Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Comparisons Between Araby and a&P

Good Essays
786 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparisons Between Araby and a&P
Araby is a story about a young boy who has an intense attraction to this girl. He goes out of his way to watch her every morning, and eventually talks to her. She says how she wants to go to the bazaar but cannot due to the fact that she’s going away on some church related trip. He wants nothing more than to impress this girl so he offers to travel to the bazaar himself and get her something. His uncle is late returning home on the day the boy is to go shop, so the boy ends up having to pay more to get into the bazaar. After looking around for a while, a lady that works there asks if he is interested in anything, and he responds saying no. As he turns to leave, the bazaar is beginning to close for the night, the light shuts off on him as he walks back to return home. A&P is a story about a boy names Sammie who works in a supermarket. In this story Sammie is telling the readers what he sees with an elaborate devotion to detail. One day while he is working, three girls walk in with swimsuits on. He is shown to have some sort of instant attraction to one of the girls. He sees the most attractive girl to be the leader of the three nicknaming her “Queenie”, and while he goes in to detail of how beautiful her features are, he tells of how her “followers” were chubby and unattractive. When Sammie’s manager spots the girls, he scolds them about their attire. Sammie wanting to come to the rescue of the girls quits. His manager is a friend of his parents and tells him he is making a mistake, but Sammie doesn’t care. He walks out the store hoping to see “his” girls, but when they are nowhere in sight he realizes he’s made a mistake that was foolish. In these stories Araby by James Joyce and A&P by John Updike, there are many similarities and at the same time, these stories contain many differences. One of the many similarities between these two stories is that both these boys are seriously intrigued with someone of the opposite sex. While they go in to detail on the appearance of the girls they are interested in, they never give a name. This can be seen as the boys being obsessed with the female species. Another trait these boys share would have to be that they will go out of their way to impress these girls. The boy in Araby offers to go to the bazaar to spend his own money and purchase her a gift. Sammie tries to impress the girls by quitting his job. He feels as if he is defending their honor. Another similarity between these two boys is they failed in impressing the girls in their stories. Sammie quits then goes outside to look for the three girls that he quit for, but they were nowhere in sight. After discovering that they are not outside he feels regret, not only for quitting his job and not impressing the girls like he intended to do, but because he let his manager and parents down, and realized how foolish and rash his decision was. The boy in the Araby story felt foolish after he went out his way to go to the bazaar for this girl, and ended up paying just to leave empty-handed. When the lights turned off on him as he was walking out made it seem as if he was taking a walk of shame. He felt unwise because he was blinded by beauty and wasn’t using his brain. Just as there similarities, there are differences between the two stories Araby and A&P. One difference between the two stories is that in A&P when religion was spoken about it was mentioned briefly. In Araby, religion was mentioned a lot, and whenever it was mentioned it was usually in a negative way. In A&P Sammie mentions how his manager works in the church and has many jobs. In Araby the first time they mention religion, they mention the death of the boy’s family’s tenant, who was a priest. Another difference between these stories is that the boy in Araby only described the girl as being a beautiful object, while Sammie made the girl in his story seem more like a sexual object. Sammie made observations on how her top strap would hang off her shoulder, making her look naked from the neck down to her shoulder. The boy in Araby made comments on how graceful the girl in his story’s hair was.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    In “A & P” Updike introduces us to a store clerk named Sammy who notices three girls in their bathing suits that have recently walked into the store. As Sammy describes each girl, he gives one the nickname Queenie. Sammy notices as the customers react to how the girls are dressed as they walk down the store isles. When it’s time to checkout, the store manager, Lengel, confronts the girls for breaking store dress policy. Which leads to Sammy quitting, to try and get the girls attention, unsuccessfully, leaving him not knowing what life will bring.…

    • 96 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The theme of the story “A&P” is “always weigh your consequences before taking actions”. The formal aspects used by the author to develop the story were symbolism, point of view, and setting. A&P written by John Updike first published in 1961 is about, the narrator, Sammy who is checking groceries when he realizes that three barefoot girls in bathing suits have walked into the store. The leader of the three, who has her bathing suit straps down, catches his eye. She walks like a queen (of which he nicknames “Queenie”) through the store, never turning to look at him or his coworker, Stokesie.…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Have you ever done something stupid, without rationalizing the consequences, and just doing something to impress someone you like. In the story Araby you have the narrator James Joyce reminiscing his childhood in Dublin Ireland. Joyce the narrator is telling a story how he went to the a bizarre , to buy a gift for Manglan's Sister the girl he liked. In the A&P a story by John Updike, you have a fictional character trying to impress a girl he nicknamed quennie. He tries to impress her by quitting his job when she is thrown out of there. Both characters in Araby and A&P are very similar and different. One similarity between both character is that beauty from the girls they liked both push them to do something to impress them.One difference is…

    • 190 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “A&P” by John Updike, the narrator Sammy struggles for freedom. He fantasizes of breaking free from working in the A&P. He became smitten when he encounter with a girl he calls Queenie, she becomes a symbol that represents his longing desires in which he sees an opportunity to escape through her. On the other hand James Joyce in “Araby,” the young adolescent narrator is always alienated in darkness so he seeks for a "light," in which, he sees it in Mangan’s sister. He instantly became captivated with her, ultimately thinking by going to the Bazaar to give her a gift will grant a secure relationship between them. Despite the differences both narrators cannot identify between reality and fiction. The role of romance comes in to play when…

    • 161 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “A&P” by John Updike and “Araby” by James Joyce are two shorts stories with similar male characters. Both Sammy and the boy of “Araby” are the protagonists. During the stories, they each go through a conflict that includes heartbreak. Sammy and the boy seem disconnected from the male figures in their life. The two main characters have unrealistic expectations. Unfortunately, Sammy and the boy both have a negative outcome. They both learn that everything is not what is appears to be. Sammy and the boy are similar because they are both distant from the male figures in their life, have unreasonable expectations, and end up in a negative situation.…

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A & P Updike Quit

    • 648 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the story “A&P” there is a eighteen year old male named Sammy, the protagonist. He worked as a cashier at a supermarket when during one of his shifts these three peculiar girls walked in wearing bathing suits. He immediately noticed them and could not stop focusing on the each of them. There was one in particular that he tended to refer to the most and he called her Queenie.…

    • 648 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why Sammy Quits

    • 952 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The short story “A&P” was written by John Updike in the mid-1950’s about a young man trapped in a planned middle class lifestyle that he wanted out of. During this time in history most teenagers around Sammy’s age were responsible for earning a living to support their families. Sammy is a young man who works in a grocery store in the same small town of which he grew up in. One day, during one of his hot summer shifts three young women walked in the grocery store. Following their arrival, Sammy began to notice how they were dressed. He noticed they were in revealing clothing like they were going to enjoy themselves a day at the beach. Not being accustomed to seeing this type of dress from women in particular, it drew a great…

    • 952 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    John Updike's A & P

    • 157 Words
    • 1 Page

    Summary: In the short story of “A&P” by John Updike, he takes us back through a flashback of his younger days when he was working at a grocery store. He had always followed all the rules and regulations regarding his work place, until one day a group of three girls came walking through with only their bathing suits on came into the store. On this day Sammy’s whole perspective changed.…

    • 157 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    A&P by John Updike is an initiation story about a young store clerk that made a haste decision. It all begins when three young girls in swim suits walked into the store. The girls were there to make a quick purchase for one of their mothers (Mays 166). They decided to not put a cover overt their suits before going in to the store, that is where the problem lies. The store manager, Lengel, is a very conservative man. Lengel is the initiator in this story. When he confronts the girls about their wearing more clothing in the store it causes the internal conflict within the narrator. There are many factors that influence ones’ perception of a situation, age being one of them.…

    • 299 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Short Story and Sammy

    • 1712 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In the short story “A&P,” John Updike writes of a nineteen year old boy, Sammy, who is overcome by his fantasies when three girls walk into the A&P grocery store. They are in nothing but bathing suits. He soon decides, after the events that occur, because of these three girls, to quit working in the third slot of the grocery store. The three girls to Sammy are damsels in distress, because of Lengel, the manager. Out of the three girls, one catches his eye, the one he calls “Queenie” (Updike 85). She soon becomes the center of his focus, from the details of her swimsuit to the color of her hair. He and his coworkers cannot seem to take their eyes off these girls throughout the entire store. This all changes when the girls go to the meat counter, where they meet McMahon. He is much older in age and the way he lusts after these young girls makes Sammy uneasy. Sammy, seeing the older man “slavering” over the girls, shows him that he does not want to be ‘that guy’. He shifts his feelings from corrupt to protective. He goes into more of a heroic mode so to speak. This is in his mind is what made him decide to quit his job, but why? After seeing the actions of McMahon, Sammy is shocked knowing he also was acting the same way. It brought to his attention how his actions cause an effect in many ways. When he quit he must explain his actions to his family, accepting responsibility for what he has done. Sammy must also decide how he wishes to perceive and interact with women in the future. In this story, Sammy goes from being an immature boy to a more mature man.…

    • 1712 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Boy Meets World "A&P"

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the story a young man Sammy, a nineteen-year-old boy, is working at the checkout line at an A&P in a small New England town. Three young girls come in to the store only in their bathing suits, like a typical guy he can 't help but look at them, he notices the chunky one first he describes her with “...good tan and a sweet broad soft-looking can with those two crescents of white just under it...”. The second girl he describes as being tall and sunburned. The third girl is the girl he really notices, she 's given the name Queenie because she was so obviously the leader of the three and the most attractive, for that reason he wanted her. Its the “want” that makes Sammy make a fool out of himself and gives him that little bit of courage to attempt to impress Queenie. Once the girls have circled through the isles they eventually come to the cash register and with his luck the girls stop at the register next to him, his friend Stokesie 's register. At the end of their check out the store manager, Langel, approaches the girls. He scolds the girls for not being “decently dressed” when in the store. Queenie and Langel have a short argument and then the girls leave. Now coming up is the part that 's relatable to…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Araby Hero

    • 622 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The destination that the boy is given in “Araby” is the bazaar that will be coming to town, named Araby. When Mangan’s sister, a young lady he has a romantic interest in, informs him of the event, he decides…

    • 622 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In both "A&P” and “Araby”, the main characters are young men expressing interest in young women. Both stories are written in first person narrative, although we are never so personally introduced to the main character in “Araby”, whereas;…

    • 246 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Alienation of "Araby"

    • 1885 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Although "Araby" is a fairly short story, author James Joyce does a remarkable job of discussing some very deep issues within it. On the surface it appears to be a story of a boy's trip to the market to get a gift for the girl he has a crush on. Yet deeper down it is about a lonely boy who makes a pilgrimage to an eastern-styled bazaar in hopes that it will somehow alleviate his miserable life. James Joyce's uses the boy in "Araby" to expose a story of isolation and lack of control. These themes of alienation and control are ultimately linked because it will be seen that the source of the boy's emotional distance is his lack of control over his life.…

    • 1885 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Themes in Dubliners

    • 1150 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The story of "Araby" is that of a young boy probably about the age of adolescence who is having his first crush on his friends sister. Although the boy seems to have no intention of realistically perusing the situation when the girl mentions that there is a fair she wanted to go to but would be unable to attend he offers to pick her up a gift at the fair. It is this situation that leads to the climax. After days of waiting and defeating great odds (his uncle coming home in time to give him money)what seemed like forever to the boy finally passed and he made it to the fair. Right from the start of the fair things looked bad all the booths where closing and his hopes of getting a nice gift where slim As the boy was searching for a gift he over heard two men flirting with a girl who worked in one of the booths. When the girl saw him listening she asked him in a tone that was not encouraging if he would like to buy by any thing to witch he replied "no thank you" (Joyce.P.27). The boy then walked away the lights went out and "Gazing up into the darkness I saw my self as a creature driven and derided by vanity: and my eyes burned with anguish and anger."(Joyce.P.27) This is how the story ends. The boy is so sickened with himself and with what was making him happy before. Because of his encounter the boy comes to a new realization about the crush he had and actually hates himself for having had it. Because of his hatred for himself which may also be do to his inability to actually…

    • 1150 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics