Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Compare and Contrast Jamestown and Massachusetts

Good Essays
643 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare and Contrast Jamestown and Massachusetts
Both settlers of Jamestown and Massachusetts colonized those different areas to establish a colony in the New World and look for resources to in return to England’s investments. However, Jamestown and Massachusetts both had more early problems than successes in their colonies. One major problem was both colonies faced harsh weather conditions. Along with limited natural resources. Also, they had problems with people coming from England to try to take control of the colonies. One major example that both Massachusetts and Jamestown had in common was the reasoning of why the colonists settled in that specific region. Starting in 1607, colonists selected with what they believed to be an easily defended location, inland setting they believed would offer security. However, the site was low, swampy, hot and humid. In the summer outbreaks of malaria occurred. Since the settlers had no prior exposure, and therefore no immunity to infections of the new land. They quickly ran into other major early problems. First, the area had thick woods which made it difficult to clear for cultivation. Second, the land laid within the territory of powerful local Indians, confederation led by an imperial chief, Powhatan. Thirdly, promoters of London demanded a quick return on their investment; the colonists spent their energy on searching for gold. They quickly found out that there wasn’t any gold in Virginia. Among those problems, the London Company had little interest in creating a family-centered community. So, at first no women were present in Jamestown, making it difficult to establish and semblance of a society. Also, greed and rootlessness contributed to the failure to grow a sufficient food; inadequate diets contributed to colonists vulnerability to disease. When John Smith came along in 1608, he organized raids on neighboring villages to steal food and kidnap natives. Soon after that the “starving time” many people succumbed fevers before cold weather came. The local Indians still antagonized by Smith’s actions, they killed livestock and barricaded colonists. Soon after in 1609, when Smith was deposed from the council and returned to England, the colony of Jamestown was showing promise of survival. In Massachusetts, Puritans merchants obtained a land grant in New England. They acquired a charter from the king allowing them to create Massachusetts Bay Company and to establish the colony in the New World. John Winthrop organized the single largest migration of its kind in the seventeenth century. He also carried the charter saying that colonists would be responsible to no company officials in England only themselves. Soon the colonists transformed into a colonial government. Their intentions were to not break away from the Church of England. Which was different to Jamestown who went settled there and work to “pay back” England’s investment. However, just like Jamestown, facing harsh weather conditions, during Massachusetts first winter, unusually severe nearly one-third of the colonists died. One thing that was extremely different than Jamestown was that there was a community church in every town. They had “complete liberty to stand alone.” Unlike churches in highly centralized Anglican structure in England. Each congregation chose its own minister and regulated its own affairs. This form of parish organization eventually became as the Congregational Church. After this formation of the church, the government taxed the people, unlike in Jamestown where the people weren’t taxed. They government also made a law acquiring attendance at church services. Colonial Massachusetts became a “theocracy”, a society in which the line between church and state were hard to see. Affluent incoming settlers brought needed tools and other goods, which they exchanged for cattle, corn, and other produce that helped establish colonists and natives. Large numbers of families, contrary to Jamestown helped ensure feeling of commitment to the community and a sense of order among settlers. Also, opposite of Jamestown, there was strong religious and political hierarchy that ensured a measure of social stability.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Jamestown Research Paper

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Jamestown was a journey to early 17th century; it was America’s first permanent English colony. Jamestown was founded in 1607 by the Englishmen. It was a four-and-a-half-month voyage from England, and they used 17th century piloting and navigation. They came in boats named, Susan Constant which carried seventy-one people, Godspeed which carried fifty-two people, and Discovery which carried twenty-one and it was also the smallest boat out of the three. 350 men and no women set sail on December 20, 1606, so when they arrived at Jamestown on May during harvest time. Half of the colony perished the first year, and then they faced a brutal winter which let them to trade with the Indians. Indians wanted English tools and the Englishmen at Jamestown needed Indians food. Starving Time—the colonists were afraid to trade with the Indians, they gave up and starved to death. Sir Thomas, owner of the VA Company, tried to get another charter for the king. Lord…

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jamestown was first built in the year 1607 with the purpose of establishing a colony that would send back supplies and gold. Jamestown started to collapse very soon after its creation because of mosquitos that carried disease and the brackish water that leaked into their water supply. They decided to trade with the Indians in order to survive, but most of the Indians realized it would be easier to kill them or let them die out. In 1608 a man by the name of John Smith took control of the colony and stated that if a man did not work, he would not eat. Smith was then captured by the Indians and as soon as he was about to be killed, Pocahontas saved him. Pocahontas helped the English establish peaceful terms with the Indians, but she was then captured and used as a bargaining chip by the English. A year later John Rolfe arrived from England with tobacco, this crop effectively saved Jamestown.…

    • 463 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Compare the early development of New England with the Chesapeake as depicted in Massachusetts and Virginia colonies. How do the governing structures differ and what do they tell us about the early challenges the two colonies faced?…

    • 1230 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Before I discuss the differences in these two colonies, I would like to give you some background information on them. Massachusetts was a New England Colony founded by John Winthrop in 1628. King James the first founded Virginia in1607. The first colony of Virginia was Jamestown. Massachusetts’ first two communities, Boston and Salem, were developed around the same time. Both Virginia and Massachusetts were royal colonies.…

    • 838 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Jamestown around one hundred out of one hundred and forty-four people died, similarly in the Plymouth Plantation, only fifty out of around one hundred people survived. The Plymouth Plantation and Jamestown have lots of similarities in the way their colonies were established and run. Although these colonies did have lots of similarities, don’t think for a second that there weren’t any discrepancies. The Plymouth Plantation and Jamestown are just as similar as they’re different from each other.…

    • 194 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The English who founded Jamestown, Virginia, the first permanent settlement, came with the intent of finding gold and getting rich by trading with the Indians. As a result of the settler's eagerness for money, they failed to think about the location on which they chose to settle, the swamp. This geographic condition started the colony off to a negative start. The southern colonies did however, have a warm climate, swamps, and thick rich soil. None of the original settlers of the Southern colonies were use to working; therefore they had no food to eat. When John Smith, a key leader in keeping Virginia alive, said to his colonists "No work, no food  the colonists took control and began a new life. As a result of the location of Jamestown, many…

    • 266 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this essay I will be talking about the similarities, what Jamestown and plymouth have in common and the differences between Jamestown and Plymouth. Jamestown was a small town in virginia and was one of the first permanent English settlement in the Americas. Plymouth was first settled in the 1620’s by a group of 100 puritan separatist pilgrims. In 1619, the first representative legislative assembly in the New World met at the Jamestown church. It was here that our American heritage of representative government was born. Since New England was outside the jurisdiction of Virginia's government, the Pilgrims established a self-governing agreement of their own, the "Mayflower Compact."Traveling aboard the Susan Constant, Godspeed and Discovery,…

    • 404 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What religious turmoil in the Old World resulted in the little colony of Plymouth in the New World?…

    • 611 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    So Jamestown and Plymouth are two colonies that were established by Europeans around the 1600, but when established, they both had different reasons for creating their colonies. When reading these two stories, you can already tell that these two colonies have a tremendous difference, but also you can identify the similarities of these two colonies.…

    • 509 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The voyage to the new land was quite a challenge with harsh conditions they faced over a period of 5 or more months. Dangerous, long, and never ending is what many would describe it if we were in their place. Two groups of different people embarked on the same voyage to the new land which were Jamestown and the Plymouth Plantation. What distinguished each other was what kind of person they hold as a leader, how they worked together as a group, and their purpose of traveling there.…

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The settlements of Virginia and Massachusetts were both established during relatively the same time, but the ways that they were established differed tremendously. Virginia had difficulty establishing itself; there were many errors and failures, especially in the beginning. Massachusetts, on the other hand, was extremely successful. The settlers made smart decisions in provisions and planning that resulted in a prosperous colony. Virginia and Massachusetts also differed in their leadership quality. Virginia, initially, had weak leadership until John Smith who established a much more rigid government system within the colony. Massachusetts enjoyed successful leadership from the beginning with Joseph Winthrop. Joseph Winthrop was able to successfully develop the settlement, and a respected, well thought out society. Virginia and Massachusetts also differed in their work ethic. Virginia produced slothful workers and relied heavily on labor from the Natives. The Puritans of Massachusetts held onto a rigid lifestyle and were very hard-working. The differences in the settlement’s upbringing were not the only thing that divided the two colonies; the differing views on religion helped to shape the economy of both…

    • 583 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Jamestown vs. New England

    • 1295 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The Jamestown colony was located near present day James City County, Virginia. Jamestown was the first permanent settlement by the English in what is in current day known as the United States. The location of Jamestown was selected primarily for the fact that it provided a favorable defensive location against any other foreign powers that may have tried to gain control of the colony. John Smith, Robert Hunt along with others provided inspirational leadership for the colonists but even so starvation became a very apparent problem. The hostile relations with the local Native American people and a lack of any profitable exports only made matters worse. Despite this and a horrible winter bearing down on them, the colonists persevered. At the end of the first winter only 60 of the original 214 English colonists survived. (jamestown virginia) The settlers who came over on the initial three ships were not well-equipped for the life they found in Jamestown. In addition to the “Gentry” who was not accustomed to manual or skilled labor, they consisted mainly of English farmers who were not prepared physically or emotionally for the problems that would face them. (old and sold antique digest) Yet despite this they persevered and worked as a team to establish a colony. However, when two ships, crudely constructed in Bermuda, arrived at the settlement with no supplies, when the colonists desperately needed supplies the most, the settlers packed up and abandoned…

    • 1295 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Virginia Colony and the Massachusetts Bay Colony were both similar and different on three main topics: religion, economics, and demographics.…

    • 458 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The New England colonies and the Southern colonies are slightly similar in some aspects, but drastically different in most. For example the new england colonies were strictly puritan and they did not tolerate any other religion but the southern colonies were not dominated by a single religion which gave way to more liberal attitudes and some religious freedom. The economy of New England was powered mostly the manufacturing in factories, whereas the Southern colonies’ economies were more agriculturally based. The social structures were different, because the New England colonies didn’t believe in slavery, so the social ladders were not the same. Religious tolerance was another major difference in these two regions. Overall the New England and Southern colonies are slightly similar, but their differences set them apart from each other.`…

    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The choice of the Jamestown peninsula; believing it would provide security from the natives, proved to be a poor one. The land “was low and swampy and surrounded by thick woods” (Brinkley 35). They became susceptible to disease such as malaria. For the Pilgrims upon the Mayflower, intending to most likely land around the Hudson River; in what is now New York, instead discovered themselves on the Cape Cod. After some exploration, they found their settlement in Plymouth a land just outside the London Company’s region. The first winter claimed the lives of half their colonist due to malnutrition, disease and…

    • 1159 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays