Preview

Compare And Contrast John Smith And William Bradford

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
741 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare And Contrast John Smith And William Bradford
John Smith and William Bradford were prominent writers and colonial leaders during the Puritan and Pilgrim era. However, both had different ways of conveying their thoughts and experiences during their travels and time in the New World. Those different ways included, but were not limited to, how they wrote about their interactions with the Native Americans, how the crews interacted with each other, and how God was perceived in their eyes. While adventuring in the New World, both colonial leaders wrote about how men interacted with their crews. In the General History of Virginia, Smith described the relationship between the captain and his men as every man for himself. The captain did not bother helping the people who were dying due to sickness, mostly due to the fear that they would also contract the disease that they carried. This usually led to fighting among the group, it lasted even after Smith was kidnapped by the Indians. It was not until the Indians gave the colonists food, that the fighting calmed down. Bradford described a different relationship between himself and his followers. The rich and healthy were helping the sick, doing everything for them until they recovered. It did not matter if they contracted a disease from them or not, all that mattered was that they …show more content…
These included, but were not limited to, the crews’ interactions with each other, the mens’ interactions with Native Americans, and how God was perceived in their eyes. They were men of God, who experienced hardships while in the New World. Those hardships were eventually overcome with the help of God and the Native Americans in both Smith and Bradford accounts. The men described different ways of how their men affected their journey; in Smith’s account, his men were not as helpful when compared to Bradford’s men. Nevertheless, both crews eventually overcame their differences and survived the New

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    In both Columbus’s and Smith’s writings, over stating how plentiful the land is common. For example, they name countless types of small and large game as well as mention how often they can go fishing. The two also emphasis how fertile the ground is with endless types of grain, seeds, fruit, flowers, berries and anything you plant will grow. They both mention how easy the Indians can be handled as well. Columbus and Smith do not forget to include the main points for colonization either. Water access, God, and land are the main advantages people look for when colonizing or relocating even today. They assure the people land and food to live, but also touch on converting these savages to God. They almost guilt trip the people in England by…

    • 182 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    John Smith and William Bradford both traveled thousands of miles on small ships to achieve religious freedom. The General History of Virginia is a historical narrative written by John Smith. The story describes the rough beginning of religious freedom, and what they had to go through to get it. If I were to settle into a new world, I would join someone brave and determined, like John Smith.…

    • 269 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Pocahontas and John Smith both have the Standard American accents, despite John Smith being from Britain and Pocahontas being a Powhatan Native American woman. Pocahontas, the heroin of the classic Disney take of this historically depressing tale, is aesthetically pleasing to the eye like Jasmine, with beautified, striking features and long sleek hair that every young girl wishes they had. John Smith’s sharp features and blond hair beautify him as well and only enhance the stereotype that American accented people are more beautiful than non-American accented people. Ratcliffe, the evil, literal gold-digger who is in charge of the English expedition, has a thick British accent and his over-weight and…

    • 110 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    and differences with their relationship to his fellow settlers, their sense of community, and their…

    • 426 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Smith’s publication, A Description of New England (1616), he goes so far as to compare the colonists to Adam and Eve; just as Adam and Eve spread productivity throughout the world, the colonists created life in the Virginia colony. Smith essentially sympathized with gentlemen; he knew it was not their fault they were useless and that this trait was merely a product of the imposed standards of English society. He recognized that “they were imprisoned by their own self-imposed limitations. What they could and could not do was decided by their awareness of traditional roles and by the shame that they would feel if others saw them engaged in physical work.” Lemay speculates that as a result of Smith’s strict rules and the emigration to America, these men could shed these roles and create new…

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Jamestown crew mostly consisted of men who were fending off for themselves in the ship. And with such corruption there this was not a surprise. Their crew was a mess until John Smith came and restored order and put everyone in their place , but before that many died and so on because they didn’t really care and tend to each other. Meanwhile, on the Plymouth Plantation they were more of a community on the ship they had women and children on there too. On (pgs 80-81) shows how when they got sick a few people would devote their time and patience to those who were ill. And even if those people died their efforts were not in vain because their recompense would be with the lord. Religion was a factor that made the voyage quite different because all they did was with purpose. And everything that happened, they believed that it was in God’s…

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The New World was not without its conflicts as evidenced in the many disputes the Puritans such as Bradford and his Separatists along with Winthrop and his Congregationalists had with other parties who were regarded as dissenters. The causes of such disputes did indeed vary but the inherent reason under all of them was thought to be the Puritan leaders’ defensive nature along with their desire to interpreting history so as to make it compatible with Calvinistic theology. This thus brings varying discrepancies in the early American literature such as those of Thomas Morton and William Bradford who describe similar events but with varying points of view thus reaching different conclusions.…

    • 1575 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    “So they committed themselves to the will of God and resolved to proceed.” (79) John smith and William Bradford were two American settlers that both came from england. They each came to a new world to better their lives. Smith came to jamestown mostly for the money and to get rich. He was a selfish person in his writing he mostly wrote about himself.…

    • 1253 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    They described America as not only the new world but as a place for opportunity and dreams. Their writings reflected the colonist view away from the restrictions of British society. Captain John Smith, using a fairly simple and open narrative, provided detailed maps and descriptions of the areas in addition to adventurous tales of his own and others. William Bradford wrote of his experiences in the new world but his text was based largely on his Puritan faith and compared their quest heavily to that of Paul's in the Bible. Despite Bradford's more rational style of writing, he also saw the new world as a land of…

    • 450 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Henry and Smith both strove for Unity through their speeches, yet both speeches and resemblances and variations. They both used a similar “avenue” of writing to talk about the topics at hand and they wanted the country, or in Henry’s case, colonies to come together. The only exception was that Henry was after war, while Smith was after…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    One difference between Bradford and Byrd is their writing styles. In of Plymouth Plantation, Bradford uses the "Plain Style" to write his account of the New World. "Plain Style" writing is the form of writing used by thenPuritans. The "Plain Style" of writing tries to stay away from figures of speech and tried to keep it plain and simple and to the point. On the other hand Byrd is in "sharp contrast", in The History of the Dividing Line, to the writing style of Bradford. Byrd used forms of ridicule to write his account of what happened. One example of this is Byrd's calling the sudden flock of people to the New World a "modish frenzy"; by this he means it was just a fad of the times. One contrast in the writings of Byrd and Bradford is the purpose for which they are written. One reason Bradford writes his story is to inform the reader about the history of the pilgrims. Another reason for Bradford's writing is to inspire future generations to Puritan ideals alive. He also wrote his story to show God's hand in their experiences. On the other hand Byrd's writing was his own personal journal that was soon to be published. Byrd may have written his story to entertain his reader. For examples all through out his story he is constantly making fun of settlers, he mentions during the story that the settlers spent 50 pounds on a church and 500 pounds on a pub. He may have made fun of the settlers to implement change in the settler's way of life.…

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    In Bradford’s narrative, the Pilgrims must settle in a strange, new, harsh world. The colonists endure a hard journey and have no warm buildings to welcome them ashore. They sleep in stick shelters. But we do not really live the adversity in Bradford’s narrative in the same way we are easily put into the experience in the other narratives. Bradford writes in a broad, sweeping fashion, while the other writers write with more detail. We hear about Mary’s captivity in her narrative. She is not fed very well, and in the early part of her captivity she had to live in pain from her injury. The Natives move frequently, which does not help her. Her captors have no respect for her. Obviously, Mary’s tribulations are terrible. But still, both narratives pale in comparison to Equiano’s narrative in terms of who had the worst experience. Equiano’s narrative is by far the hardest read when you picture what he went through. The conditions aboard the slave ship are horrifying: disease, abuse, cramped spaces, and terrible smells. It’s easy to picture the situation because Equiano describes it so vividly, yet hard to fathom how awful it really was to live. The stories are very different…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cap. John Smith and William Bradford they were completely different people because one had huge ego while the other was an honest person. The colonist of Jamestown were members of the Angelica church and the pilgrims , from Plymouth, were Puritans which was part of the England church. The Jamestown citizens were more meaner and ruder than the pilgrims because the Jamestown colonist believed that it is everybody on their own while the pilgrims believed that everybody mattered in their colony. We know more stuff from Plymouth than Jamestown because Bradford recorded everything about his colonist and…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bradford’s history dispels many myths and misinformation about Plymouth Plantation, its relationships to the Native Americans and the Virginia Colony, and the events surrounding the Pilgrims’ first years in America. When the Pilgrims first arrived, the Native Americans would try to approach them but they would just run away. But in March, a certain Indian came boldly and spoke to them in broken English. This became a start of a mutual relationship and then they decided to make peace with Squanto and it would stay intact for 24 years. The conditions were: neither he nor any of his should injure or do hurt to any of their people, that if any of his did hurt to any of their, he should send the offender, that they might punish him, that if anything were taken away from any of theirs, he should cause it to be restored,; and they should do the like to this, if any did unjustly war against him, they would aid him; if any did war against them, he should aid them, he should send to his neighbors confederates to certify them of this, that they might not wrong them, but might be likewise comprised in the conditions of peace, and lastly, that when their men came to them, they should leave their bows and arrows behind…

    • 662 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Professor Barton describes how only after a year of settlement in the New World, during the winter of 1607, there only remained 38 of the original 104 settlers of the Jamestown Colony.” This included months on end without food or supply from the British homeland, dysentery and malaria, Indian assaults, and eventual cannibalism of cats, dogs, and people. These circumstances forced colonists to learn to be independent and self-sustaining. They wouldn’t be able to rely on others in a distant land to watch over them because it took months for supplies to come, months for communications to reach England. The American colonists were the ones who sailed on a small ship for 66 days on rough waters to get there.…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays