Preview

Comparison Of Nietzche And Henry David Thoreau

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
718 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparison Of Nietzche And Henry David Thoreau
The ideas of nature between German Philosopher, Frederick Nietzche, and Henry David Thoreau show strong feelings toward their opinion. Nietzche and Thoreau had similar views on their opinion on nature and endorse it. Thoreau says “I love nature, I love the landscape because it is so sincere. It never jest. It is cheerfully, musically earnest.” Thoreau shows a positive and caring view of nature. Generally speaking, interpretations of Nietzsche and his view of nature vary according to weather his break with metaphysics is seen as complete, and whether his break is considered desirable. Henry David Thoreau, Friedrich Nietzche and Chris McCandless embodied anarchist ideals in which they rejected the facade of society, social constraints, and materialism. They instead embrace naturalism and the idea of self exploration often at extreme cost and what others …show more content…
They felt they were control of their lives and didn't need the system telling them what to do. For example, “Chris would comply with the rule but as soon as his shift was over, bang!- the first thing he’d do is peel those socks off. I mean the very first thing. Kind of like a statement, to let us know we didn’t own him, I guess,” (assistant manager 40). Chris was letting people know that he is not owned and doesn't want to obey by the rules. Chris’s actions are ultimately selfish, and do great harm to those who love him most. His inability to forgive his parents mistakes seems to contradict between his love for nature, political views, and his sometimes cruel behavior. “In 1988, as Chris’s resentment of his parents hardened, his sense of outrage over injustice in the world at large grew”(pg.123) there is more behind his anger towards his parents lies and materialistic needs but his resentment of them does spread into the rest of his life, and seems to have some connection to how isolated he becomes at

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The quote from Thoreau relates to Chris because even though his father was a brilliant and loving man, he had lied to Chris his whole life, which forced Chris to feel much hatred for his father that never resolved. “Chris’s smoldering anger, it turns out, was fueled by a discovery he’d made two summers earlier.” (Krakauer…

    • 915 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Chris McCandless was a young man from California who loved to be outdoors and was always very athletic. He always had the desire and ambition to do things on his own. However this was a positive and negative side to his personality because it would cost him his life by wanting to live this way. In school Chris was always a very smart student who had good grades and could have gone to college if he chose to. His parents wanted him to attend college but he felt it wasn’t for him so instead he chose to travel and hitchhike. This caused tension between the McCandless’s and adding gas to the fire, Chris’s father had an affair which angered him even more.…

    • 613 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Chris Mccandless Quotes

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages

    been a part of society. Chris was the type of person who did not like how greedy and…

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Everyone has an obligation to be kind and compassionate to a certain degree, but they also have their limits. McCandless simply exceeded his limit, and decided to do something for himself for once. I think that Chris could have communicated better with his parents, but all in all, he made a decision to better himself; to make him happier. Hurting his parents was in no way intentional, though I doubt he would have regretted it too much, had he known. He dealt with a lot with his parents and eventually it got to him, and he didn’t want to take anymore.…

    • 1510 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Appears to be the first sign that Chris is unaffected by the words of others whether by ignoring them, getting lost in his fantasies, or the least likely- being mentally handicapped (bipolar?), delusional? It is also said a few lines down that “[Chris] simply appeared to be absent.” which also aids the fact that Chris is doing something in his mind to avoid the words. Could almost foreshadow how Chris doesn’t deal with reality, how he just lives in his fantasies instead of facing facts. Interesting to note the “old rage of helplessness” possibly referring to a feeling she is very used the feeling; it could be that she herself has been faced with this situation. The words used in the passage suggest great strength of character from Chris. Grandfather Connor was talking to Chris but Chris seems unfazed by it and even…

    • 1896 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Chapter one: It foreshadow chris mccandless’s death. -They both believe in the same type of ideals like :”The best type of government that governs the least.” Chapter two: The winter was cold and deadly. He had nothing around him.…

    • 472 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Who was Chris ? What kind of person was he ? Some say he was foolish others say he was intelligent. Some say that Chris was a man full of hate others say he was full of love. What was Chris searching for? Perhaps it was Happiness others say it was an escape from society. If you read the book Into the Wild by John Krakuer it is clear that Chris is the mix of the both Worlds.…

    • 578 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Looking over a couple theories that related to Chris and his family, it seemed like attachment theory fit best. I believe that attachment theory is best for Chris because he had that secure attachment with his mom that allowed him branch out and do something completely unexpected of him. He knew that if anything went wrong he had someone there who had his back, which was his mom and sister. That knowledge of security allowed him to go on this journey and experience the unknown. Attachment theory, established by John Bowlby, is a set a concepts that are used to explain the emergence of the emotional bond that forms between an infant and their primary caregiver. It then goes on to explore that way in which the bond affects the child’s emotional…

    • 142 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jon Krakauer's Analysis

    • 653 Words
    • 3 Pages

    This turned out to be fatal in the end for Chris. As his death seemed to be a matter of unpreparedness as well as accident. But according to Joseph Kramp his unpreparedness was no fault of his own. He states “his life and horrid death is a witness to how our society is failing our youth today who deeply desire to be apart of communities that help them become accountable to each other’s needs without developing any kind of punitive conscience or need to entirely exit society by venturing into the wilderness” (Kramp 65). This quote is exactly what has been the case with Chris. Instead of his parents seeing what he wanted to do with his life and helping him achieve his aspirations, they tried to steer him in the direction they wanted him to…

    • 653 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    he wrote in such text that covered all aspects of life. He united man and nature as one. He wrote about the beauty of everything. I believe that everything was meant to be on this earth for a reason and there is always beauty in everything you just need to look harder. Nature its meaning and value comprises one of the most pervasive themes in Thoreau's writings, expressed through both painstaking detail and broad generalization. Like Emerson, Thoreau saw an intimate and specific familiarity with the reality of nature as vital to understanding higher truth. Thoreau's transcendental quest toward the universal drew him to immerse himself in nature at Walden Pond from 1845 to 1847. It led him to observe the natural world closely in order ultimately…

    • 133 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The preceding quote demonstrates an example of how Chris and his father were very different from each other. He wrote, “‘I'm going to divorce them as my parents once and for all and never speak to either of those idiots again as long as I live’” (Krakauer 64). This is a prime example of the consequences when Chris challenged societal expectations and it is also a prime example of how he was misjudged by his family. The consequence of defying society is that he was smart and people judged him because they might have been jealous of his intelligence. Chris himself even knew his level of intelligence. They might have judged him because he was smart but they did not realize the struggles he undertook with his family. He was judged by his family because they did not realize his level of intelligence. They judged him because they were not able to comprehend his intelligence and they did not understand his thinking process. He felt that he was too intelligent for the rest of society and he felt like he needed to leave everything and go off on his own living for himself. This makes complete sense and it is honestly a very smart decision he made. He knew there was going to be consequences along the way, but he did not care. He was living for himself and himself only.…

    • 913 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Henry David Thoreau Essay

    • 595 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The great author Henry David Thoreau once wrote, "Many men go fishing all of their lives without knowing that it is not fish they are after." Thoreau's quote is trying to express that in life we sometimes try so hard to accomplish things and gain status that we tend to forget what we are really after is happiness. People often believe that certain things will bring them happiness such as money, jobs, and material possessions. However, after they acquire these things instead of feeling contentment they feel a sense of emptiness.…

    • 595 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It’s easy to believe Chris suffers from a mental illness such as high functioning borderline personality disorder. This misconception comes from the fact that Chris creates a new version of himself, Alexander Supertramp, fails to maintain relationships he creates throughout his journey, and is meticulous with how the trail to his past life is left. These traits seem to be enough to diagnose Chris with such a disorder, that is if you take it out of context. Chris creates a new version of himself to symbolize the new life he is soon to pursue. He wants to limit the connections to his old life in all ways possible. A life that he regards with disdain, because it failed to meet his moral code. A code highly represented by a passage Chris highlighted in one of his books, “Rather than love, than money, than fame, give me truth” (Thoreau qtd. in Krakauer 117). Chris’ family failed to understand, and respect these ideals, resulting in Chris’ cutting them out of his life. His parents insisted on trying to increase his quality life with material values while also keeping their previous affair a secret from Chris. He fails to maintain his relationships with people not because he’s antisocial, but because he resents society, and doesn’t…

    • 519 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Chris is from a tough family by the name of Chambers. His family is known around Castle Rock as criminals but Chris is ashamed to be related to his audacious family. He displays this when he and Geordie are on “watch” and they start to talk about the time Chris stole the milk money. Chris tells Geordie the truth about the incident and as he is doing so, he bursts into tears. This shows that he “bottles up” his emotions and he is ashamed of telling people the truth. I personally feel like Chris is shoved aside like every other “crook” but deep inside himself, he is a kind and caring boy that holds his friends in high regard. Another aspect of Chris’s traits is leadership. He holds himself as the leader of the “friendship gang” and all the boys admire him. This is shown when he tells Geordie off for saying “Fuck writing, I don't want to be a writer. It's stupid. It's a stupid waste of time.” Chris tells Geordie off and tells him that “I wish the hell I was your dad. You wouldn't be goin' around talkin' about takin' these stupid shop courses if I was. It's like God gave you something, man, all those stories you can make up. And He said, "This is what we got for ya, kid. Try not to lose it." Kids lose everything unless there's someone there to look out for them. And if your parents are too fucked up to do it, then maybe I should. This is a perfect example of the love Chris shows towards Geordie…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In "Nietzche's Moral and Political Philosophy" Nietzches theory of the strong and weak willed is explained to us. Nietzsche “seems to want to say that anyone who is strong, independent, and so on — anyone who fits his description o the higher type of man — is one who has value in himself”.…

    • 400 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays