng hrd on the frm the yong grl trvled into the drk sclded woods ll lne. ‘Jsmine!’ voice scremed frm smewhre in the vst woods rond her. Jsmne flcked her hed rond rpidly to try nd fnd the sorce of the shrp, piercng cll. fter whle she pt it dwn to her overrectng imgintion nd the wnds tht hwld throgh the snster trees. She crried on wlking bt drk loomng fgre on the edge of the woods, the fgre ws ndr the only wrking street lght on the strt, whch ws nsl s it ws nrmlly the brghtst strt in the vllge. She ctisly pprochd it ssmng it ws nthr vllger,s she gt clser she ntcd it ws wring lrge wde brm trlby style ht nd lng jcket, chll slwly strtd to clmb p hr bck . ‘’ello’ she ttmptd to chirp confdntly bt her voice wvred slghtly s she wlkd pst. Stllnss, she flt it bhind her. She trnd bck nd ntced tht the fgre hdn’t mvd t ll. ‘Hello?’ she rpeted feelng worry chll her to her bnes.…

    • 1824 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    During a talk at his house with his little sister Phoebe, Holden creates powerful imagery to explain what he would like to be. “It is “If a body meet a body coming through the rye.” I didn’t know it then, though. “I always thought it was ‘If a body catch a body,’.... “I’d just be the catcher in the rye and all.””(Salinger 173). Holden's talk of being a catcher in the rye evokes a vision of him wearing his hunting hat in a field of overgrown rye. Holden talks about catching children from falling off of a cliff. The cliff stands for adulthood, and as the catcher, Holden saves the innocence of children. The symbol of the catcher, and depicts his loneliness, because he is caught in the middle of two distinctly opposite sides of the spectrum of life and maturity, and he can not decide if he wants to stay in the rye fields of childhood or the pit of wisdom. Furthermore, Holden gets the lyrics wrong, and Phoebe tells him that the lyrics were not “catch a body”, but rather “meet a body”. This implies that the song was actually about casual sex, or the loss of innocence. The true meaning of the song is a reminder that Holden's goals are were not even meant to be. The hunting hat has relevance to Holden being stuck between two opposite sides of maturity in and of itself. Near the end of Holden's story, he watches Phoebe…

    • 1550 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Catcher in the rye essay

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Transcendentalism is known as the philosophical movement as a protest to the general state of culture and society. Many Transcendentalists include Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry David Thoreau. The way Chris McCandless acted during the end of his life were a lot like these Transcendentalists. Many people, including myself, would consider Chris McCandless to be a Transcendentalist. The ways that he hated on society, burned his money after he ruined his car, and went out into the Alaskan nature all by himself show that he is a true Transcendentalist.…

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Poe's hunted soul has enabled him to manifest such dark, mysterious stories. But no one thought of him as an odd animal lover; one with a twisted heart of gold. In the short story "The Black Cat" the plot seems to be dripping with the illusion of what Freud would consider a dream, but there is more to the cat then what the dream convey to be. Beyond the chilling tale, "The Black Cat" is a tale about the narrator's character, dreams, and psychosis, all processed through a Freudian framework. The narrator's character has been layered in order for him to comfort himself in his time of need.…

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Cloud Storage

    • 289 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Cloud storage is a model of networked online storage where data is stored on multiple virtual servers, generally hosted by third parties, rather than being hosted on dedicated servers.Hosting companies operate large data centers; and people who require their data to be hosted buy or lease storage capacity from them and use it for their storage needs. The data centeroperators, in the background, virtualize the resources according to the requirements of the customer and expose them as storage pools, which the customers can themselves use to store files or data objects. Physically, the resource may span across multiple servers.…

    • 289 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays