Preview

Comparison between poems by Seamus Heaney, "Death of a Naturalist" and "The Barn".

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
901 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparison between poems by Seamus Heaney, "Death of a Naturalist" and "The Barn".
Both poems display very rich description from the start and continue this full description throughout the poem giving you a very clear image of the sights, sounds and smells described. The very first lines of each poem show this rich flavour and very much give you the idea that the poems are about nature. The poems are about forces of nature and they both build the effect of these forces using description. Death of a Naturalist uses the description to give the feeling that the author is control of nature that is why when it comes to the last verse it is so shocking to the author because he realises he is not in control anymore and cannot control the forces of nature. The Barn uses the description to give you the feeling you get when you are in the barn. It gives you the feeling that everything is still, dead and cold this gives it an eerie feeling and this feeling is expressed in the last verse not as still, dead or cold but very much alive.

Both poems are reminiscing about childhood experiences with the true forces of nature. You can tell that they are childhood experiences because of the language used. In Death of a Naturalist the things that tell you that it is a child speaking through Seamus Heaney are the things that this child does. The child collects 'jampotfuls' of spawn and puts them on window-sills at home and shelves at school. Also the language used tells us that it is told through the words of a child. Words like daddy and mammy are examples of the child-like language used in Death of a Naturalist. In The Barn the things that tell you that it is a childhood experience is the description and the actions. The description of the floor 'mouse-grey' is typical of a simple childish description. The action that tells us that it is a childhood experience is the way the child lays on the floor face down, although an adult may have been scared in the barn I think that an adult may not have laid face down on the floor so therefore it must have been a child. Even

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Wright uses embodiment to give the poem life and give the speaker in the story the ability to amplify his emotions of surprise, anger, and fear. In the beginning of the poem the speaker describes the scene as “guarded by scaly oaks and elms” as to say that nature guarded and preserved the scene. The speaker gives the woods life and creates an eerie feeling by saying the woods “guarded” the scene. Then he moves towards a discovery of white “slumbering” bones giving them human abilities of sleeping, which symbolize the eternal sleep of death. He uses this description early in the poem to say that someone has died here; this was their final place on this earth. Then as the speaker moves on in his story and horrifically shifts from the observer to the victim he portrays the dramatic changes in his surroundings “the ground gripped my feet; ... the sun died in the sky; a night wind muttered in the grass; … the darkness screamed with thirsty voices; and the witnesses rose and lived.” The speaker tells of his terror during his change using personification to give human properties to the woods as the ground immobilizes him, the light turns to darkness, the silence turns into chaotic screams, and the speaker relives the night of the crime.…

    • 837 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Now days, it is hard to connect or be with the nature, especially if you live in a city. While there are people that interact with the nature every day because of their rural location. The short poem “Traveling through the Dark” by William Stafford, is about a person that encounter a dead deer in the road in the middle of the night. In the story, the narrator have to decide if he would save the unborn deer or just throw the mom deer to the river to save other people that might suffer an accident by encountering the dead body. In the poem, is interesting to see how the narrator, which represent the human world, makes a connection with the natural world by encountering the deer and debating if he/she should do something for the baby deer. Interestingly enough, Stafford give a clear description of the setting, location and time where this is occurring when he mentions, “Traveling through the dark I found a deer dead on the edge…

    • 441 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Both the poems “Traveling through the Dark” and “Woodchucks” portray different types of diction, attitude, and metaphors to depict the different contrast towards the animals; while in “Traveling through the Dark”, the attitude towards the animals are reverent and humble, “Woodchucks” portray an attitude towards the animals are acerbic and resentful.…

    • 310 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Death seems to be a popular subject for literature. Death’s many unknowns may cause this—not all are sure of what comes after, and scientists cannot study its effects. Therefore, writers take a stab at describing and explaining it. Emily Dickinson and John Donne both do this in their respective poems. While they have the same topics, these two poems have plenty of differences as well. “Because I Could Not Stop for Death” and “Death, be not Proud” address the same topics but focus on different aspects of them, have drastically different styles, and flow very differently.…

    • 531 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    With close reference to the ways each poet uses language, compare and contrast what the speakers in the poems say about rural life. You should include relevant contextual material. Which poem do you find more interesting? Give your reasons.…

    • 1194 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The two poems clarify the value of life. The enclosure where the giraffe lives in "Domesticity of giraffes" is a metaphor for "no life" as her life is very lonely and restricted. On the other hand, her natural habitat is a metaphor for "life", as is identified in "she could be a big slim bird just before flight", meaning freedom. In writing about how the child prayed not to waken another animal from the wheat because it would run the risk of losing its life in "Fox in a tree stump", Beveridge conveys that life is precious. The snapping of the twig, the ringing of the branch and the flying of the galahs propose that all deaths have frightening consequences, indicating that death in itself is like a fiend destroying life.…

    • 647 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    An example of how Owen expresses nature into his poems is ‘Futility’, this poem already by the title meaning uselessness already gives us an indication of what the poet is trying to say about the soldiers. Exactly so as Owen in the first line says, ‘Moves him into the sun’ already describing the effect of the dead soldier being shifted into the sun. But why the sun? Owen could have said the shed or the hole but instead he used the sun which already starting with the nature. He almost made the theme of nature the character in the poem. You can see that nature makes him question everything. The narrator then goes on to use personification of the sun like a kind father figure, grandfatherly figure almost. The simple but powerful rhyme of ‘snow and know’ quite a moving rhyme brings home to us the death of the soldier. Owen then continues with the second stanza however takes a…

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One's a Heifer

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages

    3) The author describes the farmer’s house as following: “The yard was littered with old wagons and machinery; the house was scarcely distinguishable from the stables. Darkness was beginning to close in but there were no lights in the windows.” By describing like this, the reader feels an almost eerie mood or atmosphere, desolate even.…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Poetry is a very powerful mechanism through which writers can tell their readers something about themselves or the world around them. The language within “Traveling Through the Dark” by William Stafford and “Woodchucks” by Maxine Kumin display the speakers’ psychology and what sort of relationships they have with the animals and their deaths in their respective works. Despite being similar in a few aspects, these two works are very different.…

    • 507 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    To begin with, Thomas writes in rhyming couplets which create an on-going effect of the individuals story also reflecting the oral tradition of the English countryside. He also writes in narrative lyric which gives this poem a song like undercurrent carrying the story fluidly and seamlessly. AOMWN is a narrative poem with an irregular rhyme scheme, Frost here reflects the conflict between man and nature as death approaches. Even though the poem is irregular in rhyme, frost makes use of internal rhyme such as assonance and alliteration which may illustrate how the character feels comfortable inside but has a fear of the natural environment, feeling almost as if it is against him.…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Thanatopsis, the author shows the theme about death by comparing it to nature’s beauty. Most people see death as horrible, but Bryant shows an in-depth meaning to it. The poem starts off by personifying nature as a beautiful female, “…and a smile and eloquence of beauty” (Lines 4-5), who will always be there for you to make you feel better, “Into his darker musings, with a mild and healing sympathy.”(Lines 6-8) The poem takes a shift and talks about how death feels like “Of the stern agony, and shroud, and pall and breathless darkness, and the narrow house,” (Lines 11-12) and the idea of being in pain in a dark coffin. The poem continues going back and forth on nature’s beauty and death, and soon connects it back to the theme. “Thy growth, to be resolved to earth again, (Line 23)” shows that after death is another phase of life itself, and we will return to be one with nature. Our dead decomposing bodies will be mixed in with nature, “Shall send his roots abroad, and pierce thy mould. (Line 30)” Bryant compares nature to a coffin, “Are but the solemn decorations all of the great tomb of man.” (Line 44-45), to show the coffins of dead people created nature’s beauty, the valleys, hills, rivers. Bryant leaves a…

    • 976 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    An article, “Metaphor and Literature,’ defines metaphor as a tool that produces “meaningful communication” (MacCormac 59). Similarly, by adding visual metaphors in her poetry, Smith tries to submerge the readers into a deeper level of experience about abstract issues i.e. death and grief. She writes, “You stepped out of the body/Unzipped like a coat” (92-93). Here, Smith gives an insight to the belief that the soul leaves the body after death, which she imagines occurred with her father’s soul. She is trying to give the notion that death involves the separation of the soul. Likewise, in the later part of the poem, Smith uses different species of extinct tigers, “Javan,” “Bali,” and “Caspian,” to symbolize her father (80-82). The emptiness felt by her causes her to imagine her father as a rare species, who might also be alone in heaven. She imagines that her father might have also felt the deep pain in losing one dear to him. Smith describes this loneliness as “a solitary country” (84). However, later, she finds comfort in the fact that her father is no longer in fear. “Night kneels at your feet like a gypsy glistening with jewels” (90). “Night,” is considered to be a symbol of darkness, a time when people usually hide. Smith, adding these images throughout her poetry, tries to say that fear is eliminated in heaven .She emphasizes that her father experiences real power in his…

    • 1631 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Blue Bowl Analysis

    • 483 Words
    • 2 Pages

    “Like primitives we buried the cat with his bowl.” To me this symbolizes the use of their hands to scoop dirt, sand, and gravel as they buried their dead cat. Again you can feel the family’s sorrows. “We stood and brushed each other off. There are sorrows keener than these.” Yes there are greater losses than that of losing a pet. This poem shows the deep connection between the family and their pet. One of the two literary elements that I’m going to identify is tone. The tone of this poem to me is one of a sympathetic one. Given the references made by the narrator it would appear that the family is in a sympathetic mode.…

    • 483 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Poetry Comparative Essay

    • 491 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Both pieces have many examples of descriptive language that paint clear images of what the poets wanted us to see. For Example, "the ambiguous dread in double negative interrogation ("Did you not understand what you did was
wrong?")" (Whyte, 40-41) The image of a little boy or girl being scolded by their parents for doing something wrong went into my head; reminding me of the times I dreaded those double negative interrogations from my mom. John Keats's poem was filled with descriptive sentences like, "On the shore of the wide world I stand alone, and think till Love and Fame to nothingness do sink." (Keats, 12-13) There is a dreadful tone to this phrase, like a dying man that learned that things like love and fame are nothing in the end is speaking it.…

    • 491 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dickinson's poems share a theme of the romanticization versus the reality of nature although they contrast in their differing overall messages. She represents in her poetry what humans romantically sense as nature and the natural world while allowing her readers to ponder upon the sensibility found in the analyzing of the works.…

    • 1454 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics